I would love some feedback on my whistle videos :) Im a huge fan of mariah and have just started posting up some videos of me whistling some mariah songs. <3
Wow, her voice is as immaculate as her beautiful white grand piano once apart of the legendary Marilyn Monroe's estate. That why we call the wind Mariah as she brings the characteristics of heaven where ever she sings.
She is a Jewel: We are more blessed that she opens up her heaven for us to enter into the mysteries of the divine.
@jacquesno3 "gmafb"? Stop butchering an entire language by turning something into an acronym that no one will figure out just to excuse your laziness. Also, stereotyping won't get you anywhere when trying to understand someone.
@BlackDivas1 Her whistle is not overrated babe. That is just clear, not airy. The thing is she doesn't need to pull her larynx up to whistle, she can sing words while doing vocal runs in whistle, she can turn from chest to whistle without pausing, she can whistle higher than Minnie and she can totally control them. Yes, Minnie is her superior but actually Mariah is very good, not overrated any at all
@babylovemeonemoretim Minnie by far has the best whistle tone. Her whistle never sounded pinched or forced it just came out naturally. Mariah's whistle register is nice but not as fluid and pure as Minnie's.
@BlackDivas1 I admit that Minnie is very good, she is Mariah's idol but Mariah is very good at whistle register too. So please don't say that she is overrated because she is not. She has many rarest skills that Minnie doesn't have.
gmafb. "I AXED for a high note"? Thousands of years of this country mastering the English language....and in only 50 years! ~ an entire culture a. Still can't speak it and b. have adopted ignorant English-slander into society. Nice. Maybe instead of buying & smoking weed, crack and whatever else drugs they're on....they should go back to 5th grade elementary English class! Gross human beings.
@jacquesno3 Is there a particular kind of people you are referring to or are you speaking of people in general?.Because I am suspecting you are speaking of Black people but I hope i am wrong. I saw your comment and just could not hold myself from commenting. I ask this because of your use of "culture" and "they".
Actually, aiming for the highest notes is not psychologically damaging at all. It's a pretty high honor to be blessed with such vocal ability. As a singer myself, I look to singers such as Mariah, Whitney, Solange, Beyonce, Monica, Keyshia and Aaliyah to challenge and strengthen my own voice. It's like this: if I can do all they can do, I can do more. It's psychologically and vocally stimulating. You wouldn't understand, of course, but this is like a sport for us. And way more diff
its a shame she made whistles her gimick because people who arent fans only know her for that despite all her songs...especially her old shit. is near impossible to sing by most musicians
all you pseudo musically inclined people know that she still has 3 octaves without whistle right? she can zing easily from alto to soprano. go listen to her songs without whistles and tell me who can sing them.
why artists feel compelled to enter the whistle register is beyond me, physiologically it's horrible for you and it's completely unnecessary. Perhaps hitting an F6 makes her feel good about herself?
@plateir4ever not always but soem times yes they are. when u have just warmed up they will be airy but after an hour of being warmed up the airyness goes way.
@plateir4ever i have always wanted that. they don't always sound like that, but often enough to noticed it. it still sounds good to me. and maybe she they are airy because she might have been told to take in a lot of air to belt and push it outwards.
i used a software. and i played mariah's performance of america the beautiful the software showed up c8 on the high note part....and i played star spangled banner with her and it was a b7 at the high note part
@tipofmytongue1024 Well aren't we proper.Try this,take any recording device and say,"ask,asking and asked" in it,,preferably using each in a sentence.You'll find even you can't emphasize "ed" without a pause,who does that?"As for Snoop Dogg the ventriloquist".I think she should have used "Jaleel White" to add a little humor. Her vocal range is unthinkable,and the dog thought the same that's why he hauled ask "With a K" while he still had enough hearing to know that it's pronounced with an "S".
@alxmcnll325 Thanks for not being rude and actually answering my question with intelligence, I was losing hope for humanity for a while. lol. But you're right, ask...ed it's impossible. And I like the Jaleel White idea.
Hitting high notes does not make you a great singer. YES, she's a beautiful singer but not because of these unnatural-sounding whistle screeches. I mean, what about Amy Whinehouse? She had deep contralto vocals and was one of the best female vocalists ever.
And just an added note. Mariah Carey does NOT have a 5 octave vocal range. Don't believe everything you read in wikipedia. Octaves are only measured in notes you can actually SING, not hit like screeching banshee.
@moviegirl6 Well hun, then freakin' explain this to me cause last I checked these are PIANO notes sung!. Its a video called Mariah Carey- 5 Octaves in One Minute!! PLEASE and I mean PLEASE look at this video and THEN you can tell me or ANYONE else that this isn't 5 octaves. Oh and just so you know, Wiki isn't the only source that says Mariah has a 5 octave range, thank you very much.
@Tammie082 Once again, "hitting" and "singing" the note are two entirely different concepts. If you can SING the note, you can count it in your range. If you can only hit it on a squeak...it doesn't count.
