Barcarolle - Anna Netrebko & Elina Garanca - Offenbach Barcarola

[gougoune45]

quel est le site où il faut se connecter pour connaître l'actualité et les concerts d'ELINA GARANCA ?

Merci.

[gougoune45]

quelle date cette vidéo ?

[gougoune45]

quelle date cette vidéo ?

[JHIMATSU]

BELLISSIMO !

[gospelena]

Очень красиво звучащий дуэт!!!

[jaegerzaun]

Demütig niederknien und dem lieben Herrgott, Wien und den beiden Damen sowie dem Orchester danken dies erleben zu dürfen...!

[noopsakamrrat]

sin palabras! bohemic! prevoschodno! wunderbar! magnifique! chudovo! no words existing for this...

[pati0707]

mi soprano favorita... mi mezo favorita.... que maravillas hacen juntas.... me parece estar en el cielo.... son ángeles....

[RobboDandrea]

Beautiful, Sublime

[MRSMonkeyjunkie]

wunderschön !

[ChataignerJacques]

Cette interprétation est particulièrement réussie, les chanteurs servent ce thème de douce folie, sans essayer de se mettre en avant, c'est ça l'art véritable qui grandit les interprètes.

Merci pour ce charme.

[Yolandahanachornelia]

beautiful voices and instruments. is there anyone who have this score?

[aniellotama83]

perfezione !

[YTErwin1]

Absolutely perfect!

[retlokisnon]

melancholy booster. stendhal syndrome to the bone.

[gabrielavasila]

Nice:) Interesting, in the place, where they both singing unisono in the middle register you can hear almost only Elina:)) Hear is a real example of different tipe voices:)

[inniespace1]

two of the very best, and when they sing together, it's just simply amazing ...

[hockeywifeca]

Thank-you for this! I adored Anna in Anna Bolena. She is such a talent and a real beauty who exhibits grace at every turn!

[pinomarra43]

brave e belle

[13Bellamusica]

So wonderful music to lissen to! Nice voices and beautiful singers!

[zombie2093]

IM WRITING THIS TO GET THE ATTENTION OF THE INTELLIGENT PEOPLE LISTENING TO INTELLIGENT MUSIC, IM ASKING MAKE THE INTELIGENT CHOICE FOR PRESIDENT

VOTE RON PAUL.

I IMAGINE LAKME IS WHAT I HEAR WHEN I PASS THOSE PEARLY GATES SOMEDAY

IT REALLY MAKES YOUR SOUL FLY!!

VOTE RON PAUL!!

[Liu666able]

Good looking both them but awful singers

[Astraea52]

I'm a fan of both women! Does Garanca have her hand over her left ear, to block Netrebko out a little?

[washandwatcher]

pobresitas náidien les aplaudió *snif snif* ;( elina se rifa como las champions y aparte está requete biútiful. miamor.

[MrDarknesslover]

Elina the best

[gougoune45]

@MrDarknesslover  yessssss !!!

[AntiSocialChannel85]

Nice couple, if you know what i mean.

[loeillot]

Elina ist Assoluta - schön aber auch, daß sich Anna wirklich Mühe gibt.

[YTErwin1]

@loeillot

Interessant, Sie auch hier zu finden. In einem Punkt sind wir uns hier einig. Elina ist erstklassig. Aber wenn ich höre, Anna gibt sich wirklich Mühe, komme ich nicht mehr mit. Ich hoffe inständig, Ihr Urteil bezieht sich ausschließlich auf die gesanglichen Fähigkeiten und nicht auf die Optik der Damen.

Beste Grüße

[jaegerzaun]

...zum niederknien schön!!

[gdalmaso1]

veramente bello.......

[twitashata]

It's so beautiful! My favorite duet - Anna and Elina, their voices sound so harmoniously and sublime.

[Racz8609]

JAAAJ, DE SZERELMES LETTEM :(

[iberianflower]

So beautiful...

