there's a more succinct cohesive version as a bonus track on the smiley smile-wild honey cd. also theres a bonus track on the smile 2 disc version which i haven't listened to yet. (waiting for the right time to burn one down to)
This is wonderful. The fuzz guitar (or bass?) part is great. The flutes at the end are mystical. Even if it WAS fake it fits in perfectly. It would be cool if there were flutes throughout. You did a good job man!
I like it, and i don't really care where it came from, music is music, and if it feels and sounds good then that's it. Pop heaven. Really looking forward to the Smile box set. Wonderful musical time, wonderful music, I mean those cello's set against a theremin and sleigh bells...genius. A
@CaptainPillowMusic That is DEFINITELY something to fantasize about, but like crowley24 said, I don't know how those personalities would have gotten on with one another! Respect for each others art only goes so far before the ego takes over.
@CaptainPillowMusic Brian Jones and Syd Barrett were too stoned out of their minds to even function. They just stayed put until the day they got sacked.
@predlycon No way dude! They would totally work! And I'll explain why, because I'm just fucking with you and I'm not explaining anything, because you shouldn't take a fantasy comment so seriously. Your comment's actually a bit simplistic. I think you need to read their histories a bit deeper. But thanks for giving me another laugh, as someone yet again takes my fantasy comment as reality.
@CaptainPillowMusic Don't be a douche. All I'm giving is a reply to *your* "fantasy comment", how even in *your* fantasy, the thing would not work with Jones and Barrett. And like what the others said, it's too much of a clash of personalities.
@CaptainPillowMusic Don't forget Ray Davies, Pete Townshend and Billy Corgan (As far as music visionary's go). And you should probably add Paul McCartney for good measure too.
I mean, the Pumpkins are okay at best, but honestly putting him anywhere near Brian Wilson's league is absurd. Brian Wilson is closer to Bach or Mozart than pop songwriters.
@mothafuckajones666 Alright, I respect your opinion, but I'm going to ask you to respect mine. I believe Corgan is up there, don't call my opinions absurd. Music is subjective and not fact based. On what grounds can you call my opinion absurd? Just because you believe Wilson is closer to Mozart or Bach doesn't really make it a fact.
This is how it is: The Beatles made music that really changed everything. After Rubber Soul came out by the Beatles, Brian Wilson really wanted to live up to that new sound and so they created Pet Sounds, probably one of the greatest albums ever. Beatles albums were always very out there and very inconsistent. They had some good albums, but nothing as good as Pet Sounds BY FAR. But as for over all songs, the Beatles have better songs that are more powerful and revolutionary.
Have you heard of "Sgt. Peppers Lonely Hearts Club Band"? I mean it's like that doesn't even exist to all of you Beach Boys fans! And really Good Vibrations can't compare to Strawberry Fields Forever.
you can find alot of "extra parts" on the unsurpassed Masters of the beach boys,SMiLE bootlegs, the beach boys archology, there are all kinds of beach boys bootlegs out there....but this sounds pretty genuine to me :)
Brian had produced literally hundreds of different snippets that went unused after the epic SMiLE project collapsed. There is a box set that has all these extras and this guy edited it in his own way. It is not fake however, you can hear even more musical segments on the lost SMiLE tapes.
I guess you have never heard a Beatles song in your life. This is not the same melody and the same rhythm at all. Go ahead Israel "Abanibi"-Abaniba : Izhar Cohen and The Alphabeta. All the legend of your country stands in this 1978 Eurovision winner :-)))
This is an amazing version! Even though the original 1966 is perfect and can't be faulted, I have always loved Tony Asher's original lyrics and Brian's original vocal.
It's all nonsense this comparison rubbish. Both the Beach Boys and the Beatles live by their beautiful music. We are all made better by their existence (and their tremendous rivalry, making 1967 rather special.).
@wordtweaker then u have the people who think that The Beach Boys didn't make anywhere near the dent on rock music that The Beatles did.... such as myself
Musically speaking,Brian was far superior to Lennon/McCartney. Though they were better songwriters,I think Brian had a more overwhelming musical vision.
It's like a film or sculpting -- it's easy to take away or cut things. What you hear is everything he had imagined for the song, but not sure what to cut. By the way, when this song was produced, it was the most expensive song ever recorded at $45,000.
