Added: 4 years ago
From: enricogay
Views: 1,084,467
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,547)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • the acting is unbelievable.

  • This is unbelievable.

  • um yeah waaaaaaaay better then Lea Michele Sorry Gleeks But You Know Its True

  • @sarafranco100 I worship Lea Michele for life, but it's true. They are both amazing though.

  • The amazing voice of Barbra!

  • If you have not seen the movie Funny Girl go rent it right NOW Barbara is amazing!!

  • @Vivant22 I've had this movie at home for as long as i can remeber but never watched it. I just did, and....OMG! This just made my top ten list. I have never seen barbra more brilliant! It was in my eyes better than ''the way we were''. And thats a though one to beat!

  • Outstanding

  • she is so beautiful and has a beautiful voice !

  • Comment removed

  • I first heard this on glee and I had to come here. Listening to her she souds so beautiful and elegant. Thumbs Up if you listening to this in 2012!

  • No matter how many times I watch this I always get chills! <3

  • goosebumps.

  • "What's the diffrence if i say...." 2:01 <3

  • ♥_________________________♥

  • She's fantastic!

  • She's amazing!

  • If funny how people compare Rachel Berry/Lea Michele to Barbra.  Don't they know that Lea/Rachel idolizes Barbra? They're incomparable, and both brilliant in their own ways.

  • Hearing Barbra sing you can feel it in your soul in every inch of your body its like magic .

  • Just finished watching Funny Girl and I thought it was so sad at this part that I started to cry my eyes out!

  • i'll never get tired of this!! i just know! <3

  • i just like leas voice better

  • @wendaee The Glee fanboys and girls thinking that Lea can top Streisand in anything is absurd. Streisand is Streisand for a reason.

  • lea's version of this is more pleasing to the ears if you've never actually seen funny girl, because you wouldn't be able to tell how edited it is compared to this one. when barbra sang this, it was just raw and full of emotion. i mean, they both were, and i love both versions, but this one is just more natural.

  • @soccerchick418 amen. but if i could sing like either one of them i'd have no problems!

  • OMFG

  • @maggiehallua In order to properly appreciate Streisand's version, you need to watch the moie. The power with her version comes out of character. She isn't singing this as resell, like Lea Michele, but as Franny Brice.

  • And I thought Lea was good! Barbra I love you! Your fricken awesome!!

  • @cj4523

    Brings goosebumps! Close your eyes and listen. She's flawless. What a love song!

  • ...Rachel Berry beat barbara in this version...wow...never saw this coming...

  • @maggiehallua NO way! Never.

  • @laura030857 I'm sorry, i love barbara, but Lea's touched me far more

  • @maggiehallua If you love her, you could write her name properly! :-)

  • @maggiehallua Lea Michele can't beat her because she imitates her.

  • @Sharleen974 Yes, but i feel Barbara sings it with to much vibrato, it grates on me.

  • JoJo brought me here and i don't regret it!!!

  • the glee girl is good, but holy shitty shit, I'm listening Streisand for the first time... and it's just perfect .

  • @MrChinesecrested ... hinayupak ka kung sino ka man p_ta ka... barbra is the best..period

  • @MrChinesecrested Are you freaking serious? You need to wake up from this weird world of yours....

  • @MrChinesecrested I don't know if you're a stupid troll or an ignorant fool.

  • @MrChinesecrested

    She is beautiful. Her nose is part of her voice. Her instrument. You need a hearing aid as you're tone deaf.

  • Don't worry. In ten years, no one will remember Lea Michele's version. Barbra is eternal. And that's come from me who spend all my free time watching Glee.

  • she is a amazing singer but there will be new people like christina aguilera omg she can hit a note and lady gaga also demi lovato and more....

  • I love lea but... theres no way to top barbara, its just not possible.

  • Love it!!!

  • Although her voice is obviously fantastic, I think the performance she gives is massively out of sinc with the apparent meaning of the song. The Regina Spektor version seems much more pathetic and resigned to her fate as someone who is with a man who treats her badly, even though she knows this she stays with him. Streisand seems too powerful and independant, too busy trying to show us how well she can sing.

  • @fillap01 If you watch the movie (or at least the scene of the final meeting with her ex husband in her dressing room right before this clip starts) you'll see that she actually did interpret this really well. She's singing about a relationship that she's finally found the strength to end - this scene is when she turns her grief over the failed marriage into confidence in her ability to carry on as a performer.

  • @donphillipe81 How can you say that! She is so beautiful and talented. I bet you can never be better than Barbra so stop HATING!!!

  • @prettypeach11234 Shut up you motherfucking piece of shit!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @donphillipe81 you cant be her thats why u say that right!