[MrMusikkenner]

2 Wunderschöne Damen. Und singen können sie auch-auf höchsten Level.

[shimonros1]

The beauty of their voice and the gentleness move us to the highest level joy.

[richard041776]

¡SE ESCAPARON DEL CIELO!

[stevevasta]

I hate to be (apparently) the only dissenter, but I'm not impressed. The singing is certainly pretty -- I do like the shine on Netrebko's voice in all this upper-middlish tessitura -- but it didn't move me at all. And it puzzles me that Garanca's voice, like many other ostensible mezzos', gets so husky and diffuse as it descends -- the one extremely low phrase is barely there.

I suspect Caballe and Horne will be more my speed...!

[Whistlejocket]

@stevevasta they sound like two old hoarse chickens!

[Racz8609]

BELÉTEK SZERETTEM :)

[janpi27800]

je sais maintenant que les anges existent .... !

[dkalokeri]

BRAVO!!! EXCELLENT PERFORMANCE!!!!

[lespetitesdalles]

Le plus beau passage de l'oeuvre d'Offenbach. Divinement interprété

[elcheco81]

no se mucho de este tipo de musica pero de solo escuchar estas voces se me hace la piel de gallina. exxeellenteee.

[GuilhemHB]

Je ne m'en passe pas ...

[leptbreton]

Perfect! Thats all that needs to be said...........and thankyou.

[MrKonstantin46]

Блестящая работа и музыкантов, и дирижера, и ,конечно, певиц! Как внимательно они следят за дирижером, как умеют и слушать другого, и с абсолютным слухом, вести свою партию в этой прекрасной баркаролле!

[xvoy2002]

All i can say is WOW! BRAVO!

[mimigrenouille2003]

Je m'en lasse pas...

[sachmetixchel]

sus voces se combinan perfectamente... tienen un parecido en el color, como si fueran de la misma gamma.

[fritzwolff71]

This performance has all the hallmarks of truly professional attention to their calling as musicians....watch them. They are listening to each other, watching the conductor, listening to themselves to stay on perfect pitch, and doing exactly what is required to make something look easy that is incredibly difficult. This duet can be a mess without this wonderful attention to detail.

[ams228]

Fabulous blend of voices. Thank you for the post.

[ANONIMESP]

Perfect voices for this song.

[ilike2shagu]

Quite beautiful!

[MicaelaPalla]

The two most beautiful women in opera!!! love them so much

[RONENNAVE8]

שירת המלאחים =כנפיים

[lolithefreak]

WOOOW! this is the version that was in La Vita e bella right??

AWESOMENESS!

[starkissP]

BEAUTIFUL!!!

[MrZeitun]

Totally beautiful. Refined. Who is the conductor? He deserves credit, too.

Singio, à part critiquer la diction française des interprètes, vous auriez des choses intéressantes à nous dire? La musique, par exemple? Quant à votre commentaire en passant sur le français d'Angela Gheorghiu, il tient du grotesque. Elle a une des meilleures dictions françaises qu'on puisse trouver parmi les sopranos non-françaises. Bref, votre commentaire, c'est le grand n'importe quoi.

[edgar24na]

Belloooooooooooooooooooooooooo­oooooooooooooooooooooo!!!!!!

[wodisi]

Die beiden mögen sich aber nicht gerade?!

[operafan0anegnd]

Very beautiful and very moving. Brava Anna. Brava Elina.

Hope I never get crazy enough to care about what Elina,

or any one else, does with her hands while singing. :)

Good to see there are still a small number of people,

who actually listen to music to appreciate it and the

vocal and artistic talents of the performers.

Regrettably, many give the impression that they have very defective

ears and brains. No need to advertise it.

[tarinou49]

Magnifique !

[aschlamba]

Seelenlos!

[JDAeon]

Ah Beautiful duet - "Belle Nuit" a.k.a. Barcarolle - Les Contes d'Hoffmann by Offenbach... Anna & Elina are beautiful and gifted Goddesses!!! I love their fine work!

