Aftermath of Karbala Play San Diego MYSD chehlum arbaeen 1/6

[sfr227]

MashAllah great job!

[fatimah1523]

marshallah this was wonderful work. May Allah swt bless and reward each and everyone that made this... great work.

[KingGilgamesh89]

everyland is not karbala and everyday is not ashoura because no land is comparable to the holy karbala and no day is comparable to the day of huseyn.

[sanaabegum]

@KingGilgamesh89 Salaam. By this they mean, that if you think every day is Kerbala, you will not do gunah, sins. Think what the Imam gave us, if you are a Shia, you will do sins every day, don't. we, small, big; but, we do, what about Ashoora, NO, you are busy, mostly, there is program every center; and, then, you are just trying to do good for people, give water, as in Sabil, start, organize take part , in Majalises and so on. And as for Kerbala, think you are in Kerbala every day, No sin

[sanaabegum]

@KingGilgamesh89 Sorry, I meant every day is Ashoora, not Kerbala. typing mistake. And, every land is Kerbala.

Jazakallah.

[RIDAH71]

YA HUSSAIN

YA SHAHEED

thanks 4 posting

great video

[Najafia17]

Beautiful Very Nice thanks for posting!!! i love it! will share with other friends

[yumyguy]

I am sure; it's not permissible at all. No one in this world can re-play or repeat again what happened in Karbala. The unpleasant incident of Karbala to be treated with highest respect whatever may the feeling be. Tomorrow somebody may make fun of it and then it will become un-tolerable for us only. So we should restrict our self from doing such acts no matter how much good intentions/ purpose one has. If you have little respect for Imam Husain, please remove this video.

[amamdani15]

first of all who are you to tell me that i have no respect for imam husain. i myself participated in the above play. the way that you are saying it, is that we should not have any rememberance of what happened in karabla, no more majalis, azadari and so on. some people do azadari to remember imam hussain, others do read majalis for others to hear and remember about the hardships that the family of the prophet had to go through. now can those meathod not be made fun of also? this is just another

[amamdani15]

way of showing our love for imam hussain and as you can see there are no humans associated with the family of the prophet, all their faces are covered and unless you can figure out by voice they are just placeholders for those who cannot be present. if you believe that this is not acceptable in islam first bring me the proof from some respected documents such as the quran, hadith of prophet or imams and the sunnah of the prophet. second if you still belive that this is wrong then dont watch it.

[amamdani15]

just because you do not eat some foods does not mean that you try to wipe it off the face of the planet you just avoid it and continue on with your life so i propose that you just leave everybody alone unless you can bring me legitimate proof that what these people have done is haraam then let me know but otherwise just leave everybody alone. lastly i believe that before targeting the small groups like us, why dont you take care of those big movie producers in other countries that constantly.

[amamdani15]

make movies recreating the islamic history and shut the big people down, because we are really not making that big of a difference, just making sure that the legacy of one of the greatest men is not lost, until the last time that i checked that was not a crime. i believe that you are the one that does not have respect for imam hussain because you do not want his message to last forever, by wiping out ways in which he is remembered. who knows tomorrow you might be saying that doing

[amamdani15]

azadari and majlis is not allowed

[hanonah1115]

lol not permissable.. u need to read a little bit.. u need soem education really about islam/.. so if we dont remeber it in actions is ok too that ppl wil lstart to forget.. im sure u r unjust in ur life and u dotn follow the thing that happened in karbal

[yaalimaddad]

the beginning sentence is wrong its kullo yaomin ashura kullo arzin karbala......meaning everday is ashura and every place is karbala

[aqalidost]

how is it wrong?

[amamdani15]

its backwards. kullo arzin karbala, kullo yaumin ashura.(every land is karbala, every day is karbala.)

not that big of a deal

[hanonah1115]

no it is every land is karbala and every day is ashura.. (take it from an iraqi)

[GhulamePanjatan]

Did you guyz ask for a Marja if its 100% permissible? Cuz this act is great but i'm not quite sure if we're allowed to do this Manzar Kashi..!!!

It'd be better if u guyz had used the name Sakina instead of Sukayna...but indeed a great act i must say !

[kazimtwo]

Why do you think we are not allowed manzar kashi?

[queenzillest]

lmfao i see AMIN and KAVON and that guy covered face sounds like SALEH AL-QAZWINI