You cant take one thing that happens on it for real now. TAPS has 0 credibility. The rest of the cast know what Grant's doing and they play along with it each and every time.
5 years of work and every peice of evidence they came up with has to be thrown out as it's no longer trusted.
Still makes for a good show to fall asleep to though. And get some laughs at some of the stupid shit Grant does like the jacket pull and him pulling a lamp cord to make it look like a ghost moved it. LOL
@Titusx66 If someone else presented TAPS with what they try to pass off as real TAPS would turn it down as fast as they turned down the Lizzie Borden House and that place in California.
Watching it again has made me critical of what goes on in the show. Mostly what grant does. Like in the new one s5e22 his light goes off and on too many times, while everyone else gets footsteps and breezes. :|
I know a bit of it is probably real, but it's a bit painful thinking... are they doing this for the ratings? Is this fake?
I still watch it though to take what I can out of it. I feel it used to be 100% true, now I question things that can easily be faked (mostly what Grant does).
The thing is grant reacted just like this person recreated. I too was a big fan and I think Grant and taps felt pressure from the networks to come up with evidence. Even though, that stunt took me out of the show, we all know that something like a Jacket tug by a ghost can't be caught on tap in that dramatic fashion unless it is recreated in a movie. F--k taps, they didnt have to pull that B.S.
You know, I was pretty pissed off that they pulled that crap, too. But that doesn't mean you have to stop watching the show. I still watch the show but not in the sam manner as I used to watch. I used to watch to see what kind of ghosts they would catch on film. Now I make a game out of trying to figure out how they fake evidence. To tell you the truth, my little game has made the show a little more entertaining. Just try it for yourself and keep in touch. Happy huntings, my friend.
Well I still cant find the reason to watch it anymore but if i did I would watch it like you do and find the next B---s--t trick they try to pull. i dont know, maybe I'll try it but i just dont like anybody who doesn't have the integrity to own up and fess up. Regardless i still believe in ghosts and G H just doesn't do it for me anymore. Thanks for the reply,
Yes, shame on her, no ghosts will ever be caught, because she can recreate TAPS hoaxes. Her honesty and truth seeking does a disservice to all of us blind sheep within the TAPS herd.
You have to look at it through another perspective as well. People will find REAL ghost footage hard to believe because there are so many morons creating fakes out there.
What the...?!? Who says I don't believe in ghosts? The reason why I watched these shows in the first place was because of my strong belief in ghosts. Then I realized and saw how big of fakes they were. Now I watch to see how they are going to try to fake something next. I still strongly believe in ghosts and I still watch these shows. However, now I'm pissed off because these fakes use that belief you and I carry to exploit us with these fakes. You have to admit, it's pretty messed up of them.
You keep referring to haters. This video was not made by a 'hater' it was made by a fan who saw what looks like a trick that can be easily recreated and did exactly what Jay and Grant would want if the evidence had been presented to them. So really stop with the hater cause that isn't the case here.
That almost looks exactly like what happend to Grant. try it on a lighter colored coat so we can see more contrast, but well done. and "Tansrulesand you suck", you do have some kind of a problem, go see a shrink. I am a fan of the show and I think they used to be honest on their investigations, but I think SciFi told them to keep the live show entertaining by faking this stuff. It's going to be hard for me to believe them now. at least until they come clean about what happened.
Hey there IdobelievethatIsuck you wanna dance with me. You think you have the balls to go toe to toe with the TRUTH. I did not think so....Stupid Hater
you are small time and I can not waste my time on you. I have to put the big time haters in their place. I am the basher of the bashers. I am a hero! A voice for the mute. A hope for the hopeless. I am the hater of the haters, their worst nightmare. Do not mess with me, for I am the truth.
You have a serious complex?!? You aren't the truth you are apparently a real serious fan who has taken things real far. I'm a fan of the show and a believer in the paranormal. So no matter how much I like the show when I see evidence that looks suspect it is in the best interest of science to debunk. Which TAPS claims to do. In this case it is easily recreated.
I'm not a joke or a hater. I am a fan who is disappointed in what looks to me to be clearly fake. This is nothing different then what Grant or Jason would do if they were presented with the footage we saw in the special.
They faked it once then what guarantees every other episode is 100% rigged? Nothing and if they faked something on an episode that was promoted and promoted and promoted why not fake it on a normal show especially when its not live so you can just edit what you ant to edit out.
bc believe it or not, kids watch the show too, they did it to soup up the halloween special, bc normally they dont get a whole lot of paranormal activity on regular episodes. and it was really obvious on the halloween special that it was rigged.
So kids its ok to cheat if its really important! Was that the message they wanted? How about kids we are a good show with integrity so if nothing happenes that is what we will have to show. See that would be a better thing for kids.
well, u persistant bastard, they did it for a little something called ENTERTAINMENT. bc on HALLOWEEN which incase u didnt know is a holiday were scary shit is supposed to happen. so the kids would turn on t.a.p.s to see some crazy shit happen, so they rigged a couple things that one time to make it looked like there was more paranormal activity then what there really was. oh, there message was that they care about the viewers' being enertained. smart ass.
Why am I a bastard for responding to comments on my video? Am I not allowed? And doing it for entertainment would be a fine reason if they didn't claim it was true. They consider themselves more like a documentary on ghost hunting then an entertainment show. And that is how fans look at it. I know a lot of fans who would have preferred no faking over this.
no, thats how YOU see it. im not gonna argue with u. this is bullshit. u r fucking annoying as shit, and im not gonna keep this shit up, its pointless.