  • Omg she is shit as

  • quit the "hatin" crap for a minute, im heartbroken and this song is my life in this moment, i dont care whos singin it

  • She is so beautiful and amazing so Amazing! I love her ever since I was 8 and now I'm 11 and she is still one my Idols!

  • @prettypeach11234 You're funny. Talking like there were a very long time between 8 and 11. It's pretty much the same age. Sorry, you ll'understand that when you're my age. By the way, i'm happy that new generations can appreciate Barbra.

  • I have been a tremendous fan of this woman for most of my life. I've listened to EVERY song she's ever sung, and NOTHING compares to the sheer power and emotion of her performance here. It literally takes my breath away.

  • How do i get rid of these goosebumps?

    

  • LOVE BARBRA!

  • If you don't like how she sounds GTFO! She is amazing.

  • The bitch sounds like a fuckin goat, I can't believe she's famous for her voice.

  • @ichbineincoolcat Lol. she DOES sound like a goat..

  • Lea Michele is a fine singer. Streisand has that certain something that very few have, such as Judy Garland, Liza Minnelli, which is, AMAZING FUCKING STAR POWER!!!!!!!!!!!!! That is something you have naturally, you don't learn or acquire it. The afore mentioned have FUCKING MEGA KICK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • god this song

  • Love this song, I always sing it when I have a sad day <3

  • SHE'S JUST SO GOOD. Every nuance of this song...I watch it and keep saying "oh yeah, when her voice does that, that's my favorite!" but then she does something else even more amazing. There's just no one like Barbra.

  • Trivia - The director wanted Streisand to sing to a prerecorded track through the entire song (usual practice for musicals). However she pushed to be able to sing the first part live since it would let her be in the moment. The first part is so powerful that way. And you can hear the prerecorded track kick in on the second half of the song! Thx Babs

  • When Barbra sings, you feel it inside you.

    It builds up and just makes you want to cry because its so beautiful.

  • Thumbs Up if you watched this to see why Rachel Berry liked it to find out that this one's CLASSIC!

  • @babyvocalist OBVIOUSLY!!!!!!!!

  • she is killer with this love that all of us have feltlllllll

  • Wow :0,shes freaken awesome! :D But i feel bad for her though :( Shes about to burst into tears.

  • LOVE THE WAY HOW THE MUSIC BEAT BACKROUND BREAKS DOWN AT " WHEN I KNOW I COME BACK ON MY KNEES SOMEDAY"

  • Comment removed

  • Beautiful song , In my opinion whoever sings it makes it their own , but this is a personal favourite, just so gripping.

  • FUCK ALL HATERS! LOVE YOU BARBRA!!!!!

  • @blueeyes61553 Haters? Didn't you know that who disliked this video has 41 more fake youtube accounts?

  • Comment removed

  • I love Barbra but this version is not a spot on the Original by Fanny Brice

  • i love you barbra!

  • oh. my. god. I'm literally bawling. This woman will be like Shakespeare hundreds of years from now. FLIPPING FAMOUS AS HECK.

  • just WOW!

  • FUCKING AMAZING

  • She has an amazing voice!

  • Je l'ai tellement dans la peau, j'en suis dingo !

  • I seriously just got the chills. Barbra Streisand a stunning performer!

  • This is my all time favorite movie, barbra is genius

  • faut quand même avouer que la première moitié de la chanson est pénible ^^ mais oui, la fin est splendide !

  • There is no contest; Barbara is BOTH better at singing and acting out the song than Lea, the fact that Barbara sang this in one take & live (no pre-recording, except for the first part) just shows to further prove my point... Also we all know that Lea (not just her character Rachel) wishes she were just as good as Barbara.

  • @sgssunshine02 I don´t understand why you actually bother to explain these things to ignorants...let them live their little lives

  • @sgssunshine02 Why compare? Lea Michele is amazing - one of the best singers of this generation. Don't be a dick

  • <3

  • me gusta mas la version de lea

    

  • OMG lea and barbra are unique, are very talented with amazing voices no one can match

  • I Love both of the version´s Lea and Barbra´s

  • barbara's better at acting it out, lea's better at singing it

  • @cristinarose009 i know

  • she is absolutly without a doubt AMAZING !!!!!

  • love the way she said "what's the difference if i say" 2:01

  • at first i thought lea's version was better until the end when i was amazed! go Barbra!!

  • She starts out weak and fragile and as she gains momentum, she blows it out of the water.

  • Simply beautiful!

    I really wish Judy Garland could've done a cover of this though... not sure why her over anyone else, but I'm sure she would've been magnificent

  • i wish i'd grown up with people like this influencing me. she's incredible in every sense of the word. i find it refreshing to have someone not classically beautiful (though undeniably stunning in their own right) become a star, purely because of their talent and not because of rich family or 'the right look'. barbra is, and always will be, and inspiration to me, but i wish we had more true artists like her around nowadays.

