Added: 2 years ago
From: desenhoar
Views: 566,378
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (6,155)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • very stupid answers!!!

  • This has to be the best video ever

  • wait.. this is just the same video watch... did the subtitle just changed?

  • Religion is a severe mental illness created over 9000 years ago, at the same time as the Earth. Since then, religion has been one of the biggest sources of drama, faggotry, and unwarranted self-importance in the world today, secondary only to the internet. It is responsible for such insanity as Christfags believing that beating someone half to death with a 2,000 year old book will heal them and Muslims believing that if they blow themselves up they will get 72 virgins.

  • @MofoingSANTA it wasnt created it was always been there inside us .. it is part of our human nature. and by the way I am a muslim, and we believe if we sacrifice our life for our religon you will go to heaven afterlife.

  • I LOVE IT

  • perfect answer!!!!

  • if Einstein, the smartest man in the world, believed in God that's how you know he exists

  • lol I'm mad nobody can trust anything anymore, Einstein didn't even say this

  • interesting

  • "This apocryphal tale of a college-age Albert Einstein proving the existence of God to his atheist professor first began circulating in 2004. One reason we know it isn't true is that the same story was already making the rounds five years earlier with no mention of Einstein in it at all. "

    urbanlegends.about.com/od/reli­gion/a/einstein_god.htm

  • @yohotboy09 Detaching Albert Einstein's name from the story doesn't make the concept any less valid.

  • @massampage if god isn't real. Then who made us and the universe ? God is real but you are avoiding it just to make it easier for your self

  • @BroUmad1994 your logic seems to be turning on itself, sir. Saying "god did it" is literally the easiest answer one could have for any given problem. One that does not adequately address the problem at hand. Instead, making the claim, "We don't know yet," is a more honest answer, because we'd rather have potential answers and theories we can use to approach the actual truth, rather than sit comfortably on an ancient made-up answer to all things unknown.

  • @BroUmad1994 We are all here by happenstance and for no apparent reason or higher purpose. We are lumps of self righteous self diluted crap floating around in a seemingly endless ocean of inconsistency.

    Only the crippled "need" a crutch. But for the rest of us whose legs are not broken, we can walk freely without assistance.

  • @juggnautbitch so us and the universe just showed up for no reason ?

    this isn't humans logic .. my friend Humans since they were kids they build and believe that there is a good !! It is natural. please stop ignoring god because just to make easier for you life. because after life you will suffer.

  • @alhimaralkabir You are saying that just to make it easier for your self

  • BURN!!!!

  • Religions are evil , all of them , no exception

  • that was annoying

  • Knew this was Erik Satie!

  • nigga got told

  • @FireStormBaller do u have a proof that Einstein did not converted to Christian?? and i was saying that this exchange between him and the professor has no proof that it took place and ur saying that There's no proof that it didn't took place.

  • Comment removed

  • Einstein believe in Spinoza god => abstract and impersonal = universe/natural. None with stupid dogma and doctrine like Jesus, Muhammad hell/heaven bla bla bla

  • I've heard that Dylan,in an interview,said that he thought God was a woman,..and I've read that the existence of matter proves that there was a Creator - and that without mass there can be no matter. So,..if matter = Creator ,and mass = matter,..then female Creator = divine piece of mass. I think it's fairly sound. :)

  • "It was, of course, a lie what you read about my religious convictions, a lie which is being systematically repeated. I do not believe in a personal God and I have never denied this but have expressed it clearly. If something is in me which can be called religious then it is the unbounded admiration for the structure of the world so far as our science can reveal it."

  • i found this funny because god isnt real.

  • Mewmaster100 we shouldn't say f*** atheists we should try to help them how would it feel to suffer and burn in hell for eternity that would suck so put yourself in their position help them

  • owned

  • Einstein did not believe in God "It was, of course, a lie what you read about my religious convictions, a lie which is being systematically repeated. I do not believe in a personal God and I have never denied this but have expressed it clearly" this is a quote from Einstein himself, this may have taken place but it was not Albert Einstein who spoke it. I like Albert Einstein, he wasn't busy trying to tell people religion was bad, he was more concerned about things that could help humanity

  • @Heyitsvictoragain Einstein did believe in God, not a personal God, but God. This have taken place and it was Albert Einstein who spoke it. And in this video he wasn't trying to tell people religion was bad, he being more concerned about things that could help humanity doesn't mean this didn't happen.