No what I said is how many fans feel about the show. They feel it is like a documentary that it is true events. If you want to see stuff happening all the time you can watch Paranormal State or A Haunting. But the members of TAPS have said it themselves that not finding stuff all the time shows that they are honest. You are commenting on my video so I don't know why you are so angry that I respond. If you want me to stop responding then stop commenting.
I don't know if they fake everything. I used to say how St. A lighthouse could have been fake but I didn't think it definitely was. However since the Halloween episode now I am not sure. I am not sure about St. A lighthouse or a number of other episodes. Because if they were willing to fake once whats to say it was the first time or the only time. So its just that I'm not sure anymore.
seriously..."if it can be recreated or debunked than its not paranormal" didnt Grant say that himself...or something like it? so this guy can recreate it...so its not real..correct me if im wrong
"grant is a great christian guy I dont belive in my heart he would lie"
Oh please, the drama is killing me. Just because someone's a christian doesn't make them a good person. I know a lot of scumbags who are christians. Your religion doesn't render you immune from lying to make a buck.
He doesn't care, he probably doesn't let his kids see videos like these showing him to be a liar anyways. Look at all the drooling worshipers of this man who can't admit what they're seeing with their own eyes.
yea sure a ghost pulls on your collar and he still has his hand in his pocket comon dont fall for this crap people dont you think that if something paranormal tuched me i dont think i would be so callm about it
grant is a great christian guy I dont belive in my heart he would lie come on people his kids watch this do you think he would lie thats like so its ok to lie to a kid get a life and leav taps alone aleast they make a lot of money
Just because I question the show doesn't mean I'm not a fan. In fact I am a huge fan and Grant was my fav. All I did with this video was what Jason and Grant would do if they were presented with the evidence they gave us. I wasn't there so I don't know but what I do know is that it can be recreated just as much as some things they have discredited in past episodes.
I saw Grant a couple of weeks ago, and he swore up & down that the collar pull thing was for real. If you look at the vid closely, Grant's hand is in his pants pocket in the 1st and 3rd times. The 2nd time, his hand is outside of the pocket. He swears that it happened. I don't believe Grant is a liar.
Great job! Very well implemented! Grant, Jason, the TAPS/Ghost Hunters team and those who run the SciFi Channel are frauds and driven only by money. My message to them: Shame on you for thinking that we, the viewing audience, is ignorant enough to believe the garbage shown during the live special. Redeem a fraction of your dignity and admit your mistake.
EVPs are so easy to make.. Seeing that TAPS uses "Adobe Audition" to record they basically show they have editing programs that can be used to modify anything
I don't know what happened but I have a severely ill child and would do anything to better his and my other children's lives. On the other hand what message does that give your kids? It is the million dollar question. It is after all t.v.
wouldnt the string and safety pin have been located somewhere near the inside of his jacket near his hands? if so, im pretty positive he shows us his hands while it happens one of the times...
very disappointed of what happen in the live event. but still i dun blame them . Its live , they will need to show something. if this investigation came out nothing alot of people will be disappointed of wasting their time to watch and stuff. i still watch ghost hunters now and still love it. no point hating the show for just one fake investigation
I can do that to...it doesn´t prove that it DIDN´T happen. Also you missed alot of other stuff like the heat on the collar and so on...but it doesn´t mather...you have proved nothing.
Right I didn't prove anything and neither did they. I showed it could be re-created hence the title. Maybe if I had a thermal camera there would have been a temperature change. The temperature change could have been as simple as the heat trapped between the coat and his body being exposed to cold air.
Still, Grant and Jason NEVER stated it was a ghost or anything...just that it got pulled for whatever reason. I can re-create just about ANYTHING and still...no proof of nothing. So, it´s pretty useless.
I did exactly what they would do when trying to debunk, I can find a natural explanation for it so we can't count it. And on the reveal I'm pretty sure they said it was an interesting occurrence or something but on a show called Ghost Hunters when they say we got some pretty good stuff . . . . you could draw some conclusions.
Good job and good comments. I have heard Jason and Grant say many times on the show that if it can be explained, re-enacted or faked it has to be dismissed as evidence. Debunking is what made the show credible to me from the beginning. This coat pull is easily debunked as you have shown. Excellent video.
"Grant and Jason never stated it was a ghost.." so therefore it's not really cheating if they did stage it? Is that what you're saying? because that's not much of a defence. Your need to believe it's true is overriding seeing what's in front of your face. Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.. a recreation with a pin is precisely the opposite AND it fits the bill.
People are arguing with me saying Jay and Grant never said it was ghost. I meant to be pointing out that on a show called ghost hunters if they find something they call interesting it can be inferred they mean ghosts. I think it was fake that is way I made the recreation sorry if I wasn't clear.
No no, I am ENTIRELY agreeing with you, Jorekkeroj. I was trying to say that frx2000 has a lot to prove. Whereas you have offered the simple solution - one that's much more likely. Your video is great.
anything,wether real or fake can be recreated with enough enginuity.One should not acuse another of lying unless he or she is absolutly shure they are lying and the only one that knows fur sure is grant himself
Tell them that they Rule and to keep up the good work and there TRUE FANS love them. Tell them not to pay any attention to these fickel fans that question their Integrity.
I've been watching the show since day one. Nobody that I know thinks the show is real. But, in June, I went to a screening of the show that was done at The Red Mill in Clinton NJ. People were there swore that these things happened to them and that TAPS was on the level. So, when I see them on 11-26 in Westfield NJ, I'll ask them what the story is.
I so agree with you! These people saying they're fans of the show yet they're saying they are fake and dissing the show or the people in the show. I am a true fan and none of these fake fans were there so they shouldn't talk or try this stupid stuff. And they are wasting their time watching the show if they are watching it to debunk them. That's stupid, crazy, pointless, and cruel!
