Added: 2 months ago
From: gamespot
Views: 8,700
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (238)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Fuck Gamespot! Join my anti-Gamespot Facebook page today! The link is in my channel!

  • Xenoblade is NOT the best JRPG ever. Chrono trigger, without a the slightest doubt, is the best JRPG ever made

  • Fuck Xenoblade ,Zelda rules!!!!!!

  • XENOBLADE CAN'T BE NOMINATED IF THERE IS NOT A US RELEASE!!!!!!!!!! 

  • So far, the only reason I don't think Xenoblade should have won was because it won't release in NA until Spring 2012, even though I know that the UK also had a say in this. I don't know if Xenoblade will be better than Skyward Sword, but my decision has to do with time frames and I haven't even played Xenoblade yet. I'm not spending money for a foreign Wii that I'll only play like one or three games on.

  • rayman origins was way better then xenoblade!

  • FUCK YEAH, XENOBLADE IS THE BEST WII GAME EVER MADE!

  • Both are equals imo, but if I had to choose, I'd pick XC over SS

  • Skyward Sword. 10/10 GAME. Unorgetable Game. Only Good Game On The Shit Wii.

  • @KWelch60 *Unforgetable

  • @KWelch60 I'm sorry, do you not know about super mario galaxy 1 and 2? Resident evil 4? Okami? Donkey Kong country Returns? Super Smash Bros? Monster Hunter Tri? Metroid Prime Trilogy?

  • I love Skyward Swrod and I disaree with Gamespots review of it but this is still a deserved win, one of the best RPG's this gen, whoops anything on PS3 put it that way haha

  • Why so many dislike ? Micro / Sony rage or Skyward Sword ? Personaly I love Xenoblade and Skyward Sword.

  • @XsharkunX Zelda extremists.

  • @AquaticMeeps Ouuuh yeah !

  • I have xenoblade chronicles... it's sleeping in my DVD holder for 2 months now xD Played it only once haha..

  • i guess nintendo should have payed gamespot

  • @highlander5523 But Nintendo made Xenoblade too!

  • @AquaticMeeps

    they published it, they didnt have anything to do with it lol

  • @highlander5523

    Monolith Soft, the company that developed Xenoblade is a subsidiary of Nintendo, so that makes it a Nintendo game just like Kirby or Fire Emblem.

  • @TheGravitationist

    technically, they are owned by nintendo, nintendo themselves didn't do anything. but it is in the same situation as kirby and fire emblem

  • @highlander5523

    Either way, implying that XB won over SS because nintendo didn't pay them doesn't make sense because Nintendo owns both games.

  • @TheGravitationist

    its actually a reference to the kane and lynch situation a few years back

  • Xenoblade Chronicles= Best JRPG ever made! Best game of 2011 and maybe the best game ever made. Well, atleast thats my opinion.Still, Xenoblade deserved to win.

  • WTF

    

  • Wow gamespot, i didn't know games are better if they aren't released in north america and if no one can play them.

  • Well if Xenoblade won, its fine by me. I just didnt like the fact that Zelda wasnt even nominated. It was JUST as good as Xenoblade.

  • Comment removed

  • Zelda fanboys are mad. Ahahah. Great choice, Gamespot.

  • Can't wait to finally get Xenoblade in North America in April.

  • They should hire gamers to work at gamespot cuz Zelda was clearly the winner

  • Awwww, poor AAA bandwagon fans are mad their precious franchise didn't win? Grow up, and stop nosebleeding because Zelda didn't win. Xenoblade so deserved this award, because despite Zelda being good, it's the same old crap with a new coat of paint. Maybe this will jog Nintendo to create new IP's, instead of rehashing their AAA franchises just to make money. Plus Zelda could learn a lot from Xenoblade. Like maybe having an almost seamless world. Quit licking Nintendo's ass, Zelda puppets.

  • @megax11

    So in that since we could say Skyrim is just a repaint of Oblivion.

    I will wait for your argument.....

    *Starts whistling as he walks away~

  • @megax11 funny because Xenoblade is made by Nintendo too.

  • Xenoblade isn't going to be released in NA until 2012. So it shouldn't count for game of the year.

  • @EvilBastards Why's that? It's been released to a larger audience than North America in English, considering all of the European territories..

  • Wow fluidity is just loco roco!

