Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (396)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • guys this is like 3 years old, i think we've achieved by now that it is fake

  • This is a fake.. Yulia has confirmed in an interview

  • this is a bullshit lie that is not yulia this is fake !!!

  • Sounds a little bit like Yulia, but it isn't her. Cool song though.

  • lol its not even lady gaga nor yulia

  • what's is doing the wonderfull Yulia volkova with emmm that behind??plz, Yulia is a serius singer, come from t.A.T.u, a duo that sang amazings and deeps songs, so I wonder that she doesn't corrupt and get comercial just for get "fans"

  • ambas chicas estan haciendo buenisima musica desde que se separaron. pero igual amo tatu.

  • Como quisiera que fuera verdad!! porfavor tiene que ser verdad u_u

  • i'm sure (100%) about Юля. Точно она! But i dont know who is second girl. Exactly not Gaga.

  • amazin voice!! beautiful song!!! Please Юля & Lady Gaga record it together! It will be amazin'!!!!

  • Its Bastian Van Shield with dust, just without the full mix.

  • it's julia voice's :P

  • Who is this then? Because it's really good.

  • Yulia & Lady GaGa? i dont think so...

    tatu's not as good without eachother (its easier 2 say tatu than yulia and lena blah blah blah...)

  • что то очень знакомое? точно...

  • wow i am really confuse i want the lyrics of this song .............o_O

  • Si no es Yulia Volkova y no trabajo con lady gaga, entonces Quien es? ._. La voz de la cancion para mi se parece bastante a la de Yulia Volkova, porque seamos realistas, ya no usan los mismos tonos que usaban cuando eran adolecentes, al igual que Lena, en su nuevo disco, Yulia debe estar cantando con voz de Mujer adulta y normal, no con tonos "tan altos" como los que se usaban en TaTu.

  • @Leansandres Si, pero igual no es Yulia! Hubiese sido genial que grabe con GaGa

  • Lady Gaga said for this song : "No it's not true...But they are sexy"

    Julia Volkova said : "It' not true, I didn't work with Lady Gaga"

  • Why did they do a photo together? o-o Or is it editted? aha

  • @chloealyssamei It's edited

  • esta si es yulia?? la qe canta??

  • julia and gaga aren't doing an album. julia said so herself

  • Lady Gaga never sings!

    This is a fake, it's not Gaga who is singing!

  • this int yulia or gaga but would be hooooot if it was !

  • So... Who REALLY sings this? ._. Doesn't seem like they're getting any credit.. XD

  • Bastian Van Shield - With Dust

  • @my1ragdoll Thanks!

  • @Commoner205 Bastian Van Shield - With Dust

  • this is not julia but sound like her XDç

  • what the fuck?!that is NOT Yulia!!!!!!!!!!

  • but who is singing this song? Bastian van Shield and Miguel Picasso had just mixed this song.

  • THAT IS NOT YULIA!

  • Lmao thats not Yulia. She has a Russian accent when she sings.

  • If its not Yulia Who is this????

  • @bubblehead12cga some random girl??

  • Thats not Yulia but i like the song ;)

  • Even though it's not Julia nor Lady Gaga or whatsoever, I like the song.

  • O.O wha-wha-wha-whaaaaat?!?! O.O WTF is this shit?! whacha mean yulia Volkova and Lady Gaga?! I think you're kiddin me!

  • i dont understand how people make these songs when the people dont actually sing it...technology is so scary

  • This track is "With dust", by Bastian Van Shield.

  • it sounds like yulia but its not her

  • Jajajaja, NOT YULIA, but this song is cool I like it, anybody knows what´s the song´s singer?

    (Sorry for my english xD)

  • Comment removed

  • NOT YULIA. no accent. though the voice is like Yulia's but no, it's not Yulia.

  • it is DEEEEFFINATELY not Yulia... Her accent is not present here... decent song tho.. I dont hear gaga in here either... but yeah, no accent- no yulia... i would hope she wouldnt lose her accent, i love it. it makes her sound even better. <3

  • if i put my own face there its my song then?? XD

  • i raped replay button now O_O this song is awesome even its can be just made up XD

  • not Yulia i am sure of it xD

  • NOOOOOOOOOO. I hate Lady Gaga.

  • Noooo please!!! if Julia sings with Lady Gaga they will make subliminal satanic messages!!!

  • @digitalcyber2x Oh grow up.

  • "Miguel Picasso - Atmosphere"

    Not tatu

    Still good song

  • where can i download this song?

  • not Yulia...

  • The true t.A.T.u. fans can totally tell this isn't Yulia. Period.

