Added: 4 years ago
From: CelestrialVision
Views: 66,636
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (167)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Bored

  • You call this a "solo"? It's just random sporadic wanking over something you apparently mistook as a backing track.

  • A: Make your picking and fretting hand more cohesive, and

    B: You're playing it in D Minor, not E.

  • i really don't like the part starting from 0:51,sounds like there are some notes missing...

  • man that solo is fantastic now thats what is needed for a guirtarist to educate the mindless idiots out their,what music is all about nice!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!! keep up the good work

  • just bad

  • Some people like speed, some others like quality. I'm on the quality side. You play better than a lot of people (me included), but honestly I don't like your solo. Peace. ;-)

  • I dont care about non of what u non-metalhead bastards say....this is the art.......of shredding!!! keep it up bro!!!

  • You play the guitar extremely well, but I don't feel you are complimenting this beautiful piece of music. I also feel your self-promoting comment to be somewhat misplaced.

  • you suck. REALLY BAD INTERPRETATION!

  • Damn, it's like no one understand youtube or metal anymore, good job though

  • You learned how to play fast! Great job! Too bad there's no taste in your playing

  • Fun to watch, why the bad ratings? Dont get it. Ive been playing for 20 years and found intrigue with his playing. Nice job.

  • Congratulations, you just fucked up one of my favourite guitars with an epically gay Avenged Sevenfold sticker. But, on the plus side, I love your Star Wars videos.

  • all I gots to say is this....THOSE FINGERS ARE FLYING!!!

  • The fuck is up with this tight asses... yeah he is shredding, yeah it does not resemble the original, yeah you cant porbably play it, yeah fucking swallow the cum because it is already in your mouth.. he did well.

  • So you have fast fingers? In the words of James Hetfield, "SO FUCKING WHAT!?!" If the even greater Randy Rhoads were still around, he would kick your ass for the disgrace you have made of yourself. Right now he's probably turning in his grave because of this atrocity and blasphemy of the guitar that you have created. It should have died in '89 dude....

  • I'd hate to break it to you man, but there was nothing original about this. Much less anything cohesive and relative to the original piece. Get off of your pretentious guitar laden high horse and actually play something worth listening to. I really don't mean to be an ass hole, but it is self aggrandizing people like you that make guitarists look like a bunch of self centered idiots.

  • @ChromaticSam

    You are so kind, and I thank you for displaying your inner trollness. I can completely undertsnad your narrow minded intellect, but of course it's merely just a thing that was recorded on the fly, and no other human were harmed in the production. I hope that you can see the beauty in being flattered by such posts as yours.

  • @CelestrialVision You keep telling yourself that the world is inferior. When you finally realize that you are wrong in defending this act of an abhorrent nature, and realize that you are the one being narrow minded, THEN music will make that proposed "step forward". This will be my last rebuttal to this, because I am well aware that you are trolling for views, but I will leave with the satisfaction of knowing that I have implanted a seed of self doubt deep within your brain.

  • @ChromaticSam Thank Zues! I do not need viewers like you to add to my selective golden empire...I posted this years ago and have made significant advances in the music industry, let alone other productions - needless to say without your infidelic mentality. I can appreciate that you kind, wonderful generousity has finally worn out, and will desease just as your mother should of you when she birthed you. Farewell my unforgiving viewer! Sizzle, losser...BYE!

  • @CelestrialVision its just youtube sheesh.... lol

  • @CelestrialVision wow. i love how you think you're so badass. i'm not trolling, this is really just complete crap. you just mindlessly shredded over a masterful piece of music. if you had actual played the correct scales and stayed in key, and actually played some of the real song it would been MUCH better. btw. a troll is someone who deliberately tries to piss people off on the internet. someone who expresses their opinion in a clear and civil manner is what you would call HUMAN.

  • @ChromaticSam

    yeah hes scaling the shit out of the guitar, but hes doing it in the right key, hitting the right notes, nothing to bash really.. of course it is not the original piece, but it is his now.. we can just go an watch another video.

  • this is absolutly incredible!

  • u need to learn harmony, yes i know metal is fucking wild solos, but this is another level, read hindemith book

  • Bravo.

  • ... I dunno, I liked it... I just think that it shouldn't be listed as 'solo', that's all.

  • i love shredding as much as the next metalhead, but come on man. when we see tocatta and fugue, and see guitar we expect a guitarist to play the actual song. i love some of you improvisation, but at least play a few parts of the actual song instead of just shredding the entire time. but like i said good job, just make it a little more musical.