"The Beach Boys were trying to achieve the 'strawberry fields forever' psychedelic sound done by the beatles.
John, George, Ringo and Paul were all one step ahead of Brian Wilson"
Ahh...That is weird since Brian started recording Good Vibrations in February of 1966 (released in October of '66) while the Beatles didn't start recording Strawberry Fields until November of 1966 (released in February of '67).
The Beach Boys and The Beatles had a friendly rivalry. Pet Sounds was a response to The Beatles Rubber Soul. And Sgt. Peppers was the response to Pet Sounds, which completely murdered it. Brian Wilson could have outdone Sgt. Peppers, but he was too depressed. He said that The Beatles found the sound he was looking for. After hearing Strawberry Fields, he locked himself in his room for a few weeks.
Pet Sounds came out before Revolver. Good Vibrations was being worked on at the time Revolver was released. You are right however about Pepper, as the Beatles were recording Revolver when Sounds was released thus the earliest response concept wise is Pepper.
I remember this version, Brian Wilson signed a recording contract at PA studios somewhere in Pennsylvania and was stunned to find he was swindled (PA studios is Ammish Pennsylvania studios).
The place was was a cold empty barn.
Since the recording was due in three days he had no choice but to steal various Ammish goods to use as homemade instruments and invent a new method of recording (cow udders in binary sequence), later he re-recorded it in a pro studio (the version everyone knows).
I knew that Brian Wilson basically recorded "Good Vibrations" in tiny pieces, and only used a handful of them for the single. Nice to hear what the other pieces sound like. Thanks for posting!
Very nice. A good snapshot of where BW's head was at. I would have liked to see how he could have mixed in the section at the end (with the piccolo) into the various versions I have heard.
Also nice to hear the original lyrics in a '60's version of the song. They are much better.
Haha, you're not very good at research then. They wanted a theremin sound, but no one could play it, Paul Tanner and Bob Whitsell invented the electro-theremin (or tannerin if you like). Paul Tanner (who played the trombone) played it with a slide resistor.
I was simply pointing out that his "I'm a music tech student and I researched this song!!" didn't make him right. This whole string of comments started with him attacking poniesinashed.
dude go get an A in A level music tech then i'l listen to you. for fucks sake my argument was its not a tannerin its a theremin, which is correct, yea tennerin is another word for a different kind of the same instrument that they DIDN'T use during the recording of this track
I think SgtHooF, you'll find it is a Tannerin, clever clogs. This comes from a music tech student, so don't attack poniesinashed when you don't actually have a clue.
Shmoopydoo is partially correct. A tannerin is a simple oscillator controlled by a slide and it sounds similar to a theremin, but not the same. It's not particularly related to a theremin though.
HIP HOP SAMPLE!
AverageAmericans1 1 week ago
Very cool track. Thanks man!
BaronM 2 weeks ago
i like the ending
KIDAmnesiacBends 1 month ago
opening guitar parts Barney Kessel and Jerry Cole or...Al Casey...Glen Campbell...Tedesco?
Johng10000 1 month ago
there's a more succinct cohesive version as a bonus track on the smiley smile-wild honey cd. also theres a bonus track on the smile 2 disc version which i haven't listened to yet. (waiting for the right time to burn one down to)
briney1973 2 months ago
This is wonderful. The fuzz guitar (or bass?) part is great. The flutes at the end are mystical. Even if it WAS fake it fits in perfectly. It would be cool if there were flutes throughout. You did a good job man!
EmeraldFlowsion62 2 months ago
very fine ... ;-)
gertvangelder 3 months ago
I'm not gonna lie, I enjoy this more than the original version
Chiplinked 4 months ago
@Chiplinked I agree. I wish they kept this for smiley smile.
coasterfan321 4 months ago
I like it, and i don't really care where it came from, music is music, and if it feels and sounds good then that's it. Pop heaven. Really looking forward to the Smile box set. Wonderful musical time, wonderful music, I mean those cello's set against a theremin and sleigh bells...genius. A
cottageorgan 4 months ago
this isnt the long version its the smile version
liamrocksmysockstm 4 months ago
All i can say is GROOVY.