  • love barbra. LA AMO!

  • perfection . i wish i can have her vocals MAN!

  • she makes it seem so easy :)

    i love her && lea's version. ♥

  • I was a toddler when I learned the entire Funny Girl soundtrack, LOL, my mother originally wanted to sing opera and then she wanted to be Barbara Striesand (with a 4 octave voice she did a pretty good imitation :-) I guess you could say I attended the Barbara Streisand school of voice as a child. Feel so sorry for young singers who have NO decent influences to emulate. And I LOVE Leah Michelle! How refreshing to hear a young girl who has taste and a REAL voice instead of Katy (auto-tune) Perry!

  • Sadly, I know exactly how this feels - it's probably a good thing my man and I have never actually been together.

  • She looks like the new girl in Glee. The one who can't sing. Ironic. O.o

  • Barbara Streisand looks like the evil sister in Pride and Prejudice (2003). :/

  • this ending scene in Funny Girl was superb. goosebumps all over and watery eyes.

    i was so born in the wrong decade.

  • The title of this video should be changed to: "How to win an Oscar in 2:38" :)

  • @MissMiffed The title should be how to suck at singing and sound like a fuckin goat.

  • @ichbineincoolcat What the hell is wrong with you?

    She has one of the best ranges in music history, there's a reason people call her legendary.

  • @ChemblieandCheese Are you kidding me? I try sooo hard to like her, but her voice is just so mediocre. Nothing special at all.

  • @ichbineincoolcat ganon... sige nga kumanta ka... sinong special sa yo? give me a singer that will be more special than her... putatsina ka

  • @ChemblieandCheese You can't say her voice is amazing, it's average if anything.

  • @ichbineincoolcat I can say that until you can find someone in her era with the same natural range.

  • @ChemblieandCheese Given she may have been the best of her era, but she can't compare to todays standards.

  • @ichbineincoolcat Mostly because by today's standards, you have to be auto-tuned to sound any good. 

  • @ichbineincoolcat THAT SOUNDS WHAT YOU LIKE TO DO.FUCK GOATS AND SUCK GOAT COCK YA DUMB ASS!!!

  • @ichbineincoolcat Hmm. Maybe when you decide to use your own witty comments to stage an argument, I might just give you the time of day. Until then, go and get a taste in music.

  • Fuck that glee when streisand is singing.

  • I was fifteen when I first watched this, and when she came out and sang this, I was literally shaking with tears. I couldn't keep them in.

  • Vocally. The arrangement. Perfection.

  • She has so much emotional depth when she sings... it's absolutely amazing. She gives me chills.

  • Superb. Simply superb. I've grown up listening to this legend, but is so happy that glee is providing an outlet to encourage young artists and people who simply love good music to stars like this. Barbra forever <3

  • Dumn Glee fans think they know anything about music because they see it on Glee... Ok. Let's move on and admire this song just because it's Barbra. Why the hell do you have to discuss about that Glee girl here?

  • Maybe her finest moment.

  • No one comes close to Streisand. She is a performing genius in a class all by herself. Amazing.

  • Oh my god.

  • This is unbelievable!

  • Beautiful.

  • AMAZING!!!!!!!!!

  • Let me explain this to you unmusical boobs:

    Fanny Brice's recording was a square arrangement in a higher key; she was a soprano, not a belter.

    Streisand's is TOTALLY DIFFERENT; different key; different arrangement (more 1960's, for better and worse); she alters the melody line; she growls; she changes the rhythm, etc. In other words, she interprets it; makes it her own.

    Lea's version is....well...EXACTLY THE SAME as Streisand's. That's not being an artist, that's basically karaoke.

  • @nickplasia Are you dumb? It´s a TV show about a glee club doing covers, of course it´s gonna sound the same, it´s suppoesed to. It´s not Lea Michele CD doing My Man, is RACHEL BERRY doing My Man on GLEE

  • @boomynameisboo1 You want people who can sing better than Lea? You got it:

    Laura Benanti, Jennifer Holliday, Kristen Chenoweth, Jennifer Hudson, Sutton Foster, Betty Buckley, Karen Olivo, Janet Dacal, Donna Murphy, young Liza Minnelli (around Cabaret), Sierra Boggess, Carolee Carmello... the list goes on.

    Singing-wise, Lea is more like a 7/10, especially for a Broadway star (which she is). Her voice is slightly nasal, and she has an incredibly forced belt, if indeed she has one at all.

  • Gorgeous. Pure talent. I have to admit, i did watch funny girl at first cause of glee, but I'm happy, cause I was introduced to this awesome song.

  • 1:57 I love her voice at "all riiiiight"!