[bbcunique]

ive watched Barcaloa 20+ diff tubes this is the best would like to no  Barcorolla one l or two??

[Janaaa36]

...neither of them seems to be enjoying it! This song is supposed to celebrate the beauty of love, but they just seem to be doing their job. Their singing is flawless, but if there's no feeling to it, it appears that there's little point to it :(

[MsHeidi2010]

@Janaaa36 Yeah but that looks more like a practice than an actual performance.. You have to focus on getting it right before you can rock it out with emotion dude

[singio100]

On atteint des sommets ! Elles savent que c'est du français qu'elles chantent ou du polonais ! ???? Pire que la Georghiu quand elle se risque dans notre langue !!!!!!

[gougoune45]

@singio100 pourquoi cette remarque ?

[fFeartheDarkness]

wow....call of the sirens..

[veeerooniicaaa]

Muy lindo

[bodiloto]

canto freddo... espressione sotto 0.

livello scuola media.

[jorgegs41]

The duet is as good as that of Sutherland and Horne's professional and magnificent voices!!! Bravo...

[MrCanel66]

Squisita canzone d'amore n_n

[babooom69]

simply stunning

[sadella]

Their duets are always absolutely incredible. Two great voices, and such a beautiful harmony, such an wonderful final result.

[MrAndredekock]

They blend really beautifully, like the duo of Sutherland and Horne.

[VIRIATO1942]

The melody is absolutely beautiful. The voices are great. What a great operatic piece of art. So romantic.

[numnumcherry]

@LeMaestro123 Elina is actually considered one of the best opera singers in the world right now. She squeezes her ear shut to block out the other singer's voice so she could take a precise tone.

[hswatnik]

very enjoyable clip- thank you!

[tubista44]

Who cares if she touches her whole body!!!! She has the most incredible voice and never misses a note.

[tjakko29]

the jewel of the crown

[danielmedeiros81]

haha...all discussion was about putting the hand on the ear...actually, this was more a gesture of interpretation than to really hear herself..I think she was touching her neck...at least the 1st time that she touched, the fingers were really low...unless her ears are on the right side of her neck..haha...this songs talks about love, kiss, tenderness....

[hwlauer]

die beste baccarole einfach super von anna u. elina

[elzicsfarewell]

@LeMaestro123 Dwayne Croft obviously isn't a professional either, then. Neither is Anne-Sophie van Otter, Cecilia Bartoli, or Thomas Quasthoff. What amateurs.

[NART65]

@LeMaestro123 Thank god there are professionals like you about to show these silly singers how to do it properly. Thank god for your indepth knowledge and extreme talent.

[cundrite]

Big fat and ugly professionnal...

[edgardodeklamery]

benvenuti al festival dell'afonia...forse colpa della patata in bocca che usano entrambe...

[ilaimelui]

they do so in order to hear themselves better, to be sure to get the right note in the right tone. It is especially helpful when two or more singers don't sing in unison. Indeed it is hard not to sing the way the other singers do.

[egarrulo]

Why do sometimes singers touch their ears? Like Garanca does near the end. Anybody knows? Thanks.

[rick2853]

@egarrulo When you have a hand or finger over an ear, it allows you to hear yourself better, and therefore fix any intonation problems :)

[MrProteux]

I'm fall in love with both of this girls!!!

[bodiloto]

@BenjaminFonseca ahahahahahahahahahahahah vedi che il tuo italiano é migliore del mio ahahahahahahahahah fai dei progressi ahahahahahahahahahah

Io ti dico amico e tu mi insulti?ahahahahahahahahahah

Ti parlo con simpatia e tu mi insulti?ahahahahahahahahahah

Adesso capisco,in Mexico per dire buongiorno e come stai tu usi le stesse parole...ahahahahahahahahah

Ti avevo detto che i tuoi commenti sono pieni di insulti?...

ahahahahahahahahahahah

Parli in questo modo anche con Netrebko?!?!?

