Ha! I wasn't gonna point that out : P. The whole point of my video/comments is to urge people to present their opinions in constructive ways, I have no problem if there's disagreements.
Wow this reply system is confusing! Well I don't think people should be nice all the time, but I don't even think I was mean so obviously we have different ideas. I definitely agree that there have been alot of things said that were unjustified and uncalled for. This is the internet and people hide behind anonymity here, and don't hesitate to make personal attacks at the drop of a hat, and that's a shame.
content of character, I merely discussed my opinion on what the content of her video was, which was a rant. Again, this is a site dedicated to watching and discussing what has been posted. If I don't feel the video was good, then I have a right to say that, and explain why. I think the term "bullying" is pretty undeserved here.
Oh and, again, Youtube is a public forum, so when someone posts they are talking to everyone. And my advice was specifically regarding the methods she used to address
yourself discussing an obsession with a book, then it is, to me, perfectly acceptable for people to respond to that. I do NOT think that it's called for for the whale jokes, the harpoon meme, or the general demeaning of someone's character. I've said I don't condone it, and I have not participated in it. My critique was completely seperate from those comments.
Thirdly, and again respectfully, I think it's absurd to call this video bullying. I did not ever even say anything about the person's
Well, about the correlation. I said it was sensationalist, and I stand by that. It's not a matter of "choosing" not to see a correlation, it's the fact that the correlation is so loose and unfounded (not trying to be harsh, but those are the words that describe my viewpoint) that they ought not to be thrown around. In theory you could say that anytime someone has anything negative said about them that people ought to think of Columbine (I know there are other school shootings, but that to me is
the most often cited, and is as good as any to refer to), and that's not the way I think society should operate.
Secondly, you have to remember that Youtube is a public forum. Yes it would be strange if on the street a girl began to say aloud that she liked a book and have people stop and judge her on her ranting, but remember that this is a website designed exactly for that. People make videos with the intent of having others watch and voice their opinions. If all you show in your video is
which, to me, is a very poor perspective to take. I think it's a bit unfair for someone to ask others to not critique someone's "passion" when that person themselves rigorously believes and posts publicly that those who do not share in that "passion" are idiots.
pivotal difference between passion and obsession, the former being productive, healthy and worthwhile in contrast to the latter. But that aside, when someone makes a choice to voice that strong feeling on a public forum, the public will respond. While it is a shame a good deal of that response has been uncalled for as far as the some of the comments made, this video addresses the issue that NuttyMadam3575 refuses to acknowledge those with opinions other than hers are anything but complete morons
Hm. Well, first off, there's no sort of discrimination at all in this video, much less "unfair hateful discrimination." If you are trying to address the comments made on the original video, then post your comment on the original video please : ). When you post here it is assumed you're addressing MY response personally, and, if that is the case, please point out this unfair discrimination.
Secondly, your citing of Columbine is a little sensationalist if you ask me. I think there is a
Very well said. It amazes me how she doesn't see the pure hypocrisy of her videos by telling others they aren't allowed to have a negative opinion of something while she touts on about how amazing it is.
You're lovely - she's where the fan girl stereotype comes from. She completely fails to acknowledge the fact other people are entitled to their opinions & don't have to love everything she does.
She's kind of a hypocrite like that, she actually said in a video "since when did you get what you want by complaining" to people that don't like the books, when she herself was complaining cause people didn't like them.
Anyway, I agree with what you said (& not all fans of Twilight are like her)
Well composed, non-biased in any shape or form...wow. You totally won me over on a front that I wasn't even battling. Anyway, though this was your first video, at least you made it very reasonable. Good work.
amazing. thank you so much this. and what you said goes for both people who are fans of the series and who arent. there are people on both sides of the fandom (for and against if you will) that think they are superior for either liking or not liking the book. the insane twilight fans like nuttymadam who do what she does, and the the insane twilight haters you mock and ridicule fans for liking it. i think EVERYONE just needs to calm down. its just a book.
This man restores my hope for humanity.
There are intelligent people still on this earth.
This is worthy of a standing ovation.
lambertlover19 2 weeks ago
beautifully put, sir
creepykels 3 months ago
You should be president.
bums009 4 months ago
Well said, sir. You are like the antithesis of her, logical.
TheAngryBartender 7 months ago
I love you.
JumpyJinx4 8 months ago
@ MrXboxfiend Me too. =-)
DogInJar92 1 year ago
EXACTLY! god i hope she watched this lol
MrXboxfiend 1 year ago
have you heard what they call her??
LooksLikeARainstorm 1 year ago
What an intelligent and calm way to represent your opinion. Two thumbs up, your like my new hero! best wishes for any more videos you plan on making!
Sk8terWolf 1 year ago
Thank you. Just... thank you. Youtube should have more rational, calm people like you. It's kinda sad that there isn't.
Gwennehbird 1 year ago
Oh lord IshmaelDeux... I am grateful that people like you exist...
DemonicRemption 1 year ago
you sir, speak sense :)
TheHawksNest1990 1 year ago
You said exactly what I think everyone else wants to say. Amen to you. :)
5manga5 2 years ago
Comment removed
lilyisaparasite 2 years ago
"man the harpoons" lol.
killCrsiller45 2 years ago
Well said. Awesome video five stars.