Desiree50 5 months ago
Fantastic!
sneezepal 5 months ago
thanks D....
okay i send him good vibrations
~~~~ oooohhhoohhhhh~~~~
i do not remember this cool 'n long version in my brother's 4 foot tall stack of surfer records back in the day...
sowaycool indeed
FinallyunderstandU 6 months ago
I love the little vocal that you first hear at 2:21. It caught me off guard when I first heard it here but it really fits.
marvelboy74 6 months ago
i prefer the alternate versions found on the smiley smile/wild honey cd
briney1973 7 months ago
Brian Wilson, Brian Jones, John Lennon, Syd Barrett, and Skip Spence all should have left their bands and formed the best band ever.
CaptainPillowMusic 7 months ago
@CaptainPillowMusic would have been to much of a clash of personalities
crowley24 6 months ago
@CaptainPillowMusic That is DEFINITELY something to fantasize about, but like crowley24 said, I don't know how those personalities would have gotten on with one another! Respect for each others art only goes so far before the ego takes over.
MattHatter 5 months ago
@CaptainPillowMusic Brian Jones and Syd Barrett were too stoned out of their minds to even function. They just stayed put until the day they got sacked.
predlycon 5 months ago
@predlycon No way dude! They would totally work! And I'll explain why, because I'm just fucking with you and I'm not explaining anything, because you shouldn't take a fantasy comment so seriously. Your comment's actually a bit simplistic. I think you need to read their histories a bit deeper. But thanks for giving me another laugh, as someone yet again takes my fantasy comment as reality.
CaptainPillowMusic 5 months ago
@CaptainPillowMusic Don't be a douche. All I'm giving is a reply to *your* "fantasy comment", how even in *your* fantasy, the thing would not work with Jones and Barrett. And like what the others said, it's too much of a clash of personalities.
predlycon 5 months ago
@CaptainPillowMusic Don't forget Ray Davies, Pete Townshend and Billy Corgan (As far as music visionary's go). And you should probably add Paul McCartney for good measure too.
ArtemisFlyingV 4 months ago
@ArtemisFlyingV
>Billy Corgan
>musical visionary
I mean, the Pumpkins are okay at best, but honestly putting him anywhere near Brian Wilson's league is absurd. Brian Wilson is closer to Bach or Mozart than pop songwriters.
mothafuckajones666 3 months ago
@mothafuckajones666 Alright, I respect your opinion, but I'm going to ask you to respect mine. I believe Corgan is up there, don't call my opinions absurd. Music is subjective and not fact based. On what grounds can you call my opinion absurd? Just because you believe Wilson is closer to Mozart or Bach doesn't really make it a fact.
ArtemisFlyingV 3 months ago
This is one of the best songs ever made, can't wait till SMiLE.
CHANCHOFACE 7 months ago
I'll give you a "rope a dope" that'll be your silent night Buzzard.
DaddyBog 3 years ago
I remember a 30 minute version that I guy I knew had on a CD bootleg about 18 years ago. The song had movements. It was epic.
PVCVIDEOLA 3 years ago
@PVCVIDEOLA Jesus Christ, I need to hear that.
mysticblade35 4 months ago
i thought this was tha normal one .. its tha only one av ever heard haha
jamieleecarr 3 years ago
why this is only the 3rd beach boys hit single?
that time beatles already had more than 20 hits!
limunan 3 years ago
number 1 sing,e they had about 30 or so top top 5 hits
batman444 3 years ago
so what,quality not quantity
regentv980 3 years ago
Excellent!
The Buzzards favorite song, with "Silent Night" a
close second
BustardBuzzard 3 years ago
Could you post a link to that?
R4FAELLO 3 years ago
AWSOME SONG!!
Sweetiexnm22 3 years ago
great version thanks!
ask a musician. consistancy is something you strive to avoid. what a compliment!
angrymandopicker 3 years ago
WOH!
New to me - mind you, even as the 'truncated' single, "G.V." is a symphonic masterpiece.
This'n in it's FULL-LENGTH UNCUT GLORY is UBER-MEGA-ULTRA-*SUPERB!*
Muchas Gracias, Compadre!
BadNews88 3 years ago 3
I like it!