  • Awesome solo you said... Not for me. You play only fast. You must get more emotion to your playing. Anyhow you are skilled player. Cheers

  • Great guitar player, but the video is useless. The organ does the music and he was shredding some stuff in ..... well ......

  • Just sounds like noise to me. 

  • i know it defeats the purpose of a cover, but a suggestion is to remove the organ and put a different back round if your going to over ride the melody with your own. no sense in keeping something yer not gonna even hear that instead clash with your playing... catch the drift?

  • absolutely awesome ... just what a metal head like me wants... you really rocked out and did it your way.... loved the machine heads in the camera at the start.... you shredded the hell out of the track but that is the point.... for some one like me who loves this track so much I am glad that someone had the balls to rawk out ....

    Do get me wrong I love JS so much but it is good to hear someone who can shredd and make a lot of noise... dude you are a king thanks for sharing....

  • amazing playing, but it sounds like u snorted a bunch of speed before you recorded this. bring it down a notch bro.

  • Comment removed

  • sounds terrible

  • thanks for ruining a great peice of music

  • i mean totally!!!! this guy is a freakin genius!! major props to u man!!!! :)))

  • dude how can u guys say that!!!! this is sooooo gnarly!!! this guy is off the hook, amazing shredding!!!! excellent job man, don't let these fools tell bring u down, that was amazing :))))) keep shredding!! \m/^.^\m/

  • nice death bat on the ibanez man. a7x foREVer \m/

  • should've made the guitar louder

  • that was awsome!!!! thanks for putting that up!, marshall mode four even :)

  • your a good player, but you remind me too much of yngwie malmsteem...there is such a thing as too many notes when thier not needed.

  • My original comment on this video was 'This is a self-indulgent piece of shit. I have an appreciation for masturbation and music, but never the two combined. You might as well jizz onto the Mona Lisa.'

    Then @CelestrialVision blocked my channel, deleted the comment (because he's a pussy) and then left a reply to the comment which is no longer on the video... idiot.

    If you can't take criticism, get the fuck off YouTube. If you play this shit, stick up for it! Convince me its an art form!

  • @thebigbadjohnsmith2 Where is the criticism? I just see a piece of shit writing more shit...JO

  • @CelestrialVision I'll keep all this right here so everyone can see what you think about it...yeah..so everyone can see what a piece of shit you really are...prove me wrong some more...get another channel :D or better yet...drop dead on youtube...so at least there will be real art!

  • @thebigbadjohnsmith2

    Hahahaha... I'm sooo stoned...

    A piece of shit writing more shit.. lol

  • @thebigbadjohnsmith2

    Go away, jackass

  • @Methos200686

    really? Is this the way you present yourself? It's a matter of conjectur who the true Jackass is...the fool playing or the fool responding. It is all about drama for you trolls out there. Find the exit,

  • @thebigbadjohnsmith2

    Of course, your idiotic attempt to be recognized has been rcieved and appreciated. It's just too bad trolls like you have gained access to technology and have promoted my video by viewing it several times for inaccuracies. It's a pleasure to have this forum and to hear how much you are upset about not having any originality in your unfortunate, uncaring soul...THX!

  • @CelestrialVision the point being that bigjohn lost this duel xD

  • funny.... I never heard jews were stupid before... you take the cake. A poor representation of a beautiful, enduring people.

  • @BethHain Thanks...is this for me or the last idiot?

  • the last idiot.

  • It's toccata in d minor, not e. well played though. Im an organist, but I play the guitar as well, so I found particular enjoyment from this rendition.

  • Why don't you use your great technique to actually play the original?

  • Oh and be just another copy of a copy who want to be a copy...

  • @CelestrialVision

    Hi, my comments were not meant as 'backhanded compliments' - it was a genuine question. Improvisation is my primary musical medium and some of the most brilliant composers work in this way. Within the 'classical' domain, 'interpretations' of the repertory are often far more connservative than your own: this is not necesssarily a good thing. I abhor the stagnation of music that you describe due to religious replication of music to the exclusion of all else as much as you.

  • Nah - I can appreciate good skill and inspiration when someone can do something a little more creative with a piece.

  • I usually do not do covers or revamps, but I was so enthusiastic about this piece I thought someone would be inspired. Nevertheless, with subjects who yet have learned the craft of skillful techniques and intuitive responses with improvisation like yourself...it becomes clear to me that music may never make a leap forward when you have unbridled ignorance and subsequent lack of vision when hearing or seeing something unique or different. Yeah...that it! LOL

  • Did u have to sell your soul to play like this?very very nice

  • Its in d minor x.x

  • tocas muy bien ;D pero aniquilas el clasico de bach D=

  • GREAT!