I was as big of a fan as anyone. I have watched them from their first show. I used to tell people it is a great show you just have to believe them, which i did, and they find some amazing things. I have never watched an episode trying to debunk it but after the halloween show I went onto youtube to see if I was alone in thinking it was fishy...I wasn't. Just because you refuse to question them doesn't make you a "true fan" or better than anyone else who does and you shouldn't insult them for it.
I don't question the team as I wasn't there and if you were actually there experiencing what they were experiencing then my apologies but if you weren't there then you shouldn't assume that it's fake. If anyone is a true fan of anyone (celebrity, etc.) then you talk negative of them then they are not true fans. I wasn't intending to insult anyone, I was merely stating a fact. I think it's dumb, crazy, pointless, and cruel to talk like that of other people when they weren't there with them...
And are judging and assuming they know what they are talking about. Why should I question them when I wasn't there? I don't assume or judge without knowing the facts and only way I can get the facts is if I was there and I was not there. I have no reason whatsoever to question what they do. Have a great day!
Here head moves back and Grant's is completly stationary while his body keeps walking forward. There's no faking this part. The tug is real. Everyone get over it.
Yeah he was completely upright until a moment after the actual pulling began, and then he started moving back. Plus I did not see his collar moving back that far, or at least as far as her collar goes. So I think they were being authentic...and anyway why would they fake something when they are professional investigators? They would know better.
After I saw this, I saw another video that actually showed the moments BEFORE this footage took place...they were fluffing up his collar and when one of them patted him on the back, the part of his collar that had gone down in the footage from the "ghostly pull" went down! I think there might have been something to the hoax idea.
I agree...show this at multiple angles and speeds...but it does pull down and towards (as iamnotimpressed says, so it's not a total debunking), but great job at recreation.
I do still feel TAPS has integrity, but I really do appreciate a skeptics view. Send this into TAPS.
I could if I want to put another in in my jacket and go through the whole upload process again. I wasn't really aiming at a total debunking just showing it could be done easily. I will see maybe I will do it again. If I do I will link it as a video response.
Why send it to TAPS? They know they faked it. I personally see it as a complete debunking. Good Jorekkeroj. It doesn't need to be shown in multple angles and speeds. Thats just an attempt to make Jorekkeroj jump though more hoops then what is needed. She has shown that it work and it looks just like Grants exicution of it.
Lets look at the laws of physics. For every action there is an equal and opposite reaction. Grants jacket pulls OUT and AWAY from his back not down and towards it. Unless you had a fishing line rigged against the carven wall you cannot get that effect. Just remember what you were taught in basic science class. This so called Recreation clearly shows the jacket being pulled DOWN and TOWARDS
I never would of dreamed it either 'iamnotimpressed'....It's a shame and a sad week for the millions who have believed TAPS for years. NOBODY likes to be taken for a fool. That was too light of pull on the collar to stop Grant in his tracks. For something to actually pull him back on one leg, the whole coat would have to be pulled around the front of his neck,,*HARD* The very tip of his hood came down a little, yet he acted like he got snagged by barb wire running at full speed.. Sad, Sad, Sad.
Actually, I tried this with my hand, on a friend's coat collar, just to see what her reaction would be and it was very similar to Grant's. Try it on someone w/o warning. You really need very little effort.
Skeptics maybe skeptics but I am a fan of the show and Grant was my fav. So being a skeptic doesn't just pass off the fact that a lot of fans are pissed about this.
Thank u! I am a fan, a skeptic, but also a believer (but not a blind one). TAPS always says if something cannot be recreated, it may be paranormal, or just a personal experience, which may or may not be paranormal in nature. I feel in ur video it does pull down instead of up & out, but I would love to see a more in depth recreaction. U have done a great job. I have met J&G several times & feel they have are honest & have integrity, but by their own statements...can it be recreated?
what a cheap shot! you actually believe this clown?
TO ALL THOSE WHO WANT TO BRING TAPS DOWN:
if you don't like TAPS or GH, then they don't like you, too. they don't even have an inkling that YOU exist. the show WILL GO ON without your support and even with your baseless criticisms. so i suggest you get over yourselves and GET A LIFE.
Hey Annika RELAX!!! We all have a right to express our beliefs and opinions. If you are so damn Irked by these comments then don't read them. Seems to me that you are part of TAPS crew or related to the TAPS crew. Either way, take a midol and chill the fuck out.
Calm down I actually liked TAPS and Grant was my favorite on the team. My criticism is not baseless and I have every right to it. Believe it or not sometimes fas of the show can change their minds.
The reason I am BORING u with this same response, yet again, is that dfelts says it takes alot of effort, when in fact, it takes very little effort to pull someone who is walking, back...sleep well tonite.
I apologize. This part is NOT just for spzodiac: I feel all this hype is getting out of hand, at least for me. I have had experiences & trust TAPS, but I do appreciate the skeptics. Just defending TAPS. The skeptics also have the right, but in a nicer way, to challenge this. Please, everyone, just either, believe it, or stop watching, or continue for your own personal reasons.
there is no connection point on grant's collar first of all, you can see how sharp the point of your collar is when it goes back, watch grant's again, you wont' see that on his
two, his arms did not move as violently or as far out as yours, and it is impossible to do that without moving your arm very evidently
Yes there is I watched it. His coat goes back it looks like if it was a ghost instead of grabbing they just put a finger on it. His coat gets pulled the same way in the ame spot all three times.
sum one off camera is pulling a string in this clip during a live show?... yeah ok... you guys are too quick to believe a dubunking, instead of looking aqt camera evidence from all angles.