Winchester85 2 years ago
As much as I think this girl is okay....I agree with you.
sapherequeen 2 years ago
correct my man amen!
shilysian 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I commend this video sir
TheNinjaInShadow 2 years ago
your video is filled with logic, maturity and reason, i like that. you did a great job. i commend you for this video. you sir, deserve a prrromotion.
Nazgarot117 2 years ago 2
You are awesome! Someone who actully has a brain. And a good one. And everyone who supports you as well. Great video.
Satansapocalypse 2 years ago
Well said
JasdeviCrack 2 years ago
I, I, love you. Your opinions are full of logic and reason.
greendayrox489 2 years ago
Well said. Very well said.
username28643 2 years ago
Ah, this is what I have been looking for. I have been looking for the proper video response, and this is definitely it. REP +
polish1stdivision 3 years ago 4
Amen!
sarahBcentric 3 years ago 2
right on! =]
StarlightMayu 3 years ago 3
kudos.
i mean really, if she DID NOT care about the responses she was getting, that video would not have been made.
this video response is the only one actually worth watching.
danixk 3 years ago 11
Amen!
KayteeeKay 3 years ago
very well done. you earned a brownie of WIN.
InukoMurasame 3 years ago
cut through the thick layer of fat to get to the stupid, greasy, and still disturbingly fat inside.
goddamnfaggots 3 years ago
righton brutha
ethangk 3 years ago
dude , now thats using common sense..bravo sir
mofoker 3 years ago 15
Amen
firedragon1990 3 years ago
this ones a keeper.
legit4it 3 years ago
well said good sir
jmurockstar 3 years ago
keep talkin sense brudda.
NVRGL 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
mmmmmm... the force is strong with this newfag...
geek2521 3 years ago
My spidey sense tells me anon is here. Thanks
IshmaelDeux 3 years ago 3
He has a good point.. And when she makes the videos, she is just asking for it.
doublefjl 3 years ago
This newfag is good /b/lackup
lets keep him
Rayhollanon 3 years ago
full ack !
nilssh 3 years ago
w00t
right on brotha
golemosworld15 3 years ago
\m/
JohnTheNecrofreak 3 years ago
Plus, she's fat, mkay?
Internationalen 3 years ago 2
...respect. ♥
isabloodelf 3 years ago
BALLIN
juda789 3 years ago
ahaha. indeed. she didn't really make a point in her video except whine some more and destroy what's left of her integrity. how pitiful.
morningstarscrew 3 years ago
I know I'm not supposed to say this, but you're pretty cute.
Alikona0000 3 years ago 3
Ha! I wasn't gonna point that out : P. The whole point of my video/comments is to urge people to present their opinions in constructive ways, I have no problem if there's disagreements.
IshmaelDeux 3 years ago
Wow this reply system is confusing! Well I don't think people should be nice all the time, but I don't even think I was mean so obviously we have different ideas. I definitely agree that there have been alot of things said that were unjustified and uncalled for. This is the internet and people hide behind anonymity here, and don't hesitate to make personal attacks at the drop of a hat, and that's a shame.
My parents don't want a thing to do with me : P
IshmaelDeux 3 years ago
her intended audience. Sorry these got out of order, I hope you can make sense of my rebuttle!
IshmaelDeux 3 years ago
content of character, I merely discussed my opinion on what the content of her video was, which was a rant. Again, this is a site dedicated to watching and discussing what has been posted. If I don't feel the video was good, then I have a right to say that, and explain why. I think the term "bullying" is pretty undeserved here.
Oh and, again, Youtube is a public forum, so when someone posts they are talking to everyone. And my advice was specifically regarding the methods she used to address
IshmaelDeux 3 years ago
yourself discussing an obsession with a book, then it is, to me, perfectly acceptable for people to respond to that. I do NOT think that it's called for for the whale jokes, the harpoon meme, or the general demeaning of someone's character. I've said I don't condone it, and I have not participated in it. My critique was completely seperate from those comments.
Thirdly, and again respectfully, I think it's absurd to call this video bullying. I did not ever even say anything about the person's
IshmaelDeux 3 years ago
Well, about the correlation. I said it was sensationalist, and I stand by that. It's not a matter of "choosing" not to see a correlation, it's the fact that the correlation is so loose and unfounded (not trying to be harsh, but those are the words that describe my viewpoint) that they ought not to be thrown around. In theory you could say that anytime someone has anything negative said about them that people ought to think of Columbine (I know there are other school shootings, but that to me is
IshmaelDeux 3 years ago
the most often cited, and is as good as any to refer to), and that's not the way I think society should operate.
Secondly, you have to remember that Youtube is a public forum. Yes it would be strange if on the street a girl began to say aloud that she liked a book and have people stop and judge her on her ranting, but remember that this is a website designed exactly for that. People make videos with the intent of having others watch and voice their opinions. If all you show in your video is
IshmaelDeux 3 years ago
which, to me, is a very poor perspective to take. I think it's a bit unfair for someone to ask others to not critique someone's "passion" when that person themselves rigorously believes and posts publicly that those who do not share in that "passion" are idiots.