@moviegirl6 Haha. Well I sure AS HELL do NOT hear a squeak anywhere IN THIS VIDEO or ANY of her songs for that matter. Go look at her catalogue, once again, and then come back to me.
Mariah Carey has a voice, but she squeaks too much which makes it sound bad when she goes for those high notes. I'm sorry but that is not singing when she does that. I'm not a hater, but I'm definitely not a fan. There are so many singers out there that are so much better than her. The only reason she got all the recognition and album sales was because she was a sex symbol. Nothing more.
@moviegirl6 LOL you are the most ignorant piece of shit I've ever seen on youtube. really. the whistle note register is so rare and only 1% of the POPULATION has control over this range and are able to sing in it.
@chrisak49 Just because I'm stating my opinion doesn't mean I'm ignorant. I know about singing and music because I've been professionally trained and I've taken courses in school. This isn't coming from someone who has no experience with music. YOU on the other hand are making yourself look foolish with your unnecessary vulgar language. Get over yourself.
@chrisak49 moviegirl has a point, mariah isn't recognised for her ability to sing, she is recognised for her popularity. there has to be a point where you decide the noise coming out of someones mouth is no longer singing. because we are interpreting this professionally, there is a much higher threshold.
besides all that, imo, higher isn't better, especially when you develop vocal nodules (like two of my friends who strained their voice like this)
@fonjadidi Trick NO! Its called she can LIPSYNC all she WANTS TO BECAUSE this wonderful, amazing, 5-octave singer has proven for 20 YEARS that she can sing. She can do whatever the hell she wants. Obviously her album sales and influence show that. Oh for future reference, she's sold 200 MILLION RECORDS WORLDWIDE. I'm done.
@Tammie082 DUDE READ WHAT IM WRITING SHE HAS BEEN PROVEN TO LYPSINC BECAUSE SHE CAN'T SING ANYMORE!!! she had lost her voice, but kept singing her notes which totally ruined her just because you're ignorant doesn't mean you're right. :L
@fonjadidi Haha. You're funny cause obviously you've been under a rock the past 5 to 6 years. How about you go listen to a 2010 performance of hers and then come back to me. Just cause you're a hater, doesn't mean you're right.
@Tammie082 I'm not a hater, hate is a very strong word and you can't eve " hate " someone you don't know. no that mate i don't want to listen to her because she doesn't sing she just squeaks and to ME it doesn't sound nice in anyway. no i dont live under a rock i guess you still watch sponge bob
@fonjadidi Haha. Wow. Yeah. You're not a hater. If you say so. Whatever makes you sleep at night. Yeah. She's hasn't been singing for 20 years and she's definitely not one of the best singers of our generation. And she's definitely not influenced a GENERATION of singers by her 5-OCTAVE RANGE. If you say so. And hun, maybe you should go back to English class cause its called a figure of speech.
@Tammie082 Just because I live in a country where they don't speak English goshh, I sleep very well thank you ;) yep she is definitely not the best. your opinion will be your opinion mine will be mine hun.
@fonjadidi Haha. Um actually I didn't know you lived in another country and that definitely doesn't make a difference and two you're just trying to bring up your ethnicity for some idiotic reason. Get over yourself. once again, its called figures of speech. Mmmk. Obviously her album sales show that. Oh. I might have to remind you. 200 MILLION worldwide. Not nationwide. But WORLDWIDE. Good for you. But majority likes Mariah.
@fonjadidi Awww and why is it that? See you're making your RACE a problem when I don't even know you or even care. I don't care about who you are. Its called actually ARGUING about the topic at hand. That's really immature when people try and bring up irrevelant crap. Haha. Yeah. Mariah's voice is TOTALLY a scam and sucks. Yeah. We'll go with that.
@Tammie082 If you don't care stop commenting :L. it's not immature it's telling you not to judge people to quickly and that is a very important lesson in life. so umm yeah.
@fonjadidi Yeah I'm judging quickly. If you say so. Hey, hope you learned a lesson too. Its called STOP bringing up irrevelant crap like YOUR RACE. No one gives a crap. Definitely not me. And for future reference, if you don't like Mariah or her singing at all, then don't comment on her videos. That's what the dislike button is for. Then you move on to the next video. Buh-bye.
@fonjadidi Uhh haha. You might need to check out your Social Studies class too hun. Haha cause last I checked, ENGLISH is a LANGUAGE! Black, White, Hispanic, Asian, Hawaiian/Islander Pacific---> THOSE are races hun. Go brush up on your education of everything and THEN you can say something. At least know some basic knowledge and then try and talk about the complex subject of music. BYE NOW.
@Tammie082 OMG if those are races I never even brought them up you dumb bum! I said I wasn't English so really maybe you should go back to school and learn to read and understand !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! you said " And hun, maybe you should go back to English class cause its called a figure of speech. " and then i said "Just because I live in a country where they don't speak English goshh, " im not saying i life in a asian country or black one or what ever!!!!