No one off camera needs to be pulling a string I pulled my own string. And just cause its live there doesn't mean they didn't practice first. I am just practicing what Jay and Grant preach. If I had seen that clip of Grant and I didn't know him I would have thought for certain it was fake and I bet a lot of TAPS fans would have debunked it in a heart beat if not for the fact that it was Grant.
Very good debunking video....great job!! I have to clear something up for some people. People are saying his hand isnt in his coat pocket and that is doesnt even have pockets. Thats correct, his hand stay in his pants pocket the whole time. And from this video you can see how easy it is to fake it. Good job!
I can't cause I already removed the 'contraption' (can't give away my secret!) If I was thinking I would have done the side shot too like in the first pull.
I think it definitely shows the possibility that it is faked. It certainly shows how. I had similar results. The hood went down (not in and not to the right)
can I sell you believers a share in the Golden Gate Bridge. I am open for bids!
upussey 1 year ago
You cant take one thing that happens on it for real now. TAPS has 0 credibility. The rest of the cast know what Grant's doing and they play along with it each and every time.
5 years of work and every peice of evidence they came up with has to be thrown out as it's no longer trusted.
Still makes for a good show to fall asleep to though. And get some laughs at some of the stupid shit Grant does like the jacket pull and him pulling a lamp cord to make it look like a ghost moved it. LOL
Titusx66 2 years ago
@Titusx66 If someone else presented TAPS with what they try to pass off as real TAPS would turn it down as fast as they turned down the Lizzie Borden House and that place in California.
jorekkeroj 1 year ago
Watching it again has made me critical of what goes on in the show. Mostly what grant does. Like in the new one s5e22 his light goes off and on too many times, while everyone else gets footsteps and breezes. :|
I know a bit of it is probably real, but it's a bit painful thinking... are they doing this for the ratings? Is this fake?
I still watch it though to take what I can out of it. I feel it used to be 100% true, now I question things that can easily be faked (mostly what Grant does).
Maverynthia 2 years ago
i believe maybe at one time gh was real, till the network thought it was boring and now they just try to get ratings, fuck the fans the money talks!
dopeybear420 2 years ago
lol nice 1
CanadianMailbox 2 years ago
The thing is grant reacted just like this person recreated. I too was a big fan and I think Grant and taps felt pressure from the networks to come up with evidence. Even though, that stunt took me out of the show, we all know that something like a Jacket tug by a ghost can't be caught on tap in that dramatic fashion unless it is recreated in a movie. F--k taps, they didnt have to pull that B.S.
sltayo 2 years ago
Hi sltay.
You know, I was pretty pissed off that they pulled that crap, too. But that doesn't mean you have to stop watching the show. I still watch the show but not in the sam manner as I used to watch. I used to watch to see what kind of ghosts they would catch on film. Now I make a game out of trying to figure out how they fake evidence. To tell you the truth, my little game has made the show a little more entertaining. Just try it for yourself and keep in touch. Happy huntings, my friend.
theonlyyamaman 2 years ago
theonlyyamaman,
Well I still cant find the reason to watch it anymore but if i did I would watch it like you do and find the next B---s--t trick they try to pull. i dont know, maybe I'll try it but i just dont like anybody who doesn't have the integrity to own up and fess up. Regardless i still believe in ghosts and G H just doesn't do it for me anymore. Thanks for the reply,
Take it easy.
sltayo 2 years ago
Bow to King Tracy
TapsRulesAndYouSuck 2 years ago
No.
jorekkeroj 2 years ago
one problem in your recreation, Grants hand moved upward not downward.
buccsgirl17 2 years ago
Real ghosts will never be caught because too many morons like you keep saying everything is fake.
thedarkallies 2 years ago
Funny thing is Jo beleives in ghosts and enjoyed Ghost Hunters until this episode
AgravaineNYR 2 years ago
Yes, shame on her, no ghosts will ever be caught, because she can recreate TAPS hoaxes. Her honesty and truth seeking does a disservice to all of us blind sheep within the TAPS herd.
michiganmoon 2 years ago
You have to look at it through another perspective as well. People will find REAL ghost footage hard to believe because there are so many morons creating fakes out there.
theonlyyamaman 2 years ago
Yeah but here is the thing I believe in ghosts so the you don't find footage cause you don't believe doesn't work well.
jorekkeroj 2 years ago
What the...?!? Who says I don't believe in ghosts? The reason why I watched these shows in the first place was because of my strong belief in ghosts. Then I realized and saw how big of fakes they were. Now I watch to see how they are going to try to fake something next. I still strongly believe in ghosts and I still watch these shows. However, now I'm pissed off because these fakes use that belief you and I carry to exploit us with these fakes. You have to admit, it's pretty messed up of them.
theonlyyamaman 2 years ago
Sorry I didn't mean to be questioning your belief in ghosts. I read your post to quickly. Sorry :-)
jorekkeroj 2 years ago
Very nice recreation.
DixieComic 2 years ago
Ha, that's kind of funny. Your all still haters and will be dealt with accordingly
TapsRulesAndYouSuck 2 years ago
dont worry about ppl like 'tapsrulesandyousuck' they are on scifi's payroll
kentan2202 2 years ago
its so obvious grant faked the whole thing
kentan2202 2 years ago
Great video I applaud your debunking and your showing the world how TAPS COMMTTIED FRAUD! Good Job!
ghostfraud 2 years ago
You haters are my problem and I have a gift for you all.... Its Pure Hatetred, do you like it?
