Added: 1 year ago
From: VideogamerPS3
Views: 859,067
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (5,649)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • COD has a better soundtrack

  • :'(

  • RIP Woody, you gave all you could and fought as hard as you ever have in that fatal 4 way, but it just wasn't enough. You will always be my favorite deputy.

  • i kill edgar i kill the brother of ross and this wife and i am forever sad great game !

  • Perfect ending for one of the greatest games of all time.

  • @Loller65 That's all that needed to be said. You didn't talk in ALL CAPS or in TextMsg-Speak. *Looks at top comments and firmly places palm on face*

  • One of my favorit song :)

  • Riding across the old West with the sun on your back, riding back to your family...

  • @sirdoodlebug219 no no no you shaddap, shaddap

  • YOU'RE GONNA CARRY THAT WEIGHT.

  • Wonderful........

    

  • Ever shot that went into John was a new tear i shed :'(

  • I love this song, so peaceful yet so meaningly painful.

  • i listen to this song when i plow ur moms asshole

  • post-/vg/ official /v/ soundtrack.

  • John Marston lives 4 Ever !

  • @creeper2303 nop he dead

  • Comment removed

  • I felt like i had been seen af 20 hour long movie. And when the credits and this song played, i was so sad.

    Great game.! Absolutely great.

  • All of you guys upset over a 14-year-old's comment. Lulz.

  • i dont forgot this game...never!

  • @creeper2303 Cheers to that brother.

  • This song gets me everytime. Makes me feel Jack's loneliness after losing both of his parents. Even after avenging John, there's no telling where Jack's future will be or if he'll redeem himself someday like John did.

  • @darock06

    thanks for the spoiler, brah

  • @druidieh damn.....sorry lol

  • YOU KNOW SOME ADULTS THINK GAMES DONT TEACH YOU NOTING. BUT RDR. RDR TEACHES YOU ABOUT BRAVERY. AND STAND UP FOR SOMETHING YOU BELIVE IN. EVEN IF IT KILLS YOU. EVERYTIME I GO TO THIS SONG IS BECASUSE IM SAD OR MAD. AND THIS CLAMS ME. ..R.I.P JOHM MARSTON. DONT WORRY I KILLED ROSS. AND FOR EXTRA I KILLED HIS WIFE.

  • Comment removed

  • @zetachi001 I agree, this game never showed us to beat eachother up and such, it gave us all emotions and showed us meaning (exept for the heartless/ignorant people) this game was gold and it's a fact. This game will forever be the best and my favorite game in life

  • @xCrazyKidz421x exacly.

  • @zetachi001 I killed hes brother too, lol

  • @zetachi001 his*

  • @zetachi001 You just summed up the whole game for me, when I didn't know how to sum up all the emotional impact RDR had on me, the death of him will carry on with me until I die<3

  • i made a big mistake and sold the game after completing it

  • @lkjhgfdsasdfgful you sure did. But thankfully the government printed more than $60. Get yourself some, and buy it again. 

  • @lkjhgfdsasdfgful NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

  • I think they should make a movie, and not make it totally differant to the game make it just like the game :)

  • @Raven9478 The only trouble is they'd skip alot out, or it would be like a 20 hour film, and every moment brings you closer to John as a character and what he stands for, a film would miss this, become a flop and give RDR a bad reputation.

  • Someone should make a youtube series of reactions to the RDR ending so more peeps can get the idea that this game's got a great story to tell.

  • rest in pest john marston

  • how can anyone dislike this song!

  • r.i.p john marston

  • o wow so meny Fucking poof crying over some one who is not real

  • @MrTHEUNDEAD1 Your an idiot

  • @MrTHEUNDEAD1 u would understand if u hav completed the game!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • This song is so good!!!!! I love it!! But it's too bad that John Marston died. This is such a great game and I would rate this to be like a 100 star game if I could!

  • @SUPERVIDEOGAMEHUNTER wow...that response was cute as balls

  • 49 people have a cold heart

  • @LeifUnni Lies. 49 people don't like this song.

  • I just can't play RDR anymore, I can't stand the fact that John Marston is dead..

  • Why does rockstar always have to make a food character die? Manly tears were shed when I saw John die...😔

  • The greatest game i have ever played and i will admitt i cried at the end of this game it took me days to get over it this game will always be my fav.

    John Marston = LEGEND

    Rockstar = LEGENDERY GAME MAKERS

  • @johnpaulm551 It took you days to get over a video game? Sissy, you disgrace the men around the world. Yes, I did cry because I have emotinally connected to John Marston but I smiled at the same time, because it was funny to cry at the video game. Crying is fine, and manly, but being in derpression for days after you finished is way too far.

