Corporations exploit cheap labor, so why would average citizens support such a thing? Corporations lobby to destroy unions for better wages, and hire indentured employees. Voters are responding to getting RIPPED OFF by a labor scam, a common scheme or plan to lower everyone's living standard, except corporate profiteers.
Defending a liberal immigration policy that amounts to minting second class of citizens is profoundly wrong and immoral. Equal rights or none!
You clearly completely misunderstand the argument. She made two points regarding corporations. The first is that most corporations benefit from a larger population in general (she makes the point that there are more workers, and of course there are also more consumers). The second is that for a few companies, the opposite is true (prices would go up), because they currently exploit ILLEGAL labor to pay far under minimum wage and entrap employees through blackmail.
If a child is brought to the USA by his/her parents who are in the USA seeking asylum but are denied asylum after a decade of residing in the USA as lawful temporary residents, does the government have the right to deport them even though the child's future and livelihood is at stake since he/she is "Americanised" and doesn't speak the language of the parent's homeland. The child's life would be ruined. So can the government do this? It sounds very inhumane...
So, use your knowledge to fix immigration laws to welcome serious, useful immigrants to join our society. Illegal is illegal, the scum sneak in along with the "persecuted immigrants". We need the good folk immigrating, not the scum and criminals.
gilman claims immigration to the US is very hard, but all other counties are harder. So what is it? Seems like the US is the most tolerant nation of immigrants.
My dad's parents were working the Texas ag field due to the international 'Great depression', when my dad was born. Not buy design, but the sponsoring of family was taken advatage of. The 'anchor baby' myth is semi-true. Legal by the law!
Yeah all those hundreds of thousands of American workers who see their jobs first hand lost to illegals must all be lying and this fine upstanding liberal telling the truth.
@kmg501 Well said. As one of the hundreds of thousands without a job, I do see firsthand the effect of Mexicans migrating to the US, both legal and illegal. I start school next month and will be going for my 3rd career change in my life of 40 years. What I'm sick of hearing if people saying, "Just go get an education and move up." So help me, I wonder how they can live with their heads so far up their own ass! This is my 3rd round people! I'm not some dropout either. more coming....
Gilman ,makes her fame and fortune helping others get around the law. It took me 7 years to get my lawful wife, mother of our 3 American born children her green card. While waiting, she did not work, drive, collect benefits in accordance with US Law. So why couldn't we just cheat? No liberal treasonous groups to lobby for us.
@goru426 ...and don't you believe, this is where Mrs. Denise Gilman come into play. Perhaps not stating the obvious or sounding rhetorical, would make you seem less incompetent and or incoherent.
thats true, most people get caught up in the fear that they will loose their jobs. But illegals arent taking jobs from doctors and lawyers and such. They are taking the dirty jobs that most people didnt want to do. A reform would be the best thing because you get more people paying taxes and simply more revenue.
@Strider395 - Yes I think that whatever profession that YOU are in is the only profession that any ILLEGAL ALIEN should be allowed to take and only until YOU are dead from starvation , your family seperated form lack of finances due to unemployment and have watched as your house and belongings are foreclosed upon and sold off and until you are imprisoned from being a vagrant. That should do it for me .
Corporations exploit cheap labor, so why would average citizens support such a thing? Corporations lobby to destroy unions for better wages, and hire indentured employees. Voters are responding to getting RIPPED OFF by a labor scam, a common scheme or plan to lower everyone's living standard, except corporate profiteers.
Defending a liberal immigration policy that amounts to minting second class of citizens is profoundly wrong and immoral. Equal rights or none!
ibringthereals 1 month ago
@ibringthereals
You clearly completely misunderstand the argument. She made two points regarding corporations. The first is that most corporations benefit from a larger population in general (she makes the point that there are more workers, and of course there are also more consumers). The second is that for a few companies, the opposite is true (prices would go up), because they currently exploit ILLEGAL labor to pay far under minimum wage and entrap employees through blackmail.
EebstertheGreat 1 month ago
"Comments may be held for uploader approval."
It's rather un-american to censor responses on a public posting...don't you think?
Very well, since critical thinking skills aren't allowed...Have a Nice Day!
MikieDaC 2 months ago
You could build a wall on the bias she has about this subject
cosa65 2 months ago
Well time for electric fences.
dhamm55 3 months ago
If a child is brought to the USA by his/her parents who are in the USA seeking asylum but are denied asylum after a decade of residing in the USA as lawful temporary residents, does the government have the right to deport them even though the child's future and livelihood is at stake since he/she is "Americanised" and doesn't speak the language of the parent's homeland. The child's life would be ruined. So can the government do this? It sounds very inhumane...
