Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (2,468)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • EVERYONE! Click The Link In the Video To See This amazing performance with the correct Sound and Video!

    My english is not very good but enjoy!

  • Now I've finished writing Swedish lyrics to Vision of love, Vanishing, Emotions, Hero, Without you, Always be my baby, My all, Heartbreaker and We belong together. It's for kind of a musical! I have to say wow to myself. I wish I could show my lyrics to Mariah - she shared an apartment with a Swedish girl in New York right before she break through, and they're still friends.

  • talk about freaky lol

  • sounded like a ghost!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • DAMN Mariah can't hit them notes the way she used to and that kinda makes me sad because i love her. :(

  • i liked the original version better..

  • Wow she did a great job.

  • Ich liebe dieses lied es ist soooo schön

  • Very good. I cant understand why this clip get those comment.

  • Retire

  • she cant reach the notes anymore! but she was my idol but not anymore;(

  • what happened to mariah here? ugly huh!

  • This is funny, she just killed this song and it's her song. How she do that?

  • original is way better, i dont see why people have to change it.

  • somente uma palavra define mariah carey " maravilhosaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa"!

  • That's Live, and only professional singer can do that.

    God bless Mariah too

  • Amazing, she's still the best!

  • I think she was ill that day

  • r.i.p mariah carey

  • lmao

  • mariah carey is NOT dead

  • I like this version of Hero, it's the version of a professional singer, even if on a few words she has done something bad that she had never done in her career.

    p.s. sorry for my English

  • this is has got to be the shittiest performance that mariah carey has done....true i dont y she decided to improvise when she could have just sang the damn song properly....

  • The beginning was a little rough... pitchy and flat sometimes... but its interesting that she got a whole lot better at the end when she was really really singing. I think she was trying to improvise and so the song didnt come out as we expected... in any event, Mimi can still sing! just listen to her new album!

  • God, she just sucks 'live'. Beyonce wiped the floor w/her sorry ass. She woulda done better if she had lip-synched. She has ZERO appeal when she is on-stage. Like watching paint dry. YAWN!!!!!

  • English is not my native language and i would like to know what does she say in the begining

    after "tonight i think we all believe that a ____ ____ more"

    Thank you in advance. :)

  • Chasenip is a loser, he's just jealous MC sounds better than drug addict Whitney Houston, who REALLY lost her voice. Whitney is no more, whereas MC is getting better.

  • Don't like this new version with the extra lyrics.She should have stuck to the past vocal arrangements of the song,those were more emotional and heartfelt.She does look gourgeus though.

  • That's what happens after years of screaming from the top of your lungs...she is still, and will always be AMAZING!!! Just cpmes with age...get used to it!!! lol.

  • Frankly, I don't. As she's lost her voice hopelessly:((

  • after all these years her voice sure changed alot, but it still rocks core

  • nice voice

  • Her voice is ruined now. :( She couldn't as high as before and it's obviously damaged. She used be my favorite singer. This is bad. :(

  • she completely gave her voice to the fans..she was overworked doing all those Europe tours in the 90s..that kinda did it for her voice...But,...we have to remember that great singers have bads days too...

  • that was nice ..bravo mariah !! u were amazin'

  • this was amazing,,the note she held towards the end was amazing!!!!

  • omg what happened to her?? the original HERO doesnt sounds nothing like this.. :"(

  • of course it doesn't! everyones voice changes! she is human u know!

  • She is older is what happened.

  • honestly she sucked at this song...what happened to the old mariah carey??

  • She is 36 not 20 something

  • 39!

  • she is actually 40

  • God this bitch SUCKS!!! All style (and BAD style at that) and ZERO substance!! Twenty years and the bitch has NO stage presence. She makes me wanna BARF!!! Pure ghetto trash, it's like putting perfume on a pig! Nothing more than a man in drag... Take yer millions and yer stank ass perfume and GO AWAY already!!!

  • u should be ashamed talking in such an ugly way of someone like Carey. Yes there were times when she was much better but she got older, man, can't u realize that? and she isn't bad. you should talk with respect - or if u can't, just simply don't say anything.

  • i just love this lady; i love her style and her singing; i love the dress she has on, u go mariah, much love. 10-15-09.

  • Man i love Mariah..but this wasn't her performance and especially for the president... man this sucked.

  • Ppl that gave her a hard time about the MJ memorial should be ashamed of themselves!!! Period! You get up and sing at a loved ones funeral and do a good job! Could you do that for a brother, friend, a mentor? No! You couldn't probably even get the the alphabet and she sang an entire song beautifully! Love you Mariah!

  • Lovely! She has lost power definetly but she does her best with what she has. And that makes her an incredible woman.

