Their sexual life wasn't always (all even in most cases) so carefree like TheXLTE is asserting. Actually with castration in most cases they lost hormonical sexual appetence. And in most cases their gonad were undeveloped. Sometimes some castrates had psychical sexual appetence and in this case it was plausible that they had affairs with ladyies and with men. But otherwise their furiousness can't be universalize to all castrated individuals.
this shit is just sick in the head the give up ur dick to sing what the fuck hell a real man if he wanted to be a singer whould not get his dick chopped off or nuts chopped off fuck that !
@TheXLTE they didnt give up there dicks, they had a sergery that enabled them to have kids, but they had normal sexuall function, and they were very populer with the ladies, because there wernt any condomes back then to prevent pregnancy. The castraty alsow grew bigger and taller then the averige man.
@tissetatten Not true. They took the testicles which meant no sperm so no kids. They did it before puberty so smaller voicebox, hence the voice. There are some reports that they had some sexual function, but probably not normal. Then as now a man with skilled hands can still satisfy a woman.
@tissetatten removal of the testicles would have resulted in sterility - same as when it's performed on any other male animal. Once your testicles have been removed, there is no surgery that can enable you to have a child, you no longer have any sex cells that could combine with an egg.
His voice isn't the most pleasant, however he seems to be able to sing with real empathy. Singing about suffering, I definitely hear it in his voice, whether it's an artistic choice or not.
realmente, ele era seu tatatatatatatatataravô. Ao entrar na puberdade, ele bateu uma bronha, gozou dentro de um vidrinho (presentinho para sua tatatata...), e só depois passou o facão nas bolita.
To the listeners to and critics of this video, before you go bashing this mans voice take this into consideration. This recording was not recorded on high tech digital technology in a fancy studio to be released on I Tunes, this was most likely recorded in a small room like a study with a piano and a phonograph and that's it and alot of the sound quality is lost from the old recording methods. Listen to the piano for example it sounds pinngey and weak nothing like we know a piano sounds like.
Castrating a child at an early age to make him become a castrato was risky. If someone castrated you in hopes of making you a singer didn't work out, how would you feel. Not worth trading, if you know what I mean.
Moreschi did actually sing a few private concerts. It would be unfair to put this down to a lack of talent in any case. The church was very wary of allowing it's singers to sing secular concerts and indeed it was a mark of Moreschi's popularity that he was allowed to record these records at all. I accept that Moreschi isn't in his prime in these recordings but the inescapable fact is that he was hugely admired in his day.
By the 19th century both Italy and the Vatican (see Pope Leo XIII) had banned this practice, but it was the families of some of the young boys who got their children castrated so that they could become famous singers. I know it's always easier to spread ignorance than either knowledge or critical thinking.
@87anAxelsson The tradition of castration was a part of italian national musical culture. It has been criticized by society in other european countries, though they were christian as well. Your attack is no more then stupid attempt to claim large and complex organisation (and a whole religion), because of things, that happened for centuries ago. No way...
By the 19th century both Italy and the Vatican (see Pope Leo XIII) had banned this practice, but it was the families of some of the young boys who got their children castrated so that they could become famous singers.
BTW, Norse Mythology was HIGHLY admired by the Nazis. So, I could say that they ( who actually did awful things to people who followed Abrahamic religions) would have liked your opinion, they wanted to rediscover the Aryan ancestral gods!
@SkateNater Noo....actually i'm more baffled by the ppl who thought this is piece was beautiful =.=...........if the word "castrato" was scratched in the video title, would you still think this is beautiful?! cmon, give your ears justice!
@aiayumi he wasn´t in his best time when he recorded these arias, plus he wasn´t near the best castrattos singers. But it is listened cause it gives an idea of how those great voices would be. And different from you I think that his voice is unbeliaveble, his voice color is inimaginable, I cant imagine how Farinelli would sing, definitely that would be like an angel crying
@aiayumi - LOL, I agree completely. His voice isn't all that great and people would be saying "what in the world is this?!" if they didn't know he was a castrato.
@SkateNater i wish technology could revive Farinelli...but to say this horrible singing is representative of the legendary, unearthly castrati (church, opera ones alike) is such a shame....
@kalju By the 19th century both Italy and the Vatican (see Pope Leo XIII) had banned this practice. Castration was not a practice encouraged by the church. In most cases, it was the families of the young boys who got their children castrated so that they could become famous singers and help the family's financial situation. I know it's always easier to spread, hatred, and ignorance than either knowledge or critical thinking.
I dislike it!!!!! that's not a singer, that's like a howl, terrible....! I'm countertenor, this is an offense to the opera, I curse that horrible voice!!!!
some ppl forget that the recording is of the worst quality..note the date..and note...also how any recording of that era ppl sounded like compare to today. So really this is like listening someone on an old mobile phone... imagine how he would had sounded in real life
I just thought people might like to know that the reason this recording may not sound quite as "pleasing" to them, knowing that castrato voices were known to be very beautiful in their time, is because Moreschi was about 44 or 46 when these recordings were made and not in his prime. He was probably beginning to lose some of his abilities at this point in his life.
This sounds horrible. Not worth cutting a poor baby's balls off so that you can have someone sing like this thier whole life... It is painful to my ears.
@victorbrunswick I have to argue with this comment. The twenty people who clicked dislike are people who have a difficulty getting out of the raspiness of Moreschi at this age, and how his voice sounds much more forced than many other singers.
