Isaac Brock opened my mind up to a fascination of the spoken metaphor that continues some 15 years later, if not longer...One of the best lyricists and songwriters of my generation. I don't think even he realizes how powerful his song writing is.
@marnold6879 i've thought about that before..."does this guy have any idea what kind of impact he has made on music?" he is going to be remembered for a very long time.
I listened to this song a lot when I was 17. I lived in the outer suburbs on the edge of the city. I would listen to it on my walkman as I walked past half completed shopping centers and cookie cutter suburban housing developments on my way home from school. I really fucking get this song.
@optimisticcosmic Very well put. I first thought that when I heard the chorus of lives, "It's hard to remember.." Another lyric that sticks out is, "You don't know who you are, but you know who you wanna be."
I love Modest Mouse but there's something about their songs that compels YouTubers to make some awfully cringe-inducing, mushy comments about their own lives. I'm not saying I don't like being sentimental, but bleeeghh. I don't care about you and I doubt you'd be interested much in my story either.
@FlaminBelgianWaffles Why? He didn't say anything bad about the song. It's just an opinion. I actually think that Dashboard is a great song, not better than this one of course, but I still think that people should be able to enjoy songs like Float On and Dashboard and not get judged for it.
i can't believe how incredible modest mouse is. they've been among my top favorite bands for a couple years now, and i'm still finding songs by them that i've never heard before and are amazing. i have a new favorite every other week. i saw them in concert a few weeks ago and they were extremely good live. just altogether a genius group of people making great music.
It's funny to me that so many are raving about Brock's lyricism in this song, when for me, the drums are what make it. I believe It was Jeremiah Green on percussion here.
@austinFLAUGH ya jerimiah is an amazing drummer but i think isaac is the most important part. i mean the lyrics and singing build all the emotion but the instramentals are essential too.
@DJThrasherful On that topic, Silversun Pickups always quoted Built to Spill as their main influence, but most mainstream sorts of interviewers would be all.. "Built to who?" So now their main influence is the smashing pumpkins.
When I was young I was a punk rock/indie snob that prided myself on finding bands before everyone else. No that I am a corporate sellout I do not have the time to be the first and I don't care. I love inspired/passionate music and artists regardless if a buddy burns me a CD or if I see them live 5 years before anyone hears about them. Find good music and share it. The people who found Modest Mouse before they signed a major label made it possible for the rest of us to experience their music.
@brnoyes888 I think however it's sad to see the bands who get bigger because of the same people to completely change their style for the wider audience, it's been happening a lot recently.
@JamesWheelz artists evolve that's what he's feeling and that's what he wants to put out his old stuff is badass and will forever be one of my favorite musics but his new stuff is still pretty badass and im glad he put it out and it still moves me...
@metallvoid Oh I'm not saying the new stuff is bad, I love it! but with other bands, like Biffy Clyro for example have got worse imo as a result of wanting to appeal to a wider audience.
Fan's a fan, no one's greater. It would even seem to me, that the more obseesed one's are even missing a point somewhat. If someone dug "Float On" enough to search out some older songs of theirs, then it doesn't matter when that someone jumped on the bandwagon. You are both there.
I have been losing my Modest Mouse appeal since I stopped drinking. I use to love them in my extreme alcoholic days. They fit my depressive manic moods back then. Now, I'm a Phill Collins kind of guy.......Jk
@oxfordkingpin24 , Learn fuckin sarcasm you stupid fuck. God, how fuckin stupid are you dumb fuckers. For fucks sake. Jesus fuck. Are you kids this fuckin stupid these day? I was probably seeing Issac Brock at the electric factory when you were still being dropped on your head and didn't discover "Float on" yet you dumb fuck.
i really dig the whale song. such a unique sound. and the guitar is so powerful to it, but i cant say that takes teh tops. gotta go with fire it up tbh :P
@MrJowilson9 If I may offer my own reply, humanity tears the earth up to suit its own purposes and then does things like "naming housing developments... after the things they replace" in a manner that is just as insulting to what the place once was as not naming it in such a way at all. IMOHO
uhh i bout lonesmoe crowded west even though i already had most of the album on my ipod no i got to save up for this is a long drive for someone with nothing to think about dangit oh well
relax guys they're not trying to reinvent the wheel they just do what they do and do it very well .great musicians inspire one another to make great music i've been listening to them for a long time never got to see them in concert hope i do though i love this song.