@fonjadidi As in when I freakin' say ENGLISH CLASS, I mean LANGUAGE ARTS YOU IDIOT! That's what its freakin' called in HIGH SCHOOL. And me, I don't need to go back because I'm in Honors English and have had an A in LA my whole life. I probably couldn't say the same for you because you wouldn't understand anything since your race determines if you learn according to you. I didn't say you were or say you did live in an English-speaking country. Once again, I don't know you.
@Tammie082 You are just angry because I am right I never brought up a race...
and yep you don't know me and also what you don't know is that i gets As in all my subjects...
and OMG stop saying random shit I never said that a race determines if you learn or not YOU ARE SAYING THAT RIGHT NOW, NOW SHUT YOUR FACE AND ENJOY THE VIDEO.
you are just mad because you said i brought up a stupid race when i really NEVER DID.
@fonjadidi Haha. I'm angry. YOU'RE right. Haha. You make me laugh. Oh its called sarcasm. Take a hint. Oh maybe you didn't know what THAT was either. You should go like look in a dictionary or something.
YOU are just mad because I'm right, you know NOTHING about Mariah's musical catalogue, and I'm slammin' you verbally with each contradictory statement you have to say. Its okay hun. They have doctors for that.
I said i am right about me not bringing up any kind of RACE.
read the freaking sentence again and that don't come back because you think your top shit but you are not but hey hun sorry you will never find a cure for than..
@fonjadidi Haha. Um no. YOU DID and that's where you're wrong. it wasn't said but when you say "oh boo hoo just because i live in a country that doesn't speak English....boo hoo hoo...poor me and the whole crap story" Haha. I think I'm top shit. Ha. You said it not me. Find a cure for what? Being smart and actually knowing how to debate and argue? Ha. I think not. That's not a problem. You might need to learn how to bring your points together and then talk some. Good bye hun.
@moviegirl6 saying this isn't singing is saying mariah doesn't sing, which is just as silly as you saying you dont shit. mariah is the greatest singer of all time :)
@QueenMariahCarey Hahaha...you act like you can phase me. The fact that you need to verbally attack me and resort to name calling to prove a point shows how immature you are. Grow up. This wasn't a personal attack on you or Mariah. Get over yourself. Thank you and have a nice day.
@moviegirl6 i will rape ur ass And let the broken excrement leak into my soft nutty asshole smooth milkshake bloody ass kiss fuck dick cum white milky way lovepoem baby dick tits LMFaaooooo!!!
Studies show that dogs actually could hear the highest and softest sounds that are so high/soft that it is only the dogs who could hear them and humans can't. We could still hear Mariah's voice, so in truth and in humor, yeah, the dog's right Mariah! not high enough...still sound low to him! lols!
@freddiestorm so calling me stupid makes you feel more clever,does it makes you feel better about yourself???Gezz..is it so hard to act and talk like a civilized, decent person not like a fucking cave man???
i can hit the high note in Emotions :)
monsterhighluv17 1 day ago
wow this chick sing
KIKSTIR1 2 days ago
OMFG this is so gangster. WTF needs like 80 BILLION views more...
JessOrdaz 2 days ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Why would someone ever do that to a dog's ears?
H2oblow 2 days ago
Comment removed
H2oblow 2 days ago
she's getting the air from her breast..
MySaggin 4 days ago
@MySaggin BWAHAHAHAHA
MDB2770 3 days ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hei I have a whistle, but it isn't very clean.. can you tell me how can I clean my whistle? I have to exercise a long time yes?
iraklitushishvili 6 days ago
My one&only QUEEN!!!!!! <3
MCmaki91 1 week ago
She has SWALLOWED a whistle and because she's hella smart she used it in the right way xD
chixTaylor13 1 week ago
This has been flagged as spam show
❤ღ♥ i love her ♥ღ ♥♥ !!!!!
ninaastarlight 1 week ago
Comment removed
ninaastarlight 1 week ago
I can do the same
Masharus1 1 week ago
I would love some feedback on my whistle videos :) Im a huge fan of mariah and have just started posting up some videos of me whistling some mariah songs. <3
TheRealBabyJax 1 week ago
she's gonna explode man! ! but i love her
bokherif18 2 weeks ago
haha Snoop dog...
Tesha132 2 weeks ago
Wow, her voice is as immaculate as her beautiful white grand piano once apart of the legendary Marilyn Monroe's estate. That why we call the wind Mariah as she brings the characteristics of heaven where ever she sings.
She is a Jewel: We are more blessed that she opens up her heaven for us to enter into the mysteries of the divine.
MLabriola9 2 weeks ago 3
What does Snoop Dogg know about high notes?
idk1235cb 2 weeks ago 8
That woman could break glass with her voice. How does she go so damn HIGH?!