If you disagree with what I just said, you and the twenty so-called eunuchs are all entitled to your own opinions.
Forse già era in età avanzata...ma dio mio è veramente inascoltabile anche nel fraseggio!Penso che non ci siamo persi nessun mostro di bravura in questo caso;ed oggi una voce così non passerebbe neppure l'ultimo dei concorsi.
@DrLeonardBonesMcCoy they would have done it when he was baby, so he did nthave the option. if you are circumsized, you probaly did not consciously make the decision either.
Open your ears... Moreschi sucked. Everyone can hear it. Being last castrato didn't make him a good singer. He was castrated before his first bd, so nobody could hear if he was talented or not. He was the last "working" castrato. That's why his voice was used in Capella Sistina, even if he sounded awfully.
Castration WAS condemned under Canon Law. A person who perform such a prosedure was excomunicated exo facto. Whether certain persons in the Church decided to turn a blind eye to the highering of these Castrati, is definitely arguable. Condemned or not this did not stop secular society from performing these practices on sly...and surgons from offering services for a price. Families would have their sons castrated in hopes of him becoming a great singer and the financial support of his family.
@SEMPRELISZT Thank you! Can ya believe these nuts who goin' on and on about a subject without researching it. In anycase, for those of you reading this post and are condemning castration as a " Church practice" Alessandro Moreschi could very well have been castrated for health reasons.As for rare forms of hernia, castration wasn't an uncommon " cure"
@gilloots1 lol Ok now, come on, that is a bit of an exaggeration. His voice is 20 times more powerful than Jenkins. Plus, he's doing the warbles on purpose. It was a stylistic thing back in those days. Florence Foster Jenkins... well, she just couldn't hit the notes! XD
We humans are a crazy bunch, it would cool in a sick and twisted way if they did just one more to end the conjecture, im horrible i know!!! his voice is haunting, especially if you think what this bloke went through as a kid........
The times are very different now. Castrati usually came from poor families, and rather than possibly not surviving to adulthood because their parents could not feed all their children, some boys were castrated in hopes of a better life within the church. The few that maintained a singing talent could dream of becoming the "popstars" of their day in the opera. Those who didn't at least had a secure life in the church, as opposed to starving in poverty. Tough times, tough choices.
That horrid voice sounds freakish. It actually disturbs me that a man could sing like that. It sounds very unnatural. Typical of the Catholics to come up with a barbaric idea such as cutting a males testes of on the off chance they will sing like a mutated choir boy. Totally crap singing.
I'm not a Catholic, but you should get more information on this topic ^^ Well, at least they had their penises, in China (Imperial Palace) and even in the India of today(Hijras) they usually lost/loose EVERYTHING. And you wouldn't accept their reasons either.
Of course, castrating a man is not acceptable, but ... well, it wasn't only the church's fault. Especially rich people liked and payed for those singers in the past.
Hope, you could understand me, my English got worse
@IIiRosiII I actually did look into this. I had first heard about this on BBC radio 4 in the early hours of the morning a few weeks ago and although it disturbed me I found it fascinating. The Castratos were offered by their parents to escape poverty but many were not good enough, however by the time they realised this, too late, obviously they were not whole men.
@dromong It does sound freakish yes. Apparently even more so "in the flesh" as opposed to a very early recording (I presume this was pre dolby lol). The vocal tones of a young boy belted out by the fully developed lungs of a man. However, their testes were not actually cut off. They were made to sit in a very hot bath and their testes were "manipulated" and then when they were soft the tube supplying the male hormones to the body was crushed by means of a special tool.
@dromong i agree - it is a very disturbing voice. the first time that i heard, i felt his suffering, excrutiating agony, before i knew he was a castrato. many of those young men had no knowlegde of what had been done to them. if you read the book called "the last castrato" (i think that's the name - but i read it a long time ago) the saddness and overall emotional pain is overwhelming. i disagree the singing is crap - just a different style, a different way. good wishes, robbie
@dromong actually the church never specifically approved the practice, they just closed a blind eye. One of the reasons the singing sounds so strange to our ears is that at the time vocal technique was very different - they added a lot of slides and grace notes rather than singing the music "clean". Have you ever listened to a really good countertenor singing Contralto? And I don't mean choirboys, but grown men. They have a richness of tone that very few women are able to produce :)
He had a nice voice, but i can feel my balls heart when i listen to him... Im sorry, but every time he get his voice louder my balls got hit by an agonishing strange feeling...
It's not "very good"--Moreschi was past his prime when he made his recordings--nevertheless, his skill and lifelong dedication to his craft is still apparent.
The recordings of Moreschi are highly debated. While it's true that the voice of a castrato would deteriorate over time (as it surely would have by his 50's, when this recording was created), it is also worth noting changing musical tastes (many grace notes that were more popular in this era sound a but funky now) and poor sound quality as factors in the oddness of this performance.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Not exactly pleasant to listen to. Could be the terrible quality of the recording, but somehow, I dont think higher quality recording could make him sound good.
@LucklessGun Yes, part of it is the primitive recording. This was 1902, after all. Furthermore, he was older at the time of the recordings. He was past his prime, vocally. His voice was unstable, if you really listen. He also seems to lack the flexibility that was associated with the castrati; they were famous for long cadenzas and breath capacity. Interesting to hear this sound, that was so prized at one point in history that they mutilated many young boys to achieve it.
beh bisogna considerare sicuramente l'età che aveva Moreschi quando ha registrato questo pezzo e anche le tecniche rudimentali con cui è stata realizzata la registrazione stessa...Tutti sommato è un' importante testimonianza di come fosse la voce dei castrati, anche se non rende perfettamente l'idea...