SamuelJoaodaSuica 4 months ago
Excellent video! Thanks.
samdessordi 5 months ago
So, use your knowledge to fix immigration laws to welcome serious, useful immigrants to join our society. Illegal is illegal, the scum sneak in along with the "persecuted immigrants". We need the good folk immigrating, not the scum and criminals.
rjc1945 7 months ago
@rjc1945 can we deport useless americans? i dont want to pay for them either
jtg997 3 months ago 9
7:55,, Find me ONE LEGAL landowner near the mexican border that is mad about the "walls" being built!! What planet is this woman from????
tconst17 7 months ago
Go to notexasborderwall for a few.
Harrymfink 7 months ago
She talks funny O.o
cr4yv3n 8 months ago
gilman claims immigration to the US is very hard, but all other counties are harder. So what is it? Seems like the US is the most tolerant nation of immigrants.
kerthialfad 9 months ago
More grave demenor will carry more weight - got's to reach those uninformed on the 'fence' - I know how the Right thinks - used to be one.
PacificCircle1 9 months ago
My dad's parents were working the Texas ag field due to the international 'Great depression', when my dad was born. Not buy design, but the sponsoring of family was taken advatage of. The 'anchor baby' myth is semi-true. Legal by the law!
PacificCircle1 9 months ago
Ever noticel how the Right goes ballistic when their claims are dis-poven.
PacificCircle1 9 months ago
Ms Gilman,
Please contact me at j_m_randolph@hotmail.com.
I have some asylum questions to ask.
Thank you,
JRandolph
randee51 1 year ago
Liar.
ruthc48 1 year ago
Yeah all those hundreds of thousands of American workers who see their jobs first hand lost to illegals must all be lying and this fine upstanding liberal telling the truth.
/sarcasm
kmg501 1 year ago
@kmg501 Well said. As one of the hundreds of thousands without a job, I do see firsthand the effect of Mexicans migrating to the US, both legal and illegal. I start school next month and will be going for my 3rd career change in my life of 40 years. What I'm sick of hearing if people saying, "Just go get an education and move up." So help me, I wonder how they can live with their heads so far up their own ass! This is my 3rd round people! I'm not some dropout either. more coming....
SpeedOfDark186Kmps 1 year ago
@SpeedOfDark186Kmps Ever here of the 'Great recession'? How about job exported to China?
My situation is from bad weather for crops, and a popped housing bubble!
PacificCircle1 9 months ago
@kmg501 Look up lump of labour fallacy.
We aren't liberals. Far from it. We are economically literate (which is why we aren't liberals) people who are familiar with immigration laws.
Antitheist98 1 year ago
Gilman ,makes her fame and fortune helping others get around the law. It took me 7 years to get my lawful wife, mother of our 3 American born children her green card. While waiting, she did not work, drive, collect benefits in accordance with US Law. So why couldn't we just cheat? No liberal treasonous groups to lobby for us.
haitipi 1 year ago
Professor Denise is a really involved and commited professor, professional and citizen.
Her contribution is invaluable as a law teacher.
Many thanks.
Mathieu Corrêa de Sa
Professor Law School Orléans University France
mathieucorreadesa 1 year ago
The AZ law is just another ineffective way of dealing with our broken immigration system!
The only way we can fix out immigration System is through Comprehensive Immigration Reform!
goru426 1 year ago
@goru426 ...and don't you believe, this is where Mrs. Denise Gilman come into play. Perhaps not stating the obvious or sounding rhetorical, would make you seem less incompetent and or incoherent.
Alexe84 1 year ago
@goru426
thats true, most people get caught up in the fear that they will loose their jobs. But illegals arent taking jobs from doctors and lawyers and such. They are taking the dirty jobs that most people didnt want to do. A reform would be the best thing because you get more people paying taxes and simply more revenue.
Strider395 1 year ago
@Strider395 - Yes I think that whatever profession that YOU are in is the only profession that any ILLEGAL ALIEN should be allowed to take and only until YOU are dead from starvation , your family seperated form lack of finances due to unemployment and have watched as your house and belongings are foreclosed upon and sold off and until you are imprisoned from being a vagrant. That should do it for me .
BoxGuy1951 1 year ago