While I agree that Triangletheorytrey was wrong in his two word assessment, I do think that lyrics matter just a little bit less than music. Like, music/vocals matter 60%, lyrics matter 40%.
I think it depends on how the song was written. Some songs start with lyrics and end with music, some start with the music and end with the lyrics. The first one is always the 60%.
Really? But the song is only like 30 seconds to a minute of singing and its almost a 6 minute song. But that's the beauty of music, the meanings/feelings are different to each person and it's all open to interpretation. Regardless though, Modest Mouse if simply awesome.
If I can join this discussion, I agree with frog for dramamine and a majority of their old stuff, since they really have great instrumentals and I don't think it features the melody in the vocal part like some of their new stuff does.. I see what your saying though since Isaac does write great lyrics
i dont think the lyrics matter at all lol, like maybe 10% at most. i think they just write music to write music, jsut make cool sounding shit, not super meaningful stuff
Lol.. Isaac writes the songs pretty well, much better than the music. I mean seriously, look at Doin' The Cockroach, he isn't actually talking about Doing a Cockroach! Haha.
dude a song isnt the same without vocals if it has vocals mostly instrumental but isaac places the vocals so perfectly that it just adds to the harmony
I live in Northern New England.....these lyrics are on the money......"more housing developments go up named after the things they replace". and I don't like the change of pace either!
Isaac Brock opened my mind up to a fascination of the spoken metaphor that continues some 15 years later, if not longer...One of the best lyricists and songwriters of my generation. I don't think even he realizes how powerful his song writing is.
marnold6879 1 month ago
@marnold6879 i've thought about that before..."does this guy have any idea what kind of impact he has made on music?" he is going to be remembered for a very long time.
thefearedESK 1 month ago
if i lost everything. id still have my love for modest mouse. and that would make it okay.
hulatulafromhawaii 1 month ago 2
"No i dont like this change of pace" is the best line of all time in any song especially this one!!!
Woodlandsarms 2 months ago
This is perfect music and lyrics
Woodlandsarms 2 months ago
its was a long 394 miles, with nothing but a "her" to think about every weeken.
DontWatchListen 4 months ago
I listened to this song a lot when I was 17. I lived in the outer suburbs on the edge of the city. I would listen to it on my walkman as I walked past half completed shopping centers and cookie cutter suburban housing developments on my way home from school. I really fucking get this song.
modestlyneutral 5 months ago 11
Comment removed
oliveangekms 5 months ago in playlist Modest Mouse Playlist!
que chingona banda saludos d aqui de mexico
luismaciel16 6 months ago
2 people dont appreciate good music when they hear it, probably stuck on radio overplay!
cuzican45 6 months ago
im in love with early modest mouse right now!
coughfilmsco 6 months ago
SME is destroying my playlists
TheMrsGriffin 7 months ago
every lyrics page is different, i like "I dont think it shows" and "Remember her"
Oriente7 7 months ago
the lyrics are interchange plaza malls not interchange, plazas & malls
utubesgay1 7 months ago
Best song by modest mouse off the best album by modest mouse
caketown33 8 months ago
anyone know if theres a live version/vide of this??
cloudig 9 months ago
I get a " someone is finally thinking what i'm thinking" feeling when MM is playing
optimisticcosmic 9 months ago
@optimisticcosmic Very well put. I first thought that when I heard the chorus of lives, "It's hard to remember.." Another lyric that sticks out is, "You don't know who you are, but you know who you wanna be."
irishblood97 9 months ago
@irishblood97 yeah,
optimisticcosmic 9 months ago
is this song just MIND BLOWING or wtf i love modest mouse most creative and inspiring band EVER
uRnotGOODLikeME 10 months ago
I love Modest Mouse but there's something about their songs that compels YouTubers to make some awfully cringe-inducing, mushy comments about their own lives. I'm not saying I don't like being sentimental, but bleeeghh. I don't care about you and I doubt you'd be interested much in my story either.