The effectiveness of castrating a child for the sake of his voice really diminishes as the person gets older. The circumference of the the neck and other adjacent structures don't lend itself to the unchanged vocal cavity that the male hormone helps to develope. Thus, the voice ends up sounding really shrilly and squiky--almost alien like. It's really sad.
na boa, não achei bonito não, vai ver esses castrati nem eram tão bons como reza a lenda. Hoje em dia temos recursos que nos permitem realizar as musicas com muito mais precisão. mas isso não importa
wtf please tell me ur kidding cause if u do imagine what he would do all his life he would be ridiculed im only listening to this because it is very very ver y funny
@nikoparanza Thank YOU FOR THE OFFER. Unfortunately I have already gone through puberty. My son will sound like an ANGEL THOUGH JUST WAITING FOR THE DOCTOR TO SAY OK AND SEE HOW MUCH IT COSTS. I BOUGHT A MEDICAL BOOK AND I MAY TRY TO DO THIS PROCEDURE MYSELF IF ITS TOO EXPENSIVE
I think that, all being told, Moreschi had a pretty good voice. Considering that he was getting older when this record was made, and considering the quality of recording equipment in his day, I don't think the recording does him justice. Also, he's using 19th cent. Bel Canto technique; I think he could have benefited from using EITHER head voice, save for very low notes, or chest voice and singing lower range music. Basically, he's singing like most of his contemporaries in the Opera House.
well he was 46 when this was recorded and it's supposed to be the golden age of a voice : the recording technic can be responsible but he might have been very bad.
the true horror is that he didn't let anyone... he was a young child and his parents had it done. he reached adulthood before he discovered that he could never father a child. such horror is shown in the pain and suffering of his voice.
i think you are trying to be abusive or maybe you just don't understand biology. my mother was a woman. ALESSANDRO MORESCHI was a castrated man - that didn't turn him into a woman.... but it did destroy his manhood. and i feel compassion for his suffering.
reguardless of that rolasando said, you were right, castrati were actually like the rockstars of their time... they were ladies men, it was like birth control. I feel bad that he didnt chose that path.
yes they were the rockstars of their time.... apparently the ladies "swooned" in the the presence of the castrati !
as for rolasandos - he feels it's important to abuse people - he has abused me in private messages, put abusive comment on my channel page and even damaged my account....... what kind of person does that ?
lol the only approperiate reply I could make to that woukd just be, someone that doesnt know music of the time. Such a shame some people just cant fully grasp and get the affect of this music., so in that sense, I feel a bit sad for him.. but I hate that about your account for you. best of luck.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
@robbiew8n no he was born a girl but his parents want a man so they put a hot dog and two little bolls in his(or her) pussy so the got a man that sings like a woman
@cleon64 hmmm........ thank you replying to me, i think??? yet yours is a strange comment on the horrors that the roman catholic church committed upon these boys without their understanding or permission: doctors destroyed the potential manhood of these boys. maybe you are sexually confused? listen to his voice, feel his saddness. good wishes to you, robbie
@robbiew8n I think you don't understand the fact that perhaps, you were trolled, or somebody was just picking on the video. On the internet, people don't take things nearly as seriously as they do offline - remember that. Still, you post a good response. I wish you the best! :) But remember: never take somebody too seriously online - they may just be playing with you! Peace be with you, my dear friend. :)
@bytesize i greatly appreciate your reply. what is "trolled" please? i am happy to take thing seriously and i am always open to someone telling me that it was not serious afterwards, then revise my opinion of the comment. however, i do think "it's only the internet" is a poor excuse for some of the abuse on here - calling people by foul words, accusing them of paedophelia, offences about colour and sexuality. we accept these things at our peril: they diminish our humanity. robbie
@robbiew8n Hehe, "trolling" or being "trolled" is when somebody says something just for the shock value, or effect of readers. They don't necessarily intend it, but do it just to stir up people's emotions. I mean, just look at the user's name - BonerPirate. :P
@bytesize hey bitesize! always, after some unpleasantness on here, i find a decent person like you. you have incfreased my vocabulary by one word. maybe next time, i shall know when i have been "trolled" hahahaha and , well yes, "bonerpirate" = now that really is gay hehehehe, robbie
Florence Foster Jenkins lives!!!!!!!!!!!!
jr1844 3 weeks ago
haha it is absolutely.....horrible ^^
draZZzz34 3 weeks ago
Que mal rollo...
mickelpool 4 weeks ago
この画像がまた何とも。
たしかにすごいけど首絞められた鶏みっでたのう
00mb00cg 1 month ago
Do not play this to a 5-year-old you'll scar them for life.
7beers 1 month ago in playlist CASTRATO, BBC Documentary
I think this is beautiful.
anddrewful 1 month ago
this will haunt me in my sleep
tubertomp 2 months ago 2
for some reason i am drawn to his voice i dunno i love it
18aaronjames 2 months ago 2
EXPECTACULAR VOZ TENGO 16 AÑOS ME GUSTARIA TENER ESA VOZ!