    Still pumping out metal...U should check one out!

  • Ibanez Universe 7

  • whats the axe?

  • Oh Marshall Mode 4? How are they like???

  • Very Nice! =D

  • Good version, vieew my version. Byebye

  • yeah d minor

  • D minor...

  • Why does this badboy have only 3.5 stars?

  • because people have gotten bored of shredding coz they all got pussy and now think doing a breakdown is way cooler

  • what is more boring is screaming metal.

  • @Ruskiedann Cos there is no feeling, its noise in key, I can make noise in key, he should have two stars.

  • just noise, turn of the organ lol

  • i like ur crome finish on the guitar

  • Wait, so was this video itself recorded in 1989, or did you just write this rendition in 1989 and recorded this now?

  • @ThatGuyCalledPhillip well, do you really think that cameras that recorded with this quality existed in 1989? that should answer the question for you lol

  • @muslithefish How do you know he didn't have a high quality camera?

  • @ThatGuyCalledPhillip i would be VERY surprised if someone had a home camera in 1989 that recorded with this quality

  • w dupe se wsadź hight camere

  • dude this music was like metal these days hahahah ur just giving a new badass work up on a new instrument... great great great

  • jajajajja

  • i think your an awesome shredder :D

  • Yeah...thanks. It was just something I thought was cool at the time. One shot! ya know...the best I could.

  • tha real song is way better and so is the composer

  • is it weird to have came my pants during this video...? probably not...

  • the art of shredding shines

  • ovaj si nema pojma!haha

    Nije stvar da imas dobru gitaru,nego da znas da je sviras precizno!haha

    Awsome!!!

  • what kkind of guitar are u using? WOW

  • Ibanez 7 Universe. The best 7 string you can play...it was the best I ever played!

  • that guitar sustains like like, IDK WHAT but damn DAMN u hear me? DAAAAAMN

  • Dude i fucking love your guitar ibanez for life baby!!!

  • Sick ass playing but it sounds a lot nicer when you're slow solo'ing with the song and not just shreding and drowning out each other but, none the less you are a very skilled player

  • ????????

  • heyy dude just a random question. what scale/mode are you using?

    your awsome btw

  • I utilized E minor, phrygian and mixolydian. I had to swing a couple of notes to combine...it is quite unusual but I like the way it glides.

  • Its talented yes, but too poly tonal for classical arpeggios. But good work none the less.

  • @Bane2100

    you are a cocky asshole

  • Thank you!! :) I work hard for it!

  • u play good, but all I hear is noise...its not that much relevant to the tocata...

  • The appreciation is not the tonal theory behind it, it is merely the freddom of expression. Can't we just appreciate someone else's point of view. I f I did it technically, it would be no better or more interesting than it already is. Now wouldn't it?

  • well for an improvisation it's good..I thought you came up with it after a few days of hard work :s

    I believe if u used your skills to do it technically it would kick more asses...as long as you stay away from malmsteen...that guy is both kickass and lame at the same time....he can reaaaaaaaaally stretch a solo or get lost in licks...which is not the point

  • I dig...well thanks for the review..I appreciate it man. ~peace

  • u kewl..keep it on rawk rawk rawk :)

  • wat scale is this in???

  • E Minor, Phrygian, Mixolydian

  • That sounds very manowar- ish awesome playing 6 stars you really know the music theory not like me :D

  • amaziing :D

    wat is ur guitar?

  • Ibanez Universe 7.

  • Thanks. Got the idea from....Weird Al. (LMAO)

  • WOW, these comments are being fucking retarded -.-' FANTASTIC PLAYING DUDE!

  • For me better than the original

  • errmm i'm not so sure i like it, especially with the fact that you're playing the song with the original in the background, it's like trying to sing black metal while Luciano Pavarotti is singing a great piece.....it's lacking what the original has IMO.

    Maybe if you would have play it without the original in the background, or just presented the video as jam or great solo, i would have like it.... sorry

  • Ah I dig...just jammin to some good stuff. By the way , its not the original...so thanks alot!

  • well i know it's not the original ^^, i guess i didn't make myself clear or not use the proper words to it hehe. anyways it was a great solo, i gotta give you that :)

  • Dramatic version; I appreciate it. Thank you for sharing!

  • dude ure playeng somethink completly different THATS not bach's toccata!

  • Your parents must be proud of your unique ability to hear...Congrats!

  • Lol

    Owend good fight

  • For me it is just fast...nothing more.

  • Its called artistic nature...and my friend everyone could do it just in different ways. Learn to ecept and appreciate the differences that each and everyone can exhibit.

