Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (220)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Very beautiful song. Is it wrong that I'm crying just listening to it? Both Leona and Jennifer did a fantastic job. :,D

  • I like both of them. Strong and powerfull voices... Good job, nice duet.

  • leona lewis ♥

  • I happened to turn the television on hbo and the end of sex and the city 2 was going off, I recognized Jennifer's voice but I couldn't recognized the other exquisite sounding voice. After hearing the song I had to hear it again. Both women sounded beauitiful. I must say I have not heard a song that has moved me in this way in a very long time. "Just when you've thought you've heard it all" here comes a sound to wake your heart up.

  • @chryferram such a pleasant comment very refreshing

    love them both and they sound so good together..

  • its like mariah carey and whitney houston great voices and song they should do this live

  • They both have amazing vibrato, but if I had to pick I like Leona's vibrato/belting better. It's fuller and has more warmth/sweetness to it, which is a very unique combination.

  • Thank You Ms.Jennifer Hudson & Leona Lewis for a Beautiful song !! <3

  • Both ladies have very beautiful voices. Love the both! Beautiful song!

  • jennifer, leona, and jordin <3

  • they sound so good together :) you just cant compare when they both sound beautiful

  • Melody sounds similar to Cyndi Lauper's "True Colors".

  • stop comparing these 2 u guys, they're both great in their own ways

  • Lovely song!!!!

  • Both voices are as powerful, but Leona keeps a warmer tone in high pitch, Jhud voice thinned out a little. But anyway those TWO are for me the best voices right now. And I'm glad this duet exist, even if it could have been on a better song (like Carey/Houston or Streisand/Dion)

  • @theoneandonly2503 yes ,JHuds voice thins out as it goes higher while Leona gets whiny and uncontrolled up there, not to mention her belting doesn't stretch as high. hard to pick who's better :)

  • @MrJudube You might be right, but I still think Leona's voice is more beautiful on high belts. Jhud belts at 3:15 and Leona does this exact same note at 3:20 and she sounds fuller and add a very fast vibrato, which is quite impressive.

  • @theoneandonly2503 I don't claim Jen's voice is beautiful LOL

  • @theoneandonly2503 just enjoy the music, understands this is the way the producers produced the song, so that they can sound like they are actually singing the same song and not trying to out do one another. they blend perfectly, just like the outstanding duet, Mariah and Whitney did, or Whitney and Deborah Cox. All great female vocalist on their own and even better together.

  • Their voices complement each other so nicely.

  • love this song! <3

  • I,m Leona lewis fan, but also i can accept jennifer too! Y not they're both great! Who agree?

  • Leona Lewis have the best voice in the world

    Best voice in my opinion is not powerful but it's make me need to listen agian

  • @TheBoybangkok leona can sing in different styles.

    watch leona and il divo:she can sing with so much power there.

    watch the first time ever i saw your face;she sings so soft there.

    watch cant breathe:she sings in headvoice there

  • HATERS can say what you like, but Jennifer Hudson is the best female vocalist in the business today hands down. Jen got the haters coming from all over. Mainly now that she has drop alot of weight, and looking very gorgeous. A true super star with very much class.

  • Jennifer wails too much and that's pretty much the only problem I have with her voice. The only thing about Leona here is her voice sounded TOO soft in this compared to Jennifer's but I prefer her sound over Jennifer's. Plus I don't like her singing R&B like this either. The song does nothing for either of them.

  • @alowaaaa I think you wrong and your comment is no reasonable I mean your taste for listen song is very very poor

  • I usually love leona lewis, shes one of my fave singers.. But i did not like this .

    I prefer hudson's voice "color" where id normally always root for leona. I hatethese songs. The other song she sang at VH1 divas was so much better !

  • I honestly don't know how this turned into a Jennifer vs Leona vocal battle. They're both amazingggg. Can't we leave it at that? The factsss are that Jennifer has more power, Leona has more range. Leona has been noted to "know her voice more than any other singer out there." If it makes a difference, Simon Cowell said Leona after she sang Summertime on the x factor "across idol, across all the other shows, you are absolutely the best contestant I've ever had across any of these shows"

  • Jennifer Hudson is too great!!! She seems too relax when she sings. Leona has an angelic voice!!!

