The guys that are posting negative comments don't understand what minor threat is or what ian makaye is about. Its ashame they're so stupid. I love this cover.I'm gonna steal it.
Christ you mooks!!!!!!!!! The guy did a crafty little cover of a MT song and did it quite well. Maybe some of you would like to try to do it better? Didn't think so. No Balls. Nice job on the cover man.
Walter did a great AF cover of "Victim in Pain" ... this is sacrilegious though. I just had a flash back to the few times I've found myself in Freshman college dorms. Some nightmares are best left in the closet.
I disagree with all of you assholes. If any of you are complaining because you are Minor Threat fans, then obviously an untrue fan of Ian. Ian Mackaye would appreciate the adaptation of the song. Minor Threat was a band that wanted to be listened to, not necessarily in a literal since, but they wanted to get a point across. Plus, this is a good song.
this is brilliant, though somewhat flawed in execution.
who cares if the chords are or are not exactly the same?
whats the point of doing a cover song exactly as the original? that would be exceedingly stupid.
you give a cover song your own twist, you make it your own. you take what you hear and do something creative.
but if all you can do is paint by the numbers, and you have no creativity, no imagination, then i guess you just regurgitate an exact copy of the original. pointless...
you just turned this song into something so fucking gay. the sound that minor threat had developed for this song is part of the message, you completely lost it with this version.
If this is a joke then my bad, but still, make it funnier in that case
This is beautiful. The message is still carried through. I'm punk until i die but I got an open mind and I can step outside my boundaries. This shit is beautiful.
Do not listen to any of the negative comments. Some people can appreciate bands like Minor Threat for their originality and for saying something important, not just because it's fast and aggressive.
I realise that this is not for everyone. But... I love Minor Threat. And I love Grant Lee Buffalo. I'm just trying to "zoom in" on the melodic quality of a song I love. So I've made a "Grant Lee Buffalo" cover of this song.
It's cool that you don't like it. But don't yell at me.
hahahahahahaha please tell me this is a joke. I posted a joke version of seeing red not to long ago... It's so ironic idk.. I thought this was funny please just disregaurd this if you were trying to make any real statement.
One of my favorite quotes of all time is: There are two ways of spreading light: to be the candle or the mirror that reflects it."
Unfortunately, many people who years ago saw the candle the was Minor Threat are now looking at a cloudy, distorted mirror that seems to be sitting in a dark room... and they are understandably not please.
One of my favorite quotes of all time is: There are two ways of spreading light: to be the candle or the mirror that reflects it."
Unfortunately, many people who years ago saw the candle the was Minor Threat are now looking at a cloudy, distorted mirror that seems to be sitting in a dark room... and they are understandably not please.
Alright, I'll actually try and be constructive about this. Minor Threat was a really positive hardcore band. Their impact was greatly strengthened because they were a group of people in a menacing underground society with a menacing sound who sang positive lyrics. Taking these positive lyrics and implementing them into a more positive sounding musical genre deflates alot of the impact. I'd suggest a more negative song or band for your next acoustic interpretation.
i love MT to no end, but "Minor Threat" is my least favorite song by them. Its the one I hear covered the most, too. I want to hear a cover of Betray or Look Back and Laugh
If you don't like this song: fair enough. But it's still easier to hide under the name rudo2323 or whatever and write something awful than to make your own version of this song or anything else for that matter.
I love the original but I couldn't get anyone I know to listen to it because they hate hardcore music. The only thing I did was to slow the song down and strenghten the melody lines slighgtly. If that's selling out or whatever, fine. But have some decency when you comment.
Low, I'm an OLDer minor threat fan with 40+ years. I like the original and I like this version as well. You've got a musicians heart and mind. Nothing is so sacred that it can't be re-examined. I think Ian would agree.
i dont get why people say you should suck dick for playing a minor threat song like you did, iv heard 100s of minor threat covers, this is the best, you didnet ruin the song you showed it can be played many differant ways
I would think that people who listen to Minor Threat would be more open and accepting but apparently Ian Mackeye screaming it in your ears isn't enough.
