Girls Aloud vs. Sugababes - Walk This Way (Fame Academy)

[wozniacki15]

im much more of a sugababes fan they have more talent while GA has better performance attributes, but i must say i absolutely love nadine her voice is soo powerful and smoky

[jubanateful]

sugababes got swag lol! they dominated the girls aloud chicks lol but Naydine does have powerfull vocals lol xp

[bigbumpaa]

KEISHA!

[adamcrookedsmile]

Kimberley, Nicola, Cheryl and Sarah should just get off that stage and leave the singing to the singers.

[wozniacki15]

@adamcrookedsmile lol that would only leave nadine versus the sugababes lol

[335878]

i love keisha and heidi together :(

[MusikCassette]

oh thats so pseudo

[miredrocks]

Luv Cheryl and Nadine-3 I miss Girls aloud:(

[baskalayt]

I hate how Cheryl keeps mugging the vocals. The "like this" bits should be shared between her and Amelle.

Keisha (and Amelle) rip all the others to shreds vocally.

[Freystar24]

@baskalayt not nadine :) but those three are defo best

[alexm921]

The sugababes killed it, but nadine was amaze!!! That high note WOW!

[futurestar88]

Keisha Kilt them in Vocals! She is definitely an original sugababe, they were so dumb 4 putting her out!

[peciaqq]

love you Cheryl <3

[silentknight826]

How amazing would Jade have been in this? She would've 'brung' it performance wise (to at least Girls Aloud level) and I can just imagine her killing it vocally with the Steven Tyler belts that only she could've pulled off.

[hooy1234567890]

omfg, on this normal video i thought: whao! great girls aloud, sugababes mwah. and now: girls aloud HOW BADDDD, and sugababes almost as the original! great job sugababes and Girls Aloud go to home :\

[martinmcnultylu1]

better singers is by FARRRRRRRRRRRR the sugababes END OF FUCKIN STORY

[JillValentinesFE]

Oh please i watched a girls aloud solo performance of this song and it was HORRIBLEEEEEEEEEEE. Cheryl tried to sing Amelle's part it was SO f**king awful, for real. Sugababes ALL THE WAY!!!

[SHITONASTICK1100]

i think they should stay in the kitchen and make me a bacon sandwich whilst i listen to aerosmith. or maybe they could do a strip tease for me, that would be good as long as they didn't sing that is.

[M0SSBERG590]

@SHITONASTICK1100 hahahahaha here here!!

[chimola123]

nicola looks so good when she had this hair especially in this song. and her make up it makes her look sexy! and i love it when nadine sings just give me a kiss!

[ldi321]

GA are better.. better singers performance is so much better

[iiLyBabe12]

Sugababes are better singers

BUT

Girls aloud are better performers.

[misterangry2009]

Fucking horrible. Unbelievable. It shows the miserable standard of casted bands in the UK.

[shoutonce]

One thing I have to say is that Nadine tries too hard all the time and is over dramatic

[jeremiah007]

sarah - FLEET flying up in the air - haha! 

[RallyDude92]

Yeah, I think Nadine kicked Keisha's ASS in this performance.

[JillValentineFE]

@RallyDude92 Im not rly a Keisha fan but well... She pwned Nadine... Nadine fails

[RallyDude92]

@JillValentineFE Youre deaf then.

[JillValentineFE]

@RallyDude92 no im not deaf... im the one who likes Sugababes :)

[cbmlmz]

fails. this song is the the worst choice ever. of all time. i think that something like eat the rich would be better. some irony there, makes it better

[LarissaFae]

I don't think they realise that "Backdoor lover/Always hiding under the covers/'Til I talked to your Daddy/He say "You ain't seen nothin/'Till you're down on the muffin/And you're sure to be changin'/Your ways" refers to the singer learning to give their female partner oral sex from their partner's father. In fact, oral sex on a woman is all that this song's about.

... Yeah, I think that escaped them.

[RallyDude92]

@LarissaFae How do you know it did?

[LarissaFae]

@RallyDude92 The very awkward phrasing of it, mixing the eating-out euphemisms and imagery with the meal cheerleader and cousin references. Then again, I could be wrong and they could have known very well what the song was about. And in that case, it's a rather poor re-write of the song.

[stefan0zzic]

sugababes ftw!

girls aloud,naaah!

[JillValentineFE]

Sugababes pwn them n they r just 3 o.o S2 Heidi Range S2

[shoutonce]

Also A:Nadine tries WAYY to hard and B: why does she think she's black?

[shoutonce]

Sugababes all have good voices whereas some girls alouds are shit/alright

[bxkxrxxxx]

Sugababes are just more likeable. Girls Aloud are a bit annoying.

[baceace]

Cole does the Shouty bit coz thas all she can manage

[gurenseiten1]

it's nice but I think it would had been much better with mutya.

