Katie is Rachel Dawes and just owned her chemistry with Bale. Katie is versatile than Maggie being in TV,movies and Broadway and her roles varies unlike Maggie playing a shank always.
She even made Rachel flirty in TDK. TDK is not Secretary.
I agree with those people who are saying that katie was a better rachel dawes, but I can't believe some people are calling maggie a bad actress! Did you not see her in "sherry baby" or "secretary"?!
Maggie is a better overall actress than katie, even though katie was better in this role as she had more chemistry with bale.
I disagree. Katie's acting was cringe-worthy. I can't watch Begins because every time she does her crooked mouth thing and shakes her head, I forgot I was watching Batman.
Weel i thought that she was wonderful as Rachel Dawes, she gave a really stunning performance. I mean Rachel is supposed to be a strong woman, with strong values and Holmes just looked like she was spitting her lines all over the movie.
And talking about chemistry, Maggie Gyllenhaal certainly had more with Bale and Echkart than Katie Holmes would ever dream of.
God she is an interactive woman
nochumplovesucker2 1 year ago
love her:-)
ritzadee 1 year ago
I thought Katie's Rachel was more likable, though technically, Maggie should be the better actress...but she was rather underwhelming.
I keep wishing they'd cast someone like Cate Blanchett.
antychan 1 year ago
Comment removed
stitchgrl777 1 year ago
I don't think anyone of them were very good as Rachel Dawes....
XLifeIsABulletX 2 years ago
In comparison, Katie Holmes was way better as Rachel Dawes. Damn shame she didn't come back.
Seiyanashi 2 years ago
Katie is Rachel Dawes and just owned her chemistry with Bale. Katie is versatile than Maggie being in TV,movies and Broadway and her roles varies unlike Maggie playing a shank always.
She even made Rachel flirty in TDK. TDK is not Secretary.
buckapache 2 years ago
I agree with those people who are saying that katie was a better rachel dawes, but I can't believe some people are calling maggie a bad actress! Did you not see her in "sherry baby" or "secretary"?!
Maggie is a better overall actress than katie, even though katie was better in this role as she had more chemistry with bale.
MinutesToMidnight92 2 years ago
Katie was the right Batman lady all along.
quarterbacktop 2 years ago
Her unease never made us forget Katie is Rachel Dawes!
gunavatar 3 years ago
Both Katie and Maggie were wrong for the role.
2ndPistonHonda 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Only shows the joker is crazy for calling Maggie beautiful and she cant even act. I missed Katie in the role.
quarterbacktop 3 years ago
@quarterbacktop annoyin she always says free
fuckgd1 1 year ago
jokwe14 its "and you are beautiful"
TheCinemaReporter 3 years ago
Katie gave Rachel class. Maggie made her whorish,a tease,bouncy airhead.
quiquisalle 3 years ago
@quiquisalle
I disagree. Katie's acting was cringe-worthy. I can't watch Begins because every time she does her crooked mouth thing and shakes her head, I forgot I was watching Batman.
stitchgrl777 1 year ago
"WELL HELLO BEAUTIFUL!!!" And i mean you are beautiful.
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAAAAAAAAAAAA!!!!!
TheJoker14EVER 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
woefully miscast. Ditzy happy flirty D.A. way too smug and had no angst and chemistry with the actors.
Holmes did a better job despite the script was garbage from the getgo
dokaponmlb 3 years ago
At least maggie knows how to deliver lines properly. and as for chemistry, they didnt have too many scenes together anyway...
sgtpeppper 3 years ago 6
Weel i thought that she was wonderful as Rachel Dawes, she gave a really stunning performance. I mean Rachel is supposed to be a strong woman, with strong values and Holmes just looked like she was spitting her lines all over the movie.
And talking about chemistry, Maggie Gyllenhaal certainly had more with Bale and Echkart than Katie Holmes would ever dream of.
OsOShiny 3 years ago 10
@OsOShiny I totally agree.
I'm not a fan of the Rachel character AT ALL, but Maggie at least didn't make me feel uncomfortable.
stitchgrl777 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
awful actress and so ugly. Her moles were so scary in IMAX. Not even a dose of chemistry with her and Bale or even Eckhart.
Many sure miss Holmes Sweet Holmes.
teamusano1 3 years ago