ShilEmPara 2 weeks ago 2
@jacquesno3 "gmafb"? Stop butchering an entire language by turning something into an acronym that no one will figure out just to excuse your laziness. Also, stereotyping won't get you anywhere when trying to understand someone.
jerrywayne93 3 weeks ago
My ears, just vomited. XDDDD
chrstangirl55 3 weeks ago
@lathanregintree woah when did she hit b7?
bullet0tears 3 weeks ago
Forget her whistle, check out her LEGS! Man do I want a tan like that!!
Askimoula 3 weeks ago
ok , can someone explain to me how to do that ! I'm for real ... or are certain people born with with ?
mizzchristine1 3 weeks ago
I have a strange feeling that was fake??...
sheshines4all 3 weeks ago
@sheshines4all What do you mean fake?
babylovemeonemoretim 3 weeks ago
The best whistle note was Minnie Ripperton; Mariah's whistle is overrated, airy, and a lot of times manipulated
BlackDivas1 3 weeks ago
@BlackDivas1 Her whistle is not overrated babe. That is just clear, not airy. The thing is she doesn't need to pull her larynx up to whistle, she can sing words while doing vocal runs in whistle, she can turn from chest to whistle without pausing, she can whistle higher than Minnie and she can totally control them. Yes, Minnie is her superior but actually Mariah is very good, not overrated any at all
babylovemeonemoretim 3 weeks ago
@babylovemeonemoretim Minnie by far has the best whistle tone. Her whistle never sounded pinched or forced it just came out naturally. Mariah's whistle register is nice but not as fluid and pure as Minnie's.
BlackDivas1 3 weeks ago
@BlackDivas1 I admit that Minnie is very good, she is Mariah's idol but Mariah is very good at whistle register too. So please don't say that she is overrated because she is not. She has many rarest skills that Minnie doesn't have.
babylovemeonemoretim 3 weeks ago 3
I love this video! Mariah Carey's amazing!! :D xx
meags9497 3 weeks ago
that is her highest note better than any singer
18korwin 4 weeks ago
@18korwin that is only a c#7,lol her highest is g#7 on record but b7 off record
lathanregintree 3 weeks ago
This is not her highest note lol.
stardusth2o 4 weeks ago
lol
bimmer123 4 weeks ago
come on guys if mariah is not able to sing please tell me who is ??
juan85360 4 weeks ago
ahhhhhhh
paulosoulo 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Well done. Love the dog. Poor little guy. LOL!!!
yourtreat2 1 month ago
gmafb. "I AXED for a high note"? Thousands of years of this country mastering the English language....and in only 50 years! ~ an entire culture a. Still can't speak it and b. have adopted ignorant English-slander into society. Nice. Maybe instead of buying & smoking weed, crack and whatever else drugs they're on....they should go back to 5th grade elementary English class! Gross human beings.
jacquesno3 1 month ago
@jacquesno3 Is there a particular kind of people you are referring to or are you speaking of people in general?.Because I am suspecting you are speaking of Black people but I hope i am wrong. I saw your comment and just could not hold myself from commenting. I ask this because of your use of "culture" and "they".
NickiMinajDaBaddest 1 month ago 2
@jacquesno3 Way to stereotype.
KrysBrown89 4 weeks ago
this is nothing compared to her prime
FrostMan92 1 month ago 4
Her highest not is 4 notes in a half higher than the end part :))
DanielAvilaAGT 1 month ago
for me~ she really do have to move that hand like that?
animalscrossing 1 month ago
@animalscrossing
she's a diva!!! :P
TheCelebBubble 1 month ago
its not the hightest
HelloKitty322354 1 month ago
This is not her HIGHEST, she is even higher than that! Check out her "Emotions performance back in 90's. She's communicating to Aliens lol.
MrTourture 1 month ago 62
@MrTourture lmfao THAT WAS HELLA FUNNY
AdonisDeMarion 1 month ago
@MrTourture I think she's communicating to the angels. This woman is amazing!!!
babylovemeonemoretim 3 weeks ago
@MrTourture LMAO
MDB2770 3 days ago
Holy crap.....
ILOVEBOYS1ful 1 month ago
@coldteddies
Actually, aiming for the highest notes is not psychologically damaging at all. It's a pretty high honor to be blessed with such vocal ability. As a singer myself, I look to singers such as Mariah, Whitney, Solange, Beyonce, Monica, Keyshia and Aaliyah to challenge and strengthen my own voice. It's like this: if I can do all they can do, I can do more. It's psychologically and vocally stimulating. You wouldn't understand, of course, but this is like a sport for us. And way more diff
nancyshannon53406 1 month ago
Wow
saralawsmusic 1 month ago
Ahahaha
Indii09 1 month ago
How old MC in this video? Please tell to me..
