Added: 5 years ago
From: PlaidFox
Views: 306,306
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (203)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • no sound???? why???

  • Dude look up on youtube "get audio back on youtube" you enter some code and you get it back! :D

  • It's so sad how music companies terrorise this platform and delete songs.

    Once the will be nothing left in here but damn marriage videos and clips of pets and babies falling on their butts.

    Fuck!

  • this video is awesome! I was able to play it with another song vid. I'm sorry about the copyright issue.

  • so richtig scheiße

  • would've been 10 times better with the song, great images used tho :)

  • would've been 10 times better with the song, great images used tho :)

  • There's no sound! Excellent picures.

  • Great video, definitely one of the better 'We Didn't Star the Fire' timeline vids. Too bad about the sound, although it was easy enough to sync it with my own copy of the song. I love that you continued onto more recent events at the end! It gave me chills. The fire really never ends, does it?

  • where's the sound?!...

  • if saddam hussain was hung for war crimes, then why isnt george bush?

  • I like the extra stuff at the end. Very nice!

  • Yeah. Many good ideas for events if we were to add onto the song. Today, that would have to include Haiti, Pelosi, Obama, Bank Failures, and a whole bunch of other stuff.

  • most accurate use of photos yet...

  • :36 looks like Jim Halpert from the office

  • I just watched it while playing the music from a different one haha yours was good :]

  • Fuck copy right!

  • fire stop yahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh­hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh­hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh­hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh­hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh­hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh­hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh­hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh­hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh­hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh­hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh­hh

  • ben 10 heatblast suck

  • darn

  • your vid doesnt have ANY SOUND!!!

  • @madwallwriter COPYRIGHT TOOK IT OFF

  • this is really slow it is inching its way to the end

  • YOUR VIDEO HAS NO SOUND.

  • STUPID YOUTUBE CENSORS

  • yes youtube got rid of the sound but micah9639its their site they can do what what they will with it still pissed though

  • Did YouTube kill the sound on this? Why?

  • are there any versions of this song on youtube with sound this is the 4th one without sound or is my computer broken

  • yeah know sound

  • I like this song a lot:)

    Sehr goot!

  • idiot where is the sound

  • It's not his fault. Youtube has done it to a lot of videos about this osng.

  • i have 2 do a scrapbook bout this song!!

  • Hey!!!!!! Where's the @#$@43@%$%# sound!!!

  • Youtube removed it they been doing that to the we didnt start the fire vids, its sad oh well.

  • for serious?

  • i cant even see the vid. it wont load

  • Why are songs being muted?

  • They're censoring the net  nooooooooooooooo!

  • yeah whatever happened to our basic rights. Someone should point out youtube is infringing peoples basic rights to the government

  • that sucked! I assume you were trying to put a song in it . I gave you 3 stars for the effort.

  • what're you talking about? youtube blocked the sound out... something about copyright and whatnot. it somehow caused the video to lag, too. it was actually a really amazing video before they screwed it up

  • oh, sorry. You should repost it. Check out mine

  • Another audio block. Let me guess, they made no attempt to let you know, right?

    I had the same thing happen to me. What I'm doing (And I suggest you do it to) is reposting my video every time they block the audio. Eventually, they would have to say something.

    So repost. Don't give up. Fight for a good cause. Start a revolution. Solve world hunger. Stop Global Warming! Save the Whales! Help the Homeless!...Okay, maybe not quite that much. But at least people will see your video with audio.

  • ok dude you r friggin everywhere every we didn'y start the fire video i have been on that has been muted YOU have been there!!!!! lol oh well..........fight the power!!!...i guess ^_^

  • I"m just tryin to spread the word! :P

  • OI,mai ks lar.NOOB(*!_!*)

  • WTF YouTube Patrol Suck big time for muting this video.

  • They MUTED my video as well! DAMN IT!