TapsRulesAndYouSuck 3 years ago
You keep referring to haters. This video was not made by a 'hater' it was made by a fan who saw what looks like a trick that can be easily recreated and did exactly what Jay and Grant would want if the evidence had been presented to them. So really stop with the hater cause that isn't the case here.
jorekkeroj 2 years ago
That almost looks exactly like what happend to Grant. try it on a lighter colored coat so we can see more contrast, but well done. and "Tansrulesand you suck", you do have some kind of a problem, go see a shrink. I am a fan of the show and I think they used to be honest on their investigations, but I think SciFi told them to keep the live show entertaining by faking this stuff. It's going to be hard for me to believe them now. at least until they come clean about what happened.
iowafarmboy 3 years ago
Hey there IdobelievethatIsuck you wanna dance with me. You think you have the balls to go toe to toe with the TRUTH. I did not think so....Stupid Hater
TapsRulesAndYouSuck 3 years ago
tapsrules you are an idiot!!!
idobelieveinghosts 3 years ago
Have a nice life Hater. I am the Truth, and I have spoken
TapsRulesAndYouSuck 3 years ago
you are small time and I can not waste my time on you. I have to put the big time haters in their place. I am the basher of the bashers. I am a hero! A voice for the mute. A hope for the hopeless. I am the hater of the haters, their worst nightmare. Do not mess with me, for I am the truth.
TapsRulesAndYouSuck 3 years ago
You have a serious complex?!? You aren't the truth you are apparently a real serious fan who has taken things real far. I'm a fan of the show and a believer in the paranormal. So no matter how much I like the show when I see evidence that looks suspect it is in the best interest of science to debunk. Which TAPS claims to do. In this case it is easily recreated.
jorekkeroj 3 years ago
You are a joke. Stupid hater
TapsRulesAndYouSuck 3 years ago
I'm not a joke or a hater. I am a fan who is disappointed in what looks to me to be clearly fake. This is nothing different then what Grant or Jason would do if they were presented with the footage we saw in the special.
jorekkeroj 3 years ago
they faked it for halloween, thats it. most every other episode is 100% real, nonrigged, paranormal activities.
onelove5191 3 years ago
They faked it once then what guarantees every other episode is 100% rigged? Nothing and if they faked something on an episode that was promoted and promoted and promoted why not fake it on a normal show especially when its not live so you can just edit what you ant to edit out.
jorekkeroj 3 years ago
bc believe it or not, kids watch the show too, they did it to soup up the halloween special, bc normally they dont get a whole lot of paranormal activity on regular episodes. and it was really obvious on the halloween special that it was rigged.
onelove5191 3 years ago
So kids its ok to cheat if its really important! Was that the message they wanted? How about kids we are a good show with integrity so if nothing happenes that is what we will have to show. See that would be a better thing for kids.
jorekkeroj 3 years ago
well, u persistant bastard, they did it for a little something called ENTERTAINMENT. bc on HALLOWEEN which incase u didnt know is a holiday were scary shit is supposed to happen. so the kids would turn on t.a.p.s to see some crazy shit happen, so they rigged a couple things that one time to make it looked like there was more paranormal activity then what there really was. oh, there message was that they care about the viewers' being enertained. smart ass.
onelove5191 3 years ago
Why am I a bastard for responding to comments on my video? Am I not allowed? And doing it for entertainment would be a fine reason if they didn't claim it was true. They consider themselves more like a documentary on ghost hunting then an entertainment show. And that is how fans look at it. I know a lot of fans who would have preferred no faking over this.
jorekkeroj 3 years ago
no, thats how YOU see it. im not gonna argue with u. this is bullshit. u r fucking annoying as shit, and im not gonna keep this shit up, its pointless.
onelove5191 3 years ago
No what I said is how many fans feel about the show. They feel it is like a documentary that it is true events. If you want to see stuff happening all the time you can watch Paranormal State or A Haunting. But the members of TAPS have said it themselves that not finding stuff all the time shows that they are honest. You are commenting on my video so I don't know why you are so angry that I respond. If you want me to stop responding then stop commenting.
jorekkeroj 3 years ago
well, thatrs what i said in the first place is that its real shit, and it seemed like u was acting as if they fake everything that happens.
onelove5191 3 years ago
I don't know if they fake everything. I used to say how St. A lighthouse could have been fake but I didn't think it definitely was. However since the Halloween episode now I am not sure. I am not sure about St. A lighthouse or a number of other episodes. Because if they were willing to fake once whats to say it was the first time or the only time. So its just that I'm not sure anymore.
jorekkeroj 3 years ago
seriously..."if it can be recreated or debunked than its not paranormal" didnt Grant say that himself...or something like it? so this guy can recreate it...so its not real..correct me if im wrong
heluvagoodgurlie08 3 years ago
i do believe that jason said the same thing..
heluvagoodgurlie08 3 years ago
"grant is a great christian guy I dont belive in my heart he would lie"
Oh please, the drama is killing me. Just because someone's a christian doesn't make them a good person. I know a lot of scumbags who are christians. Your religion doesn't render you immune from lying to make a buck.
He doesn't care, he probably doesn't let his kids see videos like these showing him to be a liar anyways. Look at all the drooling worshipers of this man who can't admit what they're seeing with their own eyes.