  • @HSAdestroy In the spike VGA's The legend of Zelda Skyward sword won because of PEOPLES VOTES not opinions from a bunch of guys. Its the real gamers out there who voted for the best wii game, so therefore XenoBlade is not game of the year. I agree with you!

  • @DareDevil467 Argumentum ad populum. Ever heard of that?

  • Comment removed

  • but how can you give GOTY to a game that isn't even out yet?

  • @frostflaked Its out in Japan and if im not mistaken its also out in UK.

  • Boo hiss etc...

  • lol ps3 and wii got buttfucked by gamespot. oh well.

  • Well, I'm happy. Zelda sucks balls, motherfuckers.

  • I wonder why people write and I read the comments. Apparently no one realized that Gamespot are a bunch of game enthusiasts with their own opinions. Also, apparently people like to repeat previous hateful comments because they forget that Gamespot are a bunch of game enthusiasts with their own opinions.

  • i didn't know people still played the Wii lol

  • if they made this for ps3, i would say goodbye to FF xD

  • Booo. Should have been rayman origins

  • Wow, I like how a game that won't be released in NORTH AMERICA until APRIL 2012 was nominated and won the award for this category. I had no idea this was the case until this video, I thought it just flew under the radar. I just found my New Year's Resolution...unsubscribe from Gamespot.

  • @MrMustBNice Wise-ass.

  • @XlPackratlX Yup

  • wheres mw3?

  • Comment removed

  • Skyward Sword was a disappointment: tiny game world, backtracking, boring story.

    Xenoblade Chronicles won simply because it's a much better game.

  • Just stick it in your Wii ... and play it. XD lolz

  • Lawl, they had to pick Xenoblade Chronicles, and everyone knows why. Having played both I find Zelda left a better impression on me, Xenoblade's few design issues ruined the great story, it needed better facial animation to convey the full degree of emotion.

    PS Gamespot are utter SHIT.

  • Xenoblade is not the big deal, I like more last story and Pandora Tower. But for Gamespot Xenoblades is amazing because it use 0% motion controls, and Gamespot hates motion controls.

  • i wish america would stop being so butthurt about xenoblade originally missing the territory. try living in australia.

  • Xenoblade deserved it, I loved Zelda SS but Xenoblade was just such an epic game..not only the best wii game but one of the best games this gen overall in my eyes

  • Xenoblade's a better game. It's too bad it won't be released in 2012 in America and will mostly miss on the GOTY awards.

  • @nuccbko It was announced for North America in 2012 by Nintendo, it's coming

  • @nuccbko It will be released in America

  • @nuccbko Yes it will

  • hahahahahaha srsly ?

    pick again gamespot.

  • both games are amazing 6 deserve GOTY not only for Wii but for all, I can't wait to play Xenoblade, but you cant go against Zelda, like I said I need to play Xenoblade to make my final choice betwen the 2, but Skyward Sword to me is the Game Of The Year of 2011

  • Well, I wanted Zelda won, but, this proves that Wii has great games besides Mario Galaxy and Skyward. It's a great console for JRPG lovers (i don't consider myself as a "lover", though i like some of them) and has some of the most innovative games of this generation. It's not the best of this generation but is not a piece of crap either.

  • It deserved to win GOTY for Wii and Zelda fanboys are the most butt hurt moaning bitches on the net

  • Man, I really felt like I took an arrow to the ass after watching this!

  • I was hoping XC would win, I watched a good chunk of a walkthrough for it on another system.

  • I know a lot of people are upset about Zelda losing, but the fact of the matter is that it's BECAUSE a lot of people are upset about it that Zelda doesn't need to win. Everyone knows about Zelda, about how awesome it is, and Xenoblade is just that obscure game in the corner that has only truly gotten notice through the internet. Zelda doesn't need to win, but Xenoblade does, because it and other Nintendo RPGs' futures are uncertain. Just step back and give this game some limelight.

  • This game has every reason to win, its such a beautiful wii game that gets everything right. The story is the real hook for me, so intense and immersion

  • Xenoblade is a magnificent game of epic proportions. Get the game on April 3rd,2012, and then you can say whatever you want about it. Right now, get used to the fact that Xeno won, Gamespot is right about this. I can't explain why I think it's better then Skyward, it just IS.

  • I wish "Epic Mickey" was at least nominated. I haven't had that much fun on my Wii for a long time.

