@bobokk yes you did. i tried, and i find anti-flag THE BEST! this video is not the best there is, but this band is awesome liste to: -Anthem For The New Millennium Generation -The Project For A New American Century -Hymn For The Dead -The Press Corpse -You Can Kill The Protestor, But You Can't Kill The Protest -Sodom, Gomorrah, Washington D.C. -Good And Ready enjoy this songs and then listen to all discography then you'll recognise hoe good they are
this is pure fuckin plagiarism no matter how you look at it. It's not a fucking coincidence when it's the same song alltogether!! No respect for these turds
EVERY band copies riffs once in a while, you know why? Because there are theories which chords fit together and which not, so offcourse there are a lot of bands with the same riffs!
Even the famous wonderwall song is a rip off!!! Does anyone care about that one?
"Plagiarism" is the use or close imitation of the language and ideas of another author and representation of them as one's own original work. The two songs are similar but not to the point of "ripping off" or copyright infringement.
You seriously have no knowledge of punk or guitar theory if you think there is absolutely no chance of 2 bands using the same chord structure once a while.
Did I even say that, fuckwit? The whole point is that this ISN'T one of those same chord structure occurrences. The intro, the riff, vocal lines and trade-offs are the SAME. Added to that is the fact that it sounds nothing like AF's previous output and finally, the fact that they toured with FAR just prior.
And Kberns, there have been lawsuits won for less than this. I can't be bothered to list them.
Seems like someone is getting seriously pissed off. Fuckwit? haha. They are not the "SAME", are ears even a part of your anatomy? Doesn't seem like it. Logic would suggest it isn't plagiarism - a band with 9 albums in the bag doesn't need to plagiarise - it certainly lowers the chances. I don't deny it's the same riff, but it's not plagiarism - it happens. When did they tour with From Ashes Rise?
That's absolute bullshit. How about a band that has run out of ideas after 9 albums and is feeling the pressure of their major label bosses? This song reeks of desperation. Even the fucking drum fills are the same.
They toured together late 2003 or 2004 as part of a Jade Tree tour.
well, if you think they've sold out they haven't. the only reason they even went to a major record label is because they said they wouldnt censor any of their songs. so now they can reach a bigger audience and they're music isnt censored. so there you have it. they haven't sold out
Yeah apparenly if you have one a song based around a similar riff it's a rip off. Which is a load of bollocks, especially in punk rock. The riff isn't even the same as the From Ashes Rise song. Very similar. You think Anti-flag need to copy a riff? Hahaha. They've released 7 albums before the latest one without any problems, I doubt they need to start copying people now. Hahahha. Carry on looking for excuses to dislike them.
they didnt fuckin sell out. just cuz more people bought their newest albums doesnt mean they sold out. jackass. ill admit that their sound has changed but i think its because they are more mature. HAHAHA. i never thought i would use that phrase. but it actually seems like it. now their songs are not titled "Fuck the Pope" or "Kill the Rich"
no they didn't play it, it's like right before they come out on stage (before spit in the face), they have some music piped in by woodie guthrie or something. it's a quietish acoustic sort of song, and i really want to know what it is...
Chris doesn't give a fuck what 2 people think of him.
bairhsnyva 10 months ago
fuck this song. Anti-Flag fuckin stole the song "From Ashes Rise- Reaction" and only changed lyrics/made it sound shitty.
Disgnacio 1 year ago
@Disgnacio ok
Peruviandude96 7 months ago
bobokk
SUCK MY COCK
theChrisNum2 1 year ago
@theChrisNum2 Oh diddums. Did I offend your precious little band? Try listening to some real musicians - you'll thank me for it later
bobokk 1 year ago
theChrisNum2 1 year ago
@theChrisNum2 Die For Your Government is good. Everything after is shit
bobokk 1 year ago
this is pure fuckin plagiarism no matter how you look at it. It's not a fucking coincidence when it's the same song alltogether!! No respect for these turds
slugscrubber 2 years ago
Dude, please kill yourself or something!
EVERY band copies riffs once in a while, you know why? Because there are theories which chords fit together and which not, so offcourse there are a lot of bands with the same riffs!
Even the famous wonderwall song is a rip off!!! Does anyone care about that one?
Sorry for my bad English I'm dutch so ;)
applejaanse 2 years ago
you're fucking right!
in a few songs from my band I use also same chords.
ChrisVinegar 2 years ago
Same intro
Same verse
Same chorus
Same vocal style
Same drum fills
bobokk 2 years ago
Anyone can tell that the songs are too similar for that. Too many coincidences
HoosierMF 2 years ago
"Plagiarism" is the use or close imitation of the language and ideas of another author and representation of them as one's own original work. The two songs are similar but not to the point of "ripping off" or copyright infringement.
Fucking ridiculous...
Kberns 2 years ago
FROM ASHES RISE WOULD LIKE THEIR SONG BACK
Plaigiarism is a serious crime.
Plaigiarism is a serious crime.
Plaigiarism is a serious crime.
Plaigiarism is a serious crime.
Plaigiarism is a serious crime.
bobokk 3 years ago
Is it a crime to learn to spell? No? Gtfo and come back when you can.
AdamHarrison06 2 years ago
No it's not. Plagiarism is though.
bobokk 2 years ago
You seriously have no knowledge of punk or guitar theory if you think there is absolutely no chance of 2 bands using the same chord structure once a while.
AdamHarrison06 2 years ago
Did I even say that, fuckwit? The whole point is that this ISN'T one of those same chord structure occurrences. The intro, the riff, vocal lines and trade-offs are the SAME. Added to that is the fact that it sounds nothing like AF's previous output and finally, the fact that they toured with FAR just prior.
