I have to say though I like both versions, the Debarge version is the one I remember when someone mentions the name of the song. Good job by both of them!
i think mary did GREAT, and nobody else could have done it better than mary EXCEPT Debarge. When it comes to remakes, Mary is the best. When her version came out, i had friends who had no idea it was a remake, that just shows how much justice mary did this song-it also showed how misinformed my friends were! no remake can ever be as good as the original, but mary came real close.
i think mary did GREAT, and nobody else could have done it better than mary EXCEPT Debarge. When it comes to remakes, Mary is the best. When her version came out, i had friends who had no idea it was a remake, that just shows how much justice mary did this song-it also showed how misinformed my friends were!
I like Bunny's better. I have loved her version for years. It's almost like you can hear the pain and longing in her voice as she sings. I feel Bunny's version
I like Bunny's version better. But I love some of Mary's tunes, especially the more mature or older ones. She has indeed become a class act and is a great example to many who started where she did, i.e. Keysha Cole, etc.
I think Mary's version meant more to music at the time, just because she was singing soul when soul was abandoned, she brought it back and added hip-hop for good measure.
This is from the Money Talks movie soundtrack, I bought this cd a lonnnnng time ago because I wanted to hear this remake! lol long before youtube and being able to look up a song u wanted to hear! lol Its cool to see these vs vids! this is a good one because it's not bias like some vs vids i have seen! good work on 2 versions of one great song!
This is from the Money Talks movie soundtrack, I bought this cd a lonnnnng time ago because I wanted to hear this remake! lol long before youtube and being able to look up a song u wanted to hear! lol
Bunny made a good song and a fire beat. If you dont think it's fire, look at the great artists that sampled it that must of thought it was a good beat. Mary does the song good too. Ironically one of my favorite songs sung by both Mary and Bunny.
@MrFred145 Thats a bold statement. Id pay money to hear Bunny sing this. No disrespect to Mary J. Thats my girl and I see her everytime she comes through, Thats like Bunny singing Reminisce. It just aint the same.
I like Mary's version, it's about sex. She wants to spend the night with someone. Mary does sing it in her own special way, and it's something to cruise to. But hands down BUNNY DEBARGE's VERSION IS THE BEST EVER. Her voice is perfect for this song. She wrote it with true feelings and sings it the way it should be sung. Bunny's version is more sincere and you can hear it in her voice. You can truly relate to Bunny and her feelings. She misses her man and wants to share a life with him.
sang the orignal in a talent show when i was like 13, but in all honesty mary j's version is best. to me it just a bangin song, so much real feeling, it still gives me chills like back in da day
I can't compare the 2. I love them both! You really wrote this song? I'm in love with this song!!!! I can so relate to it! I don't care who sings it as long as they sound good, I'm with it! I have been looking for this song for years and ppl kept telling me they didn't know what I was talking about. Only one person remembered it but she thought Lisa Lisa sang it, lol... Now I can see what made her say it but DeBarge was a better group to me. Sorry about the T.M.I....lol
me too..i just heard the original{debarge,Bunny} last nyt,for the 1st tym since 84-85..i was so gettin the chills...just thort i'd have a listen to this..its ok..
dlp1965,mary's version is good but theres no feeling!!But when Bunny sings it you feel what she's saying it gives you the chills so hands down to Bunny.
I loved Mary's Version because there is more bass and feeling behind the words that she sang. I just feel that Mary always delivers well when she sings even in the songs that she has that I don't particularly like. I can respect DeBarge's version because it is quiet and the "dream" factor is captured behind the song but definitely Mary! I loved it loved it!!! Thank you though I had no idea it was remade (isn't every song a remake nowadays though)
I noticed in the original version Bunny sings "Let's build a life together" and Mary sings "Let's spend the night together" in her version. That's a pretty telling example of one thing wrong with the music industry today.
@maqclark taking the song down a few notches! Thanks for pointing that out. This is my first time hearing this version. It's always nice to hear that melody but I prefer Debarge's version. Debarge should redo this one!!!
