Dasam Granthees Exposed(challenging Superiority of Guru Granth Sahib) .wmv

[nimmasandhu1]

tere juttian marnian chahidian tusi lokan ne kom nu duba ditta hai

[nimmasandhu1]

those peoples are goats not lion

[nimmasandhu1]

they are not sikh they are hindus

[Thatguyisfat1]

I pose a series of questions to you. have you read the Dasam Granth? How is your information as reliable as mine? Are you biased against the Dasam Granth? History in itself is a contreversal thing so i ask you are u spiritually elevated to know such information? Have you ever been to these gurughars where they have Guru ji and the Dasam Granth together? If you are right why not ask these people to stop then, would you do it? Bani Guru Hai Bani- my perception on the Dasam Granth is solid

[Thatguyisfat1]

inauguration as Guru: Nanded, India, October 7, 1708. Siri Guru Granth Sahib, appointed by Tenth Guru Gobind Singh as everlasting Guru of the Sikhs. So no but did Guru not grant powers to the Panth as his personification to decide the future like the Dasam Granth, as the Guru of the panth was Guru Granth Sahib. However at this time Dasam Granth Was being recovered and re compiled, naturally it is up to the panth to decide wat happens next at a conference at the Akal Takht sahib.

[amriteighteen]

I still have not received a reply to my question.

When Guru Granth Sahib ji was bestowed Guruship by Guru Gobind Singh ji himself, was the Dasam Granth installed on par also?

[amriteighteen]

The shapes of the Gurmukhi letters is very modern that existed after the use of press in the early part of the twentieth century.

[amriteighteen]

The vowel sign ‘dulaikrey’ has always till late nineteenth century been written is such a way that of the 2 lines drawn under a consonant , the right end of the upper line touches the bottom of the consonant. However, in this letter, it never does so following the practice used during the twentieth century. The two lines of the dulainkrey vowel sign in this letter are identically drawn as in the case of printed Gurmukhi text in modern times.

[amriteighteen]

ਜੁਆਬ ਪੋਰੀ ਮੇਂ has the dot on the last letter ‘m’. Similarly, in the 14th line from the bottom text ie ਉਨਾ ਵਿਚ ਸਾਹਿਬਾਂ ਦੇ has a dot as part of the ‘kanna bindi’ on the letter ‘b’.

[amriteighteen]

In regards to Bhai Mani Singh's letter:

The writing is done with the help of a metallic nib not with a reed pen. Metallic nibs were invented around 1800 AD in England and were first manufactured in Birmingham, England, UK.

The use of dot or Bindi for nasalisation was not used in Gurmukhi till late nineteenth century. No hukamnama, or manuscript ever used a dot for this purpose prior to nineteenth century. But we have this in this letter for instance the last sentence:

[amriteighteen]

Malcolm's account of this was not his own but actually was of a Sikh priest, who was of a high Hindu tribe.

If we were to agree that this has happened, is it correct? There were idols within the sanctum of Harimandar Sahib in the past. Just because it happened in the past, doesn't mean it's correct.

[sukh38]

Lolol maha kallies is a only spoken in dasam granrh ironic that lolil

[sukh38]

Lolol go folloq ur father ragi kuta darshan out of the panth

[84WAKEUP]

THIS VID IS SO ANTI TOGURUS BACHAN WHAT HE SAYS IS RIGHT ITS EDITED MIS INTERPRETED AND THEN U WRITE UR SHIT ITS US THAT R WEAK NOT THE GURU

[pjskhalsa1]

jai jai jag karan srisht ubaran mam pritparan ,,,, jai jai tegangggggggg,,,,,,, jehde lok is tarha di videos bnande hai oho sawdhan rehan.......khalsa ne ohna da saravnash kar dena.... khalse da pita guru gobind singh , khalse da guru shri guru granth sahib , khalse da ang dasam bani....... khalse wich bir ras dasam di bani bhardi hai ate khalse wich nimarta shri guru granth sahib ji di bani bhardi hai

je khalse da guru sahib shri guru granth sahib ji hai , tan dasam di bani khalse da ang hai

[GabhrooShakeen09]

The ppl u make these videos are not from dalpanth and they don't read bania of guru ji when taking amrit pakhandis

[jatsher2]

@amriteightenn. What a stupid little boy you are. We all agree Guru Granth sahib ji is our only Guru. I am talking about giving Dasam Granth some respect. Ever heard of Chandi var , arti and chorpai sahib all written by GOD ie Guru Govbind singh.

end of arguement.