Richynew18 2 months ago
Their sexual life wasn't always (all even in most cases) so carefree like TheXLTE is asserting. Actually with castration in most cases they lost hormonical sexual appetence. And in most cases their gonad were undeveloped. Sometimes some castrates had psychical sexual appetence and in this case it was plausible that they had affairs with ladyies and with men. But otherwise their furiousness can't be universalize to all castrated individuals.
ristopearukoovit 3 months ago
this shit is just sick in the head the give up ur dick to sing what the fuck hell a real man if he wanted to be a singer whould not get his dick chopped off or nuts chopped off fuck that !
TheXLTE 3 months ago
@TheXLTE they didnt give up there dicks, they had a sergery that enabled them to have kids, but they had normal sexuall function, and they were very populer with the ladies, because there wernt any condomes back then to prevent pregnancy. The castraty alsow grew bigger and taller then the averige man.
tissetatten 3 months ago
@tissetatten Not true. They took the testicles which meant no sperm so no kids. They did it before puberty so smaller voicebox, hence the voice. There are some reports that they had some sexual function, but probably not normal. Then as now a man with skilled hands can still satisfy a woman.
7777Hugh 2 months ago
@tissetatten removal of the testicles would have resulted in sterility - same as when it's performed on any other male animal. Once your testicles have been removed, there is no surgery that can enable you to have a child, you no longer have any sex cells that could combine with an egg.
jacqui835 1 month ago
hes mourning the loss of his testicles
vincenz55 3 months ago
Was it worth....not
piraan2 3 months ago
@piraan2 not how u go do it and find out
TheXLTE 3 months ago
His voice isn't the most pleasant, however he seems to be able to sing with real empathy. Singing about suffering, I definitely hear it in his voice, whether it's an artistic choice or not.
Puppyizzy 3 months ago 2
@Puppyizzy Bear in mind this was towards the end of his singing life; i.e. he was old.
jonmcsingee 3 months ago
esse carra he meu parente axo qe he meu tatatatatatatatara vo
vinicius54013 4 months ago
Comment removed
diogoolivi 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
realmente, ele era seu tatatatatatatatataravô. Ao entrar na puberdade, ele bateu uma bronha, gozou dentro de um vidrinho (presentinho para sua tatatata...), e só depois passou o facão nas bolita.
diogoolivi 4 months ago
yeah this sucks, DEFINITELY not worth having your balls cut off
YOYOdaMOOSE 4 months ago 3
To the listeners to and critics of this video, before you go bashing this mans voice take this into consideration. This recording was not recorded on high tech digital technology in a fancy studio to be released on I Tunes, this was most likely recorded in a small room like a study with a piano and a phonograph and that's it and alot of the sound quality is lost from the old recording methods. Listen to the piano for example it sounds pinngey and weak nothing like we know a piano sounds like.
GerouchM 5 months ago
Castrating a child at an early age to make him become a castrato was risky. If someone castrated you in hopes of making you a singer didn't work out, how would you feel. Not worth trading, if you know what I mean.
thelaughingguitar 5 months ago
He makes Justin Bieber look good....
ShortStuff2187 6 months ago
@ShortStuff2187 Nah.
TrinoElrich 5 months ago
Moreschi did actually sing a few private concerts. It would be unfair to put this down to a lack of talent in any case. The church was very wary of allowing it's singers to sing secular concerts and indeed it was a mark of Moreschi's popularity that he was allowed to record these records at all. I accept that Moreschi isn't in his prime in these recordings but the inescapable fact is that he was hugely admired in his day.
uppercommander 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The Catholic Church has always hurt and humiliated people. Crush Christianity, Islam and Judaism. Hail the Nordic gods!
87anAxelsson 7 months ago 28
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@87anAxelsson nordic gods?
the gods of fire ,thunder,death,blood,human sacrificies and antropomorphic forms ?
go to burn church and listen black metal little child
MetallicAwwf316 6 months ago
@MetallicAwwf316 No, but nature worship, and no bloody vision to convert other people, or to enslave them in the name of religion.
87anAxelsson 6 months ago 21
By the 19th century both Italy and the Vatican (see Pope Leo XIII) had banned this practice, but it was the families of some of the young boys who got their children castrated so that they could become famous singers. I know it's always easier to spread ignorance than either knowledge or critical thinking.
theannoyingtruther 2 months ago
@MetallicAwwf316 Burning down a church and listening to black metal sounds like a good night out
Ultre 4 months ago 2
@87anAxelsson The tradition of castration was a part of italian national musical culture. It has been criticized by society in other european countries, though they were christian as well. Your attack is no more then stupid attempt to claim large and complex organisation (and a whole religion), because of things, that happened for centuries ago. No way...
ChatlaninUef 4 months ago
@87anAxelsson thats just stupid! u cant say fuck religion and then be religius, thats just as bad no matter what the religion
tissetatten 3 months ago
@87anAxelsson Well, in this case it wasn't for churchs or even music's sake he was castrated. read wikipedia before being stupid, man.
BlackCarc 3 months ago 3
@BlackCarc
Great! It's good to find people like you on youtube who have done some research and put in place people who don't know what they are talking about!
SEMPRELISZT 2 months ago
@87anAxelsson You reckon they're any better?
7777Hugh 2 months ago
@87anAxelsson
By the 19th century both Italy and the Vatican (see Pope Leo XIII) had banned this practice, but it was the families of some of the young boys who got their children castrated so that they could become famous singers.
BTW, Norse Mythology was HIGHLY admired by the Nazis. So, I could say that they ( who actually did awful things to people who followed Abrahamic religions) would have liked your opinion, they wanted to rediscover the Aryan ancestral gods!
theannoyingtruther 2 months ago
Guys just so you know, he was castrated. and that is for real.