  • Leona has an angelic voice

  • this sound like true colors... but i love it

  • leona is ok. she doesn't know how to control her vibratos. in the beginning, her vibratos are slow and when she starts singing high, it speeds up. it's evident in all of her songs! it's inconsistent. it seems as if she is forcing it rather than controlling it. i'm just sayin.

  • I heard she was turning into a real diva. The bad kind....She made her entire crew eat nothing but veggie food on tour and they'd be fired if they ate anything else. I love leona but....wow. She was such a sweet heart.

  • @singergx nooo,here you go wrong.I am not a veggie but if i have a principle i respect my principle.She turned 1 million dollar offer to advertise a clothing make just because they sell fur goods too.So it would be fake if she didn't do this on her tour.i totally agree,it's not a big sacrifice for the people though.And you're wrong she just decided to serve veggie food on her tour she didn't fire anybody for eating un-veggie food.

  • @Endriking well i read on a very trusted website that she fired to chefs...so....yeah.

  • @Endriking but u see what you mean.

  • @singergx

    its not true... Reports have been made that this is lies

    She had a chef who made no meat meals but she didnt force anyone. Everybody who meets her always say shes as adorable as she always was.

    She hasnt been in magazines for being a bitch. No one even eard of her breakup. Why would people assume that she changed. Kelly clarkson is adorable too and she hasnt changed in 8 years unlike a lot of people. For instance i like beyonces work but she appears as a real a°°hole!

  • love it leona is the best xxx

  • It makes me laugh how some people have put leona dont have a strong voice haha, you clearly no nothing about vocal talent, she has an amazing strong voice.

  • i don't know what you guys are talking about

    jennifer has nothing to envy to leona

    she has a marvelous voice

    and i definitely prefer jennifer over leona

  • jen over power leona so i fink they shuld of picked sum1 wif mre of a softer voice to sing wif leona fact!!!

  • I think Jennifer Hudson hasn't been given enough credit here.

    You can't compare the two because they have completely different vocal styles. Leona is brilliant but as is Jennifer. Whilst Leona is great at the ballads, Jennifer's voice is perfect for the more soulful numbers. I can't see Leona pulling off "And I am telling you".; something "gutsy". Either way both are great and I'm loving this song!! :-D

  • @Lycheaa Why? lol Leona is perfectly capable of doing generic R&B songs, and btw the majority of her songs on her first album were 'gutsy' high ranged ballads.

  • @Learner012

    I don't know why. She's a talented singer and I know she has done more up tempo songs " but I can't see her doing THAT particular song. I know she could sing it but I can't see her pulling off the emotion that goes with it. Who knows. I'd like for her to prove me wrong; I'd actually really like to hear her sing it.

  • @Lycheaa agreed 100% leona has some soft high notes that Jennifer wouldn't be able to do and Leona mooost probable wouldnt be able to belt out "one night only" or "and i am telling you" lol!

    their voices blend so well!:)

  • sorry mate but they have different voices you can't compare! and i'm not agree with your comment bout leonna is the best vocal all over the world .... she cant take da' high notes like mariah! she's behind mariah! boy!

  • @djdekolara that only cats can hear:))) da:)))

  • i agree with traymon..........they arent competing that have no need to as both are gorgious and absolutely amazingly talented. love ya gals

  • Love both of these true talents....i dont feel as though they are competing....its a great song!

  • This is underwhelming considering the talents of these two. It should have been as great as the Mariah/Whitney duet or the Barbra/Celine duet

  • Hi everyone, I'm Te'a Butler. And I'm a 14 year old female singer & dancer.

    Check out some of my covers and my dance moves ! Some of my covers: If This Isn't Love by Jennifer Hudson, Everything To Me by Monica, Heaven Sent by Keyshia Cole , & Smash Into You by Beyonce just to name a few . I'd like to know

    what you all think, so please comment, subscribe, & rate. Thanks, all is appreciated.

    Much Love, Te'a Butler:)

  • this is one of the best duets i've heard in a while.

    love this song.