    "Do the best you can with what you have"

  • she is still just as great if not better than she always was

    always the best

  • she is still great she probally has great days at singing and some bad ones just needs practice

  • I love michael jackson

  • This is just not up to scratch! Compared to the way she used to sing, and even some of the later stuff from october this year is so much better than this. A lot of stupid 'uh uh uh' 'oh oh oh' that's just unnecessary.

  • mariah is still the best.......love her so much......

  • she's even changed her singing style. She adds all these unnecessary "ugh ugh ugh" in between every word in the song and she does this stuff with her hand. can she really not hit the high notes to her own song anymore?

    ***I CONSIDER THE 90's MARIAH AND THIS "MIMI MARIAH" AS TWO DIFFERENT PEOPLE.....CAUSE THEY ARE SO DIFFERENT FROM EACH OTHER

    the 90s mariah was sweet, humble, and caring. this mimi mariah had "obnoxious" written all over her face. i guess that's what happens when FAME gets to you

  • I igree

  • The 90's Mariah was quiet, abused, locked away and controlled, she was lonely, sad, unable to leave her house at a whim, she was followed, she was watched, she was listened to.

    The new Mariah is loud, she is happy, she is free, she has many friends and a gorgeous husband, she can go whereever she wants, she is no longer followed by her husbands cronies, just by fans, she is watched on TV for her talent only, she is listened to for the same reason.

    Think before you speak moron.

  • omg ur comment is sooo good it makes soo much sence the old mariah was told to were a top to her neck an trousers down to her feet its only fair she finally gets a chance to let free no matter what her song is about

  • she's not as good as she used to be, I don't know what the hell happened. I now think she's overrated, nice person, but she's overrated now

  • i don't think so...

  • Thank god to give her that voice. Thank you Madame for being who you are.

  • love this performance!

  • DIVA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!4 eva

  • perdon??? esta es maryah carey??? esa no es su voz!!!

  • I am Loving it ALOT!!

  • She´s beautiful song... I love Mariah Carey she´s perfect...Congratulations!!!!

  • Comment removed

  • omgg where is that beautifull strong voice :((((((

  • I felt like she was hurting, and that's why she couldn't get those notes at this performance.

  • well i think that mariah always makes a new "version" of her old songs, cause she maybe can not sing them like she did in the 90s, and everybody would say"she lost her voice" and the media would attack her.

    thats just an attempt to hide/avoid this, but thats ok, but i love the original versions.

    she should stick on balads and not try out hiphop rap things, that is not her field, she only sounds ridicolous

    but with this balads

    wow there she is : the mariah everybody loves!!

  • ...and this is just a proof that MC is such a versatile singer...imagine, her original song in a different rendetion? amazing

    ...and by the way, i just viewed the video of her on a studio rearranging and recording the newer version of her song hero

  • yes, mariah is always trying to put up a new version of her songs...she's definitely trying to render the same old song in a newer version and that she just wanted to try to deliver the song in a way that it will sound a bit different from the original version...

  • she is getting older but she is still a great singer

  • shes amazin but her voice has definitely changed over the years

  • I think Mariah loves to experiment with her voice. She'll always give a different performance with the same song, so it gives you the feel like its a new song.

    Keep up the good work Mariah(:

  • Mariah I love You

  • EU ADORO AS MUSICAS DA MARAIH CAREY

  • soooo wonderful ♥

  • i love this song from her, and this is so emotional and powerfull

  • es unica!!

    pero parece ke este afonica no?o costipada pero de todas formas es lo mejor

    michael jackson siempre estaras en nuestros corazones

  • even with her voice being deteriorated she is still better than 99% of people alive. shes so awesome

  • I learned how to sing myself and I have a great talent on listening closely. This performance was scrachy but as a singer you do have bad days, but that doesn´t mean that you are going to loose your voice or even loose your talent. Mariah is unique so that means different than others. She always sang on a very difficult way. She sang the song in the right key on that night. That was one of her easier song. I can even sing it myself and that means somethin because I don't come close to Mariah.

  • I'm from Brazil ... Mariah Carey and an amazing singer! I love You

  • she is amazing sinfer and have unique talent of singing, she is great

  • NICE

  • makes leona lewis sound amateur (nt sayin leona is bad this is amazing)

  • I don't think this was her best vocal performance but I genuinely think it was difficult for her to deliver what with it being so emotional etc.

    But there were moments in that performance definitely... she's still got it in there somewhere :)) I mean she can still hit those high notes....

  • wwow esta letra tan original me encanta

  • adoreii

    sou do Brasil

    ao vooc MARIAH CAREY

    bey bey

  • wat a flop

    omg i luvved her back in the day now she finks shes beyonce

  • OH she has lost all her beautiful voice it doesnt sound equal anymore... so sad...:(

  • I think it will be good if someone can define the meaning of NODULES. Not all people or foreigners understand the word. Sorry for the ignorance....

