I found Tobey Maguire did a terrible job because I was laughing during his breakdown scene and plus he does not pull off the "masculine military" type character and believe me I know soldiers and saying he seemed like a believable soldier is like saying the the Westboro Baptist Church is reasonable.
@rainzoro The tomato-meter rating isn't reflective of what the hosts or guests themselves say, it represents every person's weighing in on the rotten tomatoes website. So while these maybe ten people praised it, there are many more who did not enjoy it.
moive was one of the best of 2009. i think it would have been better though if the peopel in the audience would have shutup instead of talking me through the whole fucking movei. "omg watch this hes going to wreck the kitchen" OBVIOUSLY
Who can, please watch the original Danish film, Brodre directed by Susanne Bier. Fenomenal, how it avoids the overdone sadness. I don't know how Sheridan remade that film, but the Danish one shows why North European filmmaking is so popular and influential nowadays.
I need to stop watching these reviews. They rave about the performances, say the movie includes some iconic scenes and then slap a 56% on it. For some reason it really pisses me off. Apparently nothing is good enough for these people. And what the fuck is depth? Could someone define "depth" in a cinematic sense for me, cause I think it's just a made-up term to make these "critics" look knowledgeable.
@LordWolven mmm, dont think thats a fair comment, they did say a few thing were off (natalies performance, jake's character depth, cheesy script), but yea, think given what they did like about it, it maybe should've scored a bit higher :)
@LordWolven u werent listenign were you? they were critizizing it, they were saying that the story wasnt good, nathalie portman character isntthta interesting and alot of other things. Pay Attention
@LordWolven the review filmed is the opinion of the hosts, the review shown is from the website, which is an averaging of other proffesional reviewers
@LordWolven I really liked the movie. But it does have plot holes and I think that a lot of people were turned off by it cause of the fact that it's a remake
you know... that's a myth... about the Eskimos... and the snow... just saying... Natalie Portman is hit-or-miss as an actress... I thought her performance in Cold Mountain was maybe one of the best I've ever seen, but in certain other movies... idk...
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
LOL, WTF?! Eskimo does not have that many words for snow, it's snow-related words like "Lake" "River" "Rain" and it's "SNOW', not "SHNOW" you fat fuck.... 2:13
56! FUCK OFF!!!!!!!!!
icantfindb 1 month ago
I found Tobey Maguire did a terrible job because I was laughing during his breakdown scene and plus he does not pull off the "masculine military" type character and believe me I know soldiers and saying he seemed like a believable soldier is like saying the the Westboro Baptist Church is reasonable.
TheGamerLand 6 months ago
The little girl is so awwwdorable in the movie "Bridge to Terabithia".
jonnyRYhollywood 6 months ago
I never even heard of this and it's funny cuz Jake Gyenhall was considered for Spiderman before Tobey...
PumaSweat 7 months ago
Natalie Portman was great
RevLSM33 9 months ago
LOL watch this review and mine back-to-back
YourMovieSucksDOTorg 1 year ago
she looked better in closer
euginam91 1 year ago
i kept waiting for tobey mcguire to turn into spider man
stiks3784 1 year ago
if it's 56, don't they think they should explain why?
EXCELLENT
WONDERFUL
EXTRAORDINARY
but 56 good bye
wtf
rainzoro 1 year ago
@rainzoro The tomato-meter rating isn't reflective of what the hosts or guests themselves say, it represents every person's weighing in on the rotten tomatoes website. So while these maybe ten people praised it, there are many more who did not enjoy it.
pstirnimann 1 year ago
I thought it was pretty cool, especially to see Tobey freak out, his now officially the new Bale!
I'd give the movie 7/10
R2R3L4 1 year ago
7 out of 10?
Id give it a 10
AndroidPhone1 1 year ago 3
@AndroidPhone1 Well, different opinions ya know.
R2R3L4 1 year ago
this movie and avatar came out right next to each other.
looks like somebody has a grudge with marines taking their women from hollywood to 29 palms and dropping them off at home sore and stumbling.lol
romeosevendelta 1 year ago
shut the fuck up
PFCPEDERSON 1 year ago
love this movie
inkybinky786 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
tobey kills his firend in afghanistan and it makes him go crazy
thugstylef 2 years ago
moive was one of the best of 2009. i think it would have been better though if the peopel in the audience would have shutup instead of talking me through the whole fucking movei. "omg watch this hes going to wreck the kitchen" OBVIOUSLY
eaglez6592 2 years ago 2
yeah and that scenes ur waiting thats over hyped from the trailer doesn't come until the last 10 min....which is a little too late and not enough.
