Celluloid Dream by The Citizen Erased [AFI Cover]

[matturibes]

i dont care what pple say i like this alot u did a great job bro! plus afi sucks now but used to be the best band ever, but turned into comercialized band but i guess everyone needs to make a buck, but i miss songs like this and the art of drowning anyways just wanted to let u know u have talent and u made it ur own sound and i personally like it alot!!

[kesschan]

Wow, this isn't bad at all but you sang a little bit slow than I expected to hear at first. I'm 1 of AFI fans and I think you done a pretty good job... good cover!!

btw,sorry for my bad English(I'm from Thailand)

[doodcruise]

you slowed it down too much mate,your just singing the words very slow.not very impressive..

[dutchuribe]

i personaly like this alot u made it ur own and it brings out alot of emotions, great job

[Roberodification]

while you do sing very well and I respect the fact that you tried to do something very different with the song I just don't see this song in particular slowed down this much. I think had you done this with a song like Ever and a day I feel like it would have gone better.

that being said, had this not been an attempt at my favorite afi song I would have considered it a great song because it is rather lulling.

[nsz1998]

I think this is a really great cover I'm a huge AFI fan and I really love this song I think what you did with it is really different (good different)

[dutchuribe]

ur own style is sick man i like it its different!!, screw pple who dis everything, express ur talent, i understand pple liking the original but come on u listen to oafi earlly 90s i love that style and now they sound emo, but i stuck with afi no matter what but i wont buy there new stuff lol anyways its a good twist on a different style song, good job

[3s2m]

copyright infrengment asshole

[Afireinside912]

Vocals- 2.5/5 (some of the notes are awful.. sorry :()

Cover Creativity- 4/5 (Nothing like original :) which is good... and can sometimes get bad.. in this case both)

[PedroRiot]

i can hear some havok tones in there but youre off and that cheap reverb is annoying.

[missmurder136912]

I'm a die hard AFI fan and I don't want to seem mean but I really don't like this version. It seems like it's trying too hard to be different in a way, also overly dramatized a bit. I just don't think this song should sound like this...

[XxFiend4LifexX]

It would be better if there was any resemblance to the original.

[AlasseT]

well the point of a cover is to have a different take on a song, so i guess keeping that in mind, this is really creative! good job, just do your thing :]

[MrChambonable]

iloved its different but i loved...

nice job u do with the song...

[blaqkflame]

I don't mean to sound like an asshole, I just wanted to offer my feedback. I hope it will be more constructive than most of these comments.

I personally don't think you're a bad singer, I think you're actually quite good.

But I think the problem with this vid is that people watched it expecting This Celluloid Dream by AFI. I understand putting your spin on the song, but you just made it a completely different song. As far as Im concerned this isn't this celluloid dream.

But I still liked it! :D

[imustbeTINO]

no no, thank you - i completely agree with you. i understand why AFI fans would be mad at it. Especially considering it's a much more punkier song than what i've done with it.

But I wanted to show it in a different light. Nonetheless, this was a year ago now, and my music style has moved on since then. Thanks for the feedback :)

[fresh098]

@imustbeTINO i am a huge AFI song, i have every album. and i only found this song cuz i just searched celluloid dream.. but personaly i think davey havok would be impressed with your talent, and putting your own style on it makes it unique, and your just not copying their style u put your own into it. 5 stars.

[MrRockerdood]

uhm, way to butcher a fantastic afi song, go die in a hole...sleezeball. your singing sucks nut

[VastFarFlung]

LOL

[XEmo4LifeX1]

......................just no not afi. :(

[rbellegrave13x31]

you aren't a great singer buddy. and the whole joy division thing isn't working for you.

[mongorfuk]

@rbellegrave13x31

baaaahahahahahahahahahahaha

[fresh098]

awesome cover ill try to get the cd

[Twaatyvagitus]

and on that note... could you do a cover of Silver and cold? PLEASE?! Best song ever - and then I'd possibly worship you :P x

[Twaatyvagitus]

SO, I love AFI... like, they are my favourite band - this means you have just gone up 10 degrees in my opinion of you. Keep on climbing! x

[boftin]

Cool cover, you could really tighten it up by losing most of that reverb and boosting the vocal tracks low and mids slightly

[SikoNoriko]

So I was actually pretty impressed with this. I was a touch leery at first to listen to it with a piano, but the music turned out to be solid, and so did the vocals.