Coraggio

[lclarke51]

La defaite d'Adowa a rempli le rangs des castrati italiens. Grand malheur! Les six mille morts qui ont fourni de quoi manger aux braves de Menelek aurait aussi pu faire la Gloire de la Botte Italienne!

[bodiloto]

@lclarke51 cioè ?

[bodiloto]

@BenjaminFonseca amico,il tuo inglese é perfetto così...ahahahahahahahahahahaha­hahah

Nella vita e meglio di scherzare e ridere che di offendere,credimi!

E poi tu parli spagnolo,questo vuol dire che capisci che voglio dirti...

Ciao amico.

[bodiloto]

@BenjaminFonseca Questo non é vero! Leggi i tuoi commenti dove parli con insulti alla gente innocente!

Leggi !

[bodiloto]

@BenjaminFonseca

Tu non parli della lirica con la gente,tu parli per dire insulti.

Mi permetti un consiglio con amicizia vai dal dottore,vai e pensa alla tua salute!

Ma perché insulti quasi tutti?!?!? Ti senti meglio così?

Hai dei problemi?Allora perché devi insultare tutta questa gente innocente e straniera dei tuoi problemi?

Peccato che non capisci l'italiano,il mio commento era amichevole...

Tu insulti,io preferisco di scherzare,credo che ridere é migliore per la salute.

Ciao

[bodiloto]

@BenjaminFonseca E chi diavolo sei TU?Come TI permetti di aggredire quasi tutti nascondendo TI dietro il tuo ordinatore? TU sei violento e non rispetti nessuno!Qua grazie al sistema democratico di YT ascoltiamo la bella musica e sopratutto parliamo della lirica senza offendere!Se non capisci qualcosa e se non hai una buona educazione( come é il caso) vai à scuola e IMPARA!

I tuoi commenti mostrano che sei un maleducato!

Perché non leggi tuoi commenti pieni di insulti?cambia lo stile,se puoi...

[Barneymum]

Grainsurlaplag: it's the same. x

[Grainsurlaplage]

@Barneymum I know... if i said so it was rhetorical...

[Barneymum]

English please??



[bodiloto]

@BenjaminFonseca tu non hai orecchio,Dio non e stato molto generoso con te..

Sei aggressivo con tantissimi youtubers... la ragione?

Della lirica non capisci nulla.

Vai da dottore e chiedi una protesi uditiva...

[shayrobbins]

Prooves that some angels are walking with us.

[asizoasizo]

thank you



[Grainsurlaplage]

Reminds me La vite e bella ^^

[Barneymum]

@Grainsurlaplage it's the same.



[Barneymum]

Did the cameraman fancy Elina most - his shots are 80% her and not Anna. What's that all about....

[pinelopipopi]

@Barneymum en même temps, elle a pas l'air très en forme Anna. (et je ne dis pas vocalement)

[Maggielicious21]

@Barneymum there's nothing wrong about it

[goknur1977]

Beautiful!

[marilyhot]

grandes mundos. maravilhosas e belas mulheres.

[rayclentchris]

Wow! There voices blend together so well! Are they from the same region?

[MrEltonMelo]

Simply wonderful! Congratulations! La Vita è bella!

[micflor531313]

Because of Youtube I've listened to more opera than I have in years. 

[hugo68422]

I think Netrebko is more attractive than Angelina Jolie.

[PatateRoussoiste]

@hugo68422 Without make-up, both are horrible.

[hugo68422]

Thing of beauty.

[kitchavez]

So beautifully done. It brought a tear to my eye. A happy tear!

[Kafa58]

einfach nur klasse!

[prayforworldpeace]

Bla Bla Bla....

Just listen.....

hehe.

[LaIraRavenous]

@BenjaminFonseca no me enoje XD! (re tarde)

[jfsanin]

Nice women, nice voices, today they are in the summit and I hope they can keep there for ever.

[luladiosa24]

Esta versión no puede ser mejor!!! Totalmente hermosa!