[boogiies]

kim <3

[cancunchubby]

i love you girls aloud and sugababes!!! Its a really shame you not have promotion in latinoamerica!!!!!! we love you from Mexico!!!!!

[gerardforgione2008]

C'Mon Nadine =) Shes The Best!!!

[yumifan88]

Kimberly was amazing in this!

[MrSjard]

They realy should make there own song.. instead of making it some whore version of it..

[Mariiiine29]

SHIT !

[TweanCoyle]

Keisha vs Nadinee, << Nadinee totally won it ;) xxx

[Crai3g]

Steven humilates them

[martinmcnultylu1]

Imagine if mutya was there. Girls aloud would have no chance in hell to outsing her. But unfortunatly she wasnt && keisha was amazing

[tomitzah665]

laaaaaame =))))))))))))

stupid chicks singing a lengedary song

they are moking aerosmith and rundmc

[JadeyWadey0x]

Nadinee, all thee wayy! ::)

[Jessinarnar]

God I hate Kiesha so much! She just wants to be the one in front, shes a attention seeking bitch in my opinion, I am glad shes out of the Sugababes! :@.

[ThePcdify]

nadine shows how better her voice is!!!!!!!

[kinkykara010]

keisha is a really good singer

[befarman]

I can only hear Keisha during the chorus. It's that distinctive.

[jlenoconel]

Its funny how people are saying how much this version sucks compared to the original. Its a charity single for God's sake. It ain't no big thing.

[lomaaz]

kimberley's really good in this!!

[7StephG]

why , why the fuck did i click on this video?? Jesus suffering christ.

Listen to original Aerosmith people. this stuff is horrific

[Falipala2]

it is jeeeez its soo poor, my ears r fuckin bleeding, damn rot in hell girl-groups!!

[thesatsfan09]

both great bands, girls aloud are better performers than sugababes though :)

[96raindrop96]

@thesatsfan09 true!

[fitsmiler1]

@thesatsfan09 they have to be cos they can hardly rely on their voices, unlike the sugababes

[gerardforgione2008]

@fitsmiler1 HA your funny... Nadine Can Outsing any of those 2 girls

[tourous4life]

@thesatsfan09 there better performers, sugababes are better singers tho!

[Urasile]

One little swaying the hips and the sugababes earn :p

[Paul8820]

This was a borderline for disaster. Long live Aerosmith

[inthelivinfor]

SUGABABES are wayyy better!!!

[macias9]

@

inthelivinfor

WELL SAID. sugababes rule

[djuwell]

nicholas and sarah have good vocals live but did not have the opportunity to show off here

[nolkababy]

Nicola my favorite!

[9coddy]

I LOVE CHERYL SHES THE BEST SHE WAS AMAZING i like kimberly and nadine too be not sure bout the other too :) CHERYL IS THE BEST and GA were the best

[TaySwiftFanxx]

If you ask me, Girls Aloud (as Cheryl would say) "SMASHED IT!" In my opinion, Girls Aloud are better by like 25%. And don't be mean to Nicola, in my opinion, she has a btter voice than Cheryl, but Cheryl's more prettier!! xx And once again Girls Aloud "SMASHED IT"!!!! xx

[mrLatorre]

sugababes waay better

[neifaen87]

care about the groups, who are best and stuff. they have both ruined the song!!!

[francishout]

wow they were all quite good..btw vocally sugababes are better i think..they all were perfect here..i don't know much about GA but some of them were a little bit off...

[djuwell]

omg catfight lol

they are all awesome though

[SuperSBfan]

I agreeee wid mizzgossip cheryl cant sing an neither can kimberley so sugababes r better

[xxNiuNiaxx91]

shit..

[MGirlsAloudFan]

Girls Aloud look stunninggg in this performance. They outshine the Sugababes. Nadine's high note at 2:22 :o. Wow. Love all their dresses. Especailly in comparison to Heidi's tracksuit type thing.

[campalamp1212]

I love Girls Aloud!! hull yea!

[xXCh3mIcAl3rOXx]

No se comparan a la vos de Steven Tyler...

[HankStafford]

Sarah Harding.

[halffade]

2:53 what's her name?

[aussieapril]

okay so here's the lowdown! Sugababes have had more number 1 singles as well as more singles but Girls Aloud have had more successful singles (20 top ten hits). I think Girls Aloud are more likeable than the Sugababes and they all consist of the original lineup unlike the Sugababes! there are pros and cons for bothe bands and i like them both very much!!