Keep doing your thing Tino, and thanks for the music. It really brightened my day, erm, night.

[amybeee3]

this' my favourite of your music videos!! :)

amazing cover! you going to be touring with your album any time soon? x

[imustbeTINO]

oh wow, lol, i wish i was touring with it,

but i don't really make enough money off my album to go touring with it.

lol, im not really that popular

(well thats what my album sales tell me)

BUT if i ever do do a gig or tour, i'll probably tell youtube, so if you're subbed, you'll know first (Y)

I'll probably play a few songs at the tibbils gathering.

Do you have my album? xx.

[amybeee3]

I dont, YET! however i've just got a new job this week! so less than three is definately on my list of things to buy when i get paid!

(and that's genuine not like a little youtube comment lie like a lot of people!)

i wish i was going to the tibbils gathering but i'm all the way in liverpool so getting there and back in one day = ridiculously expensive!

so i'll just have to look forwards to the day you finally tour! :) x

[takingbackseajay]

nooooooooooo god why????

such a great AFI song killed!

your good but just not AFI plz

[gothXqueenX08]

Please don't ever do this to a perfectly amazing AFI song again. I'm sorry but you aren't Davey Havok. Don't defile a truly great AFI song. This is painful. You have your own style and I see that but this isn't it.

[XBleedinBlackHeartsX]

awsome!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[lilithharrison]

absolutly amazing XD i loved every seconds of it :)

You have an awesome voice (:

xox

[Luxborg]

TINO!!!!!!! omfg heyyyyyy it's Selyna!!!

haha love this vid!!!

be sure 2 tell me where I can get ur album!!!! Lurves chu lots! XD

[imustbeTINO]

=P you can get my album now... if you didn't know =]

[Luxborg]

:D lolz i'm so gonna get it

:P

[Bethnesss]

Good cover

and also...

Your hair is fucking amazing (Y)

[hertfelt]

I'm pretty sure he was trying to look like the AFI singer...

[jacks5674]

Uh, Davey's hair does not look like that... or ever did, really. I think you mean the guitar player Jade... :) He had the blond fringe thing going on.

[Blargashmargeh]

When I saw him, I thought he looked kind of like Gerard from MCR. Maybe not now, but some time. I thought he actually WAS him.

P.S. Really, dude. I don't think this is a good cover for you.

[celluloidxdreams]

I finally got around to seeing your TCD cover. :P Nice rendition and singing. :]

[imustbeTINO]

wahey, i'm glad you liked it (y)

[MadamaTeschio]

I totally love your voice.

[TheWorstNightmares]

TinoTinoTino!!!

Hi it's charlotte from aisha's XD

I didnt know you did all this!

YOUR AMAZING!!

Wow.

loves =D

xx

[imustbeTINO]

thank you,

and yes, i do all this,

hope you're alright!

[TheWorstNightmares]

I stayed up untill 3 this morning watching The love hate society vids and all your ones.

They are really good! I mean wow!

How are you doing?

x

[imustbeTINO]

haha thats pretty late!

thanks for watching and all!

i'm alright thanks, doing good, exicited about the love hate society. =]

[puppydog42]

i love this song.

beautiful piano,

and voice.

=]

(don't bother the haterz)

[imustbeTINO]

thankyou lotsandlots =P

[puppydog42]

your welcome lotsandlotsandlots.

lol

[MCRock666]

this is a really groovy song but i was wondering is it you singing or the original band

also you are exteamly fitt [= jazz x

[imustbeTINO]

um, derh, its me.

[BucolicDeflagration]

Wow.. this is a really good cover-thing

[imustbeTINO]

thank you

[3sixty5days]

Still Epic :]

[imustbeTINO]

glad you love it ste!

[Punkrockboy015]

Nice Teoh. I like how you don't try to "copy and paste" your music from the originals. I'll be getting your album when you release it.

[imustbeTINO]

yay!

[TheLoveHateSociety]

The Love Hate Channel thinks:

this is crap...

but the girl below is even crapper.

[KIARA124]

hahaha omg

i wasted 6 minutes of my life,, watchin someone walking xD

lol

[imustbeTINO]

omgz, and then you wasted 30 seconds longer commenting.

[tyrannosauruslexxx]

yayayayay :]

[imustbeTINO]

your so modern.

