Added: 1 year ago
From: XObarbarellaXO
Views: 277,884
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (329)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • @Bakuganbabe7

    no.. Pink is better

  • Better than from adam lambert..!

  • ooh this is good.

  • it really shows how awesome pink is when an amazing song like this doesnt even make it in the final cut for her album lol i love her version as much as adams. i think its great to have a male and female version of the same song...especially when its one with such a universal message that could easily come from either sex :)

  • It's her song, she wrote it and it's wonderful, full credit to Alecia.

  • Adam Lambert is better!!

  • 14 deaf people voted on this song!

  • I love what this song is about 

  • Why does everyone compare Adam and Pink's version of this song! They both are the best in their own ways! Adam sang it originally and Pink covered it, so TECHNICALLY he 'ownes' it but IT DOESN'T MATTER ANYWAYS!!! The point is, the song is epic, both versions are epic, and although everyone is entitled to their own opinion ya don't have to go on about 'Pink is soo much better, Adam shouldn't be given the credit, blah' because you're wasting your time.

    LOVE this song though! xD

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • @Do1phinDreamer ugh...Pink sang it originally. Who is better is based on the listener's opinion...but I wish some ppl get it through their thick heads. PINK SANG IT ORIGINALLY. This is NOT a cover.

  • Comment removed

  • @MsFockit The track was originally recorded and co-written by Pink for the album Funhouse but did not make the final cut. On November 18, 2009, Lambert announced via his official website that his second single from his debut album would be "Whataya Want from Me". The song was the second single announced before the CD was officially available to the public.

    In 2010, Pink's recording appeared on her first greatest hits compilation, Greatest Hits... So Far!!!.

  • @chaelavandongen right. her original recordings was first heard in 2010 even thought she co-wrote the song and recorded it way back in 2008. You're just repeating what I said before.

  • @Do1phinDreamer The song was pinks WAY before Mr gay pride parade ever touched it!

  • Much better than original !

  • I didn't know ths song was pink's D: i like it anyway But I prefer thousand times Adam Version!

    think it fixes better to him!

  • like adam is gettin all the credit......while it should be pink....booya!

  • @jakeshizzle I think a duet would be awesome with a capital AWE.

  • I like them both (Adam Lambert and Pink), but I like Pink's version. She has better range and voice control. No offense Adam.

  • didnt know pink wrote this! i love pink aswell how did i not know this haha :/ i think adams is a good version thon incredible voice idk how some ppl diss other ppl it just shows how horrible u really r as a person to try n put some one down adams not shit ....... no one is whos made it there just different ....... cos if they all sounded the same what would b the point?

  • Pink wrote this song!!! she so amazing!

  • If you write a song for someone you don't sing it and take credit for it lol

  • @AlexTehGr8 she didnt write it for him!!!!! he asked her if he could have it so just shut up!!!

  • @Lilmadonna1980 but she did write it...

  • @Lilmadonna1980 She did still write it though

  • Um y'all can shut the fuck up, because Pink wrote this song for him. She's has more talent then him anyway.

  • Comment removed

  • I love pink but I prefer Adam's version. I just think it fits him more.

  • I dont know but I kinda pefer pinks version a little more. But adam lambert does put some ooomph into it! :/ I dont know lol

  • Adam sings it WAYYYYYYYY better!!

  • pink wrote this song but she gave it to adam so its aadam song but she wrote it

  • i love her voice

  • I am so in love with P!NK and all of her music, I couldn't even explain it. I hope she's doing alright.

  • Comment removed

  • @TheBJoJo Pink, Max Martin and Shellback, not Lambert.

  • @Anne21110 Lambert too. I read it

  • @TheBJoJo Not Adam!

  • @kipseva

    This song was written by Max Martin. Look it up

  • love adam but this sooo shud have been released by her instead!!!!!!

  • Wow this is amazing(:

  • this version is soo much better cos it is the original , p!nk wrote it :)

  • Comment removed

  • I love this song it's amazing :)

    Fiction!

  • Both versions are AMAZING! But I adore Pink and always will, so I prefer this version. :)

  • i like the other version better but this is still awseome!

  • i love this song pink

    sings it the best

  • She wrote this song and this version is the best, i think :)

  • love this

  • I LOVE THEMM <3

  • delilah (sing-off) do an amazing version of this

  • When I heard this was originally pink's song, it made a lot of sense to me...but I really feel like Adam made it his own and I prefer his version.

  • I'm crazy in love with ADAM's version.....But pink is the one who wrote it so guess the original is always better <3

  • I think both versions sound incredibly similar and I'd LOVE to hear a Adam, P!NK duet in the future! :)

  • pinks version is wayy better

  • its a good thing they didnt changed the musical arrangement...

  • Pink does a much better job in my opinion.

  • wow i didnt noctice that pink wrote this.

    - ASH

  • I love Adam and Pink both! they killed this song!!

  • I love <3 this song and P!nk NO HOMO

  • NICE!

  • i love this.

    i slightly like adams more

  • I like it much better coming from her. She wrote it and it's obvious when you listen to it. You can tell that she feels what she is singing, I love this!

  • i just hate how people think the song belongs to adam

  • @ImTotallySummer me too. Dont get me wrong I like both versions of the song, but pinks owns it.

  • @butterfly153239 me 3 -_- i actually thought adam wrote it

  • @Ashooshoo101 Nope Pink did.