I'm all for experimenting and all that, but this song just sucks balls. Different doesn't ALWAYS mean good. The chords aren't anywhere CLOSE to the original song, this is not a cover. This is just fucking stupid.
fucking dick head and who sead "man....its as if the lyrics take on a completely different meaning" is a damn gimp i did not think it was posible but you made Minor threat sound gay. good jod mother fucker
what makes a good punk/hardcore song good is the passion behind it, and the raw energy which moves the listener to jump and fucking feel the anger from which the song was written in the first place. I'm not saying that turning a punk song acoustic makes it crap, but in this specific case it does
you're exactly right, lowdowndeeper! what makes Minor Threat probably the greatest hardcore band (well..let's not forget Black Flag, either!) was that their songs did indeed have catchy melodies. unlike a lot of other lesser talented bands where it really was just a lot of screaming. slowing Minor Threat's songs down and playing them acoustically shows us what tuneful compositions they really were - kinda like what happened with Nirvana Unplugged...
shutup dude, just because it's acoustic doesn't make it NOT punk. Quit stereotyping you prick. So many great punk bands have done acoustic stuff. Strike Anywhere, Inquisition, Avail, Anti-flag's lead singer, Rise against, the list goes on and on. So shutup.
Yeah. It doesn't rock, but I did it to show "those not in the know" the often overlooked quality of Minor Threat melodies. They have some of the greatest melodies burried in their great, great hardcore.
i'm trying to play this, but there is a chord i don't find…. give me tabs for this please…
TheMetalheadfromhell 1 month ago
@TheMetalheadfromhell
I'm kind of playing chords with a d drone on the b string.
from heavy to thin string i play
verse and chorus x00320 x02030 020030 x32030 320030
mid x20230 300320 x20230 x02230
hope it helps :-)
lowdowndeeper 1 month ago
@lowdowndeeper tanks! :D
TheMetalheadfromhell 1 month ago
Not bad dude and I'm no pussy coffee house yuppie!
ozarkcacti 2 months ago
he sapped all of the energy out of their most energetic track
malleusss555 4 months ago
Long live sXe
Underthejrose 5 months ago
He made Minor Threat into Major Pussy.
ghandi13 8 months ago
Keep doing your thing man. Rawk on! You inspired me!
kidicarus504 8 months ago
The guys that are posting negative comments don't understand what minor threat is or what ian makaye is about. Its ashame they're so stupid. I love this cover.I'm gonna steal it.
knowurrights 8 months ago
I think this is pretty cool man, nice work
AckbarFlakes 11 months ago
hell yeah nice cover
jerryshockley 1 year ago
Christ you mooks!!!!!!!!! The guy did a crafty little cover of a MT song and did it quite well. Maybe some of you would like to try to do it better? Didn't think so. No Balls. Nice job on the cover man.
52morse 1 year ago
i say the bad religion acoustic covers are better sorry
prestonADHD 1 year ago
this is so fuckin hillarious XDD thumbs up !
4shou584 1 year ago
i love minor threat and i happen to think this is very good
MansourtheAmazing 1 year ago
Ehh. really unfitting.
xarealpersonx 1 year ago
cool cover it doesnt have to be the same as original cover means an artists own interpitatin of a song so i say great job!!!!!
pintofhappinesslabel 1 year ago
Walter did a great AF cover of "Victim in Pain" ... this is sacrilegious though. I just had a flash back to the few times I've found myself in Freshman college dorms. Some nightmares are best left in the closet.
crock703 1 year ago
good for him making this.
but i really dont like it.
AnnihalationonaStick 1 year ago
I disagree with all of you assholes. If any of you are complaining because you are Minor Threat fans, then obviously an untrue fan of Ian. Ian Mackaye would appreciate the adaptation of the song. Minor Threat was a band that wanted to be listened to, not necessarily in a literal since, but they wanted to get a point across. Plus, this is a good song.
DCbound138 1 year ago
this is brilliant, though somewhat flawed in execution.
who cares if the chords are or are not exactly the same?
whats the point of doing a cover song exactly as the original? that would be exceedingly stupid.
you give a cover song your own twist, you make it your own. you take what you hear and do something creative.
but if all you can do is paint by the numbers, and you have no creativity, no imagination, then i guess you just regurgitate an exact copy of the original. pointless...
xisotopex 1 year ago
what a the chords ? nice one :)
FlourescentF 1 year ago
Really dig it. What are the chord progressions you used?