  • Einstein is originally a Jew and converted to Christian at the age of 12. No doubt that he Believe in God ( Catholic ). But this exchange between Him and the professor has no evidence that it ever took place.

  • @reverence2324 Einstein didn't converted to Christian at all. He didn't believe in Catholic. There's no proof that it didn't took place.

  • whats the name of the song behind the video??

  • @19meva eric satie acording to my grandma

  • too bad the child does not represent the man.

  • FUCK ATHEISTS!

  • @mewmaster100 Don't tell me who to have sex with.

  • @mewmaster100 Really showing off your god's love, bro.

  • to those who search of AE religon in webs..who wrote those webs? do they know more than u do? and to those who think this only statments not facts...can u prove god dont exist? stop saying prof that god exist while u cant prof he exist

  • Comment removed

  • The truth is: Albert Einstein said this while he was a christian during his childhood but he died as an ATHEIST!!!

  • @bontanelful not true. he died believing there is god. and a great creater but he didnt pick a religion. even though he believed without religion science is nothing. who knows maybe he became muslim and was afraid to admit at time .... its hard to admit ur religion in hitlers time!

  • @funkyro0ock it was hitlers's time but he lived in america, but i woud like to ask you:Do you believe in a God?

  • @funkyro0ock you are right....Einstien believe in god until he died, but he didn't call him a god but a supernatural that created everything and heals everything.....

  • I like this. Great video, great message.

  • I call fake. Why don't God advertisers try and research a little before picking up any urban legend they can find?

  • @chiveerum You calling it fake doesn't mean it is fake.

  • @FireStormBaller No, it being fake means it's fake. I'm just trying to spread the good word. Also the logic of that argument completely disregards a lot of other attributes of god in judeo-christian belief.

  • @chiveerum Yes, you calling it fake doesn't mean it's fake. You're just trying to spread lies. Who said this is Judeo-Christian belief.

  • @FireStormBaller It's Germany, 20th century. If you're trying to criticize religion you sure as hell ain't gonna pick one nobody you know follows. Also, Einstein was a Jew, and was raised with Jewish customs, despite being public about his agnosticism (or at best deism if you consider mentions of superior beings).

  • @chiveerum It being Germany, 20th century doesn't mean it's fake. I'm not trying to criticize religion. Einstein being Jewish doesn't mean it's fake.

  • @FireStormBaller More info at snopes.com/religion/einstein.a­sp

    Of course I'm sure you won't care about gathering actual facts rather than clinging to any anecdote that might portray atheists as heartless dumb people and religious people as genii. Reality isn't as cuddly and doesn't let you laugh at idiots who don't really exist.

    Note: Are you serious? i was simply explaining why it's related to the judeo-christian religions, which was what you freaking asked!

  • @chiveerum And yet I don't see proof from that, only statements. I can show you hundreds of websites that says God exist, so that must be true. That's not actual facts, stating something isn't showing what you can do, it isn't a feat. If I stated I can fly but don't want to show it to you, would you believe me? And I'm explinging that you weren't explaining why it's related to the judeo-christians religions, which I didn't asked.

  • @FireStormBaller "If I stated I can fly but don't want to show it to you, would you believe me?" Not at all, because of burden of proof. The same reason why anecdotes like this that are presented without any sources or anything to indicate it wasn't just pulled out of someone's ass should be regarded as the scarecrow fallacy they are.

  • @chiveerum The same reason why snopes is useless.

  • @chiveerum And this wasn't pulled out of someone's ass, this is based on a true story. The only thing that's pulled out of someone's ass with no proof at all is you and snopes which are the scarecrow fallacy you both are.

  • fake, and stupid logic.

  • @pablo89212009 excuse me you are the stupid 

  • @pablo89212009 Not fake, and there no logic is stupid.

  • I am not religious, but I find this remarkeably beautiful and moving.

  • owned

    

  • In the view of such harmony in the cosmos which I, with my limited human mind, am able to recognise, there are yet people who say there is no God. But what makes me really angry is that they quote me for support for such views. (The Expanded Quotable Einstein, Princeton University Press, p. 214)

  • I find it interesting all the haters on here ridiculing people who believe in God. Why do you even bother trolling a comment section regarding something you don't care about?