IshmaelDeux 3 years ago
pivotal difference between passion and obsession, the former being productive, healthy and worthwhile in contrast to the latter. But that aside, when someone makes a choice to voice that strong feeling on a public forum, the public will respond. While it is a shame a good deal of that response has been uncalled for as far as the some of the comments made, this video addresses the issue that NuttyMadam3575 refuses to acknowledge those with opinions other than hers are anything but complete morons
IshmaelDeux 3 years ago
Hm. Well, first off, there's no sort of discrimination at all in this video, much less "unfair hateful discrimination." If you are trying to address the comments made on the original video, then post your comment on the original video please : ). When you post here it is assumed you're addressing MY response personally, and, if that is the case, please point out this unfair discrimination.
Secondly, your citing of Columbine is a little sensationalist if you ask me. I think there is a
IshmaelDeux 3 years ago
Very well said. It amazes me how she doesn't see the pure hypocrisy of her videos by telling others they aren't allowed to have a negative opinion of something while she touts on about how amazing it is.
Reichiru 3 years ago
spoken like a gentleman. well done and i agree.
RubberSoul89 3 years ago 2
AMEN
lol you rock.
meow321456 3 years ago
You're lovely - she's where the fan girl stereotype comes from. She completely fails to acknowledge the fact other people are entitled to their opinions & don't have to love everything she does.
She's kind of a hypocrite like that, she actually said in a video "since when did you get what you want by complaining" to people that don't like the books, when she herself was complaining cause people didn't like them.
Anyway, I agree with what you said (& not all fans of Twilight are like her)
lannapeanut 3 years ago
Rock on dude. Rock on.
coralin378 3 years ago
Well composed, non-biased in any shape or form...wow. You totally won me over on a front that I wasn't even battling. Anyway, though this was your first video, at least you made it very reasonable. Good work.
Sincerely,
-Laura a.k.a Sovoyita
sovoyita 3 years ago
Well done, man.
Intelligent and composed. You're a rarity around these parts, stranger.
And now, to make this comment consistent with my reputation as being a chronic troll, D00D U PWNED THAT FAT BISH.
HOO NEEDS TEH HARPOONS WHEN WE GOT U HUH?!
AnonymousWillDestroy 3 years ago
Good looking, intelligent and calm guy on Youtube? It's the apocalypse. o.O
lucyu2 3 years ago
ahhhh. diplomat.
well-said.
and the fact that you were so calm and collect about it makes it even better.
KarinAnachronism 3 years ago
Agreed.
azkun 3 years ago
Wow, people are still watching this? Thanks for the kind words guys!
IshmaelDeux 3 years ago
No, she's not Scottish. She's English and lives in Scotland; anyone with ears could tell that from her videos.
But you still PWNED her, dude!
UUUUUMAAAAAAAAAAZING BUUUUUUUKKK!!!
spoogestain 3 years ago
I love your rational thought. Great video response! You get a cookie!
ChibiGojyoluver13 3 years ago
Dear God! Is that Jason Bourne?!
Kloun42 3 years ago
She's an idiot she doesn't want to hear anyone but herself. I like you though your very rational.
yodasmom 3 years ago 4
Best video response I've seen to these rants.
That was very well-explained and rational. I doubt Nuttymadam's going to understand, but I commend you for a thoughtful, mature video response. A+.
PeaceLaur 3 years ago
Everyone deserves the benefit of the doubt sometimes, but I see this sort of stuff on YouTube all the time
IshmaelDeux 3 years ago
Your wasting your time, shes not going to understand logic.
cre8ivelicense 3 years ago
amazing. thank you so much this. and what you said goes for both people who are fans of the series and who arent. there are people on both sides of the fandom (for and against if you will) that think they are superior for either liking or not liking the book. the insane twilight fans like nuttymadam who do what she does, and the the insane twilight haters you mock and ridicule fans for liking it. i think EVERYONE just needs to calm down. its just a book.
jeanee1228 3 years ago
omfg i've never watched an intelligent video response throughout my 2 or something years on youtube. well done
OwigamiHey 3 years ago 2
Great job but this will never work on her. You used big words and spoke intelligently. Should have hired a translater who spoke CRAZY.
MintEnergy 3 years ago
Actually she's scottish, but whatever.
I appreciate your calmly given, and intelligent point-of-view.
TheEyeLinerBroadcast 3 years ago
British includes Scottish :]
Besides that, this video is just what that nuttymadam needs. If only she could understand sane talk.
topcatrox 3 years ago
Sweet, four comments. Thanks guys
IshmaelDeux 3 years ago
Yay a smart person! -high5-
"UH-MAY-ZING BUUUUUK" sorrry I had to..
CutiePie296 3 years ago 4
We need to join forces.
Yomikitsune0 3 years ago 2
you know what?...
AMMAZZZZZZZZZING BUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUK
SweGas 3 years ago 4
Dude she's a dumb fat British bitch.. she will never learn.
iamrobertpaulson 3 years ago