Added: 3 years ago
From: zcatz
Views: 31,441
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (162)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • how did you make this?

  • River Flows in You, I thought I was the only one who loved that song!

    It's a beautiful song to hear and play, excellent choice.

  • If they hadnt died for him a lot more people wouldve died. And the Doctor does even the scale with helping poeple and saving them. ( But I admit, he couldve gone with out saving Hitler, even if it was an accident)

  • If they hadnt died for him a lot more people wouldve died. And the Doctor does even the scale with helping poeple and saving them. ( But I admit, he couldve gone with out saving Hitler,

  • Very beautiful and everytime I see the Doctor cry I want to wipe the tears away and take him in my arms.The music is so appropriate.Very well done!

  • I think the thing about the Doctor is this: he's always in the middle of everything, and he brings our the very best or the very worst in people. Rory says it in series 5 and so did Martha in series 4; he makes people want to be brave, to do something good, they don't want to let him down, but as he is that powerful light, if you get too close, you might just be burned, especially after he lost Rose, when I think he started to grow reckless sometimes.

  • I think I have something in my eye...... oh it's an eyelash

  • :'''''''''''''''''''( Omg so sad

  • Very well done indeed. The Doctor is brilliant as a star, in both good and bad ways. As Martha Jones warned Donna Noble, get too close and you'll get burned

  • this is from either the stolen earth or journey end

  • Wow. This is absolutely gorgeous. I have tears in my eyes right now.

  • 0:30 Which episode is that scene from?

  • @TheStoryHome New Earth.

  • 1:16 - he didnt die. the doctor finds him afterwards.

  • 4/5 you lost 1 point because 2 of the people showed didnt die, one of which was the bad guy anyway

  • I hope his daughter returns, but aslong as matt smith isnt the doctor at the time.

    Cant wait for Torchwood Series 4 :)

  • @hessian1235 Why as long as it isn't matt smith? beacuse of the pairing, or do you just not like him?

  • @GirlVash Well, its not that Matt Smith isnt a great actor. I just think the new DW era is too.. Childish. so Really, it isnt just Matt. its moffat aswell. Moffat did great episodes in the RTD era. but now? a floating spiky eye? That is childish. And daleks like Teletubbies? i prefered the old.. 'dirty' looking ones. and in the series finals, there was always a an evil and well known enemy (Daleks, Master etc) and in Series 5. it was all of them. which made it boring, and a magical box lol :P

  • @hessian1235 Also the new series is too sci fi. #9 and 10 had a more 'old' kind of feel, history seen (The Unquiet Dead, Empty Child, Tooth and Claw, Daleks in Manhattan...). The new version has magical boxes, fezzes, childish stuff, rainbow daleks, the big eye, all those spaceships flying around, too sci fi and too childish. 9 and 10 are the mature ones.

  • gr8 video but at 1:30 she didnt die the doctor was punishing her for trying to kill him, in the episode The Family of Blood.

  • There are still some people missing like Mrs Moore from Rise of the Cybermen and he didn't lose Frank from Daleks in Manhatten but lost Soloman

  • 2:20 was so sad O_O

  • !Im old enough to know a longer life isnt always a better one, in the end you just get tired, tired of the struggle" - So very true :) :(

  • i kept watching this 2 yrs ago and last yr because it was brilliant and the music and the people that died and the person in the shadow 1 she is on the time of the angels and flesh and stone.

  • they didn't die cuz of the doctor! he either tried to save them or they wanted to die!

    But good video though!

  • wasn't this song one of the possibilities for bella's lullaby in twilight?

  • I love this song! Beautiful =))

  • i love the way he says eh......so caring and sweet

  • Would've been nice if you had included those who died for the Doctor from the classic series aswell.

    But otherwise, very good.

  • this was really beautiful, so sad

  • I didn't quite cry, but my eyes went all prickly...good work.

  • Amazing :D i loved it :) <3

  • ok so i see comments about this song being on twilight i just want to say that it wasn't.

    zcatz GREAT VIDEO!!!!

  • Excellent Video. Tears :)

    But why has no one made a video about who The Doctor has saved... Far more people then have died for him.