She is So Awesome..
mangajoentax 1 month ago
its a shame she made whistles her gimick because people who arent fans only know her for that despite all her songs...especially her old shit. is near impossible to sing by most musicians
shaunmike 1 month ago
all you pseudo musically inclined people know that she still has 3 octaves without whistle right? she can zing easily from alto to soprano. go listen to her songs without whistles and tell me who can sing them.
shaunmike 1 month ago
I could watch this all day
lasanino 1 month ago
"I axed for a high note..."
mrunderestimated1 1 month ago 4
The dogs all like Dude Wtf You're kidding this is high enough!!!! Please make it stop!
krazykotabug 1 month ago
argh my ears.
why artists feel compelled to enter the whistle register is beyond me, physiologically it's horrible for you and it's completely unnecessary. Perhaps hitting an F6 makes her feel good about herself?
coldteddies 1 month ago
why are her whistles so airy -.-
plateir4ever 1 month ago 81
@plateir4ever it was produced that way.... I think?
LoboAscuridad1 1 month ago
@plateir4ever not always but soem times yes they are. when u have just warmed up they will be airy but after an hour of being warmed up the airyness goes way.
lathanregintree 3 weeks ago
@plateir4ever It's so they sound less like a scream. It's also partly due to Mariah's vocal nodules which were playing up around this era.
BigBlyeEyes1234 3 weeks ago
@plateir4ever
because it is a whistle note and not a true falsetto
MedusaDOA4 2 weeks ago
@plateir4ever Mariah can whistle in both airy tone and full tone =)
KateConan 2 weeks ago
@plateir4ever Because it needs to be to reach the higher notes. Watch my videos and u will see, even mine are airy when i hit up to a E7
TheRealBabyJax 1 week ago
@plateir4ever i have always wanted that. they don't always sound like that, but often enough to noticed it. it still sounds good to me. and maybe she they are airy because she might have been told to take in a lot of air to belt and push it outwards.
chrisbh1992 1 week ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i used a software. and i played mariah's performance of america the beautiful the software showed up c8 on the high note part....and i played star spangled banner with her and it was a b7 at the high note part
Amandasenju11 1 month ago
whistle tones are too icy and cold on my ears for listening pleasure. i need timbre to go along with a high note like that to give it substance
jfichter69 1 month ago
O_o
vianeykinz 1 month ago
lmao @Mariah's face after the dog ran off X'D
nefsy09 1 month ago
omg , how to do it like that ?
TheViiViiAnn 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
hey, someone lite a cig.....oh wait.... nvm its just the like bar
joe87956 1 month ago
I'm gonna be really racist here and I don't care, why do black people always say "axed" when they say "asked"?
tipofmytongue1024 1 month ago
@tipofmytongue1024 Well aren't we proper.Try this,take any recording device and say,"ask,asking and asked" in it,,preferably using each in a sentence.You'll find even you can't emphasize "ed" without a pause,who does that?"As for Snoop Dogg the ventriloquist".I think she should have used "Jaleel White" to add a little humor. Her vocal range is unthinkable,and the dog thought the same that's why he hauled ask "With a K" while he still had enough hearing to know that it's pronounced with an "S".
alxmcnll325 1 month ago
@alxmcnll325 Thanks for not being rude and actually answering my question with intelligence, I was losing hope for humanity for a while. lol. But you're right, ask...ed it's impossible. And I like the Jaleel White idea.
tipofmytongue1024 1 month ago
mariah is amazing! damn
singerchiara99 1 month ago
lol love this the dog was so adorable and snoop doggs voice made me laugh and Mariah is amazing
Daya from Austrailia
4UIAMHERE 1 month ago
Haha my ears just vomited.
rayandjazz14 1 month ago
that was so funny!
hkbuddy97006 1 month ago
omgggggg !!!!!! amazing
huglecammar 1 month ago
Hey the dogs can hear 10 times better than humas.... thast cruel.
MiguelFRCable 2 months ago
what a fucking pathetic and retarded waste of space ugly loose women she is
MrRyanhancock1234 2 months ago
haha check out hayley williams whistle voice....
FallingXInXTheXDark 2 months ago
Mi ears jus vomited its still funny if yhu play it over and over again
ArMonnie14 2 months ago
I'm glad I wasn't wearing headphones for this video. That would have really left me with a headache.
archlunarwolf 2 months ago
lmfaooo da dogg had me crackin up!!
RocRoyalIsMyHubby 2 months ago
Snoop dog ....... lol
TheRaginTiger 2 months ago
Mariah's whistle has more beauty than the other singers whom also use whistle.
She has the ability the make her whistles
sound soft and bel canto, and sometimes she can make them sound fierce and piercing based on the song.
LuckyDiamond777 2 months ago 51
@LuckyDiamond777 true, she is so talented =)
JCGandMe 2 months ago
@1earthwindfire It's octave unison and it's an A5. Her highest chest is a G#5, possibly A5, but according to others it was lipped.
fuckingbrill 2 months ago
Where is that? is that her home???
maudale 2 months ago
@maudale Yes.
Raimundo91 1 month ago
O_O
Breloom267 2 months ago
Fonjadidi an tammie082 please stop
CuterBunny8 2 months ago
@CuterBunny8 haha i know right..
fonjadidi 2 months ago
Comment removed
Amnesiac18 2 months ago
what note is her highest??