CapnDingo 3 years ago
yea sure a ghost pulls on your collar and he still has his hand in his pocket comon dont fall for this crap people dont you think that if something paranormal tuched me i dont think i would be so callm about it
octacon1223 3 years ago 4
grant is a great christian guy I dont belive in my heart he would lie come on people his kids watch this do you think he would lie thats like so its ok to lie to a kid get a life and leav taps alone aleast they make a lot of money
shauna1142006 3 years ago
Just because I question the show doesn't mean I'm not a fan. In fact I am a huge fan and Grant was my fav. All I did with this video was what Jason and Grant would do if they were presented with the evidence they gave us. I wasn't there so I don't know but what I do know is that it can be recreated just as much as some things they have discredited in past episodes.
jorekkeroj 3 years ago
I saw Grant a couple of weeks ago, and he swore up & down that the collar pull thing was for real. If you look at the vid closely, Grant's hand is in his pants pocket in the 1st and 3rd times. The 2nd time, his hand is outside of the pocket. He swears that it happened. I don't believe Grant is a liar.
harpo103 3 years ago 3
Great job! Very well implemented! Grant, Jason, the TAPS/Ghost Hunters team and those who run the SciFi Channel are frauds and driven only by money. My message to them: Shame on you for thinking that we, the viewing audience, is ignorant enough to believe the garbage shown during the live special. Redeem a fraction of your dignity and admit your mistake.
BellaDea81 3 years ago
EVPs are so easy to make.. Seeing that TAPS uses "Adobe Audition" to record they basically show they have editing programs that can be used to modify anything
zenister80 3 years ago
I don't know what happened but I have a severely ill child and would do anything to better his and my other children's lives. On the other hand what message does that give your kids? It is the million dollar question. It is after all t.v.
kewlmomto5 3 years ago
wouldnt the string and safety pin have been located somewhere near the inside of his jacket near his hands? if so, im pretty positive he shows us his hands while it happens one of the times...
sebflute07 3 years ago
Nope... sorry, he don't!
nater1993 3 years ago
Haha! That was great. Good job!
Clipartlife 3 years ago
man
they are full of crap
they have been caught!!
u idiots
foreverscubbely 3 years ago
very disappointed of what happen in the live event. but still i dun blame them . Its live , they will need to show something. if this investigation came out nothing alot of people will be disappointed of wasting their time to watch and stuff. i still watch ghost hunters now and still love it. no point hating the show for just one fake investigation
xenocollin 3 years ago
I can do that to...it doesn´t prove that it DIDN´T happen. Also you missed alot of other stuff like the heat on the collar and so on...but it doesn´t mather...you have proved nothing.
frx2000 3 years ago
Right I didn't prove anything and neither did they. I showed it could be re-created hence the title. Maybe if I had a thermal camera there would have been a temperature change. The temperature change could have been as simple as the heat trapped between the coat and his body being exposed to cold air.
jorekkeroj 3 years ago
Still, Grant and Jason NEVER stated it was a ghost or anything...just that it got pulled for whatever reason. I can re-create just about ANYTHING and still...no proof of nothing. So, it´s pretty useless.
frx2000 3 years ago
I did exactly what they would do when trying to debunk, I can find a natural explanation for it so we can't count it. And on the reveal I'm pretty sure they said it was an interesting occurrence or something but on a show called Ghost Hunters when they say we got some pretty good stuff . . . . you could draw some conclusions.
jorekkeroj 3 years ago
Good job and good comments. I have heard Jason and Grant say many times on the show that if it can be explained, re-enacted or faked it has to be dismissed as evidence. Debunking is what made the show credible to me from the beginning. This coat pull is easily debunked as you have shown. Excellent video.
Clipartlife 3 years ago
"Grant and Jason never stated it was a ghost.." so therefore it's not really cheating if they did stage it? Is that what you're saying? because that's not much of a defence. Your need to believe it's true is overriding seeing what's in front of your face. Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.. a recreation with a pin is precisely the opposite AND it fits the bill.
Eponaceae 3 years ago
People are arguing with me saying Jay and Grant never said it was ghost. I meant to be pointing out that on a show called ghost hunters if they find something they call interesting it can be inferred they mean ghosts. I think it was fake that is way I made the recreation sorry if I wasn't clear.
jorekkeroj 3 years ago
No no, I am ENTIRELY agreeing with you, Jorekkeroj. I was trying to say that frx2000 has a lot to prove. Whereas you have offered the simple solution - one that's much more likely. Your video is great.
Eponaceae 3 years ago
grant has lost his credibility
kentan2202 3 years ago
anything,wether real or fake can be recreated with enough enginuity.One should not acuse another of lying unless he or she is absolutly shure they are lying and the only one that knows fur sure is grant himself
rainydaze1 3 years ago
I was doing what Jay and Grant would have done had this been presented to them by another investigator.
jorekkeroj 3 years ago
welldone
porkisgood4u 3 years ago
I'll see them in a couple of weeks and I'll ask them what happened.
harpo103 3 years ago
Tell them that they Rule and to keep up the good work and there TRUE FANS love them. Tell them not to pay any attention to these fickel fans that question their Integrity.
iamnotimpressed 3 years ago
I've been watching the show since day one. Nobody that I know thinks the show is real. But, in June, I went to a screening of the show that was done at The Red Mill in Clinton NJ. People were there swore that these things happened to them and that TAPS was on the level. So, when I see them on 11-26 in Westfield NJ, I'll ask them what the story is.
harpo103 3 years ago
I so agree with you! These people saying they're fans of the show yet they're saying they are fake and dissing the show or the people in the show. I am a true fan and none of these fake fans were there so they shouldn't talk or try this stupid stuff. And they are wasting their time watching the show if they are watching it to debunk them. That's stupid, crazy, pointless, and cruel!
Rock2HAL 3 years ago
I was as big of a fan as anyone. I have watched them from their first show. I used to tell people it is a great show you just have to believe them, which i did, and they find some amazing things. I have never watched an episode trying to debunk it but after the halloween show I went onto youtube to see if I was alone in thinking it was fishy...I wasn't. Just because you refuse to question them doesn't make you a "true fan" or better than anyone else who does and you shouldn't insult them for it.
viper100200 3 years ago
I don't question the team as I wasn't there and if you were actually there experiencing what they were experiencing then my apologies but if you weren't there then you shouldn't assume that it's fake. If anyone is a true fan of anyone (celebrity, etc.) then you talk negative of them then they are not true fans. I wasn't intending to insult anyone, I was merely stating a fact. I think it's dumb, crazy, pointless, and cruel to talk like that of other people when they weren't there with them...
Rock2HAL 3 years ago
And are judging and assuming they know what they are talking about. Why should I question them when I wasn't there? I don't assume or judge without knowing the facts and only way I can get the facts is if I was there and I was not there. I have no reason whatsoever to question what they do. Have a great day!
Rock2HAL 3 years ago
Excellent videos ladies.
(itshaunted d o t c o m)
itshaunteddotcom 3 years ago
Again. nice try. You could try to recreate it in 50 different angles and still not get it. Taps is real. End of story!
iamnotimpressed 3 years ago 2
I thought you were a man but your a woman lol a lot of plain woman these days
skateboarder178 3 years ago
Here head moves back and Grant's is completly stationary while his body keeps walking forward. There's no faking this part. The tug is real. Everyone get over it.
valpro99 3 years ago
Yeah he was completely upright until a moment after the actual pulling began, and then he started moving back. Plus I did not see his collar moving back that far, or at least as far as her collar goes. So I think they were being authentic...and anyway why would they fake something when they are professional investigators? They would know better.
angelix 3 years ago 2
I don't know what to think. I still can't see them faking this stuff and the evidence against them isn't solid enough to think it isn't PN.
valpro99 3 years ago
After I saw this, I saw another video that actually showed the moments BEFORE this footage took place...they were fluffing up his collar and when one of them patted him on the back, the part of his collar that had gone down in the footage from the "ghostly pull" went down! I think there might have been something to the hoax idea.
angelix 3 years ago
Great job.. quite impressed.
But you know what?.. I still believe TAPS. I will continue watching as I always have. And they will still be there..
SEASON 5 starts in March..
Believe or don't. Ghost Hunters is great. True FANS Remain.
hatingyoufukks 3 years ago
Me and you, man,we know who is right... and we, the true fans, are right on this on
blizzardhockey4 3 years ago
right on... new episode tonight looks sweet.
hatingyoufukks 3 years ago
hell yeah it does
blizzardhockey4 3 years ago
Good Job sista!
OKCLady 3 years ago 2
To all the skeptics with regards to this video, Jo just admit it, it was a ghost not a contraption that pulled your collar JUST LIKE Grants lol
Lorizh 3 years ago 2
Can the OP of this video do this multiple times and at different angles to shut up all the ghost humpers?
LtStarkiller 3 years ago
I agree...show this at multiple angles and speeds...but it does pull down and towards (as iamnotimpressed says, so it's not a total debunking), but great job at recreation.
I do still feel TAPS has integrity, but I really do appreciate a skeptics view. Send this into TAPS.
roryboryalice 3 years ago
I could if I want to put another in in my jacket and go through the whole upload process again. I wasn't really aiming at a total debunking just showing it could be done easily. I will see maybe I will do it again. If I do I will link it as a video response.
jorekkeroj 3 years ago
Why send it to TAPS? They know they faked it. I personally see it as a complete debunking. Good Jorekkeroj. It doesn't need to be shown in multple angles and speeds. Thats just an attempt to make Jorekkeroj jump though more hoops then what is needed. She has shown that it work and it looks just like Grants exicution of it.
FearTurtles 3 years ago
watch your mouth
wwww6666666666666 3 years ago
Thought I did - LOL. Humpers is a very clean word! Ya know...it's very difficult to find profanity on YouTube!
Anyway, great debunking video. Thanks!
LtStarkiller 3 years ago
grow up..
Lorizh 3 years ago
Lets look at the laws of physics. For every action there is an equal and opposite reaction. Grants jacket pulls OUT and AWAY from his back not down and towards it. Unless you had a fishing line rigged against the carven wall you cannot get that effect. Just remember what you were taught in basic science class. This so called Recreation clearly shows the jacket being pulled DOWN and TOWARDS
iamnotimpressed 3 years ago
The top of my collar move out the rest moves in as it is being pulled down.
jorekkeroj 3 years ago
I never would of dreamed it either 'iamnotimpressed'....It's a shame and a sad week for the millions who have believed TAPS for years. NOBODY likes to be taken for a fool. That was too light of pull on the collar to stop Grant in his tracks. For something to actually pull him back on one leg, the whole coat would have to be pulled around the front of his neck,,*HARD* The very tip of his hood came down a little, yet he acted like he got snagged by barb wire running at full speed.. Sad, Sad, Sad.
dfelts2323 3 years ago
Actually, I tried this with my hand, on a friend's coat collar, just to see what her reaction would be and it was very similar to Grant's. Try it on someone w/o warning. You really need very little effort.
roryboryalice 3 years ago
Taps would never agree to stage any cheep parlor tricks. Come on people. Skeptics will be skeptics.
iamnotimpressed 3 years ago
Skeptics maybe skeptics but I am a fan of the show and Grant was my fav. So being a skeptic doesn't just pass off the fact that a lot of fans are pissed about this.
jorekkeroj 3 years ago
Thank u! I am a fan, a skeptic, but also a believer (but not a blind one). TAPS always says if something cannot be recreated, it may be paranormal, or just a personal experience, which may or may not be paranormal in nature. I feel in ur video it does pull down instead of up & out, but I would love to see a more in depth recreaction. U have done a great job. I have met J&G several times & feel they have are honest & have integrity, but by their own statements...can it be recreated?
roryboryalice 3 years ago
what a cheap shot! you actually believe this clown?