[BritneyDigitalLive]

Keisha vs Nadine is amazinggggg

[IAIN19760]

@BritneyDigitalLive fucking awful your all tripping this was a good song b4 this lot destroyed it

[sabinemeijrink]

shut up girls aloud is much better, they have more hit then sugababes and the main reason girls aloud has all it's original members, can't say that about sugababes

[mizzgossip]

lolz u must be deaf!  its so obvious that sugarbabes has better voices then that bunch of air heads who cant sing, nicola cant sing n that proved it, .kimberley hasnt got a strong voice, cheryl cant sing n the world knows that, sarah who can barely sing a note, n nadine is the only that can actually sing but her voice is nothing compared 2 kiesha's n this video proves it, . both heidi n amelle can sing unlike that girls aloud which only can sing loolz !!! n by the way u can shut up!

[LAMBIBABY]

you don't think nicola can sing? search for girls aloud singing a medley on their chemistry tour...

[mizzgossip]

i DONT think i KNOW nicola cant sing its a FACT n this video proves it so dont tell me someone can sing when i know they cant so next time HUSH HUSH!! S.N.M (say no more)

[LAMBIBABY]

No need to get so agressive! All I'm saying is that I've seen performances where Nicola is amazing singing live. That's my opinion which I'm entitled to.

[WelshForLifee93]

not a fact she can sing.

[soplush42]

wow Sugababes are better but i still love GA but did anyone notice keisha & nadine were really battling out vocally especially towards the end when nadine hit that high not keisha kinda got pissed lol

[theGREATcoolio]

Girls aloud is better because theyre fun and friendly. Sugarbabes are obviously the better vocalists but theyre sort of boring which makes them not very likable, unlike Girls Aloud

[barguyxx]

Sugababes are soooooooo much better period!

[ddanuk]

why doesnt nadine sing on the chorus??

[MusicalVariety]

does nadine do the high note at 2:20?

[ilovecheradinexoxo]

yeah it is nadine that does the hight note :D

[ilovecheradinexoxo]

Mahoney8T7 how are girls aloud c*nts, you dont even know them to say that

[ilovecheradinexoxo]

girls aloud are so much better :)

seen them live there amazing especially cheryl :D and nadine :D x

[Goxenul]

Lol, that sucks... It doesn't have even 10% of the original song's power...

[penoo14]

Truth be told Girls aloud LOOK better than Sugababes but I think vocally Sugababes are stronger and they are well known in South Africa and Girls Aloud aren't. I like both band anyway.

[gatitoatomico]

which songs from the sugababes have been succesful in southafrica ???

[penoo14]

Round Round, Shape, Ugly, Too lost in you, Push the button, there could be more.

Also:

When I went back in December I saw Alesha Dixon (the boy does nothing) video to my surprise, maybe it's cause she was in the group Mis-Teeq, which were also popular in S.A

[cplanner97]

girls aloud are sooo bad live

[jpbmmdf]

awful

[Al3xJordanSaid3]

when you put everything together as the whole package Girls Aloud are better because when you go to there shows its sold out full of singing and high energy dance routines and have got better over the years.

i do love GA&&Sugababes and i love the fact that this performance was like a battle;

Nadine vs Keisha

Amelle vs Cheryl

Sarah; Kimberely; Nicola; Heidi don't really battle.

but still love this performance!

[TrustInFlames]

Pop groups shouldn't be covering rock classics.

[ameliacg]

i like it how cheryle and amelle have a cheeky smile at each other right at the beginning when they're saying "walk this way"

[xLouisaBabex]

Sugababes all the wayy ! Betta then girlsaloud

[Tommy1The2Bat3]

the leading singer in sugababes is best, but i think girls aloud one, espesh with nicole and sarah

[sirconorbrown]

sugababes killed girls aloud good on ye show them up for how shit they really are !!!!!

[themranthonywalker]

dream team

The 2 best girl bands on the planet

[AmnellAndreas]

they killed this song. steven and joe should have comed up on the scene, taken away the mikes from the girls and then the rest of aerosmith should have comed up. the roadies given them their istruments and a mike with mikestand. then they would have rocked the girls and then fucked them backstage XD

[whyduhavetogo]

girls aloud killed sugababes!

[myesc]

Girls Aloud are great :D

[Tomerpl]

Sugababes know in Europe. Poland really like their music. Sugababes are better singers!!!

[IFellThroughTheDoor]

girls aloud are well better than the saturdays

cheryl can sing - have you heard her live WOW

[PINKFAN133]

SUGABABES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[chibidibidi]

sugababes known in Europe not GA

[atroticious]

sugababes are more original

[neeneejr]

cheryl is such a CRAP singer, no wonder she was the only one that didn't get a solo in this.

[themranthonywalker]

you are a moron Cheryl rules

[neeneejr]

yeah but she can't sing nuff said,

[DevilsWithCleanFaces]

sugababes have the better voices but nadine is amazing !

[cheerandfluvit]

GIRLS ALOUD!!!!!

[KaTiERoCkZMaRcH1996]

I like the original

[Mahoney8T7]

GIRLS ALOUD = c*nts especially cheryl cole

SUGABABES = sold more records, have a number one at least once with EVERY new album....won more awards.....better music....better label.......more respected.