  • Go Jennifer!!!! Love her, she's brill :-)

  • Comment removed

  • I love both Jennifer and Leona and they both have such different unique voices! Their duet is great!

  • I COMPLETELY disagree. Jennifer Hudson's got the power in her vocal and i think she's on point. Leona also sings more on this track than Jennifer does. Try get Leona to sing And I Am Telling You and THEN tell me Leona's the top female vocalist on the planet. Thats complete rubbish.

  • @spunnybunny Here you go, this is Leona's version of "I Will Always Love You":

    watch?v=pqrTxDwQ51w

  • @BeatheTwinkie No thank you. I think Christina Aguilera is the top female vocalist. And i've already heard Leona's 'I will always love you'. Never changed my opinion then, it won't now.

  • @spunnybunny Hey everyone is entitled to their own opinion

  • @BeatheTwinkie Agreed.

  • @spunnybunny Lol you need to listen to better singers, Leona and Christina are all good obviously, but they are simply top notch POP "vocalist". Go listen to some pro. broadway vocals and see if you still think Christina or Leona or even Jennifer could measure up to their 100% live vocals.

  • @Learner012 It wasn't me who thought Leona was so amazing so you r confused there. I just didn't agree with the blatant Leona bias on this song & thought Jennifers power was more special to listen to. I'm just saying i think Christina has top vocal over Leona by far as the high-rated comment claimed Leona was "the top female vocalist on the planet". I actually like ppl like Billie H, Nikka Costa etc. Broadway and West End singers have a totally different dramatic style and is not my thing.

  • @spunnybunny It's their JOB to perform with drama, however broadway vocalist are clearly held to a different standard as far as range and overall vocal quality when in comparison with POP singers like christina aguilera. And btw? Leona has a higher range than Chrstina Aguilera, is her normal tone as deep? nope, but it is just as strong. Christina aguilera isn't the 'standard' so that is just your opinion.

  • @spunnybunny Oh and Btw people are allowed to like Leona's vocals in this song better. It's their opinion, just like it's YOUR *OPINION* that christina aguilera is the "top" anything.

  • @Learner012 Exactly, just like its YOUR opinion that Broadway singers r better. I simply disagreed & gave MY OPINION as u and i are BOTH entitled to. I didn't say ppl weren't "allowed" to like Leona's voice & i don't care about Leona's range, i offered a different perspective & it is MY OPINION (neva sed it was ne1 elses) that i prefer Christina. As u said yourself about every1 being allowed their opinion, i'm allowed mine. But u made an assumption that i don't listen to "better singers". I do.

  • @spunnybunny Better? lmao Hun superior vocal skill is REQUIRED for broadway, you wont see a broadway singer that actually gets work with vocal skill BELOW pop singers like leona or christina. LOL That's not an opinion, it's a fact. And I should know considering I've been taking vocal classes specifically for that kind of work. =)

    You randomly brought up christina - which shows you think YOUR opinion = fact. Get over it, it's not. LOL You also called people BIAS for having an OPINION. LOL

  • @spunnybunny Calling people Bias towards Leona just because they have an opinion you don't agree with and randomly bringing up OTHER singers who aren't even in this fucking song again proves you seem to believe your worthless OPINION = fact. get over yourself. Your opinion is worthless, just like everyone' else.

  • @Learner012 Actually, i was referring to the video only featuring her picture on the "bias" front considering Jennifer is on this track as well. Anyway, i'm over this now.

  • @spunnybunny Oh don't fucking back track now moron, you said there was only a "preference" towards Leona here because of the "bias" of her picture being there. Guess what idiot? people can still fucking hear the both of them. LOL Go cry somewhere you ignorant turd.

  • @Learner012 Lol, ur angry? Why? Cos i dont like Broadway? How many otha ppl hav u bin tryna convince? Not been successful? Lol. Again u make assumptions about me & seem 2 b offended dat i don't share ur view on Broadway singers. Its u dat needs 2 cry sumwher it seems cos u r clearly upset. I don't give a damn about ur vocal lessons & Broadway singers. U also randomly brought dat up. Feel free to listen to them urself, but like i said, it is NOT my thing. Wipe ur tears. Goodbye.