  • There was a little boy in my daughter's kindergarten class like this child in the video. Super smart, and knew things intellectually that most adults are clueless about. He was in kindergarten for a couple mos, then they skipped him to 3rd grade, then 4th a few weeks later and after that, to a different school. Little kid will prob graduate college by the time he is 10

  • Lil nigga showed him up ha

  • einstein was actaully dumb as a child

    he had to repeat grades and leave schools as a child

    only when his life started to spiral out of control

    did he try his hardest to become one of the worlds most influential and inspiring scientists

  • i love this

  • JESUS, don't question, believe. Pray for a week, read the bible and if you don't believe after that. Keep living the way you do.

  • @jimasa123 I hope i do cause the bible is what brings humans to ignorance. Religion is the true blockade to the enlightenment.

  • he does exist

    dear lord, i pray that your people will realize that you indeed exist, and that you love them

  • @McFlyer1994 I disagree. Why what sins a child's commit affect the child physically? Even if a child sinned inside the womb, which wouldn't be possible, he would never be affected in his life based off of his actions.

  • @bamsb90 Only if you're catholic. That's the most ridiculous idea in existence to any other religion on the planet.

  • Does exist?

    

  • Religion and god are hardly laws of physics, it is merely a catchy parable.

  • @dasteufelhund very true although they did relate it well in the video.

  • @jdmshiz123 no, it merely only opened a flaw in professor's reasoning, but was not sufficient to prove nor relate the existence of god.

  • One of the reason I am an Atheist is because I failed to see how a being that created the universe has anything to do with human's measure of right and wrong. These have nothing to do with each other, yet in many religions they are. Just doesn't make sense. Being an atheist doesn't make me hate religions though, religions are cool, they made some works of fiction a masterpiece = )

  • Faith keeps a person stays on what he/she believes. Respect keeps other people from loving others, not faith. Therefore, Faith is for God, respect is for those who believe and do not.

  • I'm sure this is not einstein. Anyone could've seen the flaw of this quote.

    This is just another propaganda for saying that people who do not believe in God are evil.

    ~ Cold, dark, evil are all adjectives. It's true that without heat there is cold, without light there is darkness, and (for the sake of argument) without God evil could exist. That still doesn't change the fact that God made Hell. Therefore, he is evil.

  • @jolohmm Ok, now explain to me who gave you freewill? Where does your thoughts came from? When do thoughts exists? Scientists even cannot answer the mystery of one's thought. Therefore, your logic is weak.

  • @IamISRAFEL sorry to say, but you're pretty late with the most recent trend in science. In about 2 decades from now we might have the entire internet in our contact lenses. Let me answer your questions.

    1.) "Who gave you free will." - My brain, otherwise i'd just be like any other mentally retard human being who can't seem to have any sense of free will at all." . If you say that God gave me free-will he must be evil then since he neglected those who were mentally retarded? - continued

  • @jolohmm they were born mentally retarded because of the sins of their parents

  • @McFlyer1994 You sir, are an idiot.

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • @IamISRAFEL oh and before you say anything about me using the word retarded, I'm using it in a medical context. Thought I had to throw it out there.

  • @IamISRAFEL creation of life and the universe. its a thing that noone can truly know. its all point of view and belief no matter what side you are on. creation happened (w/ or w/o god), evolution happens (take breeding, the passing of traits, man made breeds of dogs etc) religion i firmly believe has many issues and is too closed, science has people like this as well. the only true question, that people can only answer out of belief and not certainty, is how was everything made at the start

  • Oh really? Let's see what the bible has to say:

    "I form the light and create darkness, I bring prosperity and create disaster; I, the Lord, do all these things." Isiah 45:7

    Read your bibles people! We need more atheists!

  • A completely false story about Einstein. This has nothing to do with Einstein.

  • Attention: This exchange between a young Einstein and his teacher is fiction, it never occurred.

  • @MACKATTACK1970 Tell me the complete address of the person who said that.

  • WOW. LOL.

    ...

    One little question and there goes over 2,000 years of time and resources down the drain.

    ....

    I truly feel bad for anyone who has committed a large amount of time and resources and not able to defend or answer one little question regarding that effort.