  • This video was the best to watch on you tube for We didn't start the fire and it was the most infomative with the extra qoutes. You tube is plain stupid for muting this

  • I just heard about this song when our teacher played it for us, but I also hate it. Not bcuz of the lyrics and how it sounds, but bcuz it gave my teacher an idea. I have to choose a song, and put historical facts into it. Then, I have to present it...but I don't have to sing if I don't want to,although I'm pretty good at singing. It for a 3rd quarter project. If you guys have any ideas,I would appreciate it.

  • whos your teacher im curious

  • yea dont be a noob,

    lol

  • As an artist I would be pissed about this. People show love and dedication by making good videos to songs I would have sung years and years ago. And instead of encouraging an increase in my popularity as well, my record label decides to ban the music because they are not receiving any direct profits from it. BS! The artist would not have had attention at all were it not for this vid. Banning the sound is a mere "because we can so you listen to songs we make money on" play by the label.

  • Music is supposed to be free.

  • To the viewers:

    At the moment, I am extremely busy with school work and other projects. I will attempt to find a way to restore audio some way or another, either through cutting through the copyright red tape or some other way. Please be patient.

    To YouTube:

    I do not appreciate the way I found out that my audio has been muted by you. I found out because someone had posted it on my video, instead of through a formal e-mail through you. This is very unprofessional and is not appreciated.

  • NOOOOO!!! The audio doesn't work !!!!

  • Too bad in a few months this video will be outdated.

    Haha, just kidding. Great editing and nice job over all.

  • great video, well done

  • Excellent Job ! Great Video by far better than Billy Joel's...

    Bravo !

  • Amazing song, and by far the best video I have seen for this song. And with how badly this song is stuck in my head, I have seen a lot of videos for this song just to keep hearing it.

  • Best video of this song I've seen! Even better than Billy Joel's himself.

  • without a doubt, the BEST video out there of this song :)

  • and my friend said TECHNOLOGY!!! when it got to the 80s at the start

  • and everyone laughed when he said birth control and crack and i yelled OZZY!!!!!!! when he said death metal

  • today the gr8s at my school played this video on a projector behind them while they sang it---> this exact video

  • haha, that's awesome! I'm glad my video is getting out there and used for educational (and entertaining) purposes.

  • amazing video... i cant stop playing it again and again

    btw, who is the woman at 4:08?

  • Madonna

  • VOTE BNP

  • Excellent!

  • Great video, the best one I've seen yet!

  • I love the video Where did you get that post card of the stork with the baby?

  • Hey , hope you're well. Check out my version of "We didn't start the fire 2007"

    Thanks

  • who is that guy at 4:03

  • It's the Unabomber.

  • GREAT GREAT pic synch and music... loved it !!

  • i love this song!!!!! ;p

  • Your video beats the actual Billy Joel video by a landslide!

  • Great Job!

  • good job.

  • nice job!!!!

    i love the pics!

    that sing is sooo great!

    o.O

  • Good job!

  • awesome job, i love ur choices on ending pics to continue the themes.

  • i heard this song for the first time a few months ago in the tv...but before i heard it in a coca-cola commercial here in latin america...but the song was different...but the rhythm was the same...and since then i love this song...a history lesson for us.

  • I enjoyed this version, unlike some others. The most accurate use of photos I've seen yet. For Lebanon you had a President Ford policy meeting, Joel refers to 1958 when we sent troops in. Loved the thing with the stork for birth control though out of context somewhat. Nice work!

  • I have loved this song since my parents introduced it to me and I have always wondered what some of the things and people he sings about look like. Great video.

  • at jackinthebox's is creative......

  • If you like this video you would also enjoy my updated video of this song, its about 1992-2007. It took me a load of time so please check it out by clicking on my name, enjoy!

  • Very very well done, great video

  • Hey if your a fan of Billy Joel and this song, please check out my video, my friends and I made an updated version for our history class. Just click on my name to check it out.

  • Aww, JFK's son saluting his Dad's dead body. :(

  • THIS IS THE BEST SONG ive EVER HEARD IN MY MUSIC LISTENING LIFE

  • This music fits into the world's evolution, and its progresses.