  • @ItCameFromTheSkyBeLo Exactly because of that. It's much easier to show the ones he's 'killed', because the ones he's saved, even personally and discounting the times it's the entire universe, possibly even discounting entire worlds, are just SO MANY it can't be reasonably done, even if limited to New Who.

  • this is so sad I love it....yes my brain works that way.

    The girl who plays his daughter is the fifth doctors actual daughter and now tennants girlfriend....odd little family, what would they call eachother if they got married

  • Your Dr Who videos are possibly the best on youtube. Many thanks from a Dr Fan that has lived through it all.

  • truly the most beautiful video on youtube

  • i love this. well done. you are amazing.

  • Thie is the best video on youtube i have ever seen, doctor who and torchwood is the best tv show ever and this music goes perfectly with this wonderfull production it is so sad this music and how many people die in doctor who

  • Twilight AND Doctor Who? Gosh, am i the only one who feels spoilt right now?

  • Yep, probably.

  • nope, not at all. i'm right there with you :)

  • Comment removed

  • I love this i'm so glad it works again

  • pause at 0:59 for lulz

  • it works... i laughed

  • david tennant is fab u ever see the epsiode family of blood.when he wasnt the doctor he was john smith.u really believed it

  • I love this song

    I love Doctor who

    this was amazing

    (I don't want David to leave)

  • wow amazing!!

    soo sad :-( x

  • Did nobody see Turn Left?  The disaster and loss of life there would have been if the Doctor had drowned in the Thames that Christmas? There are times, believe it or not, in the series where everybody lives.

  • Well said!

  • I Know the empty child

  • @LoriCiani I wish the Doctor could have understood that...

  • @LoriCiani Ecspecially in the one with that boy (i forget the episode) when christopher eccleston was the doctor in ww2 where he says just this time rose this time EVERBODY LIVES! and the nanobot things heal everyone.

  • @beevers93 That was a great episode, The Empty Child.

    And Moffet did some great episodes, but Series 5 was a bit too innocent. There never seemed to be a real sense of danger on the line, like it was with the RTD days. You felt the tension and knew the universe would end if The Doctor didn't help. Might also have to do with Euros Lyn's directing as well, who is gone now. And I would prefer if River Song turned out to be The Doctor's daughter and not his wife. Nice change for once.

  • @TheGreatMerman i 100% agree

  • @TheGreatMerman i 100% agree oh and your right yeah the empty child

  • I am such a geek.....because I love these..

  • No matter how he tries to fix it, someone always has to die... it is so sad, he can never save everyone.

  • I'm not sure it is fair to say that the Dr. leaves a wake of destruction and death. Rather, he arrives just before that. The doctor arrives at a time to try to heal.

  • Well the doctor does what he does for the greater good essentialy most of the people died in his name to save a thousand other people or even to save just a couple more lives so it is worth it for them.

  • that was soooooooooooooooo sad :(

    but sooooooooooo beautiful

    you did (as the doctor would say) a brilliant job!!!

  • kinda doesmore than just show wat the doctor did...it shows why the timelords never interefered in the first place...anything they did would always have consequences and funnily enough why the doctor was a renegade to begin with

  • All the script writers and David do such a good job with every episode that they make you forget about the death and destruction the Doctor always leaves behind... this was really well done!!

    It's really made me rethink my opinion of the Doctor himself... not that he WANTS to leave all this in his path but... =/

    He really IS everything Tim described to John Smith.

    Thanks for such a wonderful vid!

  • im sad but not everybody because of him but this is a good vid 999999999999999999999999999999­9999999/5.

  • What is this song it is so beautiful?

  • Nvm i looked in the Description

  • its the "River flows in you" by Yiruma. I love it too!

  • I love the memories going from colour to black in white. It made it that more touching.

  • This is perfect, the way it rips into your chest pulls out your heart while causing your tear ducts to flood ... it captures all the pain and suffering of journeys end in one magnificently depressing moment. I give it 6 stars (because 5 stars aren't good enough for this video).

  • Very beautiful. Nice song, depressing, great effects! A+ and 5 stars to you!

  • This is amazing! You have done such a great vid here, the song matches it perfectly. 5 stars :D

  • Sorry, i've already commented before but wow! This video is one of my favorites on youtube, the beginning is really really good with Davros...can't congratulate you enough for this.