    I love mariah and for me she's more than a Hero

  • damn,,,, so amazing ;)

  • more of her here amandasfirst,co,cc

  • i know she sucked but she later stated she was to choked up from crying to sing good

  • she sings good; she´s a good singer... I hope you sing better; if not you have no right to say a word....

  • obviously if you could have seen between the lines I stated this performance wasn't that good but her others are just wow. type mariah carey obsessed live she's great

  • hahaha, hahaha, agree

  • i love her absolutely do but definately was not a good performance not hating i love the woman to feath but you gotta admit it shes sing this amzingly so many times but hey everyone heas theit bad days!

  • she hardly wears anything modest.

  • Who are you to judge Mariah? You can sing better than her?

  • NOW MARIAH..... you know good and well that you couldnt BREATHE in that DRESS... let Alone SING in it lmao

    shes Fierce though and looks damn good...so she can do whateva lol

  • Ok I'm no major Mariah fan but c'mon, to those who are moaning about wht she's wearing or whtever, age is nothing but a number and she looks good for her age so she has the right to make the most of that. And as for the performance, it was at a funeral/memorial so i can image her and all the other performers were at least a bit choked up and tht makes it somewhat harder sing.

  • disappointed that was wack ..she been really singing bad lately...she need 2 stop singing them simple song ..and get with the programmm

  • She is still smokin hat so have a stfu haterz..

    Sounds like she had a cold...

  • its not the same mariah carey. shes horrible in this video

  • yah she could of done way better

  • she was singing at funeral ok?

  • shes soo pathetic! cmon now! wat 40year old lady walks around dressed the way she does! she needs to get over the fact that shes not 20 nemore

  • i think she got minor sore throat that is why she didnt sing the extreme part...and she is almost in tune in the first stanza...

  • BOO MARIAH!!! she couldov done so much better! shes awesome but that perfomance was really bad

  • cool performance but where's the power in her voice she used to have?and don't tell me about her age,that's a silly excuse,Celine turned 40 but her voice is still so powerfull..

  • yesh she sang better in the 90s but mc sounded wonerful her

  • I agree with you on this she does sing better in the 90's

  • im sorry, but no. no. no. no.

  • she great even tho she didnt hit the high mariah carey pitch she could. shes still my wife. always has been. always will be.

  • I think she was trying to do a different version..but its HORRIBLEEEEEEEEE

  • wat fuckin bull crap

  • I just would like to say whether or not it's to peoples liking of what you knew Mariah as she's been doing this pretty much for 19 years and in a decades time she had no rest in between to strengthen her vocal chords.I love this song no matter which version she sings this song in because to me what she's done for my life through this song is amazing.Mariah thank you so much for performing you'll always be a favorite of mine regardless of what others say..

  • I just think Mariah needs alot of vocal rest. Maybe like a year or two honestly, just so maybe her vocal chords can restrengthen, I mean she has been singing in the whistle register for 19 years now. Eventually, that is going to take it's toll on your singing ability.

  • yeah, people change there's nothing constant around.. but we should worry not cause MC always give great things per ERA. (MOAIA)..

    and i dont think this was a bad performance she tried to bring back the 90's version of her HERO so no sweat!

  • mariah is a great singer ive listened 2 hur since i was a little kid but in this performance she is short of breath and voice just accept it people she had hur best times everybody getting older:)

  • When I first heard this performance, I thought it was pretty bad. But now, I don't actually think it's that horrible o.o She hits all the right notes and it may be a little rough on some parts but overall it's not a terrible performance like everyone says it is.

  • WHERE DID HER VOICE GO?????

  • no wer

    CANT U HEAR HEAR HER SINGING COS I NO U CNT DO BETA

    SO SHULUP

  • sumppl juscomment nd they don realise tht they r not even 1% of what she is

  • Mariah carey is so fucking amazing!!!

  • Hey guys

    Unless ya done public vocals live u have no idea what u talki about. This is a great performance live. The problem is - what you get used to is the touched up, computerised version. this was a truly good performance. x

  • the best performance was the BEYONCE'S at last

  • Whitney, er, Mariah, what happened?

  • I used to enjoy Mariah in the very beginning of her career, but I believe she should give her voice a rest. I think so many high notes has strained her to almost unrepair....She might want to retrain her voice with a very good vocal coach if she wants to sing in the years to come....This is not a mean post...it's a post of grave concern. Take a break Mariah! We still love you, at least, I know I still do. Take care of yourself!

  • anda k no esta casca dios santo

  • i dun see the diva within her animore

  • Common sense will tell you that someone who has been singing professionally for about 20 yrs now will not sound the same as they used. Its just how it is. Simple as that, like someone has already said if you early 90's Mariah go and listen to early 90's Mariah or just appriciate that she still has a gift and is using it the best she can despite the set backs. However this was a great performance especially from 3:08 to the end

  • actually this performance is the best among the performances of the same song for 10 years. She got it back in the second chorus

  • where is her stupid tiny dog?