Mustang169th 3 years ago
love it
TawhidaJonas 3 years ago
this is a great verssion, and remindsme pink floid
Emilcortes 3 years ago 5
This is a great version, and reminds me of Pink Floyd.
xbyiu97 3 years ago
I think Pink Floyd listened very careful to this!!
fietsvriend 3 years ago
Yeah i agree. It's like a mix between pink floyd and the beatles. I wish this version got played more.
krazyk9999 3 years ago
@Emilcortes Pink Floid...????
01skynyrdfan01 1 month ago
:) :)
panzelig 3 years ago
woow amazing
imthefigga 3 years ago
Brian Wilson is a genius
Canalsuper3 3 years ago 3
This is how it is: The Beatles made music that really changed everything. After Rubber Soul came out by the Beatles, Brian Wilson really wanted to live up to that new sound and so they created Pet Sounds, probably one of the greatest albums ever. Beatles albums were always very out there and very inconsistent. They had some good albums, but nothing as good as Pet Sounds BY FAR. But as for over all songs, the Beatles have better songs that are more powerful and revolutionary.
Thundercankles 3 years ago
i've gotta say i disagree when you say the beatles' albums were inconsistent.
revolver and pet sounds go hand in hand for me, really.
they're both so great that you can't really say one is better than the other.
peaceric 3 years ago
If the Beatles were inconsistent, Brian Jones was wayyyy worse. Regardless, this is one of the greatest albums ever made.
Icix1 3 years ago 2
LOL. "but nothing as good as Pet Sounds BY FAR"
Have you heard of "Sgt. Peppers Lonely Hearts Club Band"? I mean it's like that doesn't even exist to all of you Beach Boys fans! And really Good Vibrations can't compare to Strawberry Fields Forever.
ChristForte 3 years ago
Comment removed
roflganklol 3 years ago
I LOVE the Beatles but I definitely don't agree with you. Wilson made some very well thought out arrangements.
josephedwardperez 3 years ago 5
@roflganklol Lol I'm a bigger Beatles fan as well, but if you think they all sound the same you obviously aren't listening...
crowley24 6 months ago
got my leg tapping away
nicholasjames100 3 years ago
Wait, where did you find these extra instrument parts? I mean for all we know, this could be fake.
Icix1 3 years ago
you can find alot of "extra parts" on the unsurpassed Masters of the beach boys,SMiLE bootlegs, the beach boys archology, there are all kinds of beach boys bootlegs out there....but this sounds pretty genuine to me :)
pahu61 3 years ago
All the "extra" parts used here come from either the Good Vibrations: 40th Anniversary Edition EP and from The Purple Chick's bootleg of Smile.
organizm 3 years ago 3
@Icix1 there is a ton of music for this song that's been bootlegged.
69OldsNut 4 months ago
@Icix1
Brian had produced literally hundreds of different snippets that went unused after the epic SMiLE project collapsed. There is a box set that has all these extras and this guy edited it in his own way. It is not fake however, you can hear even more musical segments on the lost SMiLE tapes.
bobshenix 2 months ago
@bobshenix And they're all much better quality.
I might try and put together my own version of this, it's so good.
mysticblade35 2 months ago
this is also great(compared to the "original")! especially the beginning. and new to me.
sweetfranx 3 years ago
you edited some unused stuff for good vibrations?? how did you find them in the first place??
awesome... a really good edit
RobbieApok 3 years ago
To me, this is new discovery because I knew only the original one.
carrywet 3 years ago
not at all you are not boring
KHGEARS 3 years ago
This is absolutely brilliant.
Well done!
GerryMATW 3 years ago
Back in the USSR of The Beatles if a parody of The Beach Boys
PilMcCartney 3 years ago
I guess you have never heard a Beatles song in your life. This is not the same melody and the same rhythm at all. Go ahead Israel "Abanibi"-Abaniba : Izhar Cohen and The Alphabeta. All the legend of your country stands in this 1978 Eurovision winner :-)))
PCMusic75 3 years ago
its not a parody, its a tribute. Paul was a huge fan of the beach boys
sloser 3 years ago 3
I recently discovered how good this song is- i kept replaying at work this week :)
Anag2080 3 years ago
sounds like a dub version
995715202 3 years ago
o
My
God
nevernevernever heard of this version!!!1000stars rated!
rkremer 3 years ago
Absoultely fantastic!! One in a trillion!