  • @TriggerExDude you need to see a shrink m8. And yes i cried at a game and what a ment by i took me days to get over it i dont mean i was liyin in bed for days crying with the curtains closed. calling me a sissy? you no nothing about me so dont judge me so get a grip.

  • @johnpaulm551 I know enough about you. I know you cried and was in depression when you finished this game, I know that your YouTube username is johnpaulm551, not to mention stuff on your channel...

  • @TriggerExDude Trigger your comeback to that was pathetic m8.You no my YouTube username and the stuff on my channel so beacuse you no that you think you know me us a person?.Like i said go see a shrink and get a grip your making yourself look like a fool.I got all emotionally over a game there was no need for you to be a smart arse about it.Byee i will pray for you

  • @johnpaulm551 Don't pray for me, I'm an Atheist. Oh and by the way, it's mate, not m8.

  • @TriggerExDude Well am from Scotland and most of us say m8:L anyway have a nice life.

  • @johnpaulm551 Same, dude, same! :D

  • @johnpaulm551 good for you good for you :)

  • @ratchet755 :PP

  • @TriggerExDude No it isn't. Your a stupid insensitive fuck whom I'm sure has personality and 'ego' issues. Knob

  • @FattyBearCakes Sorry to disappoint you, but I'm perfectly fine when it comes down to my personality and ego. :)

  • @TriggerExDude When a person grieves, it is because they have lost a connection or rather a relationship, which they have grown so emotionally attached to. They miss the regular sight of them and even small interaction. You yourself even said you cried, yet your acting big by posting bullshit on Youtube about how your a real man. If you have to claim this, your probably 12. Stop trolling and fuck off faggot.

  • @FattyBearCakes Sorry, I'm 14, and no, I'm not ''acting big'' on YouTube. And no I'm not ''trolling''. I'm simply saying, that growing such A BIG FUCKING EMOTINAL RELATIONSHIP [as you claim it to be] WITH A VIDEO CHARACTER IS IMPOSSIBLE. Yes, I had these relationships with video game characters, but not soooooo fucking strong that I'll cry my heart out, instead, I'm gonna go play the fucking game again. Don't compare real life relationships and video game ones, it's not working.

  • @TriggerExDude Sorry, your 14! Your almost a grown woman then! You have simply contradicted yourself throughout everything you just said. ''A BIG FUCKING EMOTINAL RELATIONSHIP WITH A VIDEO CHARACTER IS IMPOSSIBLE'' But then '' Yes, I had these relationships with video game characters'' Naive child believing that he is superior to everyone. It does not matter what sort of relationship it is, it is still possible to feel the same.And if your not trolling, why are you commenting on everyones posts?

  • @FattyBearCakes Apology accepted. And sorry, I'm a guy. And you don't understand what I'm talking about, yes, people do emotinally connect to a gaming character, but not as much as that guy... Being in depression, pfft. No, I'm not superior to everyone either... Sorry. Yes, it's possible... With a person that has no life. And a troll is not someone who answers everyone's posts, a troll is someone who posts inflammatory, extraneous, or off-topic messages in an online community. I'm not off topic.

  • @TriggerExDude You are trolling by bringing everyone's statements down and vilifying them to all else here. Just leave them to their emotions regardless of what you think. Just because you are not affected, does not mean others are not. I'm not sitting here pretending to be noble for sticking up for that guy, so why should you sit there and act like your any more of a man than he is? Truth is your not. Apology accepted by the way :D

  • @FattyBearCakes Fine... I don't wanna argue anymore because I changed my opinion about you because of the smiley face. :D

  • @TriggerExDude No, what you mean is it took you 27 minutes to realise that you lost. Leave this video :D

  • @FattyBearCakes No, I didn't loose, I got bored! :D And No, I won't, just because you want me to leave, I won't. :D

  • @TriggerExDude Come back at me then. You've just realised that your spew of shit can't continue, so you brush it off by trying to kiss up. Moron. By the way, learn to spell.

  • @FattyBearCakes ...Have you ever heard there are other languages in the world? English ain't my native language, and no, this is where I start to troll people on this video, dickhead.

  • @TriggerExDude Well, my apologies for the language comment. However the point still stands that you lost and simply try to escape your inevitable consequence of looking like a dick to everyone. Unfortunately, you failed.

