Added: 3 years ago
From: CelineFascinated
Views: 239,791
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (206)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • why did she sung so badly?? everybody knows she can do much better..... i don't like it at all!!!!

  • she's always been a terrible singer

  • @AhmedophisIII I think the people who have made her rich would disagree.

  • Comment removed

  • This was (obviously) very early in Celine's career when she was still singing thru her nose (as the French do) and trying to find her style. This time she chose to look like Olivia Newton John from Grease. She progressed to become a wonderful singer and then went beyond that. Now, the song is unimportant to her and she only sings notes to show how long she can sustain a tone.

  • A signature song mostly referred to as Barbra's. Taking on a song perfected by possibly America's greatest female singer-Barbra Streisand- is something anyone should stay clear of even Celine

  • she trys to hard to show off but shes a great singer

  • you know, some fans should have a reset button! ...sometimes they don't even respect their idol's idols!...

  • Julie Andrews & Barbra Streisand are NOTHING compared to this Diva. Céline is best singer that the world has ever had the privilege of knowing.

  • @CelineReneRC I would not go that far...I Love Celine!!!... but I'm very sorry to tell you that Barbra Streisand is the best singer. You cannot compare this quick performance to Streisands Masterpiece. Even Celine would tell you. you are wrong, since Streisand is her idol.

  • @Jake4uinto

    You're wrong AND retarded!!! YAY!!! Your mom was raped!!!

  • A lot of hope and energy on her interpretation. Yes, we believe that there's a place for us ! It's so fresh, so virgin, far away from the crying versions, desesparating ones as Streisand.

  • She sounds sooo nasal some times, like sing through her nose, but some song are good

  • She seems to happy for this song considering it's a very emotional song.

  • don't like this rendition

  • over singing

  • Type in Somewhere Julie Andrews

  • Julie Andrews' version has the most hits of all the versions of Somewhere and theres an important reason why: "She puts feelings into it. She doesnt just sing or belt it to show off. When you listen to Barbra or Celines versions, you dont feel the lyrics, the longing, the sadness of not being able to be with the person you adore and love. Check this video out instead ...

  • Barbra's voice grates on me. Just does! Don't hate on me!

    I did like some of her vocals; like "People" for instance. But I cannot listen to her, voluntarily. If I"m a captive audience in a store, or "somewhere"; I look for an exit.

    Celine has put polish on her vocals since this was recorded And her voice is distinctly Celine!

    tomato! tomahto!

  • LOVVVEEE the way she puts a pop twist to it!!!!!

  • whats big is that there are people who dislikes the video, but rather like RAP that they themselves can understand! gosh hahaha! its so funny how pathetic people can be.

  • Celine who? There is nothing either in the voice or the appearance of this woman that is anything like Celine DION!

  • I love u celine but Babra still the best on this song....

  • cien tres bien, Celine Vous etes tres belle 

  • celine.... as much as i love you and love for most... still no one an beat babra for singin this song.... there's such deep feeling when babra sang it... it just... "WOW". but i still do love you so much ... your songs are the one i always use when i sing at poeple's wedding... thank you celine....

  • tHIS SONG HAS BEEN RECORDED BY NEMEROUS ARTISTS AND THEY ARE ALL GREAT BECAUSE THIS IS A GREAT SONG!

  • hey i've uploaded a video of myself singing this song, please listen to it and let me know what you think :)

  • unreal.

  • Say what????

    

  • I think it was a pretty good performance but a little too much adlib vibratto.

  • I hate to say it ,but with Celine singing this it is god Awful Just bad bad bad no tune no tone please make her stop

  • @PathfinderMac she had this really nasal sound before she had her nose and jaw work done.. Add years of vocal rehab and you got the Celine the world know now. She still gets on my nerves tho...

  • @PINKSTRAWBERRYSORBET She had her teeth fixed, but she didn't want to get her nose or jaw done because it would change her voice. It's very obvious her nose is the same if you bother to look. She learnt how to look after her voice so she didn't lose it but she never had a singing lesson. She has hardly changed really. I don't know what you're talking about.

  • oh my God that is awful!!!!

  • I'm sorry, but in my opinion, a performance like this one shall be forbidden.

  • @SifoDillas why?

    

  • watch barbra streisand sing this... she's wearing white suit.... the last three belts are breathtaking

  • @ElvisandCeline25 Barbra Streisand is the greatest performer.

  • hey i have uploaded a video of myself singing this song, please listen to it and let me know what you think :)

  • linda , maravilhosa , amo essa musica , e na voz da celine ainda fica mais perfeito !!!