Acipiho 3 years ago 2
wow, this is the long version.
smartheart12 3 years ago
This is an amazing version! Even though the original 1966 is perfect and can't be faulted, I have always loved Tony Asher's original lyrics and Brian's original vocal.
No1emilybrowningfan 3 years ago 2
It's all nonsense this comparison rubbish. Both the Beach Boys and the Beatles live by their beautiful music. We are all made better by their existence (and their tremendous rivalry, making 1967 rather special.).
wordtweaker 3 years ago 10
@wordtweaker then u have the people who think that The Beach Boys didn't make anywhere near the dent on rock music that The Beatles did.... such as myself
TheBass2themax 8 months ago
rare beach boys songs on my channel!!!
iwojima654 3 years ago
Genius
dminus73 3 years ago 3
Musically speaking,Brian was far superior to Lennon/McCartney. Though they were better songwriters,I think Brian had a more overwhelming musical vision.
colmanaucoin 3 years ago 15
"OVERWHELMING" is right,LOL!!
RonaldVaughan 3 years ago 3
Though I love the Beatles, you are right. Compare this to A Day In The Life, a lot of similarities
rockerdude59 3 years ago 2
@colmanaucoin They were better lyricists, he was the better composer you mean.
ArtemisFlyingV 4 months ago
This version would be good for a live show. The audience might dig it since live stuff is generally longer anyway.
Neiko410 3 years ago 3
Paul said in one of his interviews, that he thought the Beach Boys the better of the two groups. Both were inspirational.
ChiefOren 3 years ago
Lost.
rewquiopfdsahjkl 3 years ago 2
RIP Charlie :(
Turbohog 3 years ago
any time you step out of your class you step down. this is no exception. it is interesting but never on my play list. is this a "box set" leftover?
marygraceisadog 3 years ago
It's like a film or sculpting -- it's easy to take away or cut things. What you hear is everything he had imagined for the song, but not sure what to cut. By the way, when this song was produced, it was the most expensive song ever recorded at $45,000.
StanBennet 3 years ago
And it gave CAROL KAYE plenty of room to cut
loose on electric bass,didn't it? :)
RonaldVaughan 3 years ago
rofl
szatter123 3 years ago
It really sounded like others sang and superimposed over tapes. Was this an interpretation? Who did this? Was this Beach Boys.
SAT9terminus 3 years ago
Sheer genius and it still is amazing 42 years later
atilius 3 years ago 3
I made a 5:30 stereo version and it was fun fun fun.
BIGLOU48 3 years ago
this is my gymnastics floor song lol
cheergal200866 3 years ago
There's actually a 12-minute version of "Good Vibrations" on an Eighties "Smile" CD... I'd love to hear that.
NyeTunes 3 years ago
Is this a joke? Good Vibrations is one of the sweetest songs ever written. This song is just a mess.
r5t6y7u8 3 years ago
love 3:52-4:56
especially 4:22-4:56
...and i'm not much of a Beach Boys fan.
malikscifi92 3 years ago 2
by the way
5:50-6:08 is cool too.
malikscifi92 3 years ago
hehe you're right
giuliaVines 3 years ago
dude since this was made by brian HIMSELF the single version is way better, i mean longer means not better.
OropherThranduil 3 years ago
at 5:30 its like something out of "destroy all humans" sounds so cool
jacezz123 3 years ago
The perfect song.
Brian sold his soul for it.
Can you hear the devil sing?
Etcircenses 3 years ago
Great intro, the rest is..."interesting".
DaveMcIroy 3 years ago
Is this a cool song or what!!?
2LongGone 3 years ago 4
wish they played this on the radio -- Brian (pet sounds -- just wasn't made for his times)Luv My Carl, Denny and Brian!!!!!!!!!!!!!
ncarolinaluv 3 years ago
They play it in Utah, Excellent song.
Have you heard their song called Salt lake city?
kaylee51598 3 years ago
It's probably on page 50 of my site hee hee
ncarolinaluv 3 years ago
One of the weirdest, most creative minds in the history of music.
DickStainy 3 years ago
u can barely hear it at the beggining im like what is this? i got it windows music player its sooo louder =/ but i guess good vid,
michaeltheguitarhero 3 years ago
incredible Brian!!!
plotiusvegetus 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
The Beach Boys were trying to achieve the "strawberry fields forever" psychedelic sound done by the beatles.