@maqclark How do you know what she meant by spending the night together, not like she said let's fcuk! Maybe your comment is telling of what's one your mind, lol.!!
@maqclark 2 of the best artists(of my time) have also sampled De Barge tracks. "A dream" is Pac's I ain't mad at cha and "stay with me" is Biggie's "One more chance". I kinda liked the throwbacks as long as they credited the originals. IMHO even those 2 remakes are classics of that time. Anything put out today is just the same bass, snares, and dre's 808's loop a high school kid in their parent's basement could create on FL.
It was purposely done like tht & thtz y this is her version for promotional use && she still did an AWSOME job of singing with tht soul & feeling flowing throughout it @maqclark
im always partial to the originals... (even though Mary J is more my generation -- '86 baby) ... gotta give this one to DeBarge... even though Mary's version is great also.. i think she def did the song justice in the remake
I'm actually a BIG Mary fan.....but thats God AWFUL! I've said it once; I'll say it 1000 times....LEAVE THE CLASSICS ALONE! Lauryn Hill and Jenifer Hudson get a pass
IMHO, the Debarge version is better, no question. Like an earlier poster said, Bunny's vocals seemed more effortless. That said, nothing wrong with MJB's version, the vocals are definitely grittier, more raw... But that's her style... Thanks for sharing!
1st, I didn't even know MJB did a remake. SD man, sorry, but if this was the Gong Show, MJB would be gettin' that gong!! DeBarge, DeBarge, DeBarge!!!! Hands down brah!!! C'mon, you didn't really think MJB could stand up to DeBarge? Mary does better when she sings her own stuff.
I prefer Debarge's version over Mary's because the original was so heartfelt, and the passion & the melody of the words helped the song become a lovable and classic song. The remake wasn't bad, it just wasn't better than the original.
DeBarge, DeBarge, DEBARGE!!! But you knew I was gonna say them!!! LOL Bunny just ripped that song apart, especially towards the end when she started hitting those notes & doing all those runs!!! Man, she showed OUT on that track!!! Mary did her thing for this generation, but if you're gonna do a remake, do it just like, or better than the original!!! This is a great idea Sean, you should do more of these dude!!!
I agree that DeBarge's was better ...seems like less effort on the part of Bunnie............... Mary seemed like she was just singing instaed ot expressing herself in song besides she seems a little too old to be singing such a song you know she ain't into fantasy at her age ???LIke Boobear I am a fan of Mary's BUt the original seems more "authentic"...........just my take on it ....stay blessed
Hey Sean, I prefer Debarge's version hands down!!!!! Although I'm not a big fan of Bunnie's vocals, I think this particular song is well suited for her sound and vocal approach. I can't imagine any other female vocalist giving this song the treatment she did. No disrespect to Mary, I'm a fan of hers as well, but I think she's does better when she performs songs she writes or others write with her in mind. Those great songs she's chosen to remake always seem to be beyond her vocal range.
Yeah, Bunny isn't the best vocalist, but I do hear a Deniece Williams influence. As for Mary, she seems to be reaching for notes that just aren't there, which is the case on most of her 'remakes'.
i'm with bunny,more sexual mary is my wife,but bunny is my mistress,in my dream get it?lol
yubsnme 1 week ago
I have to say though I like both versions, the Debarge version is the one I remember when someone mentions the name of the song. Good job by both of them!
jctunes 2 weeks ago
I think the ORIGINAL is tha best, thats WORD UP!! How i miss the 80's when i use to tag..
haster124 1 month ago 2
Nah the soul of this song cant be touched.. Not even by Mary.. Mary brings hip hop to songs. And this song doesnt need it. Bunny hands down.