  • What language is that?

  • @Tenorforte french canadian? i think

  • Pia was going to sing this next week on Idol. Probably would have sounded very similar to this.....

  • @cjcicco ..alas, we will never know. Man, Pia was my pick for top 2.....oh, well, everything happens for a reason. God has a blessing for her, I know.

  • talent like this does exist in our generation. you just don't hear it on the radios

  • @musicspeaks234 amen!

  • @musicspeaks234 Indeed. That's why I am so grateful I was born in 1990...I have the indescribable past decades and 90s to lean on.

  • this is at the point in her career where she had yet to learn english, or was juuuust starting to... she was literally singing it phonetically with little understanding of the lyrical content, amazingly well done btw, but if you watch her more recent videos you can definitely see more of a connection to the lyrics and phrasing. i love being able to compare how far artists have come with where they started! <3 celine!

  • i like her..but, not the best rendition of this song...it is ok.

  • celine your voice are not fit with this kind of song.... pls watch regine velasquez rendition of this song it's much better

  • love youuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu!

  • Classic - -MSAE Shakespeare exhibition

  • Not sure what language they were jabbering in, but she looked good doing it. LOVE this song :-)

  • @urkal3009 French...Quebec style. :P

  • She's just AWESOME!!

  • @PurpleNightButterfly When Celine began recording at the age of 12 Barbra and Aretha were also selling millions of records and were queens of music ... next to them Celine was a child-amateur singer ... so a little bit of humbleness when refering to other singers who recently started their carears. You never know where they can go in their path.

  • @ElvisandCeline25 She's very good compares fairly favorably to Barbra, Judy, Karen but don't give me ga-ga. I didn't use the last names on purpose if you don't know them then you can't say Celine is the best.

  • the; duet; of; leona; lewis; and; il; divo; is; milessssssssssssssss; better

  • OMG! Vaseline Dion wants to be Barbra Streisand so bad. This is shit compared to Queen Barbra's version. She sounds so nasal.

  • @josbo51715 She sounds so FRENCH, as she is french canadian she is bound to have an accent. I love both barbra and Celine, they are both great.

  • Amazing I heard her say she asng this song she didn't even know what she was singing or what the words meant amazing!

  • Je le dis souvent et je le redis, comme je m'ennuie de la Céline des années 80, de ses débuts en 1981 jusqu'à 1989. En 1990 elle a lancé son premier album aglophone et il me semble qu'on l'a un peu perdu à partir de là. :'(

  • why has talent like this died! why doesn't it exist in our generation?!?!

  • @beyourselfth talent; hasnt; died,theres; LEONA; LEWIS

  • @argenies141 Leona Lewis has nothing compared to Celine Dion.

  • @beyourselfth I know what I am going to say may sound ackward but actually the reason or at least of the reasons why voices like the one of Céline isn't heard that much or appreciated as before is simply because ... people in general got tired of them (Céline, Mariah & Whitney and all the others of the same genre and style). We're in the sad era of the imediate impact and mediatism where gimmicks and stage tricks work better than just singing: Gaga? Rihanna? You got the picture I presume ...

  • @Fabian81 oh i definitely agree with the second part there. I don't think that people got sick of them though, i think somewhere along the way, some crazy vocal teacher started telling people that the correct way to sing was NASALLY! (and without tune) and then for some reason, attractive went from classy to skank and talent went from, well talent, to "sellability" based on hotness! What happened to all of those old not "hot" talented people?

  • @beyourselfth Being tired of them? Trust me they did it's all a matter of what's fashion in that particular moment so the 90s were luckly made for the great divas of pop like Celine, Mariah and Whitney worldwide but even if we have amazing follow uppers like Leona Lewis or Jennifer Hudson it's never gonna be the same as before. People follow the trashyness of Gaga and the madness of Britney who knows why ... I just know that they follow all that crap ... they like crap let's put it that way!

  • @beyourselfth Because nowadays all you have to do is scream "on pitch" and look pretty and you're a hit. XP Now this isn't the case for everyone but it obviously works for a lot of them.

  • @beyourselfth i agree!!!!!!

  • @beyourselfth

    In America, its because we haven't funded Arts education to nurture the talent when its most important.

  • @CrazyOleMoose i agree with you....

  • @beyourselfth What? Since when is Celine Dion dead?