  • Lawl, Zelda fanboys.

  • @Sneakypeex Fanboy alert!

    @mrman54blobulus Why yes, I did. And it was bloody brilliant. Did YOU play Xenoblade?

    @Wiiphantom I detect the sentiment that if it's not American, it's automatically crap.

    @mynameisnotminh Isolated example. Also, you're clearly not a PS3 user.

    @Alv62warlock You sound like the guy who created Lair, which also had bad motion control in the eyes of nearly everyone.

  • @NerfedFalcon yea totally why I enjoy:

    Dark souls (JP)

    Demon souls (JP)

    Deus ex (UK made)

    Battlefield 3 (made in sweden)

    yea totally it's got to be american.

  • @Wiiphantom All of them are available in America. What about Mother 3?

  • @NerfedFalcon

    What about mother 3? It's an rpg, it's well done. You don't see the point, I'm not complaining about xenoblade winning cause it is the best out of all the choices. Is it not odd thou a US/north America company gives a best wii game to a game not released even in the region they broadcast from?

  • @Wiiphantom They outright said in their review it was a review of the UK version. If you're that fussed about it, buy a PAL Wii and a copy of Xenoblade from a British gaming website and see for yourself what all the fuss is about.

  • @NerfedFalcon no - as a consumer I refuse to do that. Missing out on games because they are on other systems is not fair (in this case buying a PAL wii to play a game would count as another system). I'm not owing all three gaming systems because that is ridiculous. And as consumers we should let the market know this is where we draw the line. One system - 2 systems max.

    The good news is that I saw this is coming to North America April 2012

  • @asubigsaxy Tell it to the asshole who's keeping Professor Layton X Ace Attorney, if you want to do something useful with your life.

  • @Wiiphantom Oh yeah, and they gave a 9.0 to it. And 7.5 to Skyward Sword. Guess which one they're likely to be more partial towards?

  • @Wiiphantom DE:HR was made in Quebec.

  • @NerfedFalcon i have it for PS3..........

  • @mynameisnotminh You got lucky, then. Or your copy was a unique one that some modder broke into Bethesda one day and fixed the lag glitch on one Blu-ray of the game, which then fell into your hands.

  • @NerfedFalcon Well someone's butthurt........are you really telling me that you expect probably THE biggest most graphically enhanced game of the decade to be perfect? really? you act like you can make it better.

  • @mynameisnotminh "Most graphically enhanced". Yeah. So why does it even NEED fan-made texture packs? And another thing: Bigger =/= better. Oblivion /> Call of Duty 4, for instance.

  • @NerfedFalcon are you that dumb? i was hoping you would have realized ratio wise. but anyway, fan-made texture packs, ARE FAN MADE, it's like mods, just because a game has mods doesn't mean it is lacking in content. and oblivion is better than cod 4.........bigger is better when its good, like with xeno and skyrim, stop hating just because your overrated overhyped overused zelda lost to a totally deserving game

  • @mynameisnotminh Are you that dumb? I'm defending Xenoblade, not Skyward Sword.

  • Gamespot is just upset that they didn't play skyward sword correctly.

  • So there a couple of things that I have to say. First I haven't played xenoblade and in alright it looks like a good game. Second this doesn't really affect me because my opinion of Gamespot has dwained to the point where I'm not surprised by this. When they reviewed skyword sword they said the controls were terrible yet everything else was awesome and gave it a 7.5. Watch this A Look at Skyward Sword's Inaccurate Controls

    This pretty much denies everything which makes their opinion invalid.

  • @Lightbarier DWAINED! Need to transform? DWAIN!

  • I dont see why loads of people are complaining, I'm a huge Zelda fan however I'm not surprised Xenoblade won; it had an amazing story line to it and the gameplay was just brilliant. The only people that should complain are the American's since they unfortunately dont get to experience how great this game is.

  • wait wait wait. This game wasn't even released in North America? How can your awards carry weight or be representative of a region without the game itself being available to everyone?

    Gamespot is run by CBS - so you are basically telling North America - "hey there is this great game out there, but it's not available - but we've played it and dubbed it the best, so there."

    What if I told you I wrote the best PC game of the year, but I'm the only one that can play it?

  • @asubigsaxy yes t was! wtf are you talking about operation rainfall was a sucess!!