[amriteighteen]

@jatsher2

I don't understand how people can be so nieve, like DesiKayTheMusician. Having the title "Guru" infront a granth that has no status equal to Guru Granth Sahib ji, IS WRONG. I would not call my Doctor a "Professor", if he/she is not a professor. I will not call a Professor a Doctor, if he/she is not a Doctor.

By doing Chaur on the Dasam Granth, giving it's own throne, having it's own bed, taking a command (hukamnama) from this Granth, is a straight out disrespect to our Guru.

[Thatguyisfat1]

@amriteighteen Actually hisoric evidence by ppl that were their during the compiling the Dasam Granth at Poanta Sahib and Anandpur sahib that Guru ji himself said that the Dasam Granth is to be treated as the same light, that this is my play I set forward to my Khalsa Panth. This is Sri Hazur Sahib Rehit Maryada. Personally if the Dasam Granth did not exist their would not be the concept of Saint Soldier, ardas, Khanda Bhata Amrit, Nitnem or warriors of the sikh fate!

[amriteighteen]

@Thatguyisfat1

Please show me where this historical proof is.

Also one question,

When Guru Granth Sahib ji was bestowed Guruship, was the Dasam Granth also installed on par?

[Thatguyisfat1]

@amriteighteen 10.In 1812, JB Malcolm, in Sektch of Sikhs mentioned about Dasam Granth as Bani of Guru Gobind Singh. In this book, Malcolm mentions that the leading authorities of the Sikh faith during this era " bowed in front of two scriptures and sat down" This was done at Amritsar-Akal Takht sahib and he mentions the same result at Hazur Sahib.

[Thatguyisfat1]

@amriteighteen If we look at history then we can see that the two granths have always been parckashed at the same time next to each other. Guru Granth Sahib Jis palki has always been larger and higher than that of Dasam Granth Sahib Ji. This has never been an issue before, Puratan Sikhs did this as a norm. Maharaja Ranjit Singh listening to the two sacred Granths being recited near Sri Harimandir Sahib. It is from a painting by August Theodore Schoefft (1809-1888)

[Thatguyisfat1]

@amriteighteen If you look at Bhai Mani Singh ji letters to Mata Sundri ji, it shows that the 10th Gruu's bani has been recovered and parkash as been done at the Akal Takht sahib by the Khalsa panth and that his days are coming to a end. He says that the granth is safe with the Khalsa Panth right beside the Guru Granth Sahib ji- read the accounts of Puratun singhs and read the Surag Partap Granth a documentation by a singh during the compilation of the Granth, read ur sikh history of our 10 guru

[jatsher2]

Dhan siri Dasam Granth sahib ji and Dhan siri Guru Granth sahib ji. i bow down to both .even if Guru Granth sahib is Guru.

KHALISTAN ZINDABAD

[amriteighteen]

@jatsher2

Just shows how much of your Guru you are disrespecting. You are willing to bow to a Granth, which was never bowed down to Guru Gobind Singh ji himself, nor was installed on par with Guru Granth Sahib ji, at anytime.

I mean, if I was alive, during the time of Guru Arjan Dev ji, I would never, in my life, bow down to someone else, as the Guru is ONLY my teacher, and I am the Guru's discipline. It is ONLY the Guru that can help me conquer my five vices and help me in this world.

[amriteighteen]

@jatsher2 The Guru says;

The Guru who gave me my soul, has Himself purchased me, and made me His slave. ||6||

He Himself has blessed me with His Love. Forever and ever, I humbly bow to the Guru. ||7||

My troubles, conflicts, fears, doubts and pains have been dispelled; says Nanak, my Guru is All-powerful. ||8||9||

[amriteighteen]

@amriteighteen

(SGGS, 240)

[MrManpreet9]

Tell me do you beleive in sri guru granth sahib ji or dasam granth.