  • Holy crap that sounds similar to Yulia, except of course Yulia has a better voice of course. In this song the womans voice is more heavier.

  • its not a song by her. its from miguel pixasso- atmosphere. it saysit right at t bottom on the vid

  • Bellissimo!!!!!!

  • Know it's not true, but it would've been cool if they recorded a song together :P

  • I don't think this is Yulia Volkova...but I do love the song! Download link?

  • dude would lady gaga just die i cant stand her

  • LOL youtube gives away the hoax: Miguel Picasso - Atmosphere

  • no son ni lady gaga ni yulia volkova quien la canta se llama BASTIAN VAN SHIELD y la cancion se llama WITH DUST 

  • no son ni lady gaga ni yulia volkova quien la canta se llama BASTIAN VAN SHIELD y la cancion se llama WITH DUST

  • This is CONFIRMED not to be Gaga and Yulia.

  • Comment removed

  • This may not be yulya or whatsoever, I do like the song :3

  • OMG when I first heard it I was like "thins is not yulia" but then I hard that raspy thing in her voice but it's not her. Yulia has a very promonate accent that no matter what language she sings in it would be pressent. However I do like whoever issinging this song.A very superb sound-alike.

  • esa no e yulia si por algo yulia se fue de tatu

    es por q ella no quiere cantar en ingles

    ella lo a dicho pormas q lo estudia

    no puede entenderlo al 100

    ella dice q su manera de pensar y sentir es en ruso

  • Doesn't sound like Yulia.

  • I think I should rewrite my comment because ppl can easily learning how to change their accents. They have classes and people that do that. Lol. Still love the song

  • I admit the song is nice but doesn't sound like yulia. Also lady gaga and yulia wouldn't make a good mix of music. They both have very different types and looks of music

  • Why would Yulia sing with a weird hag like Lady Gaga?

    OMYGOD t.A.T.u. with LADY GAGA?!! I think I'm gonna be sick. t.A.T.u. is too talented for this. :D They deserve better.

  • it's Bastian Van Shield - With Dust it's not lady gaga or yulia volkova ._.

  • I think it is Robyn, from Sweden. Guess she is the new Gaga.

  • I know it's a totally differrent song, but fuck does her voice turn me on... Wish it was Yulia x

  • I like the song, but it's definitely not Yulya =( I wish it would, cause it would be great that she finally has made a demo. =(

  • HA! for the record this IS NOT YULIA VOLKOVA although it sounds like her ITS NOT

    she stated that her upcoming solo project is already recorded and she didnt record anything with Lady Gaga..

    its still a good song :)

  • Too bad it might not be true. It would totally be an awesome song.

  • this is off yulia's new album but lady gaga is not a part of it

  • @midnight666666 yes it is

  • this is a good song but its not yulia and lady gaga...

  • where can i get a url or this mp3 ?

  • it's Bastian Van Shield - With Dust

  • I know it's fake, but it would've been cool if it was real :P

  • Her English has IMPROVED massively!!! =O I am impressed!

  • i really like this song =/ even tho this is not really Yulia singing with lady gaga, but oh well :)

  • huh.. Yulia can't sing with such a bitch (gaga).... she just can't do this....

  • @Karan11oo7

    hello

    I could say was what really happened with "TATU"

    please I'm desperate

  • idk where the hell the people hear lady gaga in this song, all the song is singing by yulia even the final part, the part that everybody said that is LGG... and is funny cuzz i saw a interview that the reporter ask yulia about this song with LGG and yulia said: 'who is lady gaga, i dont know her'...!!!!!

  • This doesn't sound like Yulia to me.

  • accents gone o.o

  • And I don't hear lady gagag anywhere. In thi song.

  • Her voice has alot of similarities, but I really don think it is her, I am a HUGE t.A.T.u fan, and I'm 80%percent sure that it isn't her.

    But if I'm wrong and it is, why lady GaGa?! Ughhh!!! Tht just ruins it! D:

  • @SuicideSue21 I agree, this isn't Yulia. The vocals are VERY similar. But like you, I've also been a taty fan for years, and Yulia has a recognizable voice. Her Russian accent is way heavier, and she has a rasp in her voice due to her vocal cyst removal surgery years ago. :) You and I are on the same page.

  • How can anyone really believe this is Yulya? SHE HAS AN ACCENT. Where is her Russian accent? We all know she has a thick one in English. Not a trace. When the girl hits the high notes it sounds some what similar, to I don't know...the Not Gonna Get Us scream...that she doesn't do anymore because her voice CAN'T anymore. Wow...really people?

    And I highly doubt Lady Gaga has any idea who she is. No offense to Yulya, I love her.