  • @spunnybunny LMAO what an idiot, find a new argument idiot I just used that one. I didn't bring up any specific singer, simply brought up facts about required vocal skills for different vocal genres. Not an opinion, just a fact.

    Go listen to your britney and christina you moron. lol

    ANYWAYS. Leona lewis sounds gorgeous in this song. =) dont' care about the other one.

  • @Learner012 Hahahahahahahahahaha...you seem to be the idiot and are also easily wound up. Its funny to read you getting so tense and desperate. You do need to calm down. This whole Broadway mission of yours is getting on top of you, maybe the vocal lessons are not working?? But refrain from taking that frustration out on me. Its pretty pathetic to see. You need to GET OVER IT!! Dickhead.

  • Comment removed

  • leona owned this song!

    love them both though.

  • They both sound great. their voices are incomparable to one another. comparing them is like saying apples taste like oranges, if not better.

  • @dugw55 i totally agree with you!!!!!

  • you guys must be leona fans, i am not a fan of neither

    and i honestly thought leona was just doing backup singing to jennfier, almost like in when u believe with mariah and whitney, when mariah sounded like a back up singer.

    so i like Jennifers part better, both have good parts, but powers was jennifer.

    i actually think leonas career is over in USA< her 2nd cd flopped

  • @adaliso I think they both had there parts. Jennifer and Leona have very different voices. I don't think Leona is done in the US - she did get nominated for best song for movie for avatar. Her second cd wasn't as successful as the first I agree- but once she starts promoting her world tour in north america, I have hopes it'll pick up. at least I hope it will - she's amazing and doesn't deserve to be a one hit wonder.

  • @adaliso I agree! Everyone here loves Leona, and many are hating on Jennifer Hudson. I don't see know why... Jennifer Hudson has a stunning voice. Leona also has quite a voice! If people are going to give their opinion, I just ask that they do it respectfully. Just because they don't like somebody doesn't mean that another must share the same feeling.

  • Leona is a diva... Jennifer is a musical, stage singer to me! Great voice, but she doesn't compare to Leona!

  • Jennifer Hudson & Leona Lewis • Love Is Your Color [Sex And The City 2] Watch this before it's taken down f d g 5 6 3 1 w ww . Buggy Movies . c o m y a c m 2 d 4
  • jennifer has a lovely voice, but is very middle toned.

    just listen to leona's range and you will appreciate how controlled her vocals are, and she is not trying to prove she is better she is just enjoying the moment, she may not be american but its about time you showed her a lot more respect, she is an english girl dont make her unwanted in your country she deserves the best.

  • Wait to see the llve performance...

    Jennifer's voice is much better than leona lewis...Ii will be like whitney destroid mariah on the price of egpit.

    I love both...But jennifer is better!

  • @laionmarc

    i agree with u on this on both situations

    jennifer beat leona

    and whitney destroyed mariah

  • Uauuuuuuuu this song is just pure beauty! Their voices match perfectly! i like Jennifer but i love leona! Just saw her saturday @ rock in rio lisbon... She sings heavenly! I think they are perfect in this song love both ! =P

  • love it

  • Leona's amazing :D

  • Umm, what exactly is supposed to be embarrassing for Jennifer? Both Jennifer and Leona are wonderful artists in their own respective rights. Jennifer has absolutely nothing to be EMBARRASSED about. The fact that she has recently dropped 10 dress sizes, shooting a new movie in Africa, is a triple threat in entertainment, and is BACK on the SAC soundtrack (all which =$) solidifies her as being a proud glamorous woman. This song is amazing and I believe that both women did a fabulous job;)

  • @flippin87

    well said! I totally agree! :)

  • I never heard Leona sing like this, it's interesting she's really pushing herself to match Jennifer Hudson. But good for her, she sounds OK. Shame the song is as dull as dishwater.

  • Lmao @ those who tries to compare both of them. Must be headstrong and shallow minded. This is a collaboration and they have created a masterpiece. Both are good at what they're doing.