  • This is the thing you sing, alone, in your shower, with your soap, while your conditioner sets. Seriously. Get that tone deaf sound going, fling your arms wide, oh yes, it doesn't matter how awful you actually sound, it's awesome while you're doing it! Thank you Barbra for making us feel like stars! <3

  • @MommaFairy28 ROFL!  I did that this morning!

    "Oh my man I LOVE HIM SO"

    --cats yowling--

    --dogs howling--

    --squirrels running away--

    But it doesn't matter--when we do it we hear Barbra in our heads!

  • I prefer Diana Ross doing this song... I do love Babs though :)

  • Glee just doesn't make me cry like Strei Strei. Barbra is the closest thing to heaven that we have on earth

  • IDK why everyones comparing and downing lea when SHES AN ACTRESS/SINGER PLAYING A GIRL WHO IDOLIZES BARBRA SO OF COURSE ALMOST EVERY OTHER SONG SHES GONNA SING IN THE SHOW WILL BE A BARBRA SONG. Doesnt mean shes trying to top her (besides barbra's up there with chuck norris can't top her)... its called inspiration people go find some maybe it will keep you from spending your life bad mouthing ppl with talent ...that is all.

  • I love glee, but I watched Barbra because I've loved her forever.

  • I watched funny girl yesterday (because of Glee <3). I loved it! ♥

  • This is why calling people like Rebecca Black or the Pussycat Dolls 'singers' is insulting. This is singing. This is amazing.

  • this song s addicting either way. i love leas version because her voice is so clean and pure, but barbra is just pure genious.

  • When I was little I watched Funny Girl, Singing in the Rain, and Annie all the time. That's real talent. All we have today are people like Kesha and Lil Wayne... Makes me sad.

  • @SaraBear2011 That's the most legit comment ever!

  • I truly love both Barbra and Lea's versions. I think that Barbra's acting is better but I like both versions equally. Also remember that Lea is a bit younger then Barbra was at the time she sang this song though. I really love Lea but Barbra is still better, for now ;) 

  • I will get chills everytime I hear this song.

    No matter how many times I listen to it.

  • Why not just comment on the video rather than post about Barbra vs Lea? It takes way too much away from the video and I hate it and I hate myself for commenting on that, but it's getting ridiculous. Stop thumbing up people's comments about Lea on Barbra's videos. Just let it go already.

    Barbra, you amaze me. You will forever this right here. When someone says Barbra this is exactly what I think of. Right here. Perfection.

  • Both Barbra and Lea are superb, and I really really love both versions of this song.

  • @tennshaun Me too, they are both amazing but Barbra.... She's more than amazing, i can't even describe it in words...

  • She's sooooo pretty ;A;

  • Haha. Anybody who is here only because some broad from Glee did this song isn't worthy of making an opinion about this wonderful singer's performance.

    Fads will come and go, Barbra is forever.

  • The highest form of compliment is when another singer sings your music. There is no question there is only 1 Barbra. Lea Michele is fabulous however, Lea shows her love for Barbra on her own personal social media, not just because the producers of Glee pick music for her to sing. Lea has a very long career.

  • :' ))))))

  • i like this version dont get me wrong but i prefer lea michele's:).

  • Att hoppa till söta du som skulle hoppa till fula mej ,jag tycker du är både vacker och en bra skådespelerska

  • Que bello tema!!!!

  • Yes both lea and barbra song it beautiful but billie holidays full version of this song was haunting and in my opinion had more feeling and the edith plath version mon homme is fantastic peggy lee's version focused more on the musical accompaniment but i personally enjoy the way she gave a different feeling to the song rather than fight about if lea or babra was better listen to all the versions not just the ones you heard about on glee

  • Stunning.

  • Barbra, I love you and you are my idol. I'm only 14 and I love you to death!

  • I love Barbra AND Lea. I thought both of their versions of this song were phenomenal.

  • Yes, there's something about Barbra... Not only is she supremely talented– all around– but she is also an icon, which is unaffordable no matter the talent... However, no one, NO ONE– not even of Streisand's stature– can beat the Billie Holiday rendition. Despite all these emotive histrionics of Streisand's, Holiday is just much more convincing... by just her superbly original sound alone... I'm sorry to all the Bab's fans, Billie is just one icon Ms. Streisand cannot surpass...

  • i love barbra...she's the best

  • yup, this performance brought tears

  • wow she's got ugly since

  • Barbra is and always will be my favorite artists she has inspired me in so many ways with my music and with my heart. She is so strong. And gave me hope in all her movies. Her voice is always spectacular and I think we could all learn something from her. Never give up hope even when the people you love go away I'm sure that even if you don't think so that they will always love you and everything happens for a reason! I love you Barbra and God bless you all of you :)