Do you think there is no khalsa panth without dasam g

guru Gobing singh ji ne sanu guru granth sahib ji de nall jodya si na ki dasam nall. I only beleive in GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI.

[84WAKEUP]

they are deeply religious but the person who made this video cannot even read or understand gurbani

[DesiKayTheMusician]

guru gobind singh ji maharaj is our pita our farther, a true guru sikh believes in hukam hukam of the guru so if our mum dies and our farther dies we should not be hurt because our eternal farther and mother guru gobind singh ji and mata sahib kaur is still there. if our brothers and sisters die ? why would we shed a tear when we have the khalsa panth our brothers n sisters in the whole khalsa family ? this is the thinking of a propa sikh this is how we should think.

[piyaji840]

Honestly guys keep keep fighting

Editing portion : the guy in the video targeted towards guru Granth sahib when he mentioned what would we be by reading a poetry common can u not c that????

All I know is nothing is comparable to Granth sahib ji and about Dasam Granth don't wanna comment but the least we could do is

Not fighting each other

Guru maharaj saddey teh Kirpa Karan

[channpunjabi]

These people have forgotten the basics of our religion, taught by Guru Nanak Dev Ji. He was always against such fake Karam Kands. We are divided into Two like muslims , this is what Brahmin wanted when he injected this Bachitar Natak (Dasam Granth) in Sikhism. Bachtar Natak is full of junk stories any one can read the Charitropakhian and think could Guru Gobind Singh Ji write those?

[Dasam4Life]

How are they exposed? They have been doing that for centuries. I don't get how can you expose something that is already done out in the open. Stop getting paranoid and misled. Sit down, think, analyze and post something meaningful.

[sidhu1986]

without dasam bani a singh is not a singh as u will not be able to complete the amrit sanskar that guru ji gave us as 3 out of the 5 banis read are from siri dasam granth, an u will not b able to do ardass where it conducted with bani's from siri dasam granth, so do us a favour an U WAKE UP

[84WAKEUP]

i wan to ask a question are namdhari sikhs and r they allowed in sikh gurdware

[DesiKayTheMusician]

if you dont read Sri Guru Dasam Granth Sahib you aint a sikh you cant take amrit you cant read panj bhaniya in the morning at amrit vela khalsa ji les just cut to the point.

with out sri guru dasam granth there is no khalsa panth.

no you tell me are you going to be rss sons and daughters who have raped your sistsers and killed your mothers and farthers or you going to by guru gobind singh jis ladli fauj and be har tyar pur tyar. im gone. Jakaraa gajavae fateh pavae Nihal oh javae satsriakluhh!

[DesiKayTheMusician]

Khalsa ji i would like to share one thing with you, please turn yur eyes away from stupid videos like this that are trying to create hate in the minds of every1 towards Sri Guru Dasam Granth Sahib. Sarabloh Bhani says. 'Bolan Satguru Sabath Sampkhan' if we want to talk to our satguru then we have to read the shabads of your guru ? if you start believing that dasam bhani is fake. how will you get darshan of sri guru gobind singh ji ? our pita says to have his darashan we have to read jaap sahib

[DesiKayTheMusician]

Sri Guru Dasam Granth is Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji Maharaajs Bhani - First of al we nihangs do not look at Sri Guru Dasam Granth is our guru - Our guru is

Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaaj / dasam granth dae naal guru kyu kaeya jhanda some people ask ? we say Sri Guru Dasam Granth out of respect becase dasmae pitas jot is in Sri Guru Dasam Granth.

[amriteighteen]

@DesiKayTheMusician

You're a fool to say that by saying Guru infront of a granth that never got the guruship is out of respect. You are just disrespecting your father's decision of Guru Granth Sahib being the only Guru, and receiving the only title as Guru.

If someone is a Prime Minister, I will call only that person a Prime Minister. I will not call a person a Prime Minister if he never received that title. In respect towards that person, I will show my respect by putting "ji" at the end.