MrKipp09 7 months ago 4
tendré pesadillas con los castrati
sior13 7 months ago
yo tambien jejej
TheGordocho 7 months ago
Imagine this voice without the 1902 shitty recording devices and the time that rot the clip.. He's voice had to be purely inconceivable!
Jozzu696 8 months ago
@SkateNater Noo....actually i'm more baffled by the ppl who thought this is piece was beautiful =.=...........if the word "castrato" was scratched in the video title, would you still think this is beautiful?! cmon, give your ears justice!
aiayumi 8 months ago 4
@aiayumi he wasn´t in his best time when he recorded these arias, plus he wasn´t near the best castrattos singers. But it is listened cause it gives an idea of how those great voices would be. And different from you I think that his voice is unbeliaveble, his voice color is inimaginable, I cant imagine how Farinelli would sing, definitely that would be like an angel crying
mnunezper 7 months ago
@aiayumi - LOL, I agree completely. His voice isn't all that great and people would be saying "what in the world is this?!" if they didn't know he was a castrato.
FredericaBimble 6 months ago
@SkateNater i wish technology could revive Farinelli...but to say this horrible singing is representative of the legendary, unearthly castrati (church, opera ones alike) is such a shame....
aiayumi 8 months ago
GOTTA LOVE THE CATHOLIC CHURCH!
kalju 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@kalju By the 19th century both Italy and the Vatican (see Pope Leo XIII) had banned this practice. Castration was not a practice encouraged by the church. In most cases, it was the families of the young boys who got their children castrated so that they could become famous singers and help the family's financial situation. I know it's always easier to spread, hatred, and ignorance than either knowledge or critical thinking.
theannoyingtruther 2 months ago
I dislike it!!!!! that's not a singer, that's like a howl, terrible....! I'm countertenor, this is an offense to the opera, I curse that horrible voice!!!!
drj4u2b 8 months ago
this is actually a quite horrid piece......sounds quite bad....definitely not worth castrating for....
aiayumi 9 months ago
Comment removed
aiayumi 9 months ago
It's an amazing voice... But makes me sad to know he was one of castrati guys...
justlly 9 months ago
some ppl forget that the recording is of the worst quality..note the date..and note...also how any recording of that era ppl sounded like compare to today. So really this is like listening someone on an old mobile phone... imagine how he would had sounded in real life
nandihno 9 months ago
OMG!!!!! THIS SINGER SCARED THE SHIT OUT OF ME
atd87atd87 10 months ago 14
I just thought people might like to know that the reason this recording may not sound quite as "pleasing" to them, knowing that castrato voices were known to be very beautiful in their time, is because Moreschi was about 44 or 46 when these recordings were made and not in his prime. He was probably beginning to lose some of his abilities at this point in his life.
Catarra777 10 months ago
This sounds horrible. Not worth cutting a poor baby's balls off so that you can have someone sing like this thier whole life... It is painful to my ears.
Salvus967 10 months ago
20 people are eunuchs.
victorbrunswick 10 months ago 2
@victorbrunswick I have to argue with this comment. The twenty people who clicked dislike are people who have a difficulty getting out of the raspiness of Moreschi at this age, and how his voice sounds much more forced than many other singers.
If you disagree with what I just said, you and the twenty so-called eunuchs are all entitled to your own opinions.
mysteryperson1976 10 months ago
sounds like my dad singing
spinege4 10 months ago
Oddly I sound a lot like him and I'm grown!
TheEureka41 10 months ago
I think they must have castrated him AFTER listening to this!
baronjohna 10 months ago
I guess most of you like this singing but I would choose a good sopran to sing for me this sound a bit like a chicken ^^
spirit2544 11 months ago
Forse già era in età avanzata...ma dio mio è veramente inascoltabile anche nel fraseggio!Penso che non ci siamo persi nessun mostro di bravura in questo caso;ed oggi una voce così non passerebbe neppure l'ultimo dei concorsi.
Phebus74 11 months ago
Forse già era in età avanzata...ma dio mio è veramente inascoltabile anche nel fraseggio.
Ho sempre trovato pessima la sua v
Phebus74 11 months ago
I always feel sick after listening to him. How the hell could you let a person chop your bollocks off
DrLeonardBonesMcCoy 11 months ago
@DrLeonardBonesMcCoy they would have done it when he was baby, so he did nthave the option. if you are circumsized, you probaly did not consciously make the decision either.
Salvus967 10 months ago
I'd rather keep my jewels thank you very much!
Monkeyslash 11 months ago
Open your ears... Moreschi sucked. Everyone can hear it. Being last castrato didn't make him a good singer. He was castrated before his first bd, so nobody could hear if he was talented or not. He was the last "working" castrato. That's why his voice was used in Capella Sistina, even if he sounded awfully.
Mantreko 1 year ago 4
Castration WAS condemned under Canon Law. A person who perform such a prosedure was excomunicated exo facto. Whether certain persons in the Church decided to turn a blind eye to the highering of these Castrati, is definitely arguable. Condemned or not this did not stop secular society from performing these practices on sly...and surgons from offering services for a price. Families would have their sons castrated in hopes of him becoming a great singer and the financial support of his family.
isabellemarie89 1 year ago 2
@isabellemarie89
Great to find people on youtube who know what they are talking about!