  • But i don't have to like it...or do i?im just saying that I don't hear any...hmm...feeling in it?the original has that something - it's a masterpiece and ur playing is just fast but without that "something" - that's my opinion and u can ofc disagree.

  • Feeling is what you put in it. If it doesn't move you in some way then I guess it has no feeling. It sure felt good to me!

  • Mhmm tab?

  • No tab...just feeling

  • Improv?

  • YES!

    Thanks...

  • No...feel.

  • but isnt Improv, just going with it?

  • Study the composition and determine the key. Realize the structure and format in which UR playing and by what you knopw or can learn about the material do your best!

  • Hrmmm i see :p

    You should redo it it though, like add have it planned out more, because i like the tone that you threw in with it

  • wow. u knowing what that me means just makes me feel even more inferior. lol

  • I dont like it

  • I don't like Bachs constraints either, thats why I through in my own style. Neat isn't it!

  • what do you mean about constraints, I am not that skilled in technique and Theory. so what do you mean about Bach's Constraints? what your view on constraints?

  • Otganized thought and composition. It is well known that music is a revelation to feeling and theory. correct?

  • No, it sucks.

    Being out of tune is not a "style".

  • Sucking is for people who have no talent. In order for you to determine whether or not this sucks you have to demonstrate some sort of knowledge of your talent...for which you probably do not have...EL SUCKO'!

  • "you probably do not have" :)

    *lol*

  • Probably U do -SUCK!

    LOL

  • you don't have to. It is freedom brotha!

  • eh.... D minor.

  • ajajajaja

    me dan risa los weyes q presumen sus guitarras!! ajja y la marka de sus liras jaja se ven ridikulos jajaj y kreen q su guitarra es la unika q ay jajaajaj no mames rekuerden q el musico hace al instrumento jajaja no mames

  • Eh...thanks - I think!

  • fdslj fdsklv fslfjs njkfls jkvlfn fsjklvl asr4 n;lkvfnjk vjklvf sn nvfjkldswl;n svnjkflsn; vndsvnkfd;s fn;skvnfk;ldsv s;vfnjsvkf; nvfds;va ksvfgsv nsvnsvn vx vnjsnvnv fv. . . . .

    Can we get a translator for this?

  • holy shit this major shredding

  • Right on! I love just throwing it on!

  • Very fast, good sound, but no the same felling of Bach for me...

  • beautiful

  • how did you transpose the orgen track?

  • digitally re sampled and formatted. It's my own track. Did you ever hear drums in the original?

  • Cool thx!

  • Who does fucking care ?

    He did play it like a pro !

    nice playing man ! :D

  • it's toccata d-minor...

  • Very good! young one..shows your age!

  • uhmmm dude, it's D minor not E minor....

  • If you can't trnspose keys then how do you write music? Of course it's in E minor!

  • mmm.....very interesting....well...i mean....

    hey,nice t-shirt!

  • apprend a joué au lieu de caché ta mediocrité derriere une disto-monstre mal dissimulé par la musik de fond...

  • apprend a joué au lieu de caché ta mediocrité derriere une disto-monstre mal dissimulé par la musik de fond

    juste parce que quelqu'un est meilleur que vous, ne vous donne pas le droit à la diss d'autres personnes! vous pénis

  • meilleur?? ahahahahahahahaha!!!!

    AHAHAHAHAHAHAH!

  • That's right!

    You know whatever you said!

  • What? English Bravo...Aquilius Magistra.

  • Isn't tocata originaly in D minor?

  • yes...but can't anyone play it in E minor?

  • Oo holy shit!

  • Spadaj koleś. Really - I mean it.

  • It hardly follows the melody.

    -song plays-

    OMG BIG SHRED BLUR OF NOTES YAH!!!!

    BIG BEEND WWAAAAAAHH.

    -song plays some more-

    ~BIG BEND~

    OMG MORE SHREDZ

    You didn't even make harmony riffs.

    You just did a shred of notes in the same key. Kudos for being able to play fast. -clap-

  • his left hand is a little extrange

  • the guy is good, but the sound used is too metalish.

  • very good dude!

    how did you learn to alternative-pick so fast?

  • watching paul gilbert and Yngwie Malmsteen...who else!

  • hello is a great performance!!!

  • i love you're t-shirt man!.. but not only you're t-shirt... you're song to.. its sound very cool! Nice job !!

  • Ehhh...pretty bad...

  • --0 0

    -\____/

    --YA

  • I transposed it by recording the track in E minor. By doing so the key shift enables the juxtapositioning of a familiar key.

  • That's pretty sick. I liked it.