  • this is really good im taking a test on this for my final exam and the video has REALLY helped

  • I was just planning to make one of these today so came on youtube to see if anyone else had done it. WELL DONE!! you've made such a good job of it. Thanks.

  • ich würd aber gern wissen, WAS dein ach-so-toller großvater im 2. Weltkrieg gemacht hat...weil stolz auf jemanden zu sein, der menschen umgebracht hat, ist auch ein bisschen komisch. außerdem kann ich diese verdammten veteranen-treffen in den USA nicht ausstehen..so eine verherrlichung des krieges irgendwie -.-

  • hey want to see more of these type in "we didn't start the fire with amazing pics" and watch the only one

  • I smoke rocks joe rogan

  • this vidio is amazing

  • this vidio is way better then the original

  • Wonderful video, we're learning about it in my US of A History class, and I just wrote a thing about Acoustic Encoding about it's lyrics for my psychology class. Very useful, thanks!

  • That is beautiful - the only fanvid I've seen to this song that _worked_. Thank you for making it!

  • Great Video,

    i enjoyed the little quotes in between aswell

  • I liked the quotes

  • Great video!

    Recently, for some reason or another, almost everyone at my school has been randomly bursting into song, singing this.

  • You know, today is the 95th annervershery of when the Titainic snunk.

  • yes that is true my grandfather was one of the workers on the ship he was one of the only men that worked on that ship to live

  • that's sad, - was he fighting in a war (which?) tell him i said thanks!

  • he fought in ww2 and the vietnam war and he is STILL ALIVE! HE TURNS 100 THIS YEAR!

  • that's amazing! my grampa was in WW2 i think... but i am so proud of everyone who is in the armed forces! our school band- which i'm in- have a veterans concert every year- it was phenomenal this year! our director received a flag that was flown over washington D.C.- this was an order of the president and our director/received the flag in thanks- we were so proud and the music was good- we had vets there i'm moving on to high school but i'm going to go to next years vets concert!

  • great song and graet vid! I think this video is better than the original.

    Well done

  • cool

  • Awesome beyond words.

  • Very well done.

  • fan-fk'ng-tastic.... i never leave comments, ever... but this is RIGHT ON!

  • I love the song, and this video, thank-you so much for making it. I'm sure somone else has said this in a comment, but I bet Billy Joel himself would be proud of such a moving slideshow being set to one of this songs. Absolutely amazing.

  • awesome. just awesome. ^^

  • it was cvool pics are wee bit blur though !!! but cool

  • It is really ironic, i'm suppose a make report just like it. But After seeing this it shows me how ignorant i am about this song. And i am extatic about it now.

  • Im glad people are still remembering this song, It's such a great song; and a great video you've made too. Im surprise it's not getting a perfect rating.

  • I think this should be the Music ViDo for that song. it is relly relly good You did a relly good job. Billy Joel is one of my all time favorit singers. And i think this vido is great

  • i am done history 4 this year

  • THIS IS PWNZORE!!

  • awesome...i've known the words to this song since I was 12 and everyone makes fun of me *waits for it* wonderful wonderful wonderful.

  • LOve this song, the video is excellent !!!

  • thats cool

  • that's awesome

  • Who is that..at 4:03?

  • that was unibomber he sent bombs through the mail, and it was his brother who turned him in.

  • Thank you

  • Billy Joel is so awesome! XOXO

  • woooooooooooooooooooo 10 of 10 way to go

  • that was awesome!! great job

  • What a sad (but also happy) realisation of our world. Probably the best montage of this song I've seen. helllooo favorites!!

  • this song is weird dog

  • That was sweet!

    10 of 10

    My old 8th grade SS teacher would have liked it.

  • HA!! you think this is bad, you should look up final fantasy, everyone with the movie has thrown its scenes together with every song that has come out. not to mention dragon balls Z(Crapiest animay ever) and Naruto.

  • Nice job on montage. Thanks for posting.

  • There have been a lot of image montages to this song. It just seems to beg for it.

    Think I might do one . . .