[DesiKayTheMusician]

@amriteighteen im not a fool, because i know Siri guru granth sahib ji is our guru the sikhs of the guru. guru maharaaj is the living sikhs of the guru. what i was ment to say and explain is i only say guru in front of dasam granth because of respect. why do we say guru gobind singh ji if he isnt our guru ?

[amriteighteen]

@amriteighteen

Again, how much respect should a granth be given? I will not call my father a doctor, because he isn't one, why shall I call someone a Singh when he isn't one? Why shall we put the title "Guru" in the name of Dasam Granth, when the Dasam Granth isn't our Guru? If choose to give someone respect, I add "ji" at the end of the name, why cannot you do this with DG?

How dare you challenge the authority of Guru Gobind Singh ji by saying that he isn't our Guru!

[bodikutt]

khote anpar gawar

[DesiKayTheMusician]

you fool. the chaul sahib is done over dasam granth because its having satkaar for siri dasam granth sahib, the guru ghuddi was given to guru maharaaj from guru gobind singh ji, why shoudn't our pitas bhani be next to guru ji ? are you guys stupid or thick ? guru ji in dasam granth says.

" Rakhat Hai Apno Kar Dehr Kar Paap Sabo Na Paten Pavae "

guru gobind singh ji maharaaj says from dasam bhaNi read arti arta and i will protect you with my own hand and i wont even let you go near paap.

[amriteighteen]

@DesiKayTheMusician

The Gurgadhi was given forth to Guru Granth Sahib ji, was the parkash of Dasam Granth also done then? If Guru Gobind Singh ji NEVER CHOSE TO PUT HIS GRANTH BESIDE GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI, THEN WHY ARE THEY DOING IT? ARE THEY DISRESPECTING HIS DECISIONS? He never chose to give any status to his writings, so why are they doing that?

[DesiKayTheMusician]

jaap sahib - dasam bhani

chaupai sahib - dasam bhabi

rehriaas - dasam bhani

ardaas - dasam bhani

if we take this out of daily following of reading guru gobind singh ji maharaajs bhaniya what will we read ???..

so what should we do ? become paapis and refuse to read the bhani and just read japji sahib ? no khalsa ji you have to wake up stick up for dasam granth

this is our pitas bhani all of you younger genarations ar the only one that can help us, make videos SUPPORTING DASAM GRANTH

[amriteighteen]

@DesiKayTheMusician

This isn't the issue. All sikhs will and still read these baniyas (only exception only some of Chaupai Sahib). But what can we say of the other parts of Dasam Granth that support brahmnism, worship of devis, sex, etc. Can we call this Guru's writings? Can we? Then can we put this granth's parkash on par with Guru Granth Sahib ji? I mean, did Guru Gobind Singh ji did the parkash of Dasam Granth when he gave the gurgadhi to Guru Granth Sahib ji? Then why are we doing this?

[DesiKayTheMusician]

your pita guru gobind singh ji maharaaj, listen to me with what i have said because all of it is true, dont no believe this murakh who has made this video hes an donkey ass.

[DesiKayTheMusician]

EVEN IN SARBLOH GRANTH : GURU GOBIND SINGH JI SAYS.

BOLAN SATGURU SABATH SAMPAKAN.

Which means, if you want to talk to satguru

you have to read the shabads of your guru.

Naam gobind Kirtan santha.

guru gobind singh ji is your pita is our khalsa panths pita

in a every day day to day life we have farthers we all listen to

our farthers at home we would never question them or say

our farthers are faulse, so please tell me how the hell can you reject your iternal pitas bhani, which is written by

[DesiKayTheMusician]

why have you uploaded this video with this text as if your trying to say doing prakash of dasam granth next to guru ji is a bad thing.

you fools need to wake up.

with out dasam granth you cant take amrit

with out dasam granth then can be no amrit sanchaar

with out dasam granth you cant have 5 complete nitnems to recite in the morning

and khalsa ji with out siri dasam granth sahib we have no khalsa panth

if we cantr take amrit and read our bhaniya whatsa the point us being sikh ?