Zerubba 2 months ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
debarge has the best version
tequillachanel23 2 months ago
mary made the song popular because i am 43 and i never paid attention to the song until she did it, their version sounds soul-less!!!
youngghostmack10 2 months ago 2
AS WE DANCE TO THE MELODY WE HAVE SO MUCH TO SHARE WHEN THE MUSIC STOP IN A FLAH I WAS ALL ALONE!!! MY FAV I GOT CRAZY MEMORIES
ribab420 3 months ago
This is fire....I didn't even know this was a remake.....I heard it on the money talks soundtrack and sold on it....
mardria78 4 months ago
I love Mary. She is bad to the bone and a real soldier. The only woman to make me buy products from TV.
carterdavina 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i think mary did GREAT, and nobody else could have done it better than mary EXCEPT Debarge. When it comes to remakes, Mary is the best. When her version came out, i had friends who had no idea it was a remake, that just shows how much justice mary did this song-it also showed how misinformed my friends were! no remake can ever be as good as the original, but mary came real close.
supareke 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i think mary did GREAT, and nobody else could have done it better than mary EXCEPT Debarge. When it comes to remakes, Mary is the best. When her version came out, i had friends who had no idea it was a remake, that just shows how much justice mary did this song-it also showed how misinformed my friends were!
supareke 5 months ago
So many Memories
Roshelle0913 8 months ago
I like Bunny's better. I have loved her version for years. It's almost like you can hear the pain and longing in her voice as she sings. I feel Bunny's version
navlys33 10 months ago
I love BOTH versions..but NO ONE does a remake like Mary!!! I love her version more
Eightysbayb803 10 months ago 8
@Eightysbayb803 Ok, thanks for stopping by and sharing your thoughts
seand67 10 months ago
I prefer the 1983 original, myself... ;-)
gameshowluvr86 10 months ago
THIS IS SOOOOOOOOOOO LONG YO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! but good song ,good song
MzNina313 1 year ago
I like Bunny's version better. But I love some of Mary's tunes, especially the more mature or older ones. She has indeed become a class act and is a great example to many who started where she did, i.e. Keysha Cole, etc.
miamac63utube 1 year ago 2
@miamac63utube Thanks for stopping by and posting great comments
seand67 1 year ago
I liked both version but however Mary's Version meant more at the time u had a combo of both soul and hip hop.
bigmal33 1 year ago
uh uh Debarge!! way better
GellyRolll 1 year ago 5
love debarge better love bunny's part .
rainbowlor 1 year ago 2
No I like the Debarge ! Hands down the original ! Nothing against Mary !
Lillie540 1 year ago 18
I like this cover song better than the debarge's original. But their song too is alright I still like it both.
richlove404 1 year ago
damn i luv this song thanks for the posting
olwethu1000 1 year ago
I love mary but I got to got with old school " bunny"
Innocentmeetsin88 1 year ago
I think Mary's version meant more to music at the time, just because she was singing soul when soul was abandoned, she brought it back and added hip-hop for good measure.
thestaydown 1 year ago 2
MJ AND SPIDERMAN
MrTusevEnfo 1 year ago
This is from the Money Talks movie soundtrack, I bought this cd a lonnnnng time ago because I wanted to hear this remake! lol long before youtube and being able to look up a song u wanted to hear! lol Its cool to see these vs vids! this is a good one because it's not bias like some vs vids i have seen! good work on 2 versions of one great song!
cocotreasure 1 year ago 4
@cocotreasure Thanks for stopping by, and I appreciate your comments!
seand67 1 year ago
This is from the Money Talks movie soundtrack, I bought this cd a lonnnnng time ago because I wanted to hear this remake! lol long before youtube and being able to look up a song u wanted to hear! lol
cocotreasure 1 year ago
Mary is the best
Cutie13000 1 year ago
Love both versions.......I am partial to the soprano voice, as I sing soprano myself, however, Mary J. put a little more soul to the song.