KessRock840 1 year ago
i enjoyed that...fuck all the hate comments bellow me, keep it up, u should cover more songs n make them like this..its totally a cool/diferent sound
boardinbucky23 1 year ago
gay
bandrew379 1 year ago
...
Kikicube 2 years ago
R.I.P. -.-*
This song sucks! It sucks dicks!
EazyRun 2 years ago
you just turned this song into something so fucking gay. the sound that minor threat had developed for this song is part of the message, you completely lost it with this version.
If this is a joke then my bad, but still, make it funnier in that case
flikda3flip 2 years ago
gay !
1Kobeone1 2 years ago
MY EARS!!! AAH!!!!
Ortizsensei 2 years ago
u make it sound like a country song it hate it
LIVExTHExLIFEx92 2 years ago
This is beautiful. The message is still carried through. I'm punk until i die but I got an open mind and I can step outside my boundaries. This shit is beautiful.
xmoodudex63 2 years ago 2
I actually really liked that
alexvolpe7 2 years ago
Do not listen to any of the negative comments. Some people can appreciate bands like Minor Threat for their originality and for saying something important, not just because it's fast and aggressive.
elguapo136 2 years ago
I realise that this is not for everyone. But... I love Minor Threat. And I love Grant Lee Buffalo. I'm just trying to "zoom in" on the melodic quality of a song I love. So I've made a "Grant Lee Buffalo" cover of this song.
It's cool that you don't like it. But don't yell at me.
lowdowndeeper 2 years ago 2
@lowdowndeeper good job dude you made it your own,nice varshon!
danceonyourgraves 3 weeks ago
hahahahahahaha please tell me this is a joke. I posted a joke version of seeing red not to long ago... It's so ironic idk.. I thought this was funny please just disregaurd this if you were trying to make any real statement.
sceneisanoun 2 years ago 3
Maybe im tone death????
k90728 2 years ago
Easily one of the worst things I've ever heard.
Ascarebot 2 years ago 4
This is yuppie coffeehouse bullshit liberal pussy music.
kickfostermac 2 years ago 14
@kickfostermac liberal? shithead
KablamBeats 1 year ago
@kickfostermac i agree this is so gay, but Minor Threat and anything Ian has ever been involved with is FAR FAR far from right wing
doktorfaustus77 1 month ago
sorry man, but that's pretty awful...
alittledropofpoison 2 years ago 8
lame
BreakingGlass77 2 years ago 5
stfu douches...theres nothing wrong with this song
ClovePsyKoz 2 years ago
are singing to the fucking church or what dude,,,, try and find some balls cause that shit sucks....... praise juses you dip shit.
enders419 2 years ago 2
NO. this is great
magicvoodooppl 2 years ago
DAMN
Furiavegana 2 years ago
One of my favorite quotes of all time is: There are two ways of spreading light: to be the candle or the mirror that reflects it."
Unfortunately, many people who years ago saw the candle the was Minor Threat are now looking at a cloudy, distorted mirror that seems to be sitting in a dark room... and they are understandably not please.
ikilledfred 2 years ago
One of my favorite quotes of all time is: There are two ways of spreading light: to be the candle or the mirror that reflects it."
Unfortunately, many people who years ago saw the candle the was Minor Threat are now looking at a cloudy, distorted mirror that seems to be sitting in a dark room... and they are understandably not please.
ikilledfred 2 years ago
dont lsiten this kicks ass
xKiLlAx666 2 years ago
jesus christ, this sux whale ass!
ojgom17 2 years ago
fuck you asshole take this video down.
mattw5698 3 years ago
he sounds like a church singer great way to ruin a good song
rattfinkmovieguy138 3 years ago
Oh that's cool!
NervousBreakdown27 3 years ago
play this shit in minor next time
but its still pretty cool
pinballwiz820 3 years ago
its not bad. it makes me think of what it was like in the 80's and how its gone but not forgotten. hopefully someday punk and hardcore will return.
dudesons441 3 years ago
Just remember: Punk's not dead, it's just in a coma.
crassisdead 3 years ago
Alright, I'll actually try and be constructive about this. Minor Threat was a really positive hardcore band. Their impact was greatly strengthened because they were a group of people in a menacing underground society with a menacing sound who sang positive lyrics. Taking these positive lyrics and implementing them into a more positive sounding musical genre deflates alot of the impact. I'd suggest a more negative song or band for your next acoustic interpretation.