  • I am very concerned when people claim that they have found a value or faith system but they can't discuss it or explain how it works. Discussion is essential if one has convictions that are real ans are defensible.

    ...

    QUESTION: What if I am the perfect Christian and I die and go to heaven and my wife and children are not the perfect christians and they end up in Hell.

    ....

    Would it be heaven for me knowing my family will endure everlasting torture and fire in hell?

  • To all good Christians, please answer the following very simple question for me. Surely it can't be that difficult. I have been asking for quite a while with no one capable or willing to answer this simple question.

    ....

    QUESTION: What if I am the perfect Christian and I die and go to heaven and my wife and children are not the perfect christians and they end up in Hell.

    ....

    Would it be heaven for me knowing my family will endure everlasting torture and fire in hell?

  • god is perfect... but created an imperfect world

  • @ICU2P This world is ruled by Satan, for now. That will come to an end and a new world will begin.

  • @ICU2P God created a perfect world but Mankind destroyed it.....

  • @Saradomin65 yeh.. well i guess he created imperfect mankind...

    how can god be perfect and create everything, but there are war.. there is hunger.. there is uneven distibution of food? it goes to show.. he created something imperfect..

  • Somebody pl if you know the melody tell me so i can have the whole song reply here or at krromci@hotmail.com

  • If anyone knows the instrumental the melody of this video pl reply...

  • for a second i thought that einstein was the smart one...

  • Ladies and gentlemen, this is why I don't normally discuss religion with so called believers. I end up feeling badly for them as they prove themselves to be cowardly and delusional.

    ....

    JohnQuincyAdams1, If you no longer post to me, I will rest assured that you are delusional like other so-called believers and I will not visit this site any longer. If you do respond without answering the question, I will continue to expose you for the hypocrite, delusional coward that your are.

  • @MACKATTACK1970 Tony Rothman (physicist): "When confronted with the order and beauty of the universe and the strange coincidences of nature, it's very tempting to take the leap of faith from science into religion. I am sure many physicists want to. I only wish they would admit it."

  • @MACKATTACK1970 well for me my answer for your question is how can you go to heaven if you don't have faith in GOD? also if your against the holy church you cant go to heaven... those only who have faith in GOD will be save..... if you want to find answers read the holy bible.... or you can search for google.... It's really hard for you to believe cuz the only thing you believe is what you see, touch,etc.,

  • @Saradomin65 IT IS VERY SIMPLE. WHAT IS WRONG WITH YOU PEOPLE. THIS IS THE QUESTION:

    ...

    QUESTION: What if I die and go to heaven and my wife and children are not the perfect christians and they end up in Hell.

    ....

    Would it be heaven for me knowing my family will endure everlasting torture and fire in hell?

  • @MACKATTACK1970 well I just answered your question

  • @Saradomin65 NO, you moron, you did not answer the question. Are you too uneducated or too stupid to answer a hypothetical question without changing the facts.

    ...

    Seriously what is wrong with you people, are you this cowardly that you are not able to answer one simple question?

    ...

    You truly are a pathetic lot. You can't answer one question. Is it because you are all a bunch of GUTLESS RETARDS that don't have the intelligence or the courage to face the truth?

  • @MACKATTACK1970 even if you convince the believers you still can't change their faith in GOD........ and why do you really wanted someone to answer you'r question why not go to some forums about our religion and you can ruin it so that you can go to Hell....... and yeh you have already ruined it by posting ur question's and saying these vicious words of yours and it comes from the mouth of the devil inside you

  • @Saradomin65 I realize this is very difficult for you to grasp with your limited intelligence but there is no Devil if there is no God & you & yours not only can’t prove the existence of a god but you are too damn obtuse & too lost to even answer one simple question about heaven and hell.

    ….

    continued.....

  • @MACKATTACK1970 continued....

    ….

    Why you would be so afraid with your other co-horts to answer one question when your faith is so strong (allegedly) is beyond me. Unless of course your faith is fleeting & not based on any foundation of logic or reasoning. In other words, fairy tales & fiction.

  • @MACKATTACK1970 It's only you're choice if you want to believe in GOD...... It's faith.... and why would you bother Christians?.......... and oh yeah just search Google of Heaven And Hell..... if you really really want answers

  • @Saradomin65 'you're'? Please learn proper English usage. Thank you for not answering the question. You are the most recent of a long line of Christians too stupid and too afraid to tackle a simple question.