John, George, Ringo and Paul were all one step ahead of Brian Wilson
Never the less give credit to Brian
ActionJacksonSucka 3 years ago
Actionjacksonsucka, I hate to inform you but this was 1966, strawberry fields was 67.....
lalalamort 3 years ago 2
"The Beach Boys were trying to achieve the 'strawberry fields forever' psychedelic sound done by the beatles.
John, George, Ringo and Paul were all one step ahead of Brian Wilson"
Ahh...That is weird since Brian started recording Good Vibrations in February of 1966 (released in October of '66) while the Beatles didn't start recording Strawberry Fields until November of 1966 (released in February of '67).
Brian was 9 months ahead of the Beatles.
Good try, though.
gtr82 3 years ago 4
Haha, I'm a fan of the beatles more then the beach boys and I even knew how much the beatles took from the beach boys hahaha, wow.
COCHESEkramer 3 years ago
Well The Beach Boys got their ideas from The Beatles. They both took stuff from each other. It was a friendly rivalry.
rjkahlon 3 years ago 3
Pet Sounds was actually Wilson's attempt to top Revolver, before the Sgt. Pepper's sessions even took place.
Sgt. Pepper's was the Beatles' response to Pet Sounds.
studacris55 3 years ago 5
Yup.. though calling Sgt. Pepper a responce isn't really true. It took music even one step further. Making good music without making it 'love songs'.
Though conceptual it was new and exiting it musically wasn't nearly as 'new' as Pet Sounds was.
PuppyZwolle 3 years ago
The Beach Boys and The Beatles had a friendly rivalry. Pet Sounds was a response to The Beatles Rubber Soul. And Sgt. Peppers was the response to Pet Sounds, which completely murdered it. Brian Wilson could have outdone Sgt. Peppers, but he was too depressed. He said that The Beatles found the sound he was looking for. After hearing Strawberry Fields, he locked himself in his room for a few weeks.
rjkahlon 3 years ago
Pet Sounds came out before Revolver. Good Vibrations was being worked on at the time Revolver was released. You are right however about Pepper, as the Beatles were recording Revolver when Sounds was released thus the earliest response concept wise is Pepper.
tomczap 3 years ago
I remember this version, Brian Wilson signed a recording contract at PA studios somewhere in Pennsylvania and was stunned to find he was swindled (PA studios is Ammish Pennsylvania studios).
The place was was a cold empty barn.
Since the recording was due in three days he had no choice but to steal various Ammish goods to use as homemade instruments and invent a new method of recording (cow udders in binary sequence), later he re-recorded it in a pro studio (the version everyone knows).
MightySaturn5 3 years ago
sure.....
ItachitheCool468 3 years ago
...don't you like my version?....lol
MightySaturn5 3 years ago
love 1:02
batman444 3 years ago
the top
sbrannes 3 years ago 2
Nothing like it.
ilard4 3 years ago 2
There is a reasonthese clips ended up on the cutting room floor.
SaudaraLink 3 years ago
I love this song, because of all the different sounds and voices mixed together.
Temprit101 3 years ago 2
this is so much about lsd
kasperlangkjer 3 years ago
fantastic!!!
johnnyblade82 3 years ago 2
Oh! This is epiccer than the other one.
sonisisuper 3 years ago
more epic**
sweeney71 3 years ago 2
now this version is truly amazing how well Brian Wilson made it. Is this version on any CD of the Beach Boys?
waggeo99 3 years ago
I knew that Brian Wilson basically recorded "Good Vibrations" in tiny pieces, and only used a handful of them for the single. Nice to hear what the other pieces sound like. Thanks for posting!
desolateangel83 3 years ago
Dig CAROL KAYE'S electric bass playing...she
strummed with a pick...
RonaldVaughan 3 years ago
I'm posting all the SMiLE songs including this one on my channel. Just click my name.
WorkSucksProductions 3 years ago
Good good good good vibrations
Whiteblooded 3 years ago
whatever the song is the shit stop bitching!
moliere1789 3 years ago
not bad
cxtriker 3 years ago
Wow, there's some stuff on here I hadn't heard before. Quite a collage of sound. Cool.
caraphyllis 3 years ago 2
Very curious and pretty cool.