  • amazing, lol

  • I applaude your fantastic video. The metaphor of the original was a little weird, Billy joel should give you a call.

  • I applaud your use of images and quotes---especially the ones added on at the end, the images of what a more-recent version of this song might include. Very nice.

    You said you did this for an assignment? Might I ask, did you compile a quick description of each of the phrases' sources?

  • this was amazing! you did such a good job! really good choice of quotes =) absolutely LOVED it!

  • This was better than the original video!

  • oh JEZ! i cant believe liberache was gay. i didnt see that one cumin!

  • BJ is awesome!

  • nice this is way better than the real version

  • The best! Yow!

  • this song roxx dude..plus it'll help me on my history final=]

  • This needs to be in a fucking Time Capsule

  • Nicely done.

  • I absolutely adore this video! Great pictures and quotes. I was looking up the song so I could listen to it while doing my project (which is on this song for my Journalism class) and this was the first one to come up. Absolutely beautiful.  Awesome job!

  • Best one!

  • This is a very good video, and I love the quotes. The added scenes of the 1990 up until around now are a nice touch as well. You did a very good job on this video!

  • Only a normal uncreative cheap Idea

  • Only an normal uncrative cheap Idea

  • the best 'we didn't start the fire' collection of pictures I've seen

  • Very good video. But no quotes from Churchill? Lincoln? Thomas Jefferson or James Madison? Certainly they said things far more worthy of contemplation than Monroe or Malcom X.

  • Im not the creator of the video, but there are no quotes from the people you listed because the quotes are based on the people, places, things, or events between 1949 to 1989. Billy Joel wrote the song about his generation growing up in the fifties, thats why most references are from that decade. Thats why all the references are from this time period.

  • Im the creator of the video, and your right. That is exactly why I choose the quotes I did. ;-) Good Job!

  • no they did not

  • Indeed, Winston Churchill was prime minister after 1949. The others are well noted.

  • i really really like this video. i've sat through most of the ones on here, but this one is my favorite. i want to show my history class

  • Wha is the "fire"

  • SO FUNNY!! GREAT JOB!!

  • truly an awesome response to the issues that have come to plague our world since Billy Joel was born in 1949. I liked the added affect of the pictures from 1990 until recently. It shows the continuity, we humans have yet to learn.

  • Great collection of images.

  • I loved the quotes you inserted into the clip. Were any of them in the original music video?

  • None of the quotes were in the original music video. From what I can tell, the only visual in this video that's in the original is a Vietnam photo (at 1:55), where one of the communist rebel leaders executes someone. In the original, that picture is in the background behind Billy Joel. It can be seen at youtube(dot)com/watch?v=sud-Id­jIV-o

  • That was AWESOME 5 stars

  • Oh...my. It's an awesome song, but it's so much BETTER with pictures! Especially the current events at the end. It just goes that much further to prove the point of the sing.

  • This was powerful. I like how the quotes were, if I am not mistaken, from contemporaries of the times they were show. I like this even better than the actual video to the song by Billy Joel. Nothing but my praise and admiration!

  • I've seen a lot of these videos, but this one is my favorite. Great job with continuing it into the 90's and 00's.

  • Great job. Hope you don't mind but I'll be using it in my class. ;) I'll cite you though.

  • Wow great job. Also thank you for putting in the pictures of the I have a Dream, speech and march on the white house, its one of my favourite speeches so moving. Thats one of the moments in history i thought he missed, but maybe there was just no rhyme for it... anyway ty a lot

  • You did a great job. And I hate to say it but you are the only one who didn't mix up the band U2 with the american spyplane shot down over russia. I would give you a hug for that if I could.

  • Someone on another "We didn't Start the Fire" video actually thought U2 was YouTube, and another person thought space monkey and mafia were meant to go together.

  • why so many vietnam pics

  • Er because it was a huge part of the 20th century which is kinda what the song is about.

  • Excellent, excellent job!!

  • A lot of these vid's about, but this one is easily the best. Good job.

  • Fantastic!!