    ...

    Gutless and brainless, what a sad combination.

  • @Saradomin65 why I bother Christians? Because my superconducting Supercollider was cancelled by Congress in 1993 - with the question "Will we find God with this machine?" Oh also, what about stem cell research? It very much offends me that Christians say love each other, respect each others views, yet as a society we can't progress cause of these damn christians.

  • @MACKATTACK1970 Well Mack you have it all wrong. First of all, in heaven there will be no pain and no sorrow, for all tears will be wiped away. Secondly, in the entire universe there will be no pain or sin or sorrow. The Bible actually does not teach eternal torment. It teaches annihilation after those who do not accept Jesus' sacrifice for their sins and allow the Holy Spirit to change their thinking. Go to amazingfacts(org). Put "eternal torment" in the search then watch "Cities of Ash".

  • @claudiamthompson LOL, I have it all wrong? No, I believe you have it all wrong! How in common sense would someone be happy being in heaven when those he loves have to endure eternity in hell? It makes no sense whatsoever, but then sense and common sense are not the focus of the delusional and brainwashed.

  • @MACKATTACK1970 Hell is an extension of God's Mercy to mankind; He gives those who utterly reject his love and his goodness a place to go...

  • @csmuskie How very merciful of a benevolent being in his relations to his own children.

    .....

    LOL, Thank You so very much, I will forever cherish those words you have given me. It spells out in such a frank and cynical manner the hypocrisy of a fairy tale being.

  • @MACKATTACK1970 The Bible does not teach that the wicked spend eternity in hell. 

  • @claudiamthompson Revelation 21:8 But the fearful, and unbelieving, and the abominable, and murderers, and whoremongers, and sorcerers, and idolaters, and all liars, shall have their part in the lake which burneth with fire and brimstone: which is the second death.

  • @EnshiroX you dont take Revelation literally it was a vision

  • @clugerfinder ok. If you want, I can find you many other numerous passages where Jesus and Paul talk about the wicked and unbelieving going to hell.

  • @claudiamthompson Where do the wicked go according to the bible? Hawaii maybe or Tahiti? Or do the wicked also go to heaven but must live in an undesirable neighborhood there? Please enlighten us as anyone who has read the bible understands that there is destruction or a firey oven awaits them. But then again the bible has about 50 entries discussing what god will do with the wicked and of course being the bible they are open to 5000 interpretations.

  • @Saradomin65 I believe he did mention "if"... and by mentioning "if" he is giving an example.. that might not be true.. but may become true..and so "if" it is true, are you able to answer it?

  • @ICU2P how could he still able to go to heaven even if he dies if he does not have faith in GOD and is against the Holy Church?

  • @ICU2P Let me ask you a very simple question "Are you a Christian?"

  • JohnQuincyAdams1 - I am sorry for you, your convictions evaporate like a drop of water on a hot dry day. I would never run away from a situation where I am asked a question regarding my beliefs. You on the other hand have cowardly run away and refused to attempt to answer a very simple question because you are afraid of the outcome or you are spineless. Either way, if there is a god he is simply shaking his head in disgust at your for being a spineless coward.

  • @MACKATTACK1970 Arno Penzias (Nobel prize in physics): "Astronomy leads us to a unique event, a universe which was created out of nothing, one with the very delicate balance needed to provide exactly the conditions required to permit life, and one which has an underlying (one might say 'supernatural') plan."

  • snopes.com/religion/einstein.a­sp

  • @ForeverDistracted Paul Davies (British astrophysicist): "There is for me powerful evidence that there is something going on behind it all....It seems as though somebody has fine-tuned nature’s numbers to make the Universe....The impression of design is overwhelming".

  • @FireStormBaller you completly missed thepoint lol

  • The gutless nature of those that claim that they believe in god yet are too afraid to answer a simple question. Why? One may ask, if their belief is so great that they are fearful of answering a simple question.

    ....

    The answer is simple and multifaceted. Either their belief is not as great as they would us think it is or they realize the faulty nature and logic of their misguided belief system and are too fearful to face that fact.