[amriteighteen]

@DesiKayTheMusician

First of all, the whole point of Sikhism isn't to become amritdhari and read the five banias everyday. It's more then that. Guru's Bani in Guru Granth Sahib ji is enough for Amrit. In the modern Rehet Maryada created in 1945 it is mentioned that 5 Bani’s should be read in nitnem and in the Amrit Ceremony. History does not agree with this.

[amriteighteen]

@DesiKayTheMusician

There is no mention of these 5 bani’s being read in ANY historical source and all sources in until the 19th century don’t even mention any Dasam Granth Bani’s being read.

There are many other books from the 1700 mentioning NO bani's were read, while some say Anand Sahib and Jap Ji sahib were read, while some say only mool mantar was read.

[amriteighteen]

@DesiKayTheMusician

Guru Sahib says:

ਗੁਰ ਕਾ ਸਬਦੁ ਅੰਮ੍ਰਿਤੁ ਹੈ ਜਿਤੁ ਪੀਤੈ ਤਿਖ ਜਾਇ ॥: Gur kaa sabad amrit hai jit peetai tikh jaai || The Word of the Guru's Shabad is Amrit; drinking it in, thirst (of Maya) is quenched (sggs 35).

Again:

ਗੁਰ ਕਾ ਸਬਦੁ ਅੰਮ੍ਰਿਤ ਰਸੁ ਪੀਉ ॥: Gur kaa sabad amrit ras peeou: (O my mind!) Guru's Shabad is the Amrit (ਆਤਮਕ ਜੀਵਨ ਦੇਣ ਵਾਲਾ ਰਸ), drink it (sggs 891

[jindashaheed]

Those who believe in Dasam Bani are Sikhs of all Guru Sahibaans: From Guru Nanak Dev Sahib Ji all the way to Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji and believe Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji as their Guru! Dasam Granth is Guru Gobind Singh Sahib Ji's Bani and it is to be respected!

[amriteighteen]

@jindashaheed

Can we beleive that Guru Gobind Singh ji could write stories that promote sex, devi worship, and many other hindu rituals? I don't think so.

[jindashaheed]

Aarti is actually a prayer made up of Bani from Guru Granth Sahib Ji and Dasam Granth. Not just Dasam Granth. You're making it seem that those who believe in Dasam Granth don't believe in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Are you so thickheaded that you cannot understand you cannot understand Dasam Granth without Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji?

[amriteighteen]

@jindashaheed

sabh meh jot jot hai so-ay.

Amongst all is the Light-You are that Light.

tis dai chaanan sabh meh chaanan ho-ay.

By this Illumination, that Light is radiant within all.

gur saakhee jot pargat ho-ay.

Through the Guru's Teachings, the Light shines forth.

jo tis bhaavai so aartee ho-ay. ||3||

That which is pleasing to Him is the lamp-lit worship service. ||3||

[amriteighteen]

@jindashaheed

sahas tav nain nan nain heh tohi ka-o sahas moorat nanaa ayk tohee.

You have thousands of eyes, and yet You have no eyes. You have thousands of forms, and yet You do not have even one.

sahas pad bimal nan ayk pad ganDh bin sahas tav ganDh iv chalat mohee. ||2||

You have thousands of Lotus Feet, and yet You do not have even one foot. You have no nose, but you

[amriteighteen]

@jindashaheed

kaisee aartee ho-ay. bhav khandnaa tayree aartee.

What a beautiful Aartee, lamp-lit worship service this is! O Destroyer of Fear, this is Your Ceremony of Light.

anhataa sabad vaajant bhayree. ||1|| rahaa-o.

The Unstruck Sound-current of the Shabad is the vibration of the temple drums. ||1||Pause||

[amriteighteen]

@jindashaheed

Raag Dhanaasaree, First Mehl:

gagan mai thaal rav chand deepak banay taarikaa mandal janak motee.

Upon that cosmic plate of the sky, the sun and the moon are the lamps. The stars and their orbs are the studded pearls.