MsPinkleopard 1 year ago
i like bunny's version better her voice is not as rough and the song is not as shallow
kyemari 1 year ago
this iz my fav song of all time luv u mary
liltooty13 1 year ago
Bunny made a good song and a fire beat. If you dont think it's fire, look at the great artists that sampled it that must of thought it was a good beat. Mary does the song good too. Ironically one of my favorite songs sung by both Mary and Bunny.
benzo560 1 year ago
@benzo560 Great point!
seand67 1 year ago
Marys voice too powerful the other one just sounds cute mj blew her out the water. but Debarge are true innovators
MrFred145 1 year ago
@MrFred145 "Mary's voice too powerful" Oh really ? Thanks for watching
seand67 1 year ago
Comment removed
sheraz757 1 year ago
@MrFred145 Thats a bold statement. Id pay money to hear Bunny sing this. No disrespect to Mary J. Thats my girl and I see her everytime she comes through, Thats like Bunny singing Reminisce. It just aint the same.
sheraz757 1 year ago 4
@sheraz757 THanks
seand67 1 year ago
I like Mary's version, it's about sex. She wants to spend the night with someone. Mary does sing it in her own special way, and it's something to cruise to. But hands down BUNNY DEBARGE's VERSION IS THE BEST EVER. Her voice is perfect for this song. She wrote it with true feelings and sings it the way it should be sung. Bunny's version is more sincere and you can hear it in her voice. You can truly relate to Bunny and her feelings. She misses her man and wants to share a life with him.
hasalwaysBLESSEDme 1 year ago 3
aint my baby bad ????
bubaweezee 1 year ago
@bubaweezee Who Bunny Debarge...LOL
seand67 1 year ago
Nobody does it like Bunny!
LLcoolJFan001 1 year ago
sang the orignal in a talent show when i was like 13, but in all honesty mary j's version is best. to me it just a bangin song, so much real feeling, it still gives me chills like back in da day
datondra 1 year ago
Bunny Debarge all day but Mary but her signature twist on it....good remake but like 2pac said I Aint Mad at cha
reigncc 1 year ago
I love Mary and my mom cant stand her and says she's the queen of remakes...lol
umm...yea she is.
But she shudve left this to debarge 4 sure. Becuz this aint that
AshleyBellaDonna91 1 year ago
I like both versions but I feel Bunny's version. Bunny's is definitely better.
navlys33 1 year ago
i don't know, my opinion is definitely skewed... i grew up as a small kid lovin' mary j's music... all in all, they're both great!
thoyo 1 year ago
bunny did a better job
datsingingchic 1 year ago
hey!!!! thats Bunny Debarge in the 2nd part..wow!!! thats so good of Mary j Blige to do that..oh heck i just read the title..oopz my bad!!!
tewhere1 2 years ago
I can't compare the 2. I love them both! You really wrote this song? I'm in love with this song!!!! I can so relate to it! I don't care who sings it as long as they sound good, I'm with it! I have been looking for this song for years and ppl kept telling me they didn't know what I was talking about. Only one person remembered it but she thought Lisa Lisa sang it, lol... Now I can see what made her say it but DeBarge was a better group to me. Sorry about the T.M.I....lol
CallMeCharlie11 2 years ago
No, Bunny DeBarge wrote this song.
seand67 2 years ago
Oh ok. Thank you!
CallMeCharlie11 2 years ago
@CallMeCharlie11 That's cool Plus Bunny DeBarge wrote this song and her brother El produced it
MUSICENCYLOPEDIA 1 year ago
love this song used to sing this all the time i also love the original it gives me chills
Missbeautiful49 2 years ago
me too..i just heard the original{debarge,Bunny} last nyt,for the 1st tym since 84-85..i was so gettin the chills...just thort i'd have a listen to this..its ok..
tewhere1 2 years ago
oh and by da way u know mary smashed this song right=)
kevsin79 2 years ago
i really wish i could get this song=]
kevsin79 2 years ago
dlp1965,mary's version is good but theres no feeling!!But when Bunny sings it you feel what she's saying it gives you the chills so hands down to Bunny.