SEMPRELISZT 2 months ago
@SEMPRELISZT Thank you! Can ya believe these nuts who goin' on and on about a subject without researching it. In anycase, for those of you reading this post and are condemning castration as a " Church practice" Alessandro Moreschi could very well have been castrated for health reasons.As for rare forms of hernia, castration wasn't an uncommon " cure"
isabellemarie89 2 months ago
impressionante!
davidetero 1 year ago
people on here are unbearably ignorant. i don't think he could care any less about his "lost" manhood. shut up, fools!
0casteloencantado0 1 year ago
it's sound like Foster Jenkins !
gilloots1 1 year ago
@gilloots1 lol Ok now, come on, that is a bit of an exaggeration. His voice is 20 times more powerful than Jenkins. Plus, he's doing the warbles on purpose. It was a stylistic thing back in those days. Florence Foster Jenkins... well, she just couldn't hit the notes! XD
JairCrawford 1 year ago
The most beautiful singer I have ever heard.
Juliet0307 1 year ago 4
We humans are a crazy bunch, it would cool in a sick and twisted way if they did just one more to end the conjecture, im horrible i know!!! his voice is haunting, especially if you think what this bloke went through as a kid........
51m0n77 1 year ago
amazing
charliethepunk 1 year ago
for anyone interested the book "cry to heaven" by anne rice is a great fiction about castrati.
greeneyedlady01 1 year ago
i Don´t like his voice..
lahmorga 1 year ago
YOU CAN TAKE MY BALLS BUT YOU CANT TAKE MY VOICE!
Patchmagic88 1 year ago
Что-то мне стало не по себе.
InfroLife 1 year ago 2
Comment removed
InfroLife 1 year ago
The times are very different now. Castrati usually came from poor families, and rather than possibly not surviving to adulthood because their parents could not feed all their children, some boys were castrated in hopes of a better life within the church. The few that maintained a singing talent could dream of becoming the "popstars" of their day in the opera. Those who didn't at least had a secure life in the church, as opposed to starving in poverty. Tough times, tough choices.
aquaeyes11010 1 year ago 3
Makes my blood run cold - it's like something you would expect Hitler to do to the Jews, for entertainment and a bit of a laugh.
heathblanch 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
that is abusive to casurate somebody nothing suprises me since the catholic church is terriost i will kill the pope
MrJohnbarkley1000 1 year ago
Creepy...
AmIEvilll 1 year ago 4
That horrid voice sounds freakish. It actually disturbs me that a man could sing like that. It sounds very unnatural. Typical of the Catholics to come up with a barbaric idea such as cutting a males testes of on the off chance they will sing like a mutated choir boy. Totally crap singing.
dromong 1 year ago
@dromong LOL.
I'm not a Catholic, but you should get more information on this topic ^^ Well, at least they had their penises, in China (Imperial Palace) and even in the India of today(Hijras) they usually lost/loose EVERYTHING. And you wouldn't accept their reasons either.
Of course, castrating a man is not acceptable, but ... well, it wasn't only the church's fault. Especially rich people liked and payed for those singers in the past.
Hope, you could understand me, my English got worse
IIiRosiII 1 year ago
@IIiRosiII I actually did look into this. I had first heard about this on BBC radio 4 in the early hours of the morning a few weeks ago and although it disturbed me I found it fascinating. The Castratos were offered by their parents to escape poverty but many were not good enough, however by the time they realised this, too late, obviously they were not whole men.
There will always be a story of something worse.
Your English is very good. What nationality?
dromong 1 year ago
Comment removed
IIiRosiII 1 year ago
@dromong Thank you, I didn't speak English for one and a half year actively so it's not as easy as before. I'm from Germany.
But I'm relieved you actually know something about this topic. And I agree with you: It IS fascinating. (As long as it's part of the history...)
IIiRosiII 1 year ago
@dromong It does sound freakish yes. Apparently even more so "in the flesh" as opposed to a very early recording (I presume this was pre dolby lol). The vocal tones of a young boy belted out by the fully developed lungs of a man. However, their testes were not actually cut off. They were made to sit in a very hot bath and their testes were "manipulated" and then when they were soft the tube supplying the male hormones to the body was crushed by means of a special tool.
ickleian 1 year ago
@dromong i agree - it is a very disturbing voice. the first time that i heard, i felt his suffering, excrutiating agony, before i knew he was a castrato. many of those young men had no knowlegde of what had been done to them. if you read the book called "the last castrato" (i think that's the name - but i read it a long time ago) the saddness and overall emotional pain is overwhelming. i disagree the singing is crap - just a different style, a different way. good wishes, robbie
robbiew8n 1 year ago
@dromong actually the church never specifically approved the practice, they just closed a blind eye. One of the reasons the singing sounds so strange to our ears is that at the time vocal technique was very different - they added a lot of slides and grace notes rather than singing the music "clean". Have you ever listened to a really good countertenor singing Contralto? And I don't mean choirboys, but grown men. They have a richness of tone that very few women are able to produce :)
pellegrina60 1 year ago
He had a nice voice, but i can feel my balls heart when i listen to him... Im sorry, but every time he get his voice louder my balls got hit by an agonishing strange feeling...
danielf17 1 year ago 4
all i hear is a little man who seems to be sobbing in regret of his poor hairy testicles
2rip00 1 year ago 3
BALLZ!
roligare 1 year ago
Desentonaba como la mierda! le cortaron los huevitos al pedo pobre hombre, le podrían haber enseñado a cantar.