  • @FattyBearCakes Yes, it's truth! I have to escape, it's my destiny! LOL. :D

  • @TriggerExDude Your right, you were always going to lose and look like a dick!

  • @FattyBearCakes Lol. You mad.

  • @TriggerExDude I haven't cried at all. Should I call you sissy now?

  • how can some feelingless asshole dislike this

  • @PSNuserMick They are assholes because they dislike a song? You have issues.

  • @PSNuserMick Its Edgar Ross's ghost haha

  • i love this game i wish he never died

  • when i get to the first end i was shocked i stood in front the tv with my mount open i was angry because rockstar killed john but i started to realise that you cant escape your past and in life this cant happen a man that killed hundreds of man to live happily ever after like nothing happened this was the best ending to a game that ive ever seen not all other happily ever after endings i almost cried when i saw this ending and at the second i was filled with rage when i stood infront ross

  • @yeepumed Same here bro.

  • Never in all my years as a gamer, have I felt so emotionally attached to such a character! Joh Marston.. a name I will forever remember. He was a great man, fighting for his freedom, his family, HIS LIFE! He has been through so much, and we've all been with him throughout all of his struggles. We've seen his life through his eyes. He doesn't deserve his death. He was a great man, great husband, A great father! Watching him die was like loosing a piece of myself! JOHN MARSTON FOREVER!<3

  • T T

  • Why Im spanish??? I want to listent all this great songs and understand all because I thing that this song has great lyrics. :(

  • Manly guys. Doing manly things.

  • Quite simply the best game I've ever played.

  • I Wish the missions never end. ;'( Its so sad now every time i finish the game i skip the dying bit and burryal

  • I've finished this game 3 times and it's just getting sader and sader every time.But i become happier and happier every time i kill ross.

  • Add LeifUnni on psn:)

  • Add me on psn Cody_cdawg

  • Cried when John died cheered when jack killed Ross R.I.P John marston

  • This is like a mix between "The Nobodies" and "Pumped Up Kicks".

    Fucking sad though :/ i like it

  • @Freakenomics that's exactly how i felt

  • rockstar fucking bring it back with red dead redemption 3

  • @lkjhgfdsasdfgful not red dead redemption 3 haha

    the games are the Red Dead series of games :) Red Dead Revolver, Red Dead Redemption

    but i agree they should make another like this :D

    sorry for correcting you its ocd haha

  • Saddest song on this game I cry everytime I hear this

  • thumbs up if you almost cried/cried.

  • @SplatD1 Oh God, why did I think of the "liek dis if u cry evertim" when I read that?

  • this and carry on my wayward son at my funeral plz

  • plz red dead redemption 3

  • Love the Game

  • I wonder what it would have been like to hold johns gun..... This shall be announced the best game of all times it's making me cry when I listen to it

  • This song IS rdr for me! The rest of Ashtar Command's album is just as good, I went ahead and just got in on itunes because it was only like eight dollars.

  • best storyline of all rockstargames

  • Outlaws til the end!

  • I must say that I'm not happy the way John died: when John's ranch was attacked I thought it would end with Abigail dying, John taking his revenge upon the attackers, and hook up with Bonnie (by reading the forums I'm not the only fan who thought the game would end this way).

  • When John died, i felt like i lost a part of me... Like a close friend... I sank into a depression and reminisced the times i spent with him... And i got stuck with his fucking annoying son...

  • John Marston is my favorite Rockstar character

  • your not human if you don't cry

  • It seems to me that John had from the outset CONTACT Forums Edgar Ross.

  • This is seriously one of my favorite games of all time. Rockstar makes the best games out there.

    When I killed the last boss guy, and the next objective was to go back to your family, I got that extreme sense of finality, and actually felt like John (as in I was actually excited to go back to the family). Then when I got on my horse and started riding through the woods, this song started playing, and a single tear fell.

    This game fucking knows how to make me sad/pissed/happy

  • @AQrippin Again I may be wrong here, but I don't think this was the song that was playing while John rides home to his family. I am fairly certain that was a song called "Compass"

  • I hope Rockstar Games make new Red Dead Redemption, new map, guns, characters, but John was best

  • @Juomalasii I don't think its real red dead redemption without John.

  • @LeifUnni True

  • RIP Mr. Marston and my account that was cleared but i guess i'll have to beat it again on a higher difficulty

  • I wanted this game to go on forever! :(

  • @x0lamborghini0x same, i hate the fact john gets killed.

  • This is the most epic game EVER.