59771965 2 years ago 3
Thanks for the comments. As the writer of the song, Bunny had a sincere connection to the song's lyrics.
seand67 2 years ago
no sorry mary but bunny debarge version is better
abizam 2 years ago 2
I agree, Bunny's version has a haunting effect; personifies dreams and love lost. it
davetteb100 2 years ago
@davetteb100 yes it does i agree...
seven4teen4queen 2 years ago
1997!
xxxMrBligexxx 2 years ago
I loved Mary's Version because there is more bass and feeling behind the words that she sang. I just feel that Mary always delivers well when she sings even in the songs that she has that I don't particularly like. I can respect DeBarge's version because it is quiet and the "dream" factor is captured behind the song but definitely Mary! I loved it loved it!!! Thank you though I had no idea it was remade (isn't every song a remake nowadays though)
NeumannNurd 2 years ago
Thanks for watching & posting your comments
seand67 2 years ago
I noticed in the original version Bunny sings "Let's build a life together" and Mary sings "Let's spend the night together" in her version. That's a pretty telling example of one thing wrong with the music industry today.
maqclark 2 years ago 36
Thanks for that GREAT observation. Right on time
seand67 2 years ago
@maqclark very very true! i love mary's version but like tht line from debarge better
depeach20 1 year ago
@maqclark on point!
CatchingFeelings 1 year ago
@maqclark taking the song down a few notches! Thanks for pointing that out. This is my first time hearing this version. It's always nice to hear that melody but I prefer Debarge's version. Debarge should redo this one!!!
MsFruitbasket 1 year ago
@maqclark How do you know what she meant by spending the night together, not like she said let's fcuk! Maybe your comment is telling of what's one your mind, lol.!!
thestaydown 1 year ago
@maqclark 2 of the best artists(of my time) have also sampled De Barge tracks. "A dream" is Pac's I ain't mad at cha and "stay with me" is Biggie's "One more chance". I kinda liked the throwbacks as long as they credited the originals. IMHO even those 2 remakes are classics of that time. Anything put out today is just the same bass, snares, and dre's 808's loop a high school kid in their parent's basement could create on FL.
t436 1 year ago
It was purposely done like tht & thtz y this is her version for promotional use && she still did an AWSOME job of singing with tht soul & feeling flowing throughout it @maqclark
4iamKENdoll 1 year ago
@maqclark so true
SuchADamnFreak 8 months ago
the one from the old days got my vote all day.
knockout77 2 years ago 2
wow, i didnt know the classic version. thanks for ducating me there :) I love both versions now!!!!
misslynda82 2 years ago
OH NO~!! BUNNY killed it~!!
No disrespect to Mary J.. she's a true talent but this track was made for Bunny Debarge
Dayna4133 2 years ago 4
I love Mary, but when I think of this song it's always Bunny's version that I think of
mrlucky1mg 2 years ago 2
Love it.. Money Talk Soundtrack was Great!!! Mary Did this song JUSTICE!!
mzTremias808 2 years ago 2
im always partial to the originals... (even though Mary J is more my generation -- '86 baby) ... gotta give this one to DeBarge... even though Mary's version is great also.. i think she def did the song justice in the remake
wouldyoumind09 2 years ago
Mary's version has soooooo much more soul and passion in it! I'm going with Mary with this one...the Debarge one is ...cute...but Mary killed it!
sh4ebutta 2 years ago
Having said that,
I prefer the Debarge version better.
blueBlackpurple 2 years ago
I've never heard either of these songs
before so when I listen to the music
I can't help but think of 2pac's
" I ain't mad at cha."
blueBlackpurple 2 years ago
Yes 2pac sampled Debarge too!