  • Cool ich darf den ersten Kommi machen ^^

    Also das Lied finde ich echt schön :)

    Freu mich auch schon auf Satc 2... besonders auf die Stelle xD

    Liebe Grüße an alle LeLe-Fans

  • very similaar to the song true colour

  • They both are brilliant!

  • I like Jennifer Hudson but I prefer Leona and she's so much better than Jennifer !

    I like the song but unfortunately it looks like True Colors

  • @jeanhalliwell What?

  • @SoItHappens what what ? lol

  • @jeanhalliwell shhhh now

  • @SoItHappens shhhhh yourself lol

  • at the beginning sounds like true colors but after that a GREAT song with 2 Great voices ...Stop comparing they compliment each other and the song lifts you

  • FIRST: Their voices are very well connected!

    SECOND: This is not a competition! So STOP comparing Leona with Jennifer.

    THIRD: You can't tell who is better or worse hearing only this song. You have to hear all the work that they do.

    Come on they are great! And this song is awesome (Y)

  • Leona you prove everytime why you are world class!

  • Leona Lewis totally outshines Jen on this !! Leonas voice is so beautiful. Very angelic :)

  • Join the channel .... hear the music ... Three Levels - Don't Give Up ... Great Tunes!

  • I love this song i hope they perform this on x factor or american idol :D

  • i love both singers they are my first and second singers and they are doin a duet not a vocal battle together sound amazing

  • they both sound amazing :)

  • it's just identical to true colors by cindy lauper

  • i think it's a little bit corny... :(

  • I think Leona deserves better and more powerful ballad!! This is too ordinary for her! All i hear is J.Hud screaming!!! I love leona

  • Oh Dear.... How embarrassing for Jennifer. Yes she has a good voice.

    But no one stands a chance going up against Leona.

    As usual Leona Lewis proves that she is the top female vocalist on the planet

  • @pinnfree your are ao right :)

  • @pinnfree Your so right :D love Leona !!!

  • @pinnfree

    Totaly agree with you :)

  • @pinnfree Miss Oscar-winning Jennifer Hudson has got NOTHING to be embarraseed about. Rubbish choice of words. I can also see the bias...sorry, preference for Leona based on the fact that she's the only face that makes the video clip.

  • well even if you're right and leona lewis is just incredible and the best out of the two! :) I don't like a lot the "embarrassing" for Jennifer. It is too much according to me, she's not that bad. There's worse! :) If you really wanna see someone not fitting, watch the concert against the Cancer made by the PCD, Fergie, Maria Carey etc... and Miley Cyrus. Horrible for this latter the only times she was singing hehe. And I see well a duo between Leona and Agnes Carlsson btw! :) Ur opinion?? :)

  • @pinnfree I SO AGREEE I LOVE HER IF U LOOK AT MY VID OF MY COLLECTION OF LEONA :d :)

  • @pinnfree I don't care how many thumbs up you gave yourself, that was just the most stupidest comment I've ever heard! If you put them both on stage, Jennifer will completely murder Leona on vocals. Leona is nowhere near the best female vocalist on the planet. Jennifer, Beyonce, Christina, & Alexandra all have stronger voices than her. I do like Leona but she's so overrated, it's insane! Maybe that's why after 4 years of trying to be Mariah Carey, Leona still hasn't won a Grammy or a Brit Award.

  • @superx57

    Blla bla bla

    The only artist thats have singingskills like Leona is Beyonce of what u metioned.

    And she not trying to be MC - moron.

  • @DaJokern Each artist I mentioned has her own strengths and weaknesses, which is why it's impertinent to claim that Leona is best female vocalist on the planet. She only has 3 octaves (Jennifer & Christina has 4), she can't hit low notes very well (Beyonce & Alexandra can), and the only thing spectacular about her tone is when she goes into head voice. For someone who's had a lifetime of operatic vocal training, I'd expect more from Leona.

    BTW, fix your grammar before you call someone a moron.

  • @superx57

    More bla bla

    I cant seeU dont know her range - BTW she even dont know herself-

    then how should u know - LOL

    And please dont mention Alexandre here. 

  • @DaJokern There are many people who used live and studio vocals from Leona to measure her range. Take it up with those who posted the videos.

    I don't see any reason why I shouldn't mention Alexandra. After all, she has a big voice, and has been compared to Whitney, Beyonce, & Leona, so she has every right to be mentioned here.

    BTW, I see you still haven't fixed your grammar...

  • @superx57

    Yeh I know - and why do you say 3 then ?

  • @superx57

    Leona should be listened to LIVE.

    Beonce and Leona tops this generation when it comes to skills

    and technic..

    To sing is not to roar high in a microphone

  • @DaJokern Did you not read when I said "LIVE and studio vocals"?

    Like I said before, every great female artist has their strengths and weaknesses. Leona is a great singer, despite her dull tone. Her incomparable skills is her head voice, but that's it.

    As long as it's on key, roaring high is singing. It doesn't mean that it makes that artist the best singer in the world, it just shows that they have their own gifts that makes them incomparable.

  • @superx57

    Did you not read when I said :

    Leona should be listened to LIVE.

    U will completly change your mind when you hear her live voice at concert.

    U cant judge out of utubevids and cd's - it must be experienced in reality - it gives a completely different picture from her voice - I can tell you.

    BTW.

    She have shown us more than 3 ovtaves - thats what I know.

  • @superx57 Christina cannot compete with beyonce vocally, you may prefer the sound of christinas voice but beyonce is the better singer and vocallist she us the best of our generation. Second is leona lewis

  • @superx57

    Dont get me started :)

    Beyonce has flawless technique flawless placement brilliant breath support, rhythmic sensibility, she creates musical lines with her runs. Her voice us more full and rounded and she has a better lower register a more agile versatile and flexible belting range and a more powerful operatic agile full head voice. It's no competition.

  • @DaJokern Where is this coming from? I never said Christina was better than Beyonce.

    Regarding Leona, I have watched her live, and the clips posted are a combination of both studio and live vocals.

  • @superx57

    Therefore I compared Beyonce and Xtina because you could see the difference.

    To argue that Leona only has her head voice, and nothing else is even more nonsense.

    Of those you've mentioned is Beyonce and Leona far ahead of the rest you mentioned earlier when we're talking vocal skills.

  • @superx57

    U came and and told us Jennifer, Beyonce, Christina, & Alexandra all have stronger voices than her.

    As if that has anything to do with being a good vocalist - the worst nonsense I have long heard.

    Being loud is not the same as like having a strong voice -

  • @superx57

    Still i havent got an answer why u said leona have 3 octave.

    I know she have more - please answer that question

    or just get some knowledge before bashing an artist with wrong info.

  • @DaJokern If you look back at my previous comments, I explained that to you three seperate times already, and I don't have the patients to repeat myself yet again.

    All the female singers with big voices, including Leona, are loud when they sing. You're right--having the loudest voice is not the same as having the strongest voice and in my opinion, Leona is a perfect example of that.

  • @superx57

    It has shown nothing to do with patience slipping of a direct question about why you say she has 3 octave - when it is not truth.

  • @DaJokern It's the truth. Here's the proof.

    Studio:

    [(HD) Leona Lewis Vocal Range - Spirit: D3-Eb6 (Debut Studio Album, 2007)]

    [(HD) Leona Lewis Vocal Range - Echo: Eb3-Eb6 (2nd Studio Album, 2009)]

    [(HD) Leona Lewis Vocal Range - Studio: D3-F#6 (2007-2010)]

    Live:

    [(HQ) Leona Lewis Vocal Range - X Factor: D3-Eb6]

    [(HQ) Leona Lewis Vocal Range - Spirit Era (2007-2009): Eb3-Eb6]

    [(HD) Leona Lewis Vocal Range - Rock In Rio, Lisbon: F3-Eb6]

    She's most comfortable at 2.5, but her limit is 3.

  • @superx57

    Its 3.2 octave of what she has shown in these vids - I know for sure.

    Many believe she is able to sing four octave if she wants.

    The limits isnt 3.

  • @DaJokern

    Your rite... And she also can go into the whistle register and thats high!! So that wud take her to about a 4!! So I agree with you.