  • Um what? Last I checked I can't purchase xenoblade, So why even mention it?

  • Skyward Sword should have won. I never played Xenoblade Chronicles, but come on people, it's ZELDA. Once you play Zelda, all other games are a disappointment (yes, even Skyrim).

  • @Sneakypeex Zelda can't even compare to the elder scrolls. Xenoblade was the deserved winner for it truly innovates on the Wii, Zelda stuck to its same old bland formula, its a good formula nonetheless, but it didnt innovate.

  • @mynameisnotminh

    Innovates hahahahhahahahahahahahahahhaha­hhahahhahahhahahahaha

    hahahahahahahahha

    ok just a second hahahahahahah

    I'm sorry don't get me wrong I love elder scrolls I just think it going to be the next call of duty in the next few years. If all you have to do to make a game which innovates is copy and paste the same texture in about a billion locations. Don't get me wrong it a big game but you can always go back and play Fallout 3 and Oblivion to get the same experience

  • @Lightbarier oh ya because elder scrolls totally comes out every 3 years. And it's totally a copy and paste because it totally got horrible reviews. You said it yourself, you never even played xeno, so why do you knock it? asshole.

  • @mynameisnotminh

    I didn't knock it and in fact I said Xenoblade looks like a good game. I just said that I don't trust GameSpot opinion which is my personal opinion due to the fact that critic hated on controls without truly experiencing it. The critic got so much response about this that he literally came out and said he was wrong but refused to change the score. On elder scrolls side say one big thing they changed gameplay wise compared to other games. Nothing right.

  • @Lightbarier

    On a side note Skyrim looks prettier yes and improves upon a few things but everything is corly the same. Zelda comes out swinging making innovations with game controls, upgrades, and gameplay and the whole experience yet is criticised for being the same. Doesn't make since. On a side note Skyrim has cool things and is obviously better on a few grounds. But in two years people are going to say Skyrim was great and this is why the next game will fix all that what was wrong.

  • @Lightbarier ............the gameplay is the same, tell me how it is different, upgrades? really, you say skyrim barely improved WHEN THEIR ENTIRE LEVELING/UPGRADE SYSTEM IS DIFFERENT, and game controls? those were highly detremental to the game for it resulted in predicatable and stupid gamemplay, ex. "swing to the left" to hit the guy blocking to the right, or "roll the bomb" which never works xeno deserved the win

  • Xenoblade deserved to win this, for once there was a game better than Zelda. I'm sorry to say this, I love Skyward Sword but Xenoblade is sooooo great, kinda hurts me to agree with Gamespot for once.

  • Game of the Year awards shouldn't be a glorified popularity contest, regardless of whether it's overall GotY or a subcategory like "best Wii game". Sure, Modern Warfare 3 and Skyrim were the biggest sellers of the year, but Call of Duty has become more formulaic than Zelda and Skyrim was buggy as hell. Just because Skyward Sword sold more, and it's available right now in America, doesn't automatically make it any better than Xenoblade.

  • @NerfedFalcon Did you ever play Xenoblade? Cuz skyward swprd is freaking sweet.

  • @NerfedFalcon skyrim isn't buggy...........I have 50+ hours in and no ugs for me

  • Ok, we already know Zelda is AWSOME, that's why I think we should give a chance to Xenoblade.

  • @ytpw149x "zeldatards", seroiusly? Do you seriously care that much about what people say that you insult them? Don't you think you are the pathetic one here?

  • so buying this week

  • lol, wtf???

  • Xenoblade definitely deserves to be Wii-Game of the year, it's amazing. Zelda is good, nothing more. And that comes from a big Zelda-fan.

  • If I had chosen the winner, I had gone with Skyward Sword.

    Xenoblade was fun and looked really nice and all but I just liked Zelda more. I don't know why but I only played Xenoblade few times, even though I didn't have any other new games to play at that time. It just wasn't my game.

    Congratulations on winning though. I'm sure you deserved it! (:

  • The best game won. If you're complaining about Gamespot's decision, you haven't played Xenoblade Chronicles.

  • @TinyCombee EXACTLY I haven't played Xenoblade Chronicles...because I LIVE IN NORTH AMERICA. and it won't be released here for another 5 MONTHS! A game that hasn't even been released in EVERY major territory SHOULD NOT be nominated/win.