  • Comment removed

  • mom:hhey.honey how wAS SCHOOL

    me:hey slow it down

    mom:i was just asking..

    me:what do you want from me?!?!

    mom:you don't talk to me like that young lady

    me:yeah, i'm afraid

    mom;ok younge lady your grounded

    me:(takes headphone out)hey mom, guess what happen at school today?!?

  • P!nk's version better but i still like and respect Adam's. Although it is P!nk's song so of course she does better with it. Go figure. I love the fact that she gave her song to Adam saying he'll do better with it. P!nk is the coolest person I've ever seen <3

  • I love this version equaly with adams! But I admire how pink doesnt act like "yeah im too cool to do cover of someone elses songs" like other singers do! THATS WHY THEY COME OUT GREAT!!!!!!

  • @CASSOgreek It was actually her song before for another album. They just decied not to release it and gave it to Adam Lambert.

  • @CASSOgreek Actually, it's Pink's song, she wrote it, they decided to give it to Adam Lambert.

  • @CASSOgreek It is her song. It was supposed to be on funhouse. They canceled the release, but pink decided to give the demo to adam.

  • @jbl12321 OK I GOT IT!!! I GOT IT THE FIRST BIGILION TIMES!!!!! AND WHAT I SAID WAS ALSO FOR OTHER COVERS LIKE BOHEMIAN RHAPSODY ETC.!!!!!!! OK SO FUCK YOU AND EVERYBODY ELSE THAT TOLD ME THIS A THOUSAND TIMES!!!!!!!!

  • @CASSOgreek Um, sorry.... I didn't know a "bigillion" people told you this, only 2 others did. I don't really why you over reacted so much, i just told you a fact that you showed you didn't know. Typing in caps doesn't add to anything, it just makes you more irritating. Saying "fuck you" to someone trying to help is just stupid. Now I know to never try to help people like you.

  • @jbl12321 good because it pisses them off!

  • i need this on itunes!!!

  • Why does it always have to be either/or? I'm tired of YouTube comments being this way. Can't we like both versions without people insulting us?

  • YEAH!!!!!! for the picture at 1:00!!! :D

  • I like pinks version better. i got sick of adam's after hearing it 4! times on the radio then more times to come... U_U

  • I would have liked this song if pink sang it instead

  • @bransta81 I agree!

  • Comment removed

  • TO SETTLE ALL THIS ARGUEING...... I THINK THE BEATLES VERSION IS BEST!

  • Adam's version is much much better ;))) there's no heart in her version like in his version.....

  • They're both so emotional. I love both versions. :)

  • Hmmm, they're both amazing! i love them both equal I think! <3

  • I love Adam Lambert (to the moon) But BY DAMN, he has been replaced on this song! P!nk delivers it BETTER with BETTER lyrics.....

  • Adams.. IS MUCH MUCH MUCH.. Better.

  • i like both adam and p!nks version they r my favorite singers and inspire me alot

  • Adam's version is better for me. ;P

  • i Like Adams Version Better. P!nk is amazing but adam makes the song... Good :)

  • i loke both versions but i LOVE nakia's! must be said!

  • So who owns the song? Adam or Pink? The first one I heard was by Adam, then I see this and it's the exact same, except sung by a female! I mean, I love both versions but I'm so confused at which is the original.

  • @Moonlar1001 It was originally a song from Pink's 2008 album Funhouse, but it was cut, then she gave it to Adam, then released her version on the Greatest Hits... So Far in 2010.

  • @Moonlar1001 pink wrote the song for adam lambert originally

  • @Arunnya thanks

  • @Arunnya No, she wrote it for funhouse, but it didn't make the cut. then she gave it to adam.

  • P!nk wrote this song!

  • This is indeed much better! Pink wrote this song to express her own feelings and with this song she sings her soul out while Adam... he sings the lyrics, Pink sings the feelings

  • I have seriously raped the replay button on this song....Love It

  • P!nk's version is sooooooooooo much better! I love you P!nk!

  • nevermind i found out the Australian, Dutch and German version of the greatest hits has the song "Whataya want from me" on it.

  • does her greatest hits have this song on it? i looked at the list on the album and i don't see it but there are 2 unnamed songs on the album.

  • Aaahhhh!! Pink Ish Soooo KEWL!! When I Listen To This Song I Start To Boogie Dooowwwnnnn Babee! Woooo!!! <3333333

  • I always liked Adam`s version and I still am.Now that I here pink`s version,it`s very good as well.Like them both now♥

  • am i the only one here who loves both versions?

  • @ivsi90 hell no!

  • @ivsi90 no i like both versions but i feel ur pain

  • @ivsi90 Nope. I'm right there with ya

  • wow, pink totally rocks this song! i still love adam and his version, but pink's is just as good :)

  • Pink>Adam. Nuff said.

  • I like both pink and adam Lamberts versions both togetther

  • Really basing Adam Lambert common P!NK may have wrote it but Adam made this song it's HIS song and she did a great job though i prefer Adam he seems to relate to it more

  • yeah love pinks version better <3

  • they're both awesome guys! ok what i want for christmas this year is for p!nk and adam lambert to do a REAL duet of this. Santa, if you are real, make this one wish come true.

  • what r u guys talking about u lik p!nk's version better ? theres nothing differant about them ! just ones a female singer and a male. haha but i lik both singers, