Added: 4 years ago
From: ComradeJX8P
Views: 35,707
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (163)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • ok.......to clear shit up here.......this is Donald Fagan, and I gotta say this is a total embarrassment to the credibility that Our Band is being besmirched. It was a PBS thing directed by some Steven Hawkins gimp who barked at us through one of those vocoder things placed against his throat. Earlier that morning I was diagnosed with hep C and anal herpes and I just wasn't into it. Huffing a whole buch of glue while getting blown by some cracked-out nip skank just beforehand didn't help either.

  • You are a really good musician!

  • The guitar player started this mess. After that everyone started to play a different song in a different key, all at one time. Wow, what mass confusion ! Not the Steely dan I grew up with for sure.

  • The more they sound like Sun Ra the more I like it.

  • Funny!!!

  • this isn't real. you can tell that they are playing different stuff to the recording

  • This is the funniest thing I've seen on YouTube since the Herman Li guitar tutorials. Probably because it reminds me of so many Steely Dan cover band practice sessions I've taken part in. Hilarious.

  • smoke on the water. hahaHAHA. i like the build and 'fall'. hahhahHA. good work comrade

  • You should play with toys ,not with other guys hard work..

  • BEST SHRED EVER!!!

  • The look of Walter at 2:06 is almost making it look real. Hilarious!

  • GOD DAMN!

  • Very funny! It´s get weirder and weirder near the end!

  • They are SHREDDING

  • Best guitar solo ever :-)

  • Hahahahaha someone should give Fag and Waltz a ring and let them know about this if they haven't seen it already, hahahaha that's their kind of humour anyway hahhhahhh pissing myself here hah :))))

  • love it.lol

  • Goodness me. Some of you people need to lighten up! Obviously The Dan are one of or maybe even THE most well arranged and produced bands the world has ever seen. This is a joke video and it is very funny and a funny idea and well done. My fav band is probably Yes, but I laugh along with every prog rock gag going. It is good to love a band and respect them, but unhealthy when you think they are above poking fun at.

  • Comment removed

  • HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!

  • 2:34 - 2:45 smoke on the water

    2:57 - 3:05 the final count down

    this bassist is playing on a whole 'nother level

  • Comrade. This shit is FUNNY!!!

  • i'm a lost wanderer is this making fun of steely dan an awsome band?

  • @ukijhu97 Not making fun, just a clever chuckle. I love dan and I'm in no way offended.

  • @chinesefake This is the kind of crap they do to john petrucci and other guitarists videos cuz they play so ridiculously fast which is funny. Here i don't find it funny cuz peg is a good song...

  • DEH DEH DEHHHH !!!

  • Come on! the Chap or Chapes who did this knowsthier stuff. Really nicely done and a fantastic underhanded tribute (in a way) LOVE IT!

  • This is a lame video.. Sorry but to overdub a crappy performance (not theirs), onto a brilliant one (theirs), I mean that's just sad.

  • Bernard Purdie is a bit sloppy during the guitar solo (obviously patched up later during mix-down), other than that, what do you mean by "out of practice"? :D This was a good , well-needed belly laugh.... nice job, ComradeJX8P!

  • Obvious spoof.... lot's of work to produce.. good for you!

  • I am sooo using this in my high school music class to discuss performance criteria!

  • GENIUS!!!

  • ULOL!!!!!

  • wow,,,YOU, fellow vid poster, are trying to disgrace this band...how this being a fake, i can also notice just by the video alone (no sound) that there is no way they are playing this badly...i mean c'mon, ITS STEELY DAN

  • i love how when it gets to the solo, everything immediately falls apart

  • LOL. Hope Don and Walt got to see this. Priceless. Really starts to get funny around 1.49...

  • Love the way Becker looks at Jon Herrington during the solo, hilarious

  • ComradeJX8P - Nice job trying to f^&k up their music. At least YOU'RE having fun

  • Is this your work? Brilliantly done, must have taken forever.

  • Haha! First I thought the title was just a joke, as in they are playing just fine, and then.... brilliant.

  • これはひどい

  • The guitarist sounded like he was playing a Black Flag solo LMAO

  • This sort of thing happens all the time when rehearsing or just getting ready to rehearse. It's called "having fun" Or "just screwing around between songs" I believe..

  • uTTER RUBBISH.

  • This is awesome...had me going in the beginning, and then it devolved more and more, as if the acid just started to set in...great shred

  • The undeniable brilliance of Donald and Walter is on display both during and after the solo, as things move into a hole 'nother zone. Enematically speaking, the lads are interpreting the outer reaches of a proctological outflux, paralleling the chaotic universe's increasing speed. Rely on substances such as Buckley's Doucheflex to clean out an expectation that a commodity such as the Dan could be relegated to the anals of ennui; of tintinnabulation it must be said: the Dan are still swacked.

  • Finally, someone nailed it.

  • Old rockers never die. They just slow down... and slow down... and slow down... and fall apart... Great vid. STSanders would be proud.

  • Great guitar solo!

  • The point is its funny you douchebag

  • what was the point of this excercise?

  • Donald and Walter should slap the shit outta who ever done this shit!!!

  • great!

  • at first i thought they had too many drugs but later its obvious its fake

  • Hahaha, brilliant.

  • Lulz, this is great.

  • I love how it gets worse and worse. I hope people know that this is one of the greatest bands touring right now, and this is a goof..........It's done so well, though

  • Wow, this is incredible!! Funniest shit I've seen on You Tube in some time!

  • ahahahahaha

  • That is some funny shit!!!!!!!!!! LOLOL

  • I laughed so hard, brilliant 9.84736 stars

  • Hahaha it looks like he is flopping his lifeless hands onto the keyboard

  • yeah

    plop-plop-plop

    plop-plop-plop

  • That's just silly. I'm impressed how well you synched it up.

  • Brilliant. How did they do that without cracking up. Smoke On The Water as well!

  • Nice try it was cute you had me at first! But i still like it alot.

  • I could definitely hear a sun ra influence that I never noticed before....

  • There are some other funny videos like this. Check out "Paco Shreds". This one is a little too over the top.

  • They started playing pretty well except for the drums the drums had some rare timing. Then all of a sudden they started playing real bad. You can see the look con Donald Fagen's face, he didn't like it.

  • it's fake, my friend.

  • HOW DARE YOU! like spray-painting the Mona Lisa!

    Haaahaaaa... i see the funny tho!

    Chuck Rainey starts playing the bass riff from "Smoke on the water" at 2:41. too funny!

  • A dream come true for the envious right? hahahahahahaha

  • Looks like Bernerd Purdy on drums,great teacher.

  • i wonder if Becker was thinking WTF at 2:07

  • Sacrilege. But funny. Still sacrilege tho'

  • Haha yeah that was great.

  • Had to be staged...for a moment there the guitarist was sounding like BLACK FLAG....very scary.

  • They only get to play that tight because they are real musicians who work hard at their craft :o)

  • hahahah, ah every musician should see this man ! exellent smoke on the water near the end brilliant.

  • OUCH !!

  • HAHAHAHA!!! It's like a shreds vid !!!

  • excellent!

  • Comment removed

  • hahahaha! aw man. still love 'em!

  • hahahahaha

  • ROFLMAO!

  • Love how it goes from really bad to horendous at the solo. All down hill from there.

  • I´m a musician myself and it´s nice to here that pros kan have a bad day!

    -Steve Lukather for president

  • Comment removed

  • HAHAHA VERY GOOD!

  • HAHAHA....excellent!!

  • Hahhaaah. The guys seem to be enjoying a lot of their harmony :) 5up

  • hahaha I wonder if the band ever saw this little joke. Absolutely hilarious!

  • Comment removed

  • a sompin' , wailin' , chop-beatin' session indeed !

  • haha, listen to the solo at 1:47 !

  • xD at 2:37 when the bassist tries to play smoke on the water.

  • this is absaluty hilarious!

    i actualy thought it was real at first...

    the gutar solo was the best!

  • heartwarming

  • that is f'n brilliant!

  • At 2:07 when Becker looks over at Herington, it couldn't have been scripted better :)

  • No wonder why they hardly ever toured!

  • That was the funniest guitar solo ever!

  • that's awesome when Steven Cobert plays that nice guitar solo.

  • i remember steely dan when he had long hair

  • yeah jeez raylopez chill the fuck out

    these videos are funny as hell i like steely dan and it doesn't bother me

  • All the shred videos are great! And all the people hating on them either don't have a sense of humor or don't understand that it's a parody. Rock on!

  • Total genius!

  • Classic stuff.

  • This is bloody well made

  • bloody great. i love your sense of humour. your a genius. by the way im a huge dan fan.

  • waht the fuck?

    hehehe

  • steely dans used to be down with the boys

    now they's just rolling around on studios doing the jams (std)

    plus they's dead

  • Hoooy boy, thank you! And the "Smoke on the Water" bassline was a nice touch...

  • Yeah, and after that "Final Countdown"!

  • they really get their jam on towards the end there. Great Band!

  • lmao that was that was so hilarious and horrible at the same time

  • I love how it gets worse and worse.

  • i laughed so effing hard... I think Donald and Walter would like this a lot.

  • yeah! having fun is the most important thing!

    ahahahaha

  • I reckon Walter and Donald may be amused by this

  • Needs more cowbell...

  • ROFLMAO!

  • Can't believe there people who are seriously offended by this. Life's tough if your sense of humor stinks that badly.

  • I actually watched this a few months ago and found this again just now through a Steely Dan blog. Why I didn't favorite this before is beyond me, because it's fucking BRILLIANT.

  • This is fucking hilarious!

  • Of all the videos of this type, this one is one of the best. For the first couple of bars, this sounds like a fairly competent version of the song. Then, as the drums come in, the flams and muffs become more noticeable, and the performance quickly deteriorates into a glorious mess. The "Smoke On The Water" bass line is inspired lunacy at its best!

  • this is shameful

  • smoke on the water ROFL

  • Fucking Lol'd

  • that dubbing is superb

  • complete mess in the end , great job !

  • They're great enough to withstand a good joke.

    I think they'll laugh when they see it, if they haven't already.

    Cool idea.

  • I nearly pissed myself

  • Hilarious - right up there with the Michel Petrucciani shred.....

    Thanks for posting!

  • Brilliant! I love Steely Dan but I laughed for a long while!

  • I don't understand how viewers of this vid cannot figure out in the first 10 seconds that this is dubbed (and hence a prank of sorts). The 'composer' of this video should receive an award: brilliant! I'm gonna share this vid with all my mates in Aussie. BRILLIANT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • If you can't beat 'em... TRASH 'EM!

    GENIUS!

  • Wow...you trashed Steely Dan's sound.

    How cool is that.

  • bassist ...smoke on the water...prefect...the look on the drummers face fits the "shred" 5 stars from me

  • 01:52 LOL!

  • ya well if he is a guy (more like ghey) why is he called STEELY DAN huh??

  • That makes so little sense there really isn't much to say in response. The band's name is Steely Dan. The guy on the keyboard who does the vocals is Donald Fagen.

  • well i think ur a FAY GOTH (hmm wat can THAT MEAN HUH?????)

    evry1 knos for a FATC thaat steely daan is on of the best trumpets eeever but he loost his stylish!!

  • Find out what "Steely Dan" is (hint: look it up in "The Naked Lunch" by William Burroughs)see if you can find one and then stick it up your arse sideways, twist it and see if it hurts.

  • asshole!

  • This was great man. Band versions of the "shreds" -series are really welcome. Keep up the good work!

  • hey lars dodoo...steely dan is a band, not a guy. you stupid dumbass dope. GET IT RIGHT !!!

  • Right Lars DOOOD Thinks Steely Dan is a human being Lars i believe your either from the Netherlands or America either way "Steely Dan" Was the giant Dildo out of William Borrough's "The Naked Lunch"

    N U say us brits r dumb!!!

  • Ah, but it was steam powered and not battery operated.The distinction is important.

  • I'm still laughing!!! Make it stop!!!!

  • The guitar break is fantastic.

  • haha he can't even play smoke on the water properley on the bass!

  • This is genius !! Along the same lines as the 'SHREDs' vids. This one lures you into believing that the band is just lose then ........ ka .... boom !! The Smoke on the water bass line at the end is brilliant.

    This must have taken ages to build .

  • Haha This is pretty funny. I also love it when people refer to Steely Dan as one person, it's fuckin adorable.

  • everyone knows dat steely dan lost his toch when he start'd makin shit music LOL

    gr8 viddeo asshole ur mom is ghey

  • You're joking right? This is a character you've got going?

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more