Una verdadera hijoputez, castrar a alguien para que cante...
VonGamben 1 year ago
@VonGamben jajajajajajajaja
MsKkaro 1 year ago
If I viciously grabed my husbands balls-- he would sound like that too. Have Mercy!!!! lol Maybe he'll be famous too. lol
lbredikhin5 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I'm not sure it's very good....
tysa888 1 year ago
@tysa888
It's not "very good"--Moreschi was past his prime when he made his recordings--nevertheless, his skill and lifelong dedication to his craft is still apparent.
Doliath 1 year ago
My God!This singer is a pure genious!
Juliet0307 1 year ago 9
@Juliet0307 He's no genius, he just got no balls...
Hakiiz 7 months ago 2
Comment removed
Juliet0307 1 year ago 5
I found this quite scary.
kmvoss 1 year ago
I feel bad for the guy.
And for myself. Why did I put myself through listening this? The horror, oh the horror!
BlacktoryProject 1 year ago
The recordings of Moreschi are highly debated. While it's true that the voice of a castrato would deteriorate over time (as it surely would have by his 50's, when this recording was created), it is also worth noting changing musical tastes (many grace notes that were more popular in this era sound a but funky now) and poor sound quality as factors in the oddness of this performance.
But then again, maybe he just sucked...
calculusaffair 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Not exactly pleasant to listen to. Could be the terrible quality of the recording, but somehow, I dont think higher quality recording could make him sound good.
LucklessGun 1 year ago
@LucklessGun Yes, part of it is the primitive recording. This was 1902, after all. Furthermore, he was older at the time of the recordings. He was past his prime, vocally. His voice was unstable, if you really listen. He also seems to lack the flexibility that was associated with the castrati; they were famous for long cadenzas and breath capacity. Interesting to hear this sound, that was so prized at one point in history that they mutilated many young boys to achieve it.
RavenSiren 1 year ago
we must realize that his best voice was years before the phonograph was invented! this is stuff from he was in his 50's i think. but its still good.
acerb45666555 1 year ago
he sound creepy as fuck. not worth the trade off. i rather have balls
alucardgrindcore 1 year ago
@alucardgrindcore boys were not given a choice. They were castrated against their will.
RavenSiren 1 year ago
@RavenSiren it was a choice..some of them made the decision in doing so cause they would be provided with wealth through out there career
motleycrue24 1 year ago
I can feel his sadness and pain , please dont do that to your children
luxiana89 1 year ago
MR NO BALLS HAS A FUNNY VOICE
MultiMurder 1 year ago
beh bisogna considerare sicuramente l'età che aveva Moreschi quando ha registrato questo pezzo e anche le tecniche rudimentali con cui è stata realizzata la registrazione stessa...Tutti sommato è un' importante testimonianza di come fosse la voce dei castrati, anche se non rende perfettamente l'idea...
vitulanoboys91 1 year ago
Weird!
Binford61OO 2 years ago
Oh hot damn this is my jam
teddiursaGO 2 years ago
A esta cancion le faltan huevos! / This song need more balls!
BOHEMIANMEX 2 years ago
The effectiveness of castrating a child for the sake of his voice really diminishes as the person gets older. The circumference of the the neck and other adjacent structures don't lend itself to the unchanged vocal cavity that the male hormone helps to develope. Thus, the voice ends up sounding really shrilly and squiky--almost alien like. It's really sad.
OrisLover 2 years ago
na boa, não achei bonito não, vai ver esses castrati nem eram tão bons como reza a lenda. Hoje em dia temos recursos que nos permitem realizar as musicas com muito mais precisão. mas isso não importa
tirlescalvo 2 years ago
I plan on having my son castrated so he can sing like this.
BonerPirate 2 years ago 55
wtf please tell me ur kidding cause if u do imagine what he would do all his life he would be ridiculed im only listening to this because it is very very ver y funny
MultiMurder 2 years ago
I was DEAD SERIOUS MIND YOUR OWN BUSINESS.
BonerPirate 2 years ago
ur telling me to mind my own buisness yet YOU rite this comment for eveyone to read
DUMB ASS!!!!
MultiMurder 1 year ago
@BonerPirate Lmao....that's cold.
ekocentric 1 year ago
Comment removed
PresidentOffDuty 1 year ago
@BonerPirate that's illegal!!! and cruel!!
PresidentOffDuty 1 year ago
@BonerPirate and when he is older, he will no doubt say thank you daddy, offering you the same quality of love and respect that you showed him.
good wishes to you.... and yr son
robbiew8n 1 year ago
@robbiew8n MANY BLESSINGS TO YOU AS WELL.
BonerPirate 1 year ago
@BonerPirate
dude...
Guichotpresident 1 year ago
@BonerPirate loooooooooooooool
theiceman74 1 year ago
@BonerPirate Please you must be kidding, dont joke with that
luxiana89 1 year ago
@BonerPirate wahahaha
aravis123 1 year ago
@BonerPirate honestly i think the same way wahahahahah XD
aravis123 1 year ago
@BonerPirate
You're an animal.
revisionist3500 1 year ago
@BonerPirate
My veterinary would be happy to service you, for a fair price. So you could sing like Moreschi.
nikoparanza 1 year ago
@nikoparanza Thank YOU FOR THE OFFER. Unfortunately I have already gone through puberty. My son will sound like an ANGEL THOUGH JUST WAITING FOR THE DOCTOR TO SAY OK AND SEE HOW MUCH IT COSTS. I BOUGHT A MEDICAL BOOK AND I MAY TRY TO DO THIS PROCEDURE MYSELF IF ITS TOO EXPENSIVE
BonerPirate 1 year ago
@BonerPirate Uh, I don't really think that's a good idea! Honestly, don't do this procedure yourself!