TO ALL THOSE WHO WANT TO BRING TAPS DOWN:
if you don't like TAPS or GH, then they don't like you, too. they don't even have an inkling that YOU exist. the show WILL GO ON without your support and even with your baseless criticisms. so i suggest you get over yourselves and GET A LIFE.
annika829 3 years ago
Hey Annika RELAX!!! We all have a right to express our beliefs and opinions. If you are so damn Irked by these comments then don't read them. Seems to me that you are part of TAPS crew or related to the TAPS crew. Either way, take a midol and chill the fuck out.
lawdog008 3 years ago
Calm down I actually liked TAPS and Grant was my favorite on the team. My criticism is not baseless and I have every right to it. Believe it or not sometimes fas of the show can change their minds.
jorekkeroj 3 years ago
I've seen this person post this exact same thing on other videos.... yawn. Great video by the way!
spzodiac 3 years ago
The reason I am BORING u with this same response, yet again, is that dfelts says it takes alot of effort, when in fact, it takes very little effort to pull someone who is walking, back...sleep well tonite.
roryboryalice 3 years ago
Actually, I was talking about annika829 which is why I replied to annika829s comment.
spzodiac 3 years ago
I apologize. This part is NOT just for spzodiac: I feel all this hype is getting out of hand, at least for me. I have had experiences & trust TAPS, but I do appreciate the skeptics. Just defending TAPS. The skeptics also have the right, but in a nicer way, to challenge this. Please, everyone, just either, believe it, or stop watching, or continue for your own personal reasons.
roryboryalice 3 years ago
I wasn't being mean. I did exactly what Jay and Grant would have done.
jorekkeroj 3 years ago
I used to love the show. I'm not going watch the show again--not even for Kris ;)
Cinemaguy2007 3 years ago
love it!!!
yurlate3wing 3 years ago
Looks almost exactly the same. 5 stars! Thanks!
jcoverload 3 years ago
I accidentally deleted someone's comment but the person who asked the string was inside like I think Grant's would have been.
jorekkeroj 3 years ago
Like your really going to prove anything with a 4 second video. If you really want to debunk anything, you have to show detail.
Influencedbymusic 3 years ago
4 seconds is all i needed to show that it is possible. That was my aim. It may not be exactly the same but it is close.
jorekkeroj 3 years ago
Totally agree, I think a ghost also pulled her collar just like it pulled Grant of TAPS collar. She is just covering up to blemish TAPS.
michiganmoon 3 years ago
horrible
there is no connection point on grant's collar first of all, you can see how sharp the point of your collar is when it goes back, watch grant's again, you wont' see that on his
two, his arms did not move as violently or as far out as yours, and it is impossible to do that without moving your arm very evidently
dan8585 3 years ago
Yes there is I watched it. His coat goes back it looks like if it was a ghost instead of grabbing they just put a finger on it. His coat gets pulled the same way in the ame spot all three times.
jorekkeroj 3 years ago
Very well done, I especially like the arm flail as the pull happens. Great timing.
derekgossett 3 years ago
Thanks
jorekkeroj 3 years ago
sum one off camera is pulling a string in this clip during a live show?... yeah ok... you guys are too quick to believe a dubunking, instead of looking aqt camera evidence from all angles.
arbitrationer 3 years ago
No one off camera needs to be pulling a string I pulled my own string. And just cause its live there doesn't mean they didn't practice first. I am just practicing what Jay and Grant preach. If I had seen that clip of Grant and I didn't know him I would have thought for certain it was fake and I bet a lot of TAPS fans would have debunked it in a heart beat if not for the fact that it was Grant.
jorekkeroj 3 years ago
true. good response.
arbitrationer 2 years ago
GH IS FAKE....my heart is broken I thought alot of this team....:(
Deltarow 3 years ago
I really liked Grant to he was my fav on the team.
jorekkeroj 3 years ago
Wow, great job! Show this to Grant!!
klinkekula 3 years ago 4
Haha thanks.
jorekkeroj 3 years ago
Very good debunking video....great job!! I have to clear something up for some people. People are saying his hand isnt in his coat pocket and that is doesnt even have pockets. Thats correct, his hand stay in his pants pocket the whole time. And from this video you can see how easy it is to fake it. Good job!
enigmaz9 3 years ago 2
Can you post a couple more angles of this?? Great job!
stuartmoore 3 years ago 2
I can't cause I already removed the 'contraption' (can't give away my secret!) If I was thinking I would have done the side shot too like in the first pull.
jorekkeroj 3 years ago
Great recreation!
cuppacoffeeandacig 3 years ago
Best recreation I've seen so far. You even turned your head to the left as Grant did.
That this can be recreated so easily shows what a simple magician's trick it really is.
Cissy2cute 3 years ago 2
Thanks.
jorekkeroj 3 years ago
Very good work.
moviedan 3 years ago 2
I think it definitely shows the possibility that it is faked. It certainly shows how. I had similar results. The hood went down (not in and not to the right)
jorekkeroj 3 years ago
Hey Jo, it's lazacka, I am impressed girl! I cannot understand how people cannot say that Grant could have faked it after seeing that. NICE JOB! =)
Lorizh 3 years ago 2
It's CamClarkeFans from the IMDb boards,
Impressive how close to the original you got!
Camfans59 3 years ago 4