  • @MACKATTACK1970 "I was reminded of this a few months ago when I saw a survey in the journal Nature. It revealed that 40% of American physicists, biologists and mathematicians believe in God--and not just some metaphysical abstraction, but a deity who takes an active interest in our affairs and hears our prayers: the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob."

  • @JohnQuincyAdams1 Your are gutless, gutless, gutless, gutless for not answering the question I presented to you multiple times. You are a fraud, you can't defend your fairy tale bible or your fairy tale god. You have no faith and you have proven it by being unable to answer one simple question.

  • @MACKATTACK1970 Roger Penrose (mathematician and author): "I would say the universe has a purpose. It's not there just somehow by chance."

  • Einstein had so much swag...

  • Comment removed

  • By the way, this video is bullshit. This exchange with young Einstein NEVER HAPPENED. This is a fairy tale just like the bible is a fairy tale.

  • @MACKATTACK1970 This video isn't bullshit. Einstein did say this.

  • @FireStormBaller Source please, a legitimate objective third party source to prove your claim would be appreciated.

  • @MACKATTACK1970 Proof please? A legitimate proof to prove your claim.

  • @MACKATTACK1970 Ed Harrison (cosmologist): "Here is the cosmological proof of the existence of God – the design argument of Paley – updated and refurbished. The fine tuning of the universe provides prima facie evidence of deistic design. Take your choice: blind chance that requires multitudes of universes or design that requires only one.... Many scientists, when they admit their views, incline toward the teleological or design argument."

  • @MACKATTACK1970

    the bible is a HISTORY BOOK with REAL HISTORICAL EVENTS THAT ACTUALLY HAPPENED. How can you say God is not real when there is an empty tomb, why do you have little faith. Jesus loves u and he died for you on the cross for your sins. I hope that you will get saved and become a Christian before it's too late, because I dont want you to go to hell when you die. God loves you no matter who you are and what you do, I just want you to know that

  • @christiancountryteen What if I die and go to heaven and my wife and children are not the perfect christians and they end up in Hell.

    ....

    Would it be heaven for me knowing my family will endure everlasting torture and fire in hell?

  • @MACKATTACK1970 I want to ask you the same questions multiple times. Where did you come from. Some may say a rock. Where did that rock come from? Earth 1 billion years ago. Where did Earth come from. Space Matter. Where did Space matter come from. A tiny particle in space that multiplied and multiplied over billions of years. Where did that particle come from? . . . Exactly. Everything needs a creator. For painting its and artist. For buildings, theres engineers. For us theres god.

  • @altec150 Oh I see, since you can't explain something then it must be GOD!

    ....

    I realize you have no idea how silly and illogical that is but trust me it is very silly and completely illogical.

    ....

    Question: (You are the third person I have asked with no answer so far)

    ...

    What if I die and go to heaven and my wife and children are not the perfect christians and they end up in Hell.

    ....

    Would it be heaven for me knowing my family will endure everlasting torture and fire in hell?

  • @MACKATTACK1970 Ed Harrison (cosmologist): "Here is the cosmological proof of the existence of God – the design argument of Paley – updated and refurbished. The fine tuning of the universe provides prima facie evidence of deistic design. Take your choice: blind chance that requires multitudes of universes or design that requires only one.... Many scientists, when they admit their views, incline toward the teleological or design argument."

  • @JohnQuincyAdams1 Well there you have it. Scientific facts that prove a god? By the way, you may want to read more of what Ed Harrison has written on the subject. Furthermore, if this is your scientific answer proving a god existence, please be aware that you have failed.

    ...

    Proof is something that you do not have but belief and faith is different. I have no proof of Peter Pan existence but I truly believe and have faith that he exists. Do you believe in Peter Pan also?

  • @MACKATTACK1970 Wernher von Braun (Pioneer rocket engineer) "I find it as difficult to understand a scientist who does not acknowledge the presence of a superior rationality behind the existence of the universe as it is to comprehend a theologian who would deny the advances of science." (

  • @JohnQuincyAdams1 @JohnQuincyAdams1 There are hundreds of thousands, millions of scientists & you pick out a handful & one NAZI & give me their opinion, their belief, their faith. You stated that you had SCIENTIFIC prove for the existence of god.

    ….

    You lied, no one has scientific proof, no one can prove there is a god. It is Faith and Belief only. I Believe that Cinderella existed doesn’t mean she actually existed.