  • Best song on Red Dead Redemption by far.. did you guys know they have a new album out? American Sunshine! Check it out on itunes

  • This song was played at megaupload's funeral

  • this game is fantastic it is the best story in a game

  • @FuzzehTeaNpepsi he is EPIC, he is epic

  • Wow. I never thought a video game would find it's way into my heart. I love this game, and I love anybody who loves it.

  • @FedEx53 I Love you too C:

  • @FedEx53 I love you too then.

  • @FedEx53 no homo

  • @tom02061997 well of course no homo haha. That should go without saying. I may be wrong but I'd imagine homos don't particularly relate to this video game???

  • my freind died yesturday afternoon his moms boyfreind was a heroin adict and went crazy shot his mom, him, little brother (grade school), his cousin and then himself and lit the house on fire the today at school was pretty quite RIP Darnell & John Marston

  • @alienbigfoot15698 pmsl !!!!!

  • for me john marston is not a cowboy is THE cowboy

    john marston is the west itself with his death the west die too

    :(

  • You know you have finish an incredible game when you start to cry when this song begins.

  • Magnifique tout comme le jeu, merci rockstar pour ce jeu à jamais dans nos mémoires.

  • Rest in puece john marston

  • probably the best single player game i played for the ps3

  • @WWJDBibleStudyTime

    not only for yo.. game of centuries <3

  • @WWJDBibleStudyTime not trying to be a troll i love RDR too, but you should try Uncharted...

  • @hahaiamnotfunny Yeah, and Heavy Rain, and the Metal Gears now that they're all on PS3.

  • @WWJDBibleStudyTime probably the best single player game i ever played

  • @WWJDBibleStudyTime You obviously havnt played heavy rain then.

  • @WWJDBibleStudyTime MGS4 too

  • @WWJDBibleStudyTime maybe the best free roam multiplayer

  • @jokerlucas95 i dunno man its a great dynamic experience with the scenery and enemies and stuff but it gets boring when you know where you are going, i remember when i started it was so awesome i could go anywhere on the horizon and have a laugh now when i play it its just like.... fuck off i need to run soo far

  • @WWJDBibleStudyTime it feels more like a film than a game haha

  • @FuzzehTeaNpepsi yeah he is

  • This Game was one of the best games that they ever made. *_*

  • Comment removed

  • Red Dead Redemption proves to video game haters that games most defenitley don't teach people to go shoot each other. That's why this game is awesome in my view, wait i mean masterpiece not game. :)

  • @xCrazyKidz421x did that asshole jack thomson have anything to say about this?? this is THE greatest game i've ever played without a doubt!

  • STOP SPOILING THE GAME

  • @FlyToAirforce

    It's the ending song.

    Spoilers are obivious.

  • Comment removed

  • @FlyToAirforce The title itself is a spoiler

  • @FlyToAirforce Anybody who cares about this game enough will have already FINISHED it. If you don't want spoilers, don't come on RDR videos then. It's that simple.

  • Wow if you are looking for spoilers just read the comments

  • This is most amazing game in the world. This is the most moving song in the world. The Wild West is my dream, and always has been. thats why this game is so good to me. I dont want to end it. I havent finished the game yet. Im just meeting Seth for the first time on the graveyard ATM. I have a long way to go. This is awsome, this is my dream.

    Long live John Marston

    Long live the wild west.

  • @MrCoolvidsonline Finally a person who feels like i...or me...or whatever.. i'm swiss, sry for my english ;)

  • This game is a true piece of art, better than any movie or book

    If they make red dead r3 im gonna preorder it and buy every single dlc available

  • I like Jack but honestly, John is the one video game character I truly wanted to keep playing. After 90 hours of playing you get attached to a character. I cried at the credits honestly. It was the best 80 hours of my life. I'm never going to give up because you know, if this video game character can go through this I think I can do whatever I want in real life.

  • @thefarnorth12 Best 80 hours of your life? I mean i definetely enjoyed the game, but it wasnt like the best time of my life.

  • @kalleerbedst He's forever alone :(

  • Red dead Redemption will be the best game ever!!!

  • im not verry much of the reactions on youtube,but john marston have earned my respect even if it was a game character

  • Still and always will be THE best character in ANY game

  • Naked snake: Aka : big boss, the legendary soldier, legendary mercenary, Saladin, jack

    Real name: john

    Birth place: America

    Birthdate: 1935

    Age: 79 at death

    Height: 180 cm (1999)

    192 cm (2014)

    Weight: 89 kg (1999)

    Current status: Deceased