  • @Midfrost1 LOLOL not her, just talent like hers don't seem to find their way to the mainstream anymore

  • @beyourselfth technology... no one has the patience to actually practice.. i don't know

  • @beyourselfth celion dio isn't dead. O.o

  • @beyourselfth it's alive and living in Las Vegas. Three shows a week and twice on Sunday.

  • MY my... way to ruin this song Celine.

    Good voice, but too much style.. in my opinion....

  • i love celine dion but this was not that great (mostly the beginning) - barbara's voice is more full.

  • We are very fortunate to have voices even existing like Judy Garland, Barbra Streisand, Karen Carpenter and Celine Dion and certainly any opera-like talent out there.

  • @cspaikido agreed

  • @cspaikido - This is good but speaking of "opera-like talent," the best version of this song is by Sarah Brightman. It is sooooo beautiful.

  • I don't like this version, Celine has a great voice but she lacks Barbra's emotion.

  • wow i just love this song and the way its sang by all these great singers .. Celine dion, The supremes and barbara streisand I want to cover to sing too!! LOVE IT

  • What a load of rubbish Barbra is far better.

  • well, wat i can say about this performance is that celine's style of singing doesn't suit this song..that's why it sounds a lil weird..she's still awesome=D

  • celine has a different style from babra, so we can't compare like that

  • Celine will NEVER be Barbra. Queen Streisand slays Vaseline Dion.

  • no need to be insulting,,, there both amazing !!! and btw celine is considered number 1 in the world, and shes french,,,

  • @mrtrintob because sometimes the world does it right and encourages talented people not only beautiful people. Her voice is amazing, and that's why she is so famous. She's one of the best singers this world has ever known and nobody with some clarity in his head would deny that. If you don't like her go and see Megan Fox or someone who's only worth for her beauty. That's what models are for. End of discussion.

  • @Happyfer Sorry Happyfer that's a load of bollocks, she's still bloody awful, now as she was then.

  • what a creeper

  • wow everybody fails babs and celine our both lagging behind Diana Ross' version come on ppl

  • wow everybody fails babs and celine our both lagging behind Diana Ross' version come on ppl

  • celine dion will never be the legend that is Barbra Streisand. She has croaked out some nice little ditty's but that's all they are. She has never recorded the fine standards that make Barbra a legendary performer.

  • @davidshep45 are u insane...barbra will never come close to celine... celine is the top international selling female artist of all time!!! now i am one of her biggest fans and i will say i didnt not like this performance nor arrangment but to say shes not a legend and wont eve be on barbra level is just plan crazy

  • sorry Celine, but u got style, but sometime ur style and voice just make the song sound really lame :(

  • Sorry. Not even in Barbra's league. Needs to hold notes longer. Barbra's ending causes chills. Celine's simply doesn't.

  • @werehavinaparty She wasn't even 20 here...so I don't imagine she would be in Bab's league.

  • She has an amazing voice, but there just is no emotion, its to show smiley.

  • DISGUSTING, performance and voice quality by Celine! While Celine is a fantastic singer, she did not do justice for this beautiful song sang by the GREAT Barbara Streisand, sorry Celine. Better stick to songs like Power of Love, the song the made you famous.

  • Oh, dear...where's Streisand when she's needed?

  • that lady can sing!

  • how about geting celine to sing with the great SHIRLEY BASSEY the two of them could really belt a song out. i love them both.

  • Que canção bonita, e que interpretação fantástica. Essa mulher sabe bem cantar...

  • NIce rendition but there's best rendition too from regine velasquez of the Philippines. just type regine somewhere....she got powerful voice than celine...........

  • one of my favorite Barbara songs...done by another one of my favorite artists. I would like to hear Celine sing this in concert now...shes grown a little :)

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • First of all - Celine IS a singer with life in her voice.

    Second of all - if you think Rene Angelil is pedophile then you know completely nothing about true love. I'm so sorry for you.

  • Comment removed

  • And by the way, Celine sings "Some can criticize and sit in judgment of us

    But THEY CAN'T TAKE AWAY the love that lives inside us always"

  • So you can say bad things about their relationship, but they don't care about what you're saying. they just go on loving each other, and they're happy. There's no worst thing on the earth than to not love and be loved. From your words I can assure myself that you have no idea about how is it to love and be loved, and that's why i'm so sorry for you. You lose more than you could imagine.

  • here's a humble rendition of this classic....pardon the video...kinda dark...constructive comments would be most welcome...thanks and happy listening

  • @PurpleNightButterfly I never said that Latoya London was a beter singer than Celine Dion. I think celine is the best singer ever, but when i compare the two versions latoyas arrangement is much better and makes her voice sound great. I'm sure celine can sing the hell out of a phone book, thats why she is the best.