Dhoop mal-aanlo pavan chavro karay sagal banraa-ay foolant jotee. ||1||

The fragrance of sandalwood in the air is the temple incense, and the wind is the fan. All the plants of the world are the altar flowers in offering to You, O Luminous Lord. ||1||

[jindashaheed]

1:43... If you knew anything about Dasam Granth Maryada, you'd know that one, it is kept lower than Guru Granth Sahib Ji, even if its just an inch, it much be lower, and in that video it is clear that it is lower. Second, Akhand Paath Sahib can only be done of Dasam Granth Sahib along with Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. When the Bhog is happening, First Guru Granth Sahib Ji's is done first, THEN Dasam Granth Sahib Ji's bhog can be done.

[rutpunjab]

bhakhi sikhs mafia of punjab propagating hindu mythas on khalsa panth.

I saw them going mute when the kanjar kavita in gurdwaras. Sham on these kache wale brahhmans

[sanjay20071]

i Dont understand some people.. ... Dasam Guru Granth sahib jee has dont nothing 2 any of you.... People go Straight for the way things are in there material forms... Have any of you actuall met any of the nihang jathedars?? NO.. Read maharaajs writtings... GET SANTHIYA READ DASAM AND LISTEN TO KATHA... The meanings are deeper than they appear.... All you bloody manmukhs go straight to whats written and not what it actually means.....

[MrPSingh81]

ki gal jijja nu pachan nahi sakea....baki rahi gal Tiger Group dee ....saram karo tusi 150 atte asi 5 fir vee tohade fancy dress wallen kutt kha ke gaye...zara menu us apne us veer da patta ley ki dasi jis de skull wich fracture ho gaya hai ....menu apnee vee pic bheg devee jai maa da dudd pitta hai te nalle patta lag jave ki asli jatt kaun hai Jara apna DNA check karva layee kitee Dhumme Dee Saat he na hove ..hahahahaah

Kalka Panth layee Sirdardi

Tiger Group

[MrPSingh81]

ki gal jijja nu pachan nahi sakea....baki rahi gal Tiger Group dee ....saram karo tusi 150 atte asi 5 fir vee tohade fancy dress wallen de dang ferri...zara menu us apne us veer da patta ley ki dasi jis de skull wich fracture ho gaya hai ....menu apnee vee pic bheg devee jai maa da dudd pitta hai te nalle patta lag jave ki asli jatt kaun hai Jara apna DNA check karva layee kitee Dhumme Dee Saat he na hove ..hahahahaah

Kalka Panth layee Sirdardi

Tiger Group

[MrPSingh1980]

By the way just few days back Prof Darshan Singh bowed down to Dasam Granth and stated he have few doubts but he is willing to get educated on it.

Yupe Truth is coming out. Finally.

[singhamaninder]

@MrPSingh1980

How do you come up with these false stories,Come out of your Kaalka wonderland.

[aman113]

@MrPSingh1980 you are one of the most phudu people i have seen on youtube you make up so much shit just to persuade people ahhha i fell pity for you man, why don't you carry on believing watever you want and leave the rest to make their own decision and furthermore you saw that straight away that this video is edited but you never saw that when pro darshan singh ji's video was edited

[MrPSingh1980]

@aman113

Where is the real video I've seen many bark that video is edited and how come the real version is not online here on youtube?

Fact is it will expose Darshan Ragi being your illlegal daddy.

[9nihal1]

that guy in the begining looks like a dam chore...khalsa ji stay away from these chores.

[MrPSingh1980]

only a fool would not see how this video is edited for false propoganda.

[MrPSingh81]

@MrPSingh1980

Film wich double role te vekhe san par ID wala double roll pehle war vekh reha hain.

Khote sher dee khal pa ke sher nahi ban jande....pass my message to all of kalka panti barahman...

Tohade laye sirdardi

Tiger Group UK

[MrPSingh1980]

lol only 111 views? people don't even bother with ur LIES

[jasssingh87]

veerji sach ta ik din samne aa hi jaaoga

Guru Sahib Kirpa Karan

[bodikutt]

khote da putter

Akar da andha

Sant da putter