  • wow, thats amazing. its so sad, the poor doctor. great use of a beautiful song too

  • Fantastic. I feel so sorry for The Doctor, imagine having that much death on your conscience for so many centuries.

    The music is beautiful too.

  • i have to say

    this was better than the original!

    lol well done!

  • i agree 95% of the way with you.

    the only thing is, and i know zcats couldn't help this, but the audio isn't perfect, its just a bit dicey in m opinion. don't get mad at me, im just giving my opinion.

  • but i 100% agree! it was amazing!!

    and the audio sounded ok to me! but its probably b/c i just watched a video with the crappiest audio ever!!

  • lol. ^_^

  • Beautifully done, but terribly sad.

  • He is the Oncoming Storm. The Death God. In his wake is nothing but sadness. In his wake there is nothing but death. This is his penance, his curse. Forever to walk time and space alone. To never know more then a fleeting happiness. He is the Lonely God. Last son of Gallifrey.

  • OMG! I luv this vid, i just want to give him a big hug!! murtagh29 is right i'm surprised he hasn't had to have councelin!!LOL

  • u no wot? i'm suprised the doctor hasnt had counceling! i think they shd du a special with that! lol-intergalactic counceling! funny as! love da vid bi da way!

  • I'm surprised you didn't include Jack cause he pretty much got his life ruined when Rose made him immortal (though I guess including the Face of Boe includes Jack)

  • Very good video and a very good idea basing on him leaving destruction behind him. 5/5!

  • The Doctor is a great man. But sometimes I think that living like that would make you want to die.

  • I cried at the end of this video! Great job!

    -Leia

  • How the melody name?

  • vey good....

    poor doctor... no wonder he's a pacifist

  • That was really good, ,honestly, i would be proud!

  • Briliant Job! :D

  • Very moving, the slow motion of what's-his-name at torchwood against the werewolf was powerful.

    It felt incredible unresolved, which probably was your intention, I feel left hanging!!! What happens next!? Sequel please!?!

  • wow. great video!

  • perfection. I'm speechless...the song was just beautiful as well. thank you

  • fantastic

  • Beautiful but hardly his fault.

  • I know it is not his fault and that was never my intention but as the lovely Matron said in "The Family of Blood" if the Doctor had not randomly chosen here would people have died? No, it is not his fault directly it is a result of his being the last of the time lords.

  • Just amazing. You caught so many of the sorrows of the new series and there are so many more from the old. Vicki and Adric to name just a few. The Doctor really is best described as "The Oncoming Storm" as so much destruction is left in his wake like earth after "The Parting of Ways".

    Amazing Job

  • :o the 9the doctor would say it's FANTASTIC

  • I know I commented on this a while ago - I just want to say it was so good I was inspired to learn how to play the song,and as I don't take piano lessons it shows just how amazing this video is :)

  • Briliant video! great job

  • That was so poignant, and so beautiful! Well done and thank you. :)

  • I wish someone would tell him that so many more would have died without him.

  • Beautiful, so beautiful and emotionnal and sad.

    I'll not cry...no, I'll not cry *sob* Oh well. Magnifique.

  • So amazing... brilliant vid... (: best vid ever.. nd soo emotional x great job darlin x

  • OMG this song along with the film made me nearly cry

  • this has to be one of my top favorite MVs to watch this year

  • I agree with powergoods. this is great

  • Beautiful!

  • the man who never looks back for the pain that comes with the memories

  • i was crying and i NEVER do that. :(

  • fantastic video! i was crying :(

    wel done tho :) x

  • Sooooo sad! Nice choice of music in the background. It made the scenes even more sad! Well done!

  • Why do you enjoy making me cry????:(  :)

  • Talk about depressing...... and absolutely brilliant!  This was loads better than the quickie flashbacks from BBC. Can't wait to see more of your stuff.

  • WOW!

    I want Sony Vegas Now

    Your AMAZING

    Best Vid Ever

    Im Crying :(

  • omg that vid was just... just brilliant im adding it to my favorites my bebo and im subscribing :D:D:D

  • Aw! That was really good! But it made me sad!