    But the song is catchy. I would like to know who it really it.

  • This could be a demo for her, but there{s no chance in hell Lady Gagas working with her aqnytime soon

  • the best musical duo with yulia's voice has a magnificent voice break

  • i love this song so much. and whoever is singing it aswell!

  • It's obvious this isn't Yulia. Sure the voice is raspy and all, but even then. Listen to it when it isn't raspy. Definitely not Yulia.

  • no is not yuliaaaa

  • I love Gaga and Yulia it will be fantastic if they did something together i hope some day!

  • Woulde be Awesome a Cameo with Tatu and Lady gaga

  • Heard the singer singing the song ain't yulia but a similar voice 2 her but still luv the song

  • like the song but no lady gaga in it?

  • This is not tatu. They have an accent and aren't this good at pronouncing English words. I've heard all their songs both Russian and English. The voice is raspy like Yulia's but not the same.

  • @Voltius Of course it's not Yulia or t.A.T.u. , its a demo made for them.

  • @Voltius

    it sounded like yulia to me...

  • @Voltius Thats why its called a Demo you idiot.

  • @TheBlackBird11 It's called checking the facts and realizing that Yulia herself said she didn't sing it, it was on Russian news, the song isn't hers. Idiot.

  • @Voltius Maybe Julia's voice changed? Maybe she learned English better?

  • Yulia gave an interview in which she said she never recorded anything like this and that she didnt have any contact with Lady Gaga. End.

  • @againme1 What interview was it? :) I LOVE t.A.T.u!

  • what website did you find this on?

  • She sounds like Kylie Minogue in this song. I think it's kinda cool she's working with Gaga. Good for her! It means she's getting more attention

  • Espero que Lady Gaga haga un videoclip con Julia para q conozca la gente de tATu, Lena no te pongas celosaaaa!!!

  • tiene la voz clara de Julia volkova.. :S pareceella... it has julia's voice :s

  • Where can we download it ???

  • mira yo tengo años escuchando a yulia, y la verdad que les puedo decir esq en algunas partes si parece su voz con como en el min 0:18 hasta en 0:26 es simile despues 0:32 hasta el 1:09 .. es simile pero.. de lady gaga ????

    hahahaa por Dios!! ella no tiene velas en este entierro..

    aca no hay lady gaga =)

    Saludos

  • Comment removed

  • on wikipedia they had part of an interview she did do this song with lady gaga but this is not her just sounds like her and she isnt sure if it will be a single on her album and it should be coming out late 2010 or 2011 and it also said the album is being placed in america not moscow

  • @Thehemsky Wiki isn't always accurate. It's good that t.A.T.u. producers finally care about US fans now. Cuz I feel that the good stuff ALWAYS goes to Russia, then the US songs that t.A.T.u. do aren't the same. I don't have anything against Russians; just saying.

  • @3cheers4Ger It's a Russian band.... just like you don't see Britney Spears targeting Russian market befor American... not that she's wanted in Russia so its a good thing lol.

  • Jajaja no es Yulia ni Lady Gaga, idiotas los que creen que si.

  • OMFG

    i am so happy she is also going solo!!

    !!

  • really enjoyed this as with all Volkovas material =)

  • En realidad es mentira, no es ni lady gaga ni yulia; es "bastian van shield" y la cancion es "with dust"... es un rumor el duo....

  • @anmatamon es o no xq la voz de yulia si calza la de gaga no se xq no me gusta asi q esa no me importa no se digan quiero saber para descargarla jejeje aunq este gaga jajaja

  • este tema es un demo para julia esta confirmado!!!

    t.A.T.u

  • obvio no es Yuliaaaa... solo se parece la voz de esta chica... ¬¬

  • que mal español

    bad spanish bad bad

    is: califique y suscribase por favor

    VIVA YULIAAAA

  • Doesn't Yulia (best singe eva) still like Lena??

  • PEro Yulia dijo que ese rumor de que va a cantar con Lady Gaga es pura mentira

  • @DeOlegovna ERES VREDAD???onde tu vio eso???qué sitio???onde tu sabes qué yulia dijo eso??

  • @yasmineling si en serio....según lo que leí Yulia no hizo ningún dueto con Lady GaGa

  • Me queda claro que es Yulia,pero dudo que la otra voz sea Lady Gaga!

  • is lady gag actually singing with her in this ?????

  • @whitewingangel5 no, bastian van shield

  • oh my god!!!really seem the yulia volkova's 'voice!!!!!congratulations...i­f you sing a cover of all the things she said maybe you can de the third t.a.t.ugirl

  • @yasmineling tATu isn't make music anymore at least not for a long while. Jeez, keep up.