5*****'s
~ Tim
spotswoodthenewt 3 years ago 2
Excellent! thanks for posting!
ncarolinaluv 3 years ago
hay guys you are going to thank this funny hehehe i forgot i had just turned down the volume. cool song
casper10581 3 years ago
what the f#@& is this i guess the joke is on me i cant hear no sound humm hahah haahah very funny
casper10581 3 years ago
faced
gerbertgerbertgold 3 years ago
This a good version, is better than i listened always
nandostein 3 years ago
Nice. THanks for posting it
rimian 3 years ago
Very nice. A good snapshot of where BW's head was at. I would have liked to see how he could have mixed in the section at the end (with the piccolo) into the various versions I have heard.
Also nice to hear the original lyrics in a '60's version of the song. They are much better.
txmystic 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i think poniesinashed you'l find its called a theremin
clever clogs,
this comes from a music tech student
so don't try and act all clever when you dont actually have a clue
SgtHooF 3 years ago
Actually, poniesinashed is correct. The instrument used in Good Vibrations was a modification of the theremin called a Tannerin.
shmoopydoo 3 years ago 4
bullshit i had to spend like two month researching this song and anylising the shit out of it and the word tannerin was never mentioned
SgtHooF 3 years ago
Haha, you're not very good at research then. They wanted a theremin sound, but no one could play it, Paul Tanner and Bob Whitsell invented the electro-theremin (or tannerin if you like). Paul Tanner (who played the trombone) played it with a slide resistor.
eyeball226 3 years ago
yes exactly an electro theremin bellend
SgtHooF 3 years ago
Exactly, not the same thing as a theremin. You didn't do your research properly.
eyeball226 3 years ago
OH NOES, he didn't do his research properly.. Hopefully, RESEARCH PATROLMAN EYEBALL226 WAS HERE TO SAVE THE DAY. Not.
Elendil963 3 years ago
I was simply pointing out that his "I'm a music tech student and I researched this song!!" didn't make him right. This whole string of comments started with him attacking poniesinashed.
eyeball226 3 years ago
yea but i am right
SgtHooF 3 years ago
No. Poniesinashed said it was a tannerin which was played by moving a slider. That is correct.
You went straight into attacking him saying:
"i think poniesinashed you'l find its called a theremin
clever clogs,
this comes from a music tech student
so don't try and act all clever when you dont actually have a clue"
Which is quite funny, because you're wrong.
eyeball226 3 years ago
dude go get an A in A level music tech then i'l listen to you. for fucks sake my argument was its not a tannerin its a theremin, which is correct, yea tennerin is another word for a different kind of the same instrument that they DIDN'T use during the recording of this track
SgtHooF 3 years ago
lol
SgtHooF 3 years ago
I think SgtHooF, you'll find it is a Tannerin, clever clogs. This comes from a music tech student, so don't attack poniesinashed when you don't actually have a clue.
Shmoopydoo is partially correct. A tannerin is a simple oscillator controlled by a slide and it sounds similar to a theremin, but not the same. It's not particularly related to a theremin though.
eyeball226 3 years ago
What CD is this version on?
wagdi71 3 years ago
cool i never heart the long version
verry niceeeeeee beter than the small 1
SEETER1 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
beach boys sucks............ the rolling stones owns: for the win
adhddaan 3 years ago
why are you here then?
BestTits 3 years ago 6
beach boys and rolling stones are to completely different bands, you clearly dont like the beach boys style... keep ur shit to yourself :)
theres too many fans for someone petty like you to come here and diss k thanks bye
MiK3i 3 years ago 7
bet you must be like, 15 years old? I was like that in my teens...hey, this band is better than yours etc. crap! GROW UP!
pinheadsen 3 years ago
i am 19 years old... it is not the age if you like it... but i like it very much.. it makes me happy:)
bajertje 3 years ago
I wish I could put this on a CD...I LOVE this song :)
JeremiahTrane 3 years ago
hey do u know that is long version is already on a cd!!!!!!!
iwojima654 3 years ago
Really...That I didn't know.....I'll see if I can find er :)....Thanx
JeremiahTrane 3 years ago
my god this is so wonderful, the original lyrics are so great
dannynar 3 yea