And Kberns, there have been lawsuits won for less than this. I can't be bothered to list them.
bobokk 2 years ago
Seems like someone is getting seriously pissed off. Fuckwit? haha. They are not the "SAME", are ears even a part of your anatomy? Doesn't seem like it. Logic would suggest it isn't plagiarism - a band with 9 albums in the bag doesn't need to plagiarise - it certainly lowers the chances. I don't deny it's the same riff, but it's not plagiarism - it happens. When did they tour with From Ashes Rise?
AdamHarrison06 2 years ago
That's absolute bullshit. How about a band that has run out of ideas after 9 albums and is feeling the pressure of their major label bosses? This song reeks of desperation. Even the fucking drum fills are the same.
They toured together late 2003 or 2004 as part of a Jade Tree tour.
bobokk 2 years ago
well, if you think they've sold out they haven't. the only reason they even went to a major record label is because they said they wouldnt censor any of their songs. so now they can reach a bigger audience and they're music isnt censored. so there you have it. they haven't sold out
FeverishDonkey 3 years ago
THIS BAND IS A TOTAL RIP OFF
deathwishnani 3 years ago
Rip off? Rip off of what? This band has existed for soon over 15 years and you call them a rip off? god..
DeejayLouis 3 years ago
Yeah apparenly if you have one a song based around a similar riff it's a rip off. Which is a load of bollocks, especially in punk rock. The riff isn't even the same as the From Ashes Rise song. Very similar. You think Anti-flag need to copy a riff? Hahaha. They've released 7 albums before the latest one without any problems, I doubt they need to start copying people now. Hahahha. Carry on looking for excuses to dislike them.
AdamHarrison06 3 years ago
Exactly what i ment brother. A-F haven't sold out, and theyre certainly haven't started to rip off other bands. A little research would back that up.
DeejayLouis 3 years ago
NO I DON'T GIVE A FUCK WHAT YOU THINK OF ME
ARE WE GETTING ANYWHERE?!
I'M GETTING the FUCK out of HERE
profitprophet368 3 years ago
I didn't know Anti-Flag did a From Ashes Rise cover :P
Ha ha ha
TheBattleContinues 3 years ago 6
they didn't make a cover. they fuckin stole it and made a shitty version
Magrudergrind 3 years ago
The solo live is so much better than the album one.
And btw, they don't need to stop stealing songs. Did they ever start?
JustAnotherGuy66 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
They need to stop stealing songs.
AutoPanic 3 years ago
what song did they steal?
pvgangstapunk 3 years ago
Reaction by From Ashes Rise
AutoPanic 3 years ago
Hell Yeah Anti-Flag Fuckin Ripped Them
LazCole 3 years ago
From the sounds of it, #2 doesn't give a fuck what you think of him.
Kasrkin25 3 years ago 11
first they sell out and now they have no originality? jesus what happened to my favorite band?!?!?!
AquaSka753 3 years ago
they didnt fuckin sell out. just cuz more people bought their newest albums doesnt mean they sold out. jackass. ill admit that their sound has changed but i think its because they are more mature. HAHAHA. i never thought i would use that phrase. but it actually seems like it. now their songs are not titled "Fuck the Pope" or "Kill the Rich"
albertassociate 3 years ago
i'm feeling like you man
danihatesyouguys 3 years ago
fuck yeah<3
JowsePunk 3 years ago
Can someone tell me what happened to Pat? I can't find anything about why he wasn't there...
breadpoint 3 years ago
When I saw them in Philly on 5-3-08 they said that Pat had to go back to Pittsburg for family matters or something
Kidrobo24 3 years ago
Sucks for him.. he also wasn't in the Melkweg 26th june.. will he be allright?
JeroenRos 3 years ago
idk
Kidrobo24 3 years ago
does anyone know the last (recorded) song that played, right before they took the stage?
discipleofjos34 3 years ago
cities burn or which song do yoe mean?? the one with the 'woah' part
skunkhead25 3 years ago
no they didn't play it, it's like right before they come out on stage (before spit in the face), they have some music piped in by woodie guthrie or something. it's a quietish acoustic sort of song, and i really want to know what it is...
discipleofjos34 3 years ago
haha oke, was wondering that to actually!
sorry mate, can't help you out!
skunkhead25 3 years ago
Is that Pat Thetic?
Oo
RaphaRadcliffe 3 years ago
no Pat was not there.
why ? i don't know
Siscolito 3 years ago
damn wish it still was groezrock!! but I'll see them again on pukkelpop :D
skunkhead25 3 years ago
Yup I was there and f*cking enjoyed the show.
Piedoke 3 years ago
same
Kimaira91 3 years ago
pownage i was there to
Pl0x3Yz04 3 years ago
sucks to be home though .. wish i could stay 2 days
Kimaira91 3 years ago
indeed ..
but
it is kinda expensive thhough
Pl0x3Yz04 3 years ago
atleast the company was great ^^
Kimaira91 3 years ago
billy talent was great aswell .. ô
Pl0x3Yz04 3 years ago
heard 'em.. didn't go see them =(
Kimaira91 3 years ago
I agree, but I'm off soon to another metalfest. That's the reason why I didn't go two days.
Heaven Shall Burn was all I came for!
Piedoke 3 years ago
graspop metal meeting is your next one?
Pl0x3Yz04 3 years ago
Almost yer.. but there's a local death metal gig today in Ham.
But I'll be on Graspop for three days ofcourse. :)
Piedoke 3 years ago
Graspop fuck yeah! Comeback kid and madball!!!
TacTx 3 years ago