Chopin etude op 25 n 11 Winter Wind Yundi Li

[AngoSkazz]

I'm cold.

[CD122344]

Notes are there and that's all. It's bland - a run through - no expression! Listen to Lhevinne's recording. You'll hear the difference.

[kwanhui1990]

@CD122344 both have expressions of course, different expressions. One has the expression that you prefer.

[CD122344]

@kwanhui1990 Sorry, speed - great technique, nothing else - sounds like a computer played it - no climax at 2:31 leading to the main theme among other things - there are counter melodies all over - you don't hear those - musicianship is required here - even Slenczynska does a better job. You haven't heard enough of the great pianists of the past to offer an opinion many of whom I heard in public including Brailowsky. This is why I don't like commenting on anything - too many baby responses.

[kwanhui1990]

@CD122344 really... musicianship is required? lol I play this song... why don't u upload ur interpretation and I ensure you that I will upload my playing. 

[kwanhui1990]

@CD122344 Sorry if I am rude in my reply, I feel you need to be more humble... any great pianist would not criticize that any one of these grand masters is "bad", but only that one interpretation is preferred, because he'd understand that to play a song in this level'd require over 50 hours of practice at the minimum.

[440HertzPiano]

@kwanhui1990 50 hours!? A pianist such as Yundi shouldn't need 50 hours to master this piece. Since the piece has a lot of similarities to Op. 10 No. 2 and Op. 10 No. 12 among others, he should've be able to learn it fairly easy.

[kwanhui1990]

@CD122344 Like you, I also refrain from debating which pianist is "better". This topic is truly an area of taste which is different from individual to individual and there is really no fruit wouldn't u agree?

[tigertolyy]

yundi li is the greatest pianist ever in the whole worlds history. im blown away. by this winter wind. :)

[loyalistish]

Doesn't take much convincing that this piece is entitled Winter Wind. The speed at which the fingers ae moving along the keyboard is just amazing. I thin Youndi has the best version

[DJodby]

è uno degli studi di chopin che più preferisco!!sto cercando di suonarlo proprio in questo periodo...comunque Yundi Li non è propriamente l'interprete che preferisco...anche se è stao eseguito con molta precisione...

[Nganguen]

""Bellassima""

[Zazzauser]

Io Chopin ce lo vedo esclusivamente suonato da Vasary. Sono in fissa col modo di suonare di quell'uomo.

[MagicDonDino]

se ti posso consigliare ascolterei anche Pherapia e Magaloff.

[Angel94angel94]

Attenzione, vi avviso gentilmente del fatto che in modo reciproco con la mia personalità unica non ho una conoscenza della lingua italiano. Capito? non so l'italiano.

[MagicDonDino]

commento singolare.... lei non è italiano? Io si, ma ancora non comprendo tale commento.

[miliona1re]

La parte della mano sinistra mi piace piu' possente e in generale preferisco un 'esecuzione piu' travolgente e potente soprattutto.Comunque e' sempre da apprezzare la delicatezza e la precisione di Yundi Li.

[MagicDonDino]

Mano sinistra possente ed una esecuzione più travolgente... mmmm come la celebre performance di Richter!!!

[amantedipiano]

bella esecuzione....

[MagicDonDino]

mmmm....... scusa FranzFerenclistz ma non mastico bene l'inglese sono italiano.......:-(

[santissimopadre]

Sublime.....musica e immagini eccelsamente abbinate....complimenti