  • Actually, yes she can. Search Celine Dion Phone Book. It's fantastic.

  • well mine is by julie andrews.... barbra is great yet ifeel the emotion of the song from julie. it seems that she's not just singing the song but acting the song...

  • The best version of somewhere is by the legend...PJ PROBY,  IT JUST CANT BE TOUCHED !!

  • This rendition is ok...

  • This song is awesome, but Latoya Londons version of it is the by far the best. I am a fan of music an I know a great voice. No one sings this song better than her.

  • Stacey Soloman sang this better last Saturday on the X Factor semi-final with toothache and bruises!!!

  • @21161960 barbara is relly by far the best ever female singer in the world! celine comes after her, she has great voice too, and can sing, little stacey is very amture, her voice is not in a league with these 2 ladies....so she starts yelling to compensate for the vocie

  • don really live ger version... but her voice is incredible

  • celine is great.

  • Brilliant! J aime enttendre tous vos songs et Je vous aime Celine Dion.

  • I can has reri grist plz?

  • I think "ugh" sums it up perfectly.

    thumbs down commence!

  • Purement K E T A I N E ~ She had no idea what she was lyrically singing - proof is how she moves around as if she was an Elvis wannabe

  • ugh

  • Kuh Ledesma's version is the best

  • well, i wouldn't say this is awful..nor is barbara's version better....but, Celtic Woman outdo the both of them!

  • I second murphy before me, too much vocal gymnastics makes this a rubbish version. This song is really beatifull if sung pure and worm and with a heartfelt forcefull ending.

  • Barbra's version is the best

  • She's always great.. And she's beautiful, inside and out.

    Love you Celine!

  • Beautiful heart, wonderful personality.

  • Bull. Stand-up comedians love making fun of Whitey and Whiteness. It's funny--just like this version of the song.

    No biggie. I'm just sayin' ...

  • she seems to make this song her own

  • Dear Celine, you're not Barbra you're way better than Barbra.

  • I think we just found simon cowell's youtube username.

  • I totally agree

  • when that is said, julie andrew is even better

  • @82celinedion82 What kind of drugs are you on. Sounds very nasily to me. Not that good really. Babs blows this performance away when she was 65 yrs old sorry you fail.

  • @BBBYpsi Blow it out your ass! It's my opinion!!!!!

  • @82celinedion82

    you got that right...Celine is in a class of her own.

    keep in mind this was in 1988 and Celine was only know in the canadian province of Quebec back then...to think she is now the best selling female artist in history and without a question the biggest international female singer in the world.

  • @82celinedion82 Listen to Shirley Bassey's version, please! ;-))

  • @82celinedion82 I agree that Celine Dion is at least comparable to Streisand but someone tried to put Lady Gaga in the same category. Celine Dion is possibly close to the talent of Barbra Streisand but certainly not way better.

  • @cspaikido I'm obviously not the only one who feels this way. Album and concert sales prove that.

  • @82celinedion82 so what - most of society are media's jerkoffs. album sales can say whatever

    it is the QUALITY of the music.

  • @cspaikido agreed!

  • Listen to Barbra Streisand videos from the mid-60's. You haven't watched from when she was Celine's age. She immediately got a television show and multiple movies, Funny Girl, Hello! Dolly, On a Clear Day You Can See Forever and others. Celine Dion is certainly in the argument with her international success. But just as Madonna opened doors for Brittany and others Judy Garland and Barbra opened doors for Celine. But you must agree that Lady Gaga is not in this conversation.

  • @82celinedion82 she is not better than barbra- no one is better than anyone. they are both amazing.

  • @impatientwithdesire I totally agree

  • @Googaify thanks!

  • @82celinedion82 whoa whoa whoa... I love Celine Dion, but I wouldn't say she's better than Barbra. Barbra is a big legend, a big voice! She was/is Celine's idol. They're both incredible. Celine is a baby diva even yet next to Streisand. Don't get me wrong I'm not saying Barbra is better because it's no true. She is just a huge legend and like I said Celine's idol and she's much older than Celine and it's impossible to say who is better. Anyway, I think they both will be remembered forever

  • No need to explain to me... Im from Quebec as well... but was replying to someone that made a comment involving France and some history/politics, which have nothing to do with Celine. Comment seems to not be showing up anymore, which is good :)

  • celine dion.. nothing else to be saiddd.. the best voice i heard singing thi song.. effortless