DJTEVAdotCOM 2 years ago
Guys, seriously. Go see this movie. I was shocked of how realistic the three cast were with their acting.
Amazing, emotional, intense.
Tobey was fantastic of how he changed from Spiderman to a crazy former Solider.
Awesome American movie.
CollegeLoheart 2 years ago 3
Comment removed
CollegeLoheart 2 years ago
masturbate
nongo 2 years ago 11
I just wanted to comment on how one of those reviewers had a poster of confession of a shopaholic behind him on his wall.
that just makes it really difficult for me to hold any credibility to his words. just sayin
wonderbreadyears 2 years ago
watch the ninja assassin review.. the same guy had a new moon poster in the background during THAT one
dude004004 2 years ago
How come they don't just admit, that this is a remake of a danish movie.. A great one btw..
Tjellevejrup 2 years ago
I"m still going to see it
mimimerlot13 2 years ago
Dude that kid had some cajones!
abci23billionmillion 2 years ago
movies these days just don tell good stories anymore... they forgot how to do it................. the 90s was ALL about the story...
djkikis 2 years ago 2
Who can, please watch the original Danish film, Brodre directed by Susanne Bier. Fenomenal, how it avoids the overdone sadness. I don't know how Sheridan remade that film, but the Danish one shows why North European filmmaking is so popular and influential nowadays.
Ironbee07 2 years ago
UPLOAD THE FULL EPISODE FFS
On3Sound 2 years ago
Dear Adds by Google: Get the fuck off my internet
Love,
TheSilentFool
TheSilentFool 2 years ago 4
if it pops up, press refresh. the refreshed one usually dosent have an ad
jellybeansies 2 years ago
all of mine have ads.
TheSilentFool 2 years ago
TA! : totally agree
Thiren111 2 years ago
When the kid yelled at her dad, i was like, "OH SH*T!!"
CarManiac225 2 years ago
I need to stop watching these reviews. They rave about the performances, say the movie includes some iconic scenes and then slap a 56% on it. For some reason it really pisses me off. Apparently nothing is good enough for these people. And what the fuck is depth? Could someone define "depth" in a cinematic sense for me, cause I think it's just a made-up term to make these "critics" look knowledgeable.
XBillums 2 years ago 4
tobey looks like eminem
maranji85 2 years ago
These reviews make no sense, they spend the entire time praising the movie and yet at the end we find out it only gets a 56.
LordWolven 2 years ago 15
Its not just there review it has to do with big time critics and site reviews
AppleFlavoredTea 2 years ago 2
Reminds me of the time they praised Orphan, only for the film to be critically panned.
Jai137 2 years ago
@LordWolven mmm, dont think thats a fair comment, they did say a few thing were off (natalies performance, jake's character depth, cheesy script), but yea, think given what they did like about it, it maybe should've scored a bit higher :)
rxuk 1 year ago
@LordWolven lol where's all the praise?
slinkyphil 1 year ago
@LordWolven
the percentage isn't from the guests or reviewers, it's an overall rating from anyone who gave it one on the website
cicada300 10 months ago
@LordWolven thats because they are stupid,
MrPinaka 10 months ago
@LordWolven u werent listenign were you? they were critizizing it, they were saying that the story wasnt good, nathalie portman character isntthta interesting and alot of other things. Pay Attention
Iceking137 7 months ago
@LordWolven the review filmed is the opinion of the hosts, the review shown is from the website, which is an averaging of other proffesional reviewers
buddythecow 2 months ago
@LordWolven I really liked the movie. But it does have plot holes and I think that a lot of people were turned off by it cause of the fact that it's a remake
FuckWorkdays 2 months ago
you know... that's a myth... about the Eskimos... and the snow... just saying... Natalie Portman is hit-or-miss as an actress... I thought her performance in Cold Mountain was maybe one of the best I've ever seen, but in certain other movies... idk...
AdderallApocalypse 2 years ago
matthew is an AWFUL critic
TubedUp909Part3 2 years ago
im 50/50 on this
drftme 2 years ago
Wow.. Elizabeth is a BITCH. Send her to bed with no dinner and ground her for 2 months.
eeedel 2 years ago 2
this move is more like perl harbor, it's the same thing.
brageritu 2 years ago
I can't stand Natalie Portman. The role of a ho is perfect for her!
Thegrinch17 2 years ago
its spiderman!, ^-^
145kristy145 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
LOL, WTF?! Eskimo does not have that many words for snow, it's snow-related words like "Lake" "River" "Rain" and it's "SNOW', not "SHNOW" you fat fuck.... 2:13
DeCrypedMonkey 2 years ago
Hes Crazy
TheDGDX 2 years ago