JeremyPassarelli 1 year ago
@BonerPirate
I'm pretty sure its illegal to do this now
emeraldrafael 11 months ago
@BonerPirate man i hope ur joking, aswell as the 53 people who liked this.
Salvus967 10 months ago
@BonerPirate your username and the comment doesn't make sense
atd87atd87 10 months ago
a voz dele é assim porque ele foi castrado na infância.
torrestoledolucas 2 years ago
I think that, all being told, Moreschi had a pretty good voice. Considering that he was getting older when this record was made, and considering the quality of recording equipment in his day, I don't think the recording does him justice. Also, he's using 19th cent. Bel Canto technique; I think he could have benefited from using EITHER head voice, save for very low notes, or chest voice and singing lower range music. Basically, he's singing like most of his contemporaries in the Opera House.
olcorganist 2 years ago
Sur une voix plus belle, le résultat aurait été encore meilleur, mais bon, honneur à lui d'avoir sacrifié sa descendance au Dieu Chant.
mariasarda 2 years ago
Gran voz, pero pobre amigo, castrado para el canto.
luismanuelcd 2 years ago 3
That song needs more balls / A esa canción le faltan huevos
BOHEMIANMEX 2 years ago 2
@BOHEMIANMEX jajjaajjajajajja!! asi es.
luismanuelcd 2 years ago
man....the guy sung really badly...
wonder if it always had been the case, or it's just the age..?
marribor 2 years ago
well he was 46 when this was recorded and it's supposed to be the golden age of a voice : the recording technic can be responsible but he might have been very bad.
firstlaughinghyena 2 years ago 3
Was I imagining it but there was some noise at 1:15?
daanok 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
that gay is pussy
rolasandos 2 years ago
ow...
he's tone deaf too. bummer for him. all that snippin' and the voice still be slippin'
scotttblisss 2 years ago
hi mefondlevagina
the true horror is that he didn't let anyone... he was a young child and his parents had it done. he reached adulthood before he discovered that he could never father a child. such horror is shown in the pain and suffering of his voice.
good wishes
robbie
robbiew8n 2 years ago 7
This comment has received too many negative votes show
robbiew8n your mom is Alessandro Moreschi
rolasandos 2 years ago
hi rolasandos
i think you are trying to be abusive or maybe you just don't understand biology. my mother was a woman. ALESSANDRO MORESCHI was a castrated man - that didn't turn him into a woman.... but it did destroy his manhood. and i feel compassion for his suffering.
good wishes
robbiew8n
robbiew8n 2 years ago 20
reguardless of that rolasando said, you were right, castrati were actually like the rockstars of their time... they were ladies men, it was like birth control. I feel bad that he didnt chose that path.
janet20099 2 years ago
heya janet20099
yes they were the rockstars of their time.... apparently the ladies "swooned" in the the presence of the castrati !
as for rolasandos - he feels it's important to abuse people - he has abused me in private messages, put abusive comment on my channel page and even damaged my account....... what kind of person does that ?
have fun janet 20099, take care.
robbiew8n
robbiew8n 2 years ago 2
lol the only approperiate reply I could make to that woukd just be, someone that doesnt know music of the time. Such a shame some people just cant fully grasp and get the affect of this music., so in that sense, I feel a bit sad for him.. but I hate that about your account for you. best of luck.
janet20099 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@robbiew8n no he was born a girl but his parents want a man so they put a hot dog and two little bolls in his(or her) pussy so the got a man that sings like a woman
cleon64 1 year ago
@cleon64 hmmm........ thank you replying to me, i think??? yet yours is a strange comment on the horrors that the roman catholic church committed upon these boys without their understanding or permission: doctors destroyed the potential manhood of these boys. maybe you are sexually confused? listen to his voice, feel his saddness. good wishes to you, robbie
robbiew8n 1 year ago
@robbiew8n I think you don't understand the fact that perhaps, you were trolled, or somebody was just picking on the video. On the internet, people don't take things nearly as seriously as they do offline - remember that. Still, you post a good response. I wish you the best! :) But remember: never take somebody too seriously online - they may just be playing with you! Peace be with you, my dear friend. :)
bytesize 1 year ago
@bytesize i greatly appreciate your reply. what is "trolled" please? i am happy to take thing seriously and i am always open to someone telling me that it was not serious afterwards, then revise my opinion of the comment. however, i do think "it's only the internet" is a poor excuse for some of the abuse on here - calling people by foul words, accusing them of paedophelia, offences about colour and sexuality. we accept these things at our peril: they diminish our humanity. robbie
robbiew8n 1 year ago
@robbiew8n Hehe, "trolling" or being "trolled" is when somebody says something just for the shock value, or effect of readers. They don't necessarily intend it, but do it just to stir up people's emotions. I mean, just look at the user's name - BonerPirate. :P
bytesize 1 year ago
@bytesize hey bitesize! always, after some unpleasantness on here, i find a decent person like you. you have incfreased my vocabulary by one word. maybe next time, i shall know when i have been "trolled" hahahaha and , well yes, "bonerpirate" = now that really is gay hehehehe, robbie
robbiew8n 1 year ago