[transferXmofts]

I liked the editing to your voice

It makes it sound really cool :D

This is a great video

You're awesome (:

[BethOnTop]

i really loved this video :)

yay for mark filming :D

<3 you xxxxxxx

[imustbeTINO]

yay for beth's approval!

[xrockgoddess36x]

i love that song :]

this is so chillllll.

it just made me forget about what a shitty day i was having. thank you <3333

[KHSLproductions]

well it is

[imustbeTINO]

shut up!

[LittleMissJadeykins]

aww lovely song and lovely video Tino :) <3 see you soon hopefully xxxxxxx

[imustbeTINO]

jadey, i tried to invite you out tonight... really drunk now... charlie... charlieskies... is here, i wanted you out seeing as you only lie in bexyleyheath, and laura, from townley is here!!! im sure you could have made it!

[LittleMissJadeykins]

Laura from Townley?? which Laura is this =O and I was in Birmingham sorry!! =[ xxxxxxxx

[KHSLproductions]

this is a rly good song and i hope u make more :D

[imustbeTINO]

=D yay

[ibegangstur]

tbh not the best.

[imustbeTINO]

=0 well.... at least your honest.

[elwarete]

I fucking love your jacket from the beginning .... were did you get it??

please reply

great singing BTW

[imustbeTINO]

i kind of stole it off a friend!

[elwarete]

XD XD

[abbieasalways]

Your beautiful in this video, my saviour! :]

[imustbeTINO]

wow i feel like jesus. =]

[DoctorBenjy]

Ahh love it.

I wouldnt want to be the cameraman though! lol

[imustbeTINO]

hahaha,

god bless mark and his camera skills!

[ariaraad]

WOW Teoh!!! xXx

[Marschmellowkid]

i like it!

[meganisyou]

Teoh you have no idea how happy you have now made me. AFI is my favorite band, and I am a HUGE fan. I love them ALMOST as much as I love you. XD I'm even a member of The Despair Faction (their fan club). And this. This was ultra fantastic. Thank you for being so freaking amazing. THANK YOU. *favorites*

[imustbeTINO]

as usual, all i need is megan approval to be happy!

so HORRAY!

=]

[neverHADitALL]

i love it =)

[Klairyyy]

i haven't listened to A.F.I in ages.

nice cover (:

[imustbeTINO]

thankyou,

i guess you'll be listening to AFI a bit more now!

[BabiiWinks008]

Really amazing tino <3

[midivonross]

how long were you walking around for?

i couldnt keep a straight face lol watching someone filming me whilst walking backwards

and it sounded awesome btw i'll give youu 5 stars **** :)

[imustbeTINO]

we filmed for like an hour or so,

it wasn't that long really.

we had to plan routes and then walk it.

lol.

[NessaR12]

this was so cool! i love the song.

<3

[ZoeMoi]

wow I love AFI's videoes, but this one was just awesome..

[XP108]

lol, your hair looks cool, nice dramatic death scene at the end there XD

[litair]

AMAZING!

[MrHpProductions]

(: I love anything like this.. Nicely done.

[MyChemicalLaura]

il describe it with words..

it goes: wow....ooooh...this is AWESOME...SHEEETE MAN NO WTF...why does everything i love leave me?

=] like that

[MyChemicalLaura]

=] this is amazing

it makes me smile like a fish on drugs

(y)

[imustbeTINO]

i wonder what a fish on drugs reaction to this song would be... hmmm...

[WriterSingerAwesome]

Beautiful!

Loved it!!You're awesome!!

[HatticusRex]

<33 this is amazing, im gunna listen to the original now and compare while i wait for twilight to load. *i watch films illegally*

[imustbeTINO]

you illegal film person! gah!

[MrHpProductions]

ARUGH! ^.^ Twilight was amazing.

[tradewellzrulz]

Hmmm....You should put some Cd's on eBay cause alot of my friends want some. I;l but about 6. No joke

[imustbeTINO]

i can't post this song because its not my song,

this is me singing it, it is my version,

but i dont have the copywright to release this song.

sorry.

[tradewellzrulz]

Not only this song. The other ones. I have to admit this song is good. But I know you can't do it.

[veebeeseesyou]

amazing :O <3

you're great, t.

[imustbeTINO]

***MARKEYBEE***

I GOT THERE FIRST