Amnesiac18 2 months ago
@Amnesiac18 Her highest note in full voice is a A5 in this song (A5 live was possibly lipped), highest whistle ever G#7
fuckingbrill 2 months ago
anyone else not able to do that?
naijadiva96 2 months ago
was that dog snoop dog?
anGelZgo2HeaVen 2 months ago 127
@anGelZgo2HeaVen snoop dogg* and yeah it was him. xD
iiAmitx3 1 month ago
@anGelZgo2HeaVen or eminem?
CrazyONe531989 1 month ago
Hitting high notes does not make you a great singer. YES, she's a beautiful singer but not because of these unnatural-sounding whistle screeches. I mean, what about Amy Whinehouse? She had deep contralto vocals and was one of the best female vocalists ever.
SantanaLopez100 2 months ago
And just an added note. Mariah Carey does NOT have a 5 octave vocal range. Don't believe everything you read in wikipedia. Octaves are only measured in notes you can actually SING, not hit like screeching banshee.
moviegirl6 2 months ago
@moviegirl6 haha i agree.
fonjadidi 2 months ago
@moviegirl6 Well hun, then freakin' explain this to me cause last I checked these are PIANO notes sung!. Its a video called Mariah Carey- 5 Octaves in One Minute!! PLEASE and I mean PLEASE look at this video and THEN you can tell me or ANYONE else that this isn't 5 octaves. Oh and just so you know, Wiki isn't the only source that says Mariah has a 5 octave range, thank you very much.
Tammie082 2 months ago
@moviegirl6 Just so you know for future reference, she can hit every note between E2 to G#7. Look at her catalougue and THEN come back to me hun. :)
Tammie082 2 months ago
@Tammie082 Once again, "hitting" and "singing" the note are two entirely different concepts. If you can SING the note, you can count it in your range. If you can only hit it on a squeak...it doesn't count.
moviegirl6 2 months ago
@moviegirl6 Haha. Well I sure AS HELL do NOT hear a squeak anywhere IN THIS VIDEO or ANY of her songs for that matter. Go look at her catalogue, once again, and then come back to me.
Tammie082 2 months ago
Mariah Carey has a voice, but she squeaks too much which makes it sound bad when she goes for those high notes. I'm sorry but that is not singing when she does that. I'm not a hater, but I'm definitely not a fan. There are so many singers out there that are so much better than her. The only reason she got all the recognition and album sales was because she was a sex symbol. Nothing more.
moviegirl6 2 months ago
@moviegirl6 LOL you are the most ignorant piece of shit I've ever seen on youtube. really. the whistle note register is so rare and only 1% of the POPULATION has control over this range and are able to sing in it.
chrisak49 1 month ago
@chrisak49 Just because I'm stating my opinion doesn't mean I'm ignorant. I know about singing and music because I've been professionally trained and I've taken courses in school. This isn't coming from someone who has no experience with music. YOU on the other hand are making yourself look foolish with your unnecessary vulgar language. Get over yourself.
moviegirl6 1 month ago
@chrisak49 moviegirl has a point, mariah isn't recognised for her ability to sing, she is recognised for her popularity. there has to be a point where you decide the noise coming out of someones mouth is no longer singing. because we are interpreting this professionally, there is a much higher threshold.
besides all that, imo, higher isn't better, especially when you develop vocal nodules (like two of my friends who strained their voice like this)
TheBluePianist 1 month ago
Her vocal range is fucking insane. Mariah is the best singer of all time at the end of the day :)
MEareCAT 2 months ago
The poor dog probably went deaf after the first whistle note. lol Poor wishbone :/
alejandroporter 2 months ago 69
She is proven to lipsync because she can't sing anymore.
fonjadidi 2 months ago
@fonjadidi Trick NO! Its called she can LIPSYNC all she WANTS TO BECAUSE this wonderful, amazing, 5-octave singer has proven for 20 YEARS that she can sing. She can do whatever the hell she wants. Obviously her album sales and influence show that. Oh for future reference, she's sold 200 MILLION RECORDS WORLDWIDE. I'm done.
Tammie082 2 months ago
@Tammie082 DUDE READ WHAT IM WRITING SHE HAS BEEN PROVEN TO LYPSINC BECAUSE SHE CAN'T SING ANYMORE!!! she had lost her voice, but kept singing her notes which totally ruined her just because you're ignorant doesn't mean you're right. :L
fonjadidi 2 months ago
@fonjadidi Haha. You're funny cause obviously you've been under a rock the past 5 to 6 years. How about you go listen to a 2010 performance of hers and then come back to me. Just cause you're a hater, doesn't mean you're right.
Tammie082 2 months ago
@Tammie082 I'm not a hater, hate is a very strong word and you can't eve " hate " someone you don't know. no that mate i don't want to listen to her because she doesn't sing she just squeaks and to ME it doesn't sound nice in anyway. no i dont live under a rock i guess you still watch sponge bob
fonjadidi 2 months ago
@fonjadidi Haha. Wow. Yeah. You're not a hater. If you say so. Whatever makes you sleep at night. Yeah. She's hasn't been singing for 20 years and she's definitely not one of the best singers of our generation. And she's definitely not influenced a GENERATION of singers by her 5-OCTAVE RANGE. If you say so. And hun, maybe you should go back to English class cause its called a figure of speech.