  • If you already know what game is going to win, what's the point of watching in the first place? If you want to see Skyward Sword win, watch another best Wii game award. Just because they didn't pick the game you want to win, doesn't mean they suck.

  • @fecalfarts the reason they suck is because they awarded and nominated a game that hasn't even been released in every major territory yet.

  • @MrMustBNice You have a point, but if they receive a game that they feel is better than Skyward Sword, then so be it. All-in-all though, it doesn't really matter. It's just their opinion, but if you don't feel like it should be nominated, then...well...tough luck...do something else.

  • gamespot you just lost a subscriber (and no not just because skyward sword didnt win - there're other reasons :)

  • Lol. Get the fuck over it Zeldatards. Just because Skyward Sword didn't win, doesn't mean it's a shitty game. MW3 won best shooter at the VGA's, yet everybody hates that game. You guys are so pathetic. XD

  • skyward sword is THE BEST GAME ON WII YET

  • FUCK GAME(shit)SPOT!!!!

  • You're hating on the video yet most of you haven't even played Xenoblade Chronicles, I own the port and I have to say the game is absolutely amazing. Skyward Sword is a great game but Xenoblade Chronicles definitely deserved Best Wii Game. Don't bash it until you try it guys.

  • no surprising, just check the skyward sword review, in game spot they hate it

  • i hope this is good promotion for xenoblade, which is coming to the states next april.

  • Skyward Sword was released too late for most of these lists, and it's late for people to have played it fully...

  • Comment removed

  • lol@all the hate on graphics, yet 99% of the people that do it still pretend the xbox 360 has better graphics than gaming pcs

  • love this game

  • @CrazyKrafty like zelda/s are better

  • What ??? Wii is a console ???

  • Xenoblade yeah :)

  • all the nominees that they said were the games that he spoke of in the beginning of the video...=/ lame

  • :) xenoblade

  • and the winner is Skyrim!!! :)

  • wtf!! xenoblade? get df out of here yall some dumbasses

  • because the game isn't released in the US doesn't mean it shouldn't count. The game is amazing and it deserves it.

  • i want this game nintendo, wtf?

  • Why would they pick a game that isn't available in North America..

  • WTF?!?!?! Xeno fuck farts?

  • @MrYugioh4life then they would be like EVERYONE else, that's like Skyrim winning GoTY. Wait.....Dammit!!!!!

  • WTF...? how...

  • i cant even buy this in the u.s.? what the fuck?

  • EPIC PS2 Graphics!!

  • @SmokinSNYP3R Funny guy, gameplay and immersion over graphics any day please...

  • @SmokinSNYP3R EPIC TROLL!!!!!

  • That bugger in the beginning pissed me off...

  • my fav wii game this year is definitely rayman origins. as much as i wanted to like xenoblade, it just wasn't my cup of tea. i was one of the few that didn't like the live-action fighting. i like the traditional turn base more.

  • Xenoblade Chronicles is coming to america now.I live in Europe and ever since the game has been released I have been looking for it in shops and i have not found even one copy :/

  • haha wii... 

  • wow I'm surprise zelda didn't win.

  • wtf really? WTF? Skyward Sword? What the hell? I though it was obvious....

  • I personally think that Skyward Sword is better, but Xenoblade is a worthy winner. It's such a great game to play, and so well presented, and so well paced and with such great music that it's a must for all gamers. Anyone who claims the Wii has no good games has been proved so wrong over the years.

  • that fluidity looks exactly like locoroco for the psp

  • wtf? guys come on what about skyword sword?

  • @justcallmeliam you haven't even played this game,so you don't have the exoerience to judge

  • @justcallmeliam Zelda just isnt that great. Good, but not great! But opinions are opinions. I just wanna ask u if uve played Xenoblade chronicles?

  • @heythatisjourney - Wind Waker was the last great Zelda game IMO. Skyword sword had a chance but it cut a few corners in trying to streamline the experience. And the whole Zelda is Hylia plot device seemed incredibly unnecessary.

  • @justcallmeliam Remember, their poor excuse for a review, they gave it a 7.5

  • The Wii is crap now:(

  • @Qwetzgreen only cuz Nintendo did not put enuf thought into online :P

  • wow. these cunts dont even choose zelda which is the clear winner. another gamespot fail.

  • xenoblade is good if you like endless running

  • Skyward sword.

  • Still a fucking RPG!.