SclafaniBagni 10 months ago 4
fav mm song = neverending math equation
torun54321 11 months ago
I fuckin love this song so much. It can bring me up out of a very bad mood. Then again any MM song can
:)
CaptainMcDank 11 months ago
my fav mm songs: sleepwalking, positive negative, novocain
jugjugsthekoolaidman 1 year ago
@jugjugsthekoolaidman my exact favourite three mm songs too. well played.
skankaholix 11 months ago
this makes me miss being 16
ukulele414 1 year ago 3
@ukulele414 4 reals
IAmSmokingDank 1 year ago
@ukulele414 no shit
joshsaysorry 11 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
an awesome song but not as good as float on or dashboard
indyaidan 1 year ago
@indyaidan i hope to GOD you are joking ... >.>
FlaminBelgianWaffles 1 year ago 13
@FlaminBelgianWaffles hahaha seriously.
allisonmaurine 1 year ago
@FlaminBelgianWaffles Why? He didn't say anything bad about the song. It's just an opinion. I actually think that Dashboard is a great song, not better than this one of course, but I still think that people should be able to enjoy songs like Float On and Dashboard and not get judged for it.
TheHowl77 2 months ago
@FlaminBelgianWaffles what's wrong with what he said? i share his opinion, it's just a slightly different taste in music.
MrNukeaholic 3 weeks ago
@indyaidan you be trollin
murdockpt 1 year ago
Comment removed
indyaidan 1 year ago
if you like Modest Mouse so much at least have the curtiousy to spell it out
blinkman1821 1 year ago
@blinkman1821 um.... why on earth would that even matter
allisonmaurine 1 year ago
@blinkman1821 courtesy*
dallas2denton 1 year ago
one of my favorite MM songs
blueskys561 1 year ago
My favourite MM song
wannabn00b 1 year ago
the good ol days of mm
774434 1 year ago
i can't believe how incredible modest mouse is. they've been among my top favorite bands for a couple years now, and i'm still finding songs by them that i've never heard before and are amazing. i have a new favorite every other week. i saw them in concert a few weeks ago and they were extremely good live. just altogether a genius group of people making great music.
mergs8690 1 year ago 7
@mergs8690 their the only band ive left in the top 5 favorite band spot my whole life.
and1234z 1 year ago
It's funny to me that so many are raving about Brock's lyricism in this song, when for me, the drums are what make it. I believe It was Jeremiah Green on percussion here.
austinFLAUGH 1 year ago 8
@austinFLAUGH i totally agree....there is just something about his timing and everything
he11sbe11s 1 year ago
@austinFLAUGH ya jerimiah is an amazing drummer but i think isaac is the most important part. i mean the lyrics and singing build all the emotion but the instramentals are essential too.
DIGFOOL 1 year ago
issac brock your such an amazing writer. Your songs bring joy to everyone. I cant tell you how amazing your music is!
W00Dyyyy 1 year ago
WHY IS MODEST MOUSE SO GOD DAMNED GOOD?!
Zrskate38 1 year ago 2
This song is really happy! a lot happier then the title. well the title could be happy too hahah
EKstudios 1 year ago
this song has made me cry before.
equallyeasilyfuqyou 1 year ago 3
Isaac Brock is a genius
MrrANDOM34 1 year ago
Definitely in my top 5 MM songs.
vaguelyhumanoid 1 year ago 4
@vaguelyhumanoid my top 5 songs anyway lol
and1234z 1 year ago
this whole album rocks-makes me feel things
jojoluvtool 1 year ago
this song reminds me of my uncle Rudy who committed suicide eight years ago
R.I.P. RUDY 10
TheCrimsnChin 1 year ago
In the beginning of this song i feel depressed and then my feelings do a complete 180... 38 seconds into it i love this song so much!