[domthebitch123]

so not true

[Tayuyaxxx]

lmao that's a lie girls aloud has like been #1 till loving kind...

[PushTenx]

I liked Girls Aloud WELL better. : )

[hellu882]

girls aloud look better but sugababes got strongest voice

but love both bands

[marcusmooney23]

this song REALLY doesnt do anything for nicolas voice

shes got a great voice

[ashlavs]

girls aloud seem more innocent,

sugababes seem to have more of an attitude.

[domthebitch123]

yh this is only on this live performance the rest of the time girls aloud have the most attitude

[t2hkm3]

this sux

[marcusmooney23]

i absoluitely love both bands and think there both talented

but nadine mops the floor with keisha on the end part

[gerardforgione2008]

she deffinatly does

[useapen]

Ahhh Goddamnit Not Again.

There's always some crappy pop singers who like to ruin good rock classics the last time i saw one of these it was Celine Dion who tryed to kill You Shook Me All Night Long By AC/DC

[Cuddles5799]

i agree with 4kedTunge483

[4kedTunge483]

yup!

[4kedTunge483]

and the truth is what you have heard, my friend.

[4kedTunge483]

thank you.

[Cuddles5799]

Thanks for this - my dance teacher made up a dance to this - told us to practice and could not find it!

Thanks sooooo much!

Cuddles5799 x

[4kedTunge483]

WTF?

IT SHOULD ILLEGAL TO DO THIS TO A SONG!!!

IF YOU DID TO A DOG WHAT THEY DID TO THIS SONG THE RSPCA WOULD SEND YOU TO LIFE IN A CONCENTRATION CAMP!!!! IF I WAS AEROSMITH, I WOULD BE ASHAMED THAT PEOPLE LIKE THIS WERE ABUSING MUSIC!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!

f*cking sods!

[BlackFairyHorses]

Nadine rocks xD!!!

That was awesome!!

[kualitee88]

bit of a competition wiv kiesha and nadine there lol

[juhgug]

real vidoe plz not the live one

[MrsEmilyKate]

girls aloud can dance but sugabaes can't

[SMPTE82]

aerosmith .....

[nikolefilan]

girls aloud:)

sugababes:(

[depjojo]

i love girls aloud specially nicola and sarah nicola always sing good at live she was maybe distracted thinking of other things i don't know but she have i great voice really beautiful like an angel voice and the sugababes are good but its just something about them that make me love GA instead of them well i heard first about GA and then about them but they have great voices the 8 of them!!!

[henerz1441]

this version sucks

run Dmc and Aerosmith 4 life

[4kedTunge483]

i agree, man!

[brownertoxic]

Love me, hate me, say what you want about me.

but all the boys and all the girls are begging to if you seek amy

[evilburper]

they fucking ruined the song

[justboycrazy45]

That was fire!

[emmabuntonorg]

OMG Nicola CANT sing live!

[ReDaKaNoiR]

I hate all their voices.

They're giving RUN DMC and Aerosmith a bad name.

:(

[gxkhxn]

sometimes less is much! sugababes are much better! stop girls aloud singing live! i can't bare it!

[luvinTVtalent]

Girls Aloud THE BEST GIRL GROUP EVA!!

Sugababes gud too but u can tel just by watchin that GA beta! I mean cum on they sing & dance! Sugababes dont do much more than sing really!

[brownertoxic]

yea ur ryt . girls aloud preform this way better on their own. sugababes r alryt but they dont have half the talent of GA

[mizzGemmaRoberts]

your DUMB.......girls aloud  got talent!! what a joke lol sugababes is 10 times better than that stupid bunch of fakes!! who can't even sing....they only sell cuz of they image......out of 5 girls theys only one that can sing thats what you call shit!!!

so don't even come with them talks idiot!!!

[kloddey]

i hate cheryls voice

[biscuitgogo]

if u hate cheryls voice then there is somthing wrong with you! shes the best!

[kloddey]

eh lol, up 2 me wot i fink aint it!!! jus dont lik it, shes def got the weakest voive in ga

[biscuitgogo]

kk soz

[jesslovesgirlsaloud]

I agreee! lol.! wel said!

<3 Cherylllll!

[Sevta22]

kloddey:

I agree .. I think she is the worst singer in GA

[kloddey]

thank you .....

glad you agree

[callofdutyman13170]

what the hell happened to nicola 1:50 - 1:55 her solo bit there is usually good wtf happened to her voice

[anma123]

LIIIVEEE yeah!

[clyme99]

ahhhhhhhhhhhhhh i love it!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[penoo14]

KEISHA KEISHA KEISHA!

[savomatto]

KEISHA BAUCHANAN BEST GIRLS IN THE VIDEO!!!!suga forever!!

[emthemouthy]

Cheryls the best!! She's so funny!