OriginalName90 3 years ago
ya honestlty
i can understand some bands bt
what are you ben gibard
covering Complicated by avril lavigne
you took such a hardcore song full of energy
and made it seem so generic and mediocore
it reminds me of something you would hear in a christian rock festival
reaperofsilk 3 years ago
why the fuck would you put this up man.
Its a good idea but come on maybe for like a bob dylan cover or some shit
but ..... minor threat?
its good not trying to put you down overall good job
not for minor threat though!
HungryEyeBallMan 3 years ago 2
that sounded really good.
xbm 3 years ago 2
i love MT to no end, but "Minor Threat" is my least favorite song by them. Its the one I hear covered the most, too. I want to hear a cover of Betray or Look Back and Laugh
iArgueAboutMusic 3 years ago
minor threat for the contemperary/adult alt rock crowd hahahahaha
CURKLP1T 3 years ago
ROFL
richardxsucks 3 years ago
GOD this song pisses me off somebody would actually put this up for the thrill.
ReinSTONED 3 years ago
GOD this song pisses me off.
ReinSTONED 3 years ago
You just destroyed a perfectly fine hardcore punk song.
If the person was a true person into the hardcore punk scene he would not have just RAPED Ian MacKaye.
You just raped Minor Threat and turned into a country acoustic shit song.
There is no respect for you.
ReinSTONED 3 years ago
Props man Minor Threat is awsome and so are you. Anyway i can get hold of this song on my computer?
xXNASRATXx 3 years ago
If you don't like this song: fair enough. But it's still easier to hide under the name rudo2323 or whatever and write something awful than to make your own version of this song or anything else for that matter.
I love the original but I couldn't get anyone I know to listen to it because they hate hardcore music. The only thing I did was to slow the song down and strenghten the melody lines slighgtly. If that's selling out or whatever, fine. But have some decency when you comment.
lowdowndeeper 3 years ago
Low, I'm an OLDer minor threat fan with 40+ years. I like the original and I like this version as well. You've got a musicians heart and mind. Nothing is so sacred that it can't be re-examined. I think Ian would agree.
freeyourcrt 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
get some new friends lol
iArgueAboutMusic 3 years ago
we would have beat your whining little ass back then , and I want to right now ,KILL YOURSELF
rudo2323 3 years ago
i dont get why people say you should suck dick for playing a minor threat song like you did, iv heard 100s of minor threat covers, this is the best, you didnet ruin the song you showed it can be played many differant ways
beatles61 3 years ago
I love the photo of Ian, it just adds to the power of the song. Thank you.
maverickxpunk 3 years ago
im completely open minded to acoustic punk covers. but this is not good at all.
pbass2676 3 years ago
I would think that people who listen to Minor Threat would be more open and accepting but apparently Ian Mackeye screaming it in your ears isn't enough.
Beenzanotto 3 years ago
Everyone says this sucks and its shit and gay and you ruined punk or whatever.
Punk to me is about ideas, doing something different, positive and possibly original.
Stop being ignorant, small minded fucks. Now go flame metalheads or other people who don't like your 'underground' music.
AcidNinety 3 years ago 5
Dude you totally just said what i was about to say.
qlap10 3 years ago 2
I'm all for experimenting and all that, but this song just sucks balls. Different doesn't ALWAYS mean good. The chords aren't anywhere CLOSE to the original song, this is not a cover. This is just fucking stupid.
wormsofthesenses 3 years ago
In fact only the chords in the chorus are slightly different.
lowdowndeeper 3 years ago
dude you fucking suck dick. why would you so thoughtlessly assrape this song?
birdsatemyjaw 3 years ago
nah i dont like
rbabydoll 3 years ago
who can argue with that.
filobetto941 3 years ago
WTF? I've heard good acoustic covers of punk songs before. This is NOT one of them. Please never sing anything by Minor Threat ever again.