  • she make the key low she did.nt make it she's deriorating but she sang this from her heart..

  • R.I.P Mariah Carey

  • mariah didnt die mj did

  • welll vocally...she dieying too...(I love her but she should take a break)

  • mariah does not lip the song. mariah has a seven octive voice. mariah can still hit those notes when she wants, trust. its just mariah concentrates too hard on trying to make it sound good instead of singing with emotions like how she use to. Mariah is really insercure, especially since for the past decade, everybody wants to talk about her singing everytime she performs live, lik their waiting for that one note she cant hit, then their lik... oop she cant sing. mariah just has to b secure

  • had a seven octave voice.

  • awful,boring etc. No power, no emotion, awful. 2.53. some parts lip synced.

  • None was lip synces but i agree this was pretty bad. But definetly heart felt.

  • she cant sing no more..maybe thhose silicons on her chest is damaging her!

    she can only oh no oh no no no no more high notes!

  • She sounds awesome as usual. Those who are looking for 1992 stuff, then look there. People get better with age, and, well, Mariah's like a great bottle of wine.

  • who are you trying to kidd?

  • OMG She's lost what makes her different, unique! She sings cool but she's not "Mariah Carey" anymore

  • lip synced the high part. thats true. im a mariah fan and i know that she lipsycs the song. y can she be able to hit the high notes if she cannot sing the song well in the verses??

  • yes she loses her voice and power, but i think its time to lose. now she is not so young. but it seems still beautiful and awesome. no one can follow after her. she is the sole she is original she is still STAR. i Still love her singing and style

  • she lost power

  • wow amazing!

  • cool awesome ;

  • Without sounding rude..

    Whats happened to her voice?

    if u click on her duo with Pavarotti ii get goose bumps listening to it..

    and was expecting to when i listened to this.. but never.. :/

    Mariah Carey is a legend but .. god noes whats happening nowadays. x

  • mariah carey is awesome...but i think that she had lost her real voice...

  • me 2

  • this song really make me cry.. sad

  • this song really make cry

  • SHE WAS OKAY BUT NOT THE SAME

  • she has stressed voice but she still sang it good though.. credit for md. mariah even though she was sick.

  • she's tired.

  • shes not as good as she was but i love her! she could b betta if she really tired its Nick's fault but its ok Mariah lol! ;)

  • NOT AS GOOD AS THE ORIGINAL....

  • True soul!

  • Mariah carey still is the best....MC, Whitney Houston, BEYONCÉ THE BEST SINGERS in the worlddddd..!! so GO DIVAS (L)

  • LOL at 3:28

    LIP-SYNCING FAIL!

    She sang "so", and then realised that the pre-recorded track doesn't have that in it. you can see by her facial expression that she knew she cocked up.

    Wierd how so very few people missed that.

  • She doesn't even say so at 3:28. wtf?

    And, if she was lip syncing you wouldn't be able to hear her breathing in the microphone idiot.

  • agree...noticeable...but she wouldnt sing so horribly in a lip sync performance.. late;y her live singing has been really bad..remember i'll be there at michael jackson memorial... so guess this is live too ;-)

  • Thanks! I guess some people aren't blind.

  • agree...but i still think its live

  • I completly agree

  • See! Someone who has common sense. <3 ;)

  • SHE DID NOT LIP SYNC. you are wrong

  • Okay, believe what you want. But the evidence is there. She cocked up here.

  • She didn't sing "so". I can't believe you think THIS was pre-recorded. But I believe you hit a record in being idotic.

  • I know she didn't. Read it again dumbass. If you actually use your eyes you'll be able to see that she sings "So" at the time I previously posted. But obviously, the pre-recorded last chorus doesn't have that in, so nothing came out and she looked scared as if she had messed up. If she were singing live that "So" would have been sounded, but it wasn't. That's what you call forgetting what is on a pre-recorded track.

    Don't call me idiotic when about 4 people before your comment agreed. Jackass.

  • GREAT !

  • Mariah Carey didn't sing this song as good as when she first sang it was she was an amazing singer but know she is just alright , i don't think she can handle the song anymore which is a shame

  • Yes a shame, this version is down a half-step, and still can't even come close.[to the original]

    Surgery could help, but has LasVegas odds.

    Judging from previous surgeries, she should give it a chance,

    those nodules are awful, It's too bad it even got to this point.

  • Yep, I agree. She's just so fond of her much-achieved whistle register and she has every right to be because it's truly amazing that she doesn't feel comfortable having surgery to remove the nodules

  • Madonna - 2.5m tickets for S & S tour

    Mariah - 2,500 tickets she reportedly can't sell