Added: 3 years ago
From: d60944
Views: 7,692
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (19)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • FANTASTIC PERFORMANCE!!! Thank you for sharing this Wonderful video.

  • unbelievably clear - how wonderful

  • wow this is amazing that something this old, you can still hear *is gobsmacked* :O

  • 120 years later still sounding crystal clear!!

  • im in awe.

    this is the clearest and most discernable cylinder for its age ive heard (bar that one from 1860, the oldest recorded sound, here on youtube i believe)

  • Yep, definitely get the Marston CD, it's one of the most important issues in many years. Some of the Josef Hofmann 1894 records and the 12 year old Heifetz records sound superb.

    WRT to the Brahms cylinder: Fact is that we are not actually hearing the cylinder.

    What we hear is an acetate dub of the very tired cyliinder, broadcast by the BBC and taped by someone. Neither the cylinder nor the acetate seem to have survived.

    Cheers,

  • The Brahms cylinder does exist but is almost unaudible. It is actually stored in Austria. The famous transfer that we know is a 1935 transfer on 78rpm (acetate or other) which was also used again for an LP album. If you want the exact story, there is a cheap CD called Brahms Spielt Klavier and sold by this Autrian Library. It contains three different transfers including the 1935 one, and even the second part of the cylinder, hardly audible, but identified.

  • Thank you I was told by a few people who know the topic that the cylinder was gone. Thank you for correcting me.

  • @videogamehistorian I made a new transfer of that Brahms cylinder and uploaded it on my channel. You can actually now hear something Brahms performance style now... Curious what you think of it.

    Rolf

  • @otterhouse Hello, I wonder if there are new ways to transfer cylinders into digital audio without the need for a needle. Perhaps the 'virtual stylus' technique used for the phonautograph etchings might be of use?

  • background noises are even louder than the performance itself.. The recording technology at the time NEVER did justice to this guy's superb skills..

  • Quite amazing to hear this! Thanks for posting...

  • Never ever knew that such a fabulous record exists!!!! Taneyev - Rachmaninoff's closest teacher of music composing...

    You don't even know how much did you make me feel on heaven by uploading this record!!!!! Thank you so so so so much!!!

  • A real treasure from the past. Thank you for posting!!! I have that Marston CD set - marvelous!!!

  • Hi d60944,

    This is Ward Marston and I would love to "speak" with you...please respond so I may be in touch....

    Thanks,

    Ward

  • After hearing this I am probably going to purchase the Marston set. I was under the false impression the recordings would be of no musical value due to sound quality.. WOW

  • Taneyev gives this piece an almost operatic flavor. He also taught Nikolai Medtner.

  • amazing how well i can listen this, especially when this was recorded only 2 years after brahms´s bad recording, it is fantastic

  • quite spell bounding thankyou

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more