Robotocracy 3 years ago
dont sing this song ever again
BreakingGlass77 3 years ago 3
fucking dick head and who sead "man....its as if the lyrics take on a completely different meaning" is a damn gimp i did not think it was posible but you made Minor threat sound gay. good jod mother fucker
ghotidude 3 years ago
man....its as if the lyrics take on a completely different meaning when sung at this style
openyourmind25 3 years ago 2
at first i thought this would be dumb.
pretty awesome though.
props.
BurnThatStrat666 3 years ago
i gotta say this is pretty random, not in a bad way though
krisisrad 3 years ago
not a big fan of this acoustic but whoever did this has balls i give them major fuckin credit
anarchist894 3 years ago
lol never thought i'd hear minor threat this way.
bunerzissou 3 years ago 3
I like it. I agree a whole album of their stuff accoustically would be interesting.
freeyourcrt 3 years ago
what makes a good punk/hardcore song good is the passion behind it, and the raw energy which moves the listener to jump and fucking feel the anger from which the song was written in the first place. I'm not saying that turning a punk song acoustic makes it crap, but in this specific case it does
Moybin 3 years ago 2
You got some serious fucking balls doing this song in this style. I love it.
BarrySeroff 3 years ago
you're exactly right, lowdowndeeper! what makes Minor Threat probably the greatest hardcore band (well..let's not forget Black Flag, either!) was that their songs did indeed have catchy melodies. unlike a lot of other lesser talented bands where it really was just a lot of screaming. slowing Minor Threat's songs down and playing them acoustically shows us what tuneful compositions they really were - kinda like what happened with Nirvana Unplugged...
manwithnoname123 3 years ago
How is this NOT punk ..man?..what the hell?
JoeRobot111 4 years ago
i like this... you don't need to shout to be angry! small man big mouth!
thepriceofreality 4 years ago
Feck. Just.....Feck.
sectioneightpiper 4 years ago
what the fuck is this shit man this is not punk what the hell man what the hell
punkznotdead1990 4 years ago
shutup dude, just because it's acoustic doesn't make it NOT punk. Quit stereotyping you prick. So many great punk bands have done acoustic stuff. Strike Anywhere, Inquisition, Avail, Anti-flag's lead singer, Rise against, the list goes on and on. So shutup.
lucaslt12 3 years ago
a hope this never happens again. you have put a small stain on what was power of minor threat
apunkrockhero 4 years ago
good try but, mate.... wheres you balls?!
uve just shit all over one of hardcores greatest songs. and im pretty open minded.
ollie104 4 years ago
who ever made this video is a doche
tob1203 4 years ago
agreed.
chancho213 3 years ago
WOW!!Im impressed. This song is fucking awesome. Nice job.I havent a clue how these other faggots can say it sucks.
rawwew22 4 years ago
LOL THIS MAKES ME LAUGH SO HARDCORE! Pun intended. The original is so raw and powerful and this version sounds like a song from the top 100
ClydeELish 4 years ago 2
I agree with you, man.
skatetolive85 4 years ago
i like it man
jesusfuckingchrstbit 4 years ago
i am pretty sure this is unlistenable.
jetblackiam 4 years ago 2
Tyler says,... it's called plagiarism.
twoboots4you 4 years ago
wow this sucks.
TheRealMeatMafia 4 years ago
good effort! sucks tho
Reegatron 4 years ago
ouuuchh
forced much ?
kungfufreddy 4 years ago
Yeah. It doesn't rock, but I did it to show "those not in the know" the often overlooked quality of Minor Threat melodies. They have some of the greatest melodies burried in their great, great hardcore.
lowdowndeeper 4 years ago
ouuuuuuch, but hey thats just my opinion.
pirate0131 4 years ago
gay as fuck man
coldog2003 4 years ago
sucks
wayoflife420 4 years ago
good bid but ouch
ClutchHandsome 4 years ago
F##king great song. Excellent version.
An album of Minor Threat covers like this would be a crack. Sometimes you need this to balance out the feedback
Quincey113 4 years ago
Better than Bright Eyes. lol Im just glad Minor Threat never sounded like this.
mdmetalhead7 4 years ago
I'm not gonna lie, I wasn't expecting much, but this was really good.
Polizia187 4 years ago 2
sweet song man i actually fucking love it,
all these other faggot views dont know how to appreciate music, keep it up.
punkdaz 4 years ago