M0destCasanova 1 year ago
thank you for posting this(:
can someone, anyone, PLEASE post white lies and yellow teeth by modest mouse? i can't find it...
ofurbanesuavity 1 year ago
@ofurbanesuavity youtube.com/watch?v=7ipusjp6COg
Lobodomy69 1 year ago
lets all have 19 kids each .......
lovetheNorml 2 years ago
@DJThrasherful On that topic, Silversun Pickups always quoted Built to Spill as their main influence, but most mainstream sorts of interviewers would be all.. "Built to who?" So now their main influence is the smashing pumpkins.
hpsfl 2 years ago
one of the best songs, ever, by anyone. subjectively speaking, of course...
milkmit 2 years ago 7
lolno
ModestMouse1207 2 years ago
any one know where to get a copy of the original interstate 8?
hardigan66 2 years ago
When I was young I was a punk rock/indie snob that prided myself on finding bands before everyone else. No that I am a corporate sellout I do not have the time to be the first and I don't care. I love inspired/passionate music and artists regardless if a buddy burns me a CD or if I see them live 5 years before anyone hears about them. Find good music and share it. The people who found Modest Mouse before they signed a major label made it possible for the rest of us to experience their music.
brnoyes888 2 years ago 158
Well said bro, if you really enjoy the music why not let others enjoy it as well.
purpledrohaze777 2 years ago
Yes please!
RyanMurphy 2 years ago
You still seem to be a little egocentric
rudek 2 years ago
Little is an understatement. Thanks for your comment.
brnoyes888 2 years ago
@brnoyes888
you read hipster runoff regularly?
oimeloimel 2 years ago 2
I had not heard of it prior to your comment. I checked it out. Seems like a good site to follow. Thanks.
brnoyes888 2 years ago 2
@brnoyes888 lol i was listening to modest mouse before they got big though, you jelly?
dallas2denton 1 year ago
@brnoyes888 I think however it's sad to see the bands who get bigger because of the same people to completely change their style for the wider audience, it's been happening a lot recently.
JamesWheelz 8 months ago
@JamesWheelz artists evolve that's what he's feeling and that's what he wants to put out his old stuff is badass and will forever be one of my favorite musics but his new stuff is still pretty badass and im glad he put it out and it still moves me...
metallvoid 5 months ago
@metallvoid Oh I'm not saying the new stuff is bad, I love it! but with other bands, like Biffy Clyro for example have got worse imo as a result of wanting to appeal to a wider audience.
JamesWheelz 5 months ago
Fan's a fan, no one's greater. It would even seem to me, that the more obseesed one's are even missing a point somewhat. If someone dug "Float On" enough to search out some older songs of theirs, then it doesn't matter when that someone jumped on the bandwagon. You are both there.
MindfulAwareness 2 years ago 4
i like never ending math equation
vot0726 2 years ago
I have been losing my Modest Mouse appeal since I stopped drinking. I use to love them in my extreme alcoholic days. They fit my depressive manic moods back then. Now, I'm a Phill Collins kind of guy.......Jk
Yinzerdude 2 years ago
@Yinzerdude
Don't ever mention Modest Mouse and Phil Collins in the same sentence!
jgood911 2 years ago 3
@jgood911 phil LAWL
oxfordkingpin24 2 years ago
hahahahahaha
someone thumbs downed you
looshkin66 2 years ago
@Yinzerdude end your life quickly, u got that lame ass magikarp type swag LOL
oxfordkingpin24 2 years ago
@oxfordkingpin24 , Learn fuckin sarcasm you stupid fuck. God, how fuckin stupid are you dumb fuckers. For fucks sake. Jesus fuck. Are you kids this fuckin stupid these day? I was probably seeing Issac Brock at the electric factory when you were still being dropped on your head and didn't discover "Float on" yet you dumb fuck.
Yinzerdude 2 years ago
@Yinzerdude why so angry u little caterpee LOL
oxfordkingpin24 2 years ago
haha was that a pokemon reference
noreggi 2 years ago
spitting venom is my favourite
kknowyouronion 2 years ago 2
spitting venom is pretty good......not my fav of all time but my fav off of "we were dead.."
looshkin66 2 years ago
Float on... ;)
subucni09 2 years ago
i like king rat
madpuppet666 2 years ago
what is your favorite modest mouse song?
shadyreefer69 2 years ago
hmm difficult question..
hmm I think it's lives or third planet
BritishRulez 2 years ago
My mom's god is a woman, and my mom she is a witch...
looshkin66 2 years ago
@looshkin66
I LIKE THIS.
MY HELL COMES FROM INSIDE COMES FROM INSIDE MYSELF
WHY TRY THIS
ljfish420 2 years ago
It's "Why fight this?" not why try this
jgood911 2 years ago
Everyone's afraid of their own lives,
If you could be anything you want....