    I loved that last face, it was full of emotion!

    The evil dude is right though. He never carries a gun, hates killing people, but people have to sacrifice themselves for him. Every episode. :(

    But he's Still awesome.

    A really good vid =]

  • Lovely Vid, That was sooo Good. =) ♥

    Nearly bawled my eyes out. =)

  • Which episode is :45 from?

  • 'The Idiot's Lantern' :)

  • Aww that was soooooooooo good!!!

  • Wow, very, very good. It reminds of what seduff would make. Well done, very skillful video, I love it!

  • what the name of the muisc

  • River Flows in You - Yiruma

    =]

  • i all most cried the best video i have ever seen

  • oh that's so sad :/

    but it's wounderful.

    really great!

    (:

    x

  • perfect

  • Brilliant!!! Perfect video:D

  • wow - great video

  • Aww this was really sad but good! Love the editing and fading you did with the black and white. Fived and faved! :)

  • WOW! great job, Catherine!! beautiful video, amazing really!! Another fav and im putting this one in my blog <3 loove it!!

  • that was so sad i could have cried. but it was also brilliant :) great job!

  • You probably won't believe this, but that was honestly the best video I have seen on YouTube ever. Better than some of seduff's videos (She's great though aint she :D), all of BabelColour's, this is just so amazing. At least 20 of the views you have on this are from me. You have already got my subscription, but in my eyes, you are the new seduff! Well done, 5 stars, already faved, wish I could give you more!

  • Wow! Tahnks sefulan! That's the nicest comment I've had in ages. That really brought my spirits up. They were low because my computer has broken and I need to use my mums machine for ages... but that comment is so lovely xxx Thanks xx

  • WOW!!!5 stars and favourited)

  • oh i love this! oh so sad... and so amazing at the same time! poor doctor!!

  • oh sorry, just read your description lol :P

  • this is stunning. :O i nearly cried, lol. what's the piano piece called?

  • OMG.. This video is really ace. It's so true and sad and you've matched the scenes together perfectly. I've almost forgot about some of the earlier ones (so to speak) and you've just reminded me about them. Thanks so much for making such a touching video.

  • WOW! That was MARVELOUS! I love the instrumental music, it fits quite perfectly with the voices, all echoing through his memories - all of which he feels guilty of. And I think you did a wonderful job of depicting that! So congrats! :D :D 5/5 stars! ^^

  • OMG :D

    That was brilliant and so beautiful.

    I really really really liked that!

    5 stars and favourited (:

  • waouh that was amazing really I love it you put the right clips at the right moment this was amazing !!!

    5* faved and suscribed don't want to miss your next vid ^^

  • Absolutely AMAZING video! You made me cry :'(

    So sad :'(

  • That is one of the curse's of the time lords he only way they can help is also cause destruction, and he knows it, but you forgot to put galifrey burning cus even though its said the doctor also destroyed his people to destroy the daleks

  • OMG you made me cry!

    That was so sad but so beautiful...

    well Done!

    You did an amazing work!

  • Wow! Well done!

  • beautiful

  • i watched most of these eppies tihis mornin

  • So beautiful, so sad ... loved it!

  • Nicley done....

  • wow, great new vid, Catherine, really great job!! Loved it!

  • Absolutely amazingly beautiful <3

    100/100 :P

    favs x

  • Gorgeous video and amazing music.

    Seriously wicked, wish I was this talented :)

  • What a beautifully sad video. Lovely editing!

  • wow that was beautiful

  • Sooo Amazing

    Rose Tyler + 10th Doctor will always be something special

    I cant say anything about this its so beautiful

  • Oh, wow. I wish I could say more, but I am utterly speechless. The whole video has such a beautiful aura. 5/5 and faved.

  • Lovely video!! :D really brings a tear to your eye. you have a natural talent for instrumental videos. 5* and faved <3 x

  • Oh I'm so glad you all liked it :D

    Thanks everyone :D

  • OMG, How utterly depressing! Yet Beautiful! Zcatz your talent is fantastic! ... :) 5 Stars and Faves.. :D *claps* molto Bene

  • that was beautiful

  • Tis Is Amazing

    I love it nd im favouriting it

    =] XoXo

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more