  • @EvilKarmaAngel ok!!!

  • ahahahah THAT IS NOT YULIA VOLKOVA trust me xD

  • sorprendida...No me lo esperaba, tampoco me lo imagine.

  • Yulia said this isn't her. She said yeah, it sounds similar to me, but it isn't. SO, there ya go! :)

  • Awh /: I hope they do a song together :D !!! <3 Yulia&Gaga (&Lena <3)

  • I heard Yulia, Im not crazy, is Yulia!

  • this isnt tatu or lady gaga its with dust by bastian van shield

  • ulia is very perrrtttyyy

  • its not lady gaga nd Yulia Volkova, Yulia even said it herself that it isnt her and she never made a duet with Lady Gaga

  • @xxxmcrchickxxx She also said she'd never heard of Lady Gaga.

  • i like tatu as the group but i am curious to see what their solo projects are gonna be

  • I like this song and it does sound like Yulia but I read on a different site that it's supposedly someone named Jenny Karr???? Is this true?

  • Maybe I'm deaf but I never heard Lady GaGa...

  • @mnietzsche Neither has Yulia Volkova.

  • Nice sing

    I like yulia's voice

  • Is not yulia

  • Is not yulia

  • C'est pas Yulia

  • I am just going to say now! THIS IS FAKE, NOT LYUBLYUTATU  FAULT IT WAS RUMOURED!(I LOVE YOU LYUBLYUTATU) THE SONG IS BY BASTIAN CALLED "DUST" I LOVE T.A.TU AND GAGA PLEASE STOP HATING! YULIA HERSELF EVEN COMFIRMED IT JUST RECENTLY THIS IS FAKE SHE WAS INTERVIEWED ON NTV!

  • Is yulia working on a solo? But not with lady gaga, any tatu fan should now this isnt yulia

  • @sparrow5678 Yulia is doing a solo project but NOT collaborating with Lady GaGa. This demo is NOT Yulia.

  • @sparrow5678 Sorry, but any tatu fan should recognize voice Yulia. This is her voice.

  • @TheBestChomik Not, it's not her voice. She said it.

  • Haha hilarious! Lady Gaga is on the top, called "new queen of pop" by loads of reporters. What about Julia? Tatu were not even able to get a lable to release their last album internationally. By the way, Julia's voice seems to be totally distroyed. Her voice sounds very husky on the last records.

  • @LaurentiusRex Lady GaGa is a GREAT singers but she cant be called a "new queen of pop" becuase shes bealy "new"(not really) and Modonna IS the queen of pop and has been in the game FAR longer then GaGa and t.A.T.u. didnt get a lable becuase they didnt want one, they are restected in Russia. Russia is very proud of t.A.T.u. and yes its a shame Yulia's voice ws hurt but shes still a great singer!

  • @ariosvids @ariosvids

    Nothing to discuss about Lady Gaga and Madonna. DEFINITELY Madonna is the Queen. I just said that some reporters call Gaga the new one. I like Lady Gaga but Madonna is the one. She's the icon.

    However, Lady Gaga is still a superstar. t.A.T.u. which I like very much by the way are not selling much records anymore, not even in Russia. And of course they would like to release their album internationally but they are just not able.

  • @LaurentiusRex I think Lady Gaga is and is goona get only better! I think Im a fan now? haha I watched Telephone, nice video.

    hmm I see your point. but their last album is doing well not AS good as their first one but well. either way Ill still support t.A.T.u.! Im proud of the girls :)

  • @ariosvids

    So am I. I ordered their album from Russia because I badly needed to have it. Love them from the very beginning. I hope one day will come a fourth album from them... now looking forward to Lena's first solo album.

  • @LaurentiusRex Me, too! I get to see her first solo performance at Pride Fest in Milwaukee! <3

  • cool!!!!!!!

  • yeas its like stepping in to the 80's with this retarded song

  • It sounds like how Yulia might sound if she had no Russian accent.

  • i don´t care who the singer is or who the writer is...

    i think it´s a realy cool song <3

    (i can´t get it out of my head ;D)

  • lol, this is just a remix of with dust. Its still got the original girl singing it, which aint yulia volkova or lady gaga.

  • baaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa­aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa­aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa­aaaaad

  • People, chill.

    Yes, its BAstien Van Shield. Yes, its a rumor. No, its not true.

    Yulia has said in the past that she has NEVER heard of Lady Gaga. and as for the wiki... Anyone can edit the articles, seriously. It's not true, sorry to dissapoint.

  • She said in an interview that she IS going to a concert of Lady Gaga and she's going to do a duet with her..... The interview was on MTV you can search it on YouTube ^^