I bet you'd be disappointed, am I right?
looshkin66 2 years ago
@ljfish420 idiot boy
oxfordkingpin24 2 years ago
Thats easy....any song that im listening to at the time is my fav. I love all m.m. equally.
looshkin66 2 years ago 3
I think my favorite is Dramamine, it's just amazing.
Facless55 2 years ago 3
spitting venom - by far the best
ztwede 2 years ago
lolno
ModestMouse1207 2 years ago
i like think long...or talking shit about a pretty sunset.
looshkin66 2 years ago
i really dig the whale song. such a unique sound. and the guitar is so powerful to it, but i cant say that takes teh tops. gotta go with fire it up tbh :P
BowlboKhabra92 2 years ago
good question... i dig gray ice water.
drewjb 2 years ago 3
Brock is one of the most over looked singers when it comes to his lyrics. A total poet.
EamonJgod 2 years ago 9
i hate chain restraunts....
drewjb 2 years ago 5
You must construct additional chain resteraunts.
abigyellowdoggie 2 years ago 7
brock's a damn poet.
hollleee 2 years ago 8
yeah he is!!!1
vanessasjealous 2 years ago
duhh dont you know it!
shadyreefer69 2 years ago
Comment removed
Asper49 2 years ago
I <3 this song.
abigyellowdoggie 2 years ago 3
Comment removed
Asper49 2 years ago
fuck fuck fuck
hockeyplyr3 2 years ago
"more housing developments go up..named after the things theyve replaced." Brilliant.
John190x 2 years ago 67
everything they do is brilliant!
TheStrokesBaby 2 years ago 3
@John190x so welcome to meadowbrook and welcome to shady space.
goddamnitcorey 1 year ago
@John190x Can you explain what this quote means to you?
MrJowilson9 9 months ago
@MrJowilson9 If I may offer my own reply, humanity tears the earth up to suit its own purposes and then does things like "naming housing developments... after the things they replace" in a manner that is just as insulting to what the place once was as not naming it in such a way at all. IMOHO
MrrANDOM34 9 months ago in playlist the greatest music playlist ever
i frying to this song
playstarr08 2 years ago 3
This song is great, it's definitely one of my favorites.
sakusofon 2 years ago 2
I just bought this CD. : )
sakusofon 2 years ago
uhh i bout lonesmoe crowded west even though i already had most of the album on my ipod no i got to save up for this is a long drive for someone with nothing to think about dangit oh well
MrFunnybunny66 2 years ago
yo thats only twelv dollors, make a lemond aid stand
Icepatch24 2 years ago 3
Good i dea
MrFunnybunny66 2 years ago 3
love the guitar at the start
MrFunnybunny66 2 years ago
just found this and love it!! check out the typography!! its on my favorits...
sebasthechecka 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Nice work. keep it up. mean time come for social media marketing for esteembpo**com erterf
jeamsanna 2 years ago
tv stained my memories
dinosore9 2 years ago
I mostly don't like songs like this one, I mean that how it starts. But then it goes better and better and the music is just amazing!
Bruchac 2 years ago
I went back to HMV today and I bought the CD. I feel better now. :)
gottalovemymovies 2 years ago 4
MM has that effect on people :)
baseballerdude11 2 years ago 2
changed my life
Room217Productions 2 years ago 4
Is the quality a lot better on the CD?
bigmac364 2 years ago
of course nubbins even youtube hq is poop compared to 320KBit quality of a cd. go buy it now
WeFloatInSpace 2 years ago
I saw this CD in HMV today. I regret that I didn't buy it.
gottalovemymovies 2 years ago 2
probably my favorite modest mouse song right now.
gangstarrpirate 2 years ago
Wow...I've just found a cool song.