seand67 2 years ago
@seand67 So Did BlackStreet
MUSICENCYLOPEDIA 1 year ago
@MUSICENCYLOPEDIA Right, Teddy Riley did use the sample. Thanks
seand67 1 year ago
@seand67 No problem. He sampled this song for BlackSTREET's classic "Don't Leave Me'
MUSICENCYLOPEDIA 1 year ago
@MUSICENCYLOPEDIA Oh yes, Blackstreet's 'Another Level' was one of the BEST CDs from 1996. I have it in my collection
seand67 1 year ago 2
@seand67 I got it for my moms for Christmas. DeBarge needs to be honored by BET and Soul Train
MUSICENCYLOPEDIA 1 year ago
I'm actually a BIG Mary fan.....but thats God AWFUL! I've said it once; I'll say it 1000 times....LEAVE THE CLASSICS ALONE! Lauryn Hill and Jenifer Hudson get a pass
thisiskevinw 2 years ago
LMAO x 5!! Call me later Kevin...;~)
seand67 2 years ago
I prefer Mary's cause it was the first version I heard.
canthidefromluv 2 years ago 6
cool video man enjoyed both versions.
NCGUY74 2 years ago 2
Love Mary ,but Bunny owns this song!!!!!!
smoothgroov 2 years ago 3
IMHO, the Debarge version is better, no question. Like an earlier poster said, Bunny's vocals seemed more effortless. That said, nothing wrong with MJB's version, the vocals are definitely grittier, more raw... But that's her style... Thanks for sharing!
reeseereece 2 years ago 4
1st, I didn't even know MJB did a remake. SD man, sorry, but if this was the Gong Show, MJB would be gettin' that gong!! DeBarge, DeBarge, DeBarge!!!! Hands down brah!!! C'mon, you didn't really think MJB could stand up to DeBarge? Mary does better when she sings her own stuff.
indigirl86 2 years ago 3
Im sticking with Debarge on this one...I just remember that poster hanging in my room.... plus I will alway love that melody.
alm619 2 years ago 3
I prefer Debarge's version over Mary's because the original was so heartfelt, and the passion & the melody of the words helped the song become a lovable and classic song. The remake wasn't bad, it just wasn't better than the original.
NasharaLaunyiah1992 2 years ago 5
I dig them both.
IG2HI 2 years ago
DeBarge, DeBarge, DEBARGE!!! But you knew I was gonna say them!!! LOL Bunny just ripped that song apart, especially towards the end when she started hitting those notes & doing all those runs!!! Man, she showed OUT on that track!!! Mary did her thing for this generation, but if you're gonna do a remake, do it just like, or better than the original!!! This is a great idea Sean, you should do more of these dude!!!
thruthealcove 2 years ago 3
Thanks Kev, but you know we have to be careful posting the music now. Stay tuned, I may post another Remake vs Original video again soon.
seand67 2 years ago
Dude, you know I know that BEST!!! LOL But as long as WMG don't own it, we're okay!!!
thruthealcove 2 years ago
Cool. I may also create a few mixes (3-4 songs) and post them.There's still a wealth of possiblilities with or without WMG.
seand67 2 years ago
I agree that DeBarge's was better ...seems like less effort on the part of Bunnie............... Mary seemed like she was just singing instaed ot expressing herself in song besides she seems a little too old to be singing such a song you know she ain't into fantasy at her age ???LIke Boobear I am a fan of Mary's BUt the original seems more "authentic"...........just my take on it ....stay blessed
Backatwon 2 years ago 2
Hey Sean, I prefer Debarge's version hands down!!!!! Although I'm not a big fan of Bunnie's vocals, I think this particular song is well suited for her sound and vocal approach. I can't imagine any other female vocalist giving this song the treatment she did. No disrespect to Mary, I'm a fan of hers as well, but I think she's does better when she performs songs she writes or others write with her in mind. Those great songs she's chosen to remake always seem to be beyond her vocal range.
boobear467 2 years ago
Yeah, Bunny isn't the best vocalist, but I do hear a Deniece Williams influence. As for Mary, she seems to be reaching for notes that just aren't there, which is the case on most of her 'remakes'.
seand67 2 years ago