Tammie082 2 months ago
@Tammie082 Just because I live in a country where they don't speak English goshh, I sleep very well thank you ;) yep she is definitely not the best. your opinion will be your opinion mine will be mine hun.
fonjadidi 2 months ago
@fonjadidi Haha. Um actually I didn't know you lived in another country and that definitely doesn't make a difference and two you're just trying to bring up your ethnicity for some idiotic reason. Get over yourself. once again, its called figures of speech. Mmmk. Obviously her album sales show that. Oh. I might have to remind you. 200 MILLION worldwide. Not nationwide. But WORLDWIDE. Good for you. But majority likes Mariah.
Tammie082 2 months ago
@Tammie082 It makes a hell of a difference. i feel sorry for the scam 200 million people took place in.
fonjadidi 2 months ago
@fonjadidi Awww and why is it that? See you're making your RACE a problem when I don't even know you or even care. I don't care about who you are. Its called actually ARGUING about the topic at hand. That's really immature when people try and bring up irrevelant crap. Haha. Yeah. Mariah's voice is TOTALLY a scam and sucks. Yeah. We'll go with that.
Tammie082 2 months ago
@Tammie082 If you don't care stop commenting :L. it's not immature it's telling you not to judge people to quickly and that is a very important lesson in life. so umm yeah.
fonjadidi 2 months ago
@fonjadidi Yeah I'm judging quickly. If you say so. Hey, hope you learned a lesson too. Its called STOP bringing up irrevelant crap like YOUR RACE. No one gives a crap. Definitely not me. And for future reference, if you don't like Mariah or her singing at all, then don't comment on her videos. That's what the dislike button is for. Then you move on to the next video. Buh-bye.
Tammie082 2 months ago
@Tammie082 You were the one bringing up the English class ( English is a race ) mmmhhhh.. yeah you're real stuck now. BYE
fonjadidi 2 months ago
@fonjadidi Uhh haha. You might need to check out your Social Studies class too hun. Haha cause last I checked, ENGLISH is a LANGUAGE! Black, White, Hispanic, Asian, Hawaiian/Islander Pacific---> THOSE are races hun. Go brush up on your education of everything and THEN you can say something. At least know some basic knowledge and then try and talk about the complex subject of music. BYE NOW.
Tammie082 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Tammie082 OMG if those are races I never even brought them up you dumb bum! I said I wasn't English so really maybe you should go back to school and learn to read and understand !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! you said " And hun, maybe you should go back to English class cause its called a figure of speech. " and then i said "Just because I live in a country where they don't speak English goshh, " im not saying i life in a asian country or black one or what ever!!!!
fonjadidi 2 months ago
@fonjadidi As in when I freakin' say ENGLISH CLASS, I mean LANGUAGE ARTS YOU IDIOT! That's what its freakin' called in HIGH SCHOOL. And me, I don't need to go back because I'm in Honors English and have had an A in LA my whole life. I probably couldn't say the same for you because you wouldn't understand anything since your race determines if you learn according to you. I didn't say you were or say you did live in an English-speaking country. Once again, I don't know you.
Tammie082 2 months ago
@Tammie082 You are just angry because I am right I never brought up a race...
and yep you don't know me and also what you don't know is that i gets As in all my subjects...
and OMG stop saying random shit I never said that a race determines if you learn or not YOU ARE SAYING THAT RIGHT NOW, NOW SHUT YOUR FACE AND ENJOY THE VIDEO.
you are just mad because you said i brought up a stupid race when i really NEVER DID.
fonjadidi 2 months ago
@fonjadidi Haha. I'm angry. YOU'RE right. Haha. You make me laugh. Oh its called sarcasm. Take a hint. Oh maybe you didn't know what THAT was either. You should go like look in a dictionary or something.
YOU are just mad because I'm right, you know NOTHING about Mariah's musical catalogue, and I'm slammin' you verbally with each contradictory statement you have to say. Its okay hun. They have doctors for that.
Tammie082 2 months ago
@Tammie082 You seriously can't read can you??
I said i am right about me not bringing up any kind of RACE.
read the freaking sentence again and that don't come back because you think your top shit but you are not but hey hun sorry you will never find a cure for than..
fonjadidi 2 months ago
@fonjadidi Haha. Um no. YOU DID and that's where you're wrong. it wasn't said but when you say "oh boo hoo just because i live in a country that doesn't speak English....boo hoo hoo...poor me and the whole crap story" Haha. I think I'm top shit. Ha. You said it not me. Find a cure for what? Being smart and actually knowing how to debate and argue? Ha. I think not. That's not a problem. You might need to learn how to bring your points together and then talk some. Good bye hun.