Modest Mouse is awesome.
baseballerdude11 2 years ago
This song is just so unbelievably awesome, I've been addicted to it for years and years now
dummbatz48 2 years ago
hey seansean you ever heard of fucking poetry you stupid faggot
alphameda123 2 years ago 2
hey seansean you ever heard of fucking poetry you ignorant faggot
alphameda123 2 years ago 2
GOOD
isolationeitheror 2 years ago
groovy tune
DustenMcFarland 3 years ago
relax guys they're not trying to reinvent the wheel they just do what they do and do it very well .great musicians inspire one another to make great music i've been listening to them for a long time never got to see them in concert hope i do though i love this song.
shvitzenator 3 years ago
favorite mm song
TV STAINED MY MEMORIES!
samdewfoo 3 years ago 2
so much passion. this is one of the best albums ever recorded imo.
lostpillman10 3 years ago
one of thier best songs!!
otakukun82 3 years ago
i prefer the interstate 8 version, but this is still an awesome song
nuerotica987 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
To repetitive
triangletheorytrey 3 years ago
Listen to the lyrics. They are what count. You can't evaluate a song, a piece of the soul, in two words.
doom876 3 years ago 3
While I agree that Triangletheorytrey was wrong in his two word assessment, I do think that lyrics matter just a little bit less than music. Like, music/vocals matter 60%, lyrics matter 40%.
Rafaelure 3 years ago
I think it depends on how the song was written. Some songs start with lyrics and end with music, some start with the music and end with the lyrics. The first one is always the 60%.
ItallstartswithH 3 years ago
I think all of Modest Mouse's songs, the lyrics matter 70%.
ModestMouse1207 3 years ago
Dramamine begs to differ. Though the lyrics are still awesome in my oppinion, the actual music clearly gives the song all of its emotion and meaning.
froggut198 3 years ago
Not really... I really pay attention to the lyrics in that song.. the instruments just make the lyrics sound better.
ModestMouse1207 3 years ago
Really? But the song is only like 30 seconds to a minute of singing and its almost a 6 minute song. But that's the beauty of music, the meanings/feelings are different to each person and it's all open to interpretation. Regardless though, Modest Mouse if simply awesome.
froggut198 3 years ago
Well, I think the instruments set up the singing which make the singing even better. But, it's all great.
ModestMouse1207 3 years ago
If I can join this discussion, I agree with frog for dramamine and a majority of their old stuff, since they really have great instrumentals and I don't think it features the melody in the vocal part like some of their new stuff does.. I see what your saying though since Isaac does write great lyrics
zano0was0his0namo 2 years ago
You can't seriously tell me that stuff on the Lonesome Crowded west album doesn't have a great melody of lyrics..
ModestMouse1207 2 years ago
i dont think the lyrics matter at all lol, like maybe 10% at most. i think they just write music to write music, jsut make cool sounding shit, not super meaningful stuff
SeanSeanSeanCanada 2 years ago
Lol.. Isaac writes the songs pretty well, much better than the music. I mean seriously, look at Doin' The Cockroach, he isn't actually talking about Doing a Cockroach! Haha.
ModestMouse1207 2 years ago 3
haha, in my opinion, vocals are jsut anotehr instrument, so if the lyrics sound good with the music, its more important then actual meaning, imo...
SeanSeanSeanCanada 2 years ago
Eh, I think meaning > lyrics lol.
ModestMouse1207 2 years ago 4
Lyrics are meaning if you think about it... I mean it gives the song the elements for it to have meaning (singing wise)
froggut198 2 years ago 4
Yeah, that's true. But I mean that the meaning behind the lyrics are better than the lyrics alone.
ModestMouse1207 2 years ago 4
there needs to be a balance of both...
NathanPathan 2 years ago
dude a song isnt the same without vocals if it has vocals mostly instrumental but isaac places the vocals so perfectly that it just adds to the harmony
zachy3621 2 years ago
I like how it goes sad to happy.
BaconBeast11 3 years ago 5
kinda like 'trailer trash'. two of my favorite songs, actually, from them and from anyone.
milkmit 3 years ago
it actually says welcome to meadowbrook that is a housing development outside of there home town
samdewfoo 3 years ago
I live in Northern New England.....these lyrics are on the money......"more housing developments go up named after the things they replace". and I don't like the change of pace either!
BrothersCup313 3 years ago
same thing is happening near my hometown. There's just too many people...fucking. and having kids.
I don't like this change of pace.
lameuser1 3 years ago 3
At least you don't live in an overcrowded 3rd world country..... yet.
ItallstartswithH 3 years ago
still one of my fave modest mouse tracks
cocho75 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
it's remember FIRST. sounds.