[urbic69]

Tremendamente bello

[gruposentimiento]

dos voces preciosas y ensamblan maravillosamente.. juntas marcan una diferencia de todo lo que he podido escuchar!!! hermoso y la canción no tiene desperdicio

[funusdei]

Ante la belleza de estas voces, la hermosura de estas mujes y la genialidad de Offenbach las palabras son inútiles!...

[Milylily4Ever]

ambas son hermosas!!! y tienen voces diferentes pero juntas elina hace que netrebko parezca una diva...sin ella no se escucharia iwal...elina es magnifica

[oihanen]

Hahaha, Garanca with her finger in her ear and those sideways looks at Netrebko made me laugh out loud!

And Elina Garanca is not ugly! Shame on the person who said that. Just because she has a lower voice, don't be fooled into thinking she looks like a man. She is gorgeous!

[geutzaMstrajeru]

they are both beautifoul and best in singing...

[bodiloto]

Chi é la mezzo Netrebko?

Chi é la soprano Garanca?

mistero...

[lheoinferno]

@bodiloto

Netrebko = Soprano

Garanca = Mezzo

[bodiloto]

@lheoinferno

Netrebko = soprano lirico un po'ingolato

Garanca =soprano che canta come mezosoprano

[mariusfelix]

@bodiloto bodiloto = typical youtube-expert

[bodiloto]

@mariusfelix io?ahahahahahahahahahahah

Non sono esperto di canto,sono esperto di boxe...ahahahahahahahahahahah

ero campione 3 volte.

Vado a teatro dal 1958...

In due anni ho visto più di 300 recite...e lei?

[bodiloto]

@mariusfelix capisco bene il tuo gusto raffinato,anch'io apprezzo molto la voce di Netrebko e anche come donna mi piace,purtroppo con la sua tecnica non farà grandi miracoli nella sua vita se non trova un maestro di canto italiano... per la cinema americana ve bene,l'unica cosa e che e un po' tardi... ma non fa niente...

Anche Garanca e una bella donna e ha una bella voce del soprano corto...

[bodiloto]

@lheoinferno 2 la voce della mezzosoprano non esiste piú...

[numetutelare]

@bodiloto ahahaha.. esilarante, e se fossero solo due diverse falcon, magari un po' corte???In effetti due soprani veri come la Freni e la Scotto in questa incisione avevano un colore ' un timbro ed una intensità più marcata di queste due. Speriamo che il futuro non sia questo...

[bodiloto]

@numetutelare ancora un bellissimo commento!

Lei è dalla professione!

Apprezzo moltissimo i suoi commenti.

Dal vivo se mi ricordo bene soprano corto era la Tebaldi,ma questa Signora conosceva lo stile e negli anni 50 era una attrice meravigliosa...

Netrebko ha una bella voce e ha acuti,purtroppo canta alla russa,perde l'appoggio e squillo-la chiave per registro acuto.

Garanca é uno soprano corto,chi sa un giorno canterà Aida ma... per Aida ci vuole la giusta tecnica,e cuore...

[SgtOBrien]

Absolutely one piece of music which belongs to the sweetest tunes that were ever written in (music) history. Very wonderful interpretation. I think in heaven it does sound like that, too.

[theacorpse]

Sublime.

[LaIraRavenous]

WTF? in 2:04 you look at her face and thats all you seee but at 2:05 she is suddenly with her hand in her ear o.o

[dnmurphy48]

@LaIraRavenous WEll spotted. I have watched this numerous times and never noticed that. I guess this is numerous takes edited together for the best effect. Still sound wonderful to me though.

[MARISOLDELMONACO]

Extraordinarias voces

[SugarTomAppleRoger]

These two sure ain't exactly innocent flower maidens...

[finalmentis]

wunderbares Duett...

...gleichermassen wunderbare Sängerinnen (...auch visuell..)

[prescreption]

Vielen Dank für diesen großartigen, berührenden Clip!!

[scargo1013]

the best.

[nanard111]

M A G N I F Q U E!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!