Tammie082 2 months ago
@Tammie082 This just shows again that you can't read....
I said "because you think your top shit but you are not but hey hun sorry you will never find a cure for that.. "
and than your'e like a cure for what hahaha you are very funny...
AND NO I DIDN'T SAY ANYKIND OF RACE SO YOU ARE WRONG and here you are bringing random stuff again.
fonjadidi 2 months ago
Good Bye hun...
fonjadidi 2 months ago
Those aren't whistles... Those are high notes and are being "sung"... Don't hate because you cant sing...
jenn0will0rock 2 months ago
@jenn0will0rock this is not singing. :l
fonjadidi 2 months ago
I'm sorry but that's not singing. That's squeaking/screeching and does not sound good in anyway, musically.
moviegirl6 2 months ago 4
@moviegirl6 saying this isn't singing is saying mariah doesn't sing, which is just as silly as you saying you dont shit. mariah is the greatest singer of all time :)
CalemMartin 2 months ago
@moviegirl6 Thank goodness your FAILED opinion holds ZERO weight! Mariah's whistle sounds beautiful, IDIOT!
QueenMariahCarey 2 months ago
@QueenMariahCarey Hahaha...you act like you can phase me. The fact that you need to verbally attack me and resort to name calling to prove a point shows how immature you are. Grow up. This wasn't a personal attack on you or Mariah. Get over yourself. Thank you and have a nice day.
moviegirl6 2 months ago
@moviegirl6 Hun you are an IDIOT and what I said still stands. CHOW!
QueenMariahCarey 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@QueenMariahCarey Thank you for continuing to prove my point.
moviegirl6 2 months ago
@moviegirl6 i will rape ur ass And let the broken excrement leak into my soft nutty asshole smooth milkshake bloody ass kiss fuck dick cum white milky way lovepoem baby dick tits LMFaaooooo!!!
MrRyanhancock1234 2 months ago
@MrRyanhancock1234 What in the world is wrong with you?
moviegirl6 2 months ago
@moviegirl6 lol squeaking/screeching, hahaha
crayyawn 1 month ago
cool .. :))
jhepfoy 2 months ago
lol, i love the video, but i dont believe she can REALLY sing that high, im sorry, i just can't
joetoeb15 2 months ago
what do you suppose is doing it then? it does seem quite unbelievable but she whistles in almost all of her songs and live performances??
CalemMartin 2 months ago
@CalemMartin well it could be fake because it is not a live video ofcorse, but if she does it in live performances, then i've said nothing ;)
joetoeb15 2 months ago
@joetoeb15 Lol, she just did though... She's sung higher in the past :P
BigBlyeEyes1234 2 months ago
Is she half dolphin?
myNSproductions 2 months ago
Mariah is the best the whistles are clear ,whistles with husky. shes not human, PERFECT!
miyash100 2 months ago
My dogs began to bark when I played this. lmao. :D
iamblessed2005 2 months ago
I'd love to hear her do a note like that in full voice instead of whisper
Poet2916 2 months ago
Studies show that dogs actually could hear the highest and softest sounds that are so high/soft that it is only the dogs who could hear them and humans can't. We could still hear Mariah's voice, so in truth and in humor, yeah, the dog's right Mariah! not high enough...still sound low to him! lols!
rrhotj 2 months ago
SAHE IS IN HEAT
nosnayack 2 months ago
awesome o:
s3naeyeshield 2 months ago
Incredible vocalist. Mariahs range is inhuman.
MEareCAT 2 months ago
WTF How did she do that..
Phia8913 2 months ago
hahaha i do it with my dog hahaha! he gets the "wtf" face! hahahahahhaha
Naneoc 2 months ago
My ears .. still vomiting =))
MrRares18 3 months ago
Satanic 666 @ 0:13.
Calbenmike 3 months ago
sounds great but this is not the highest note ever....Georgia Brown can do much higher and sustain it sooooo much!
watch this: watch?v=OtJHz5jwG0I
AbsolutelyMyself100 3 months ago
@AbsolutelyMyself100 Stupid is the Mariah Carey's highest not ever, nobody talking about just the highest not ever
freddiestorm 3 months ago
@freddiestorm so calling me stupid makes you feel more clever,does it makes you feel better about yourself???Gezz..is it so hard to act and talk like a civilized, decent person not like a fucking cave man???
AbsolutelyMyself100 3 months ago
@AbsolutelyMyself100 Adam lopez can do much higher than Georgia Brown
watch?v=Kdp4NHWr7G8
MultiWilliam15 2 months ago
@MultiWilliam15 agreed,Adam can do higher but he can't sustain the notes as much as Georgia!
AbsolutelyMyself100 2 months ago
Wow who else can reach those notes other than her??
skyblue3219 3 months ago
lol this is cute.
Raven544 3 months ago
OMG
MrGaaabo 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
wow,
i dont know what i can say:]
very high notes
keneth3493 3 months ago
Poor dog, what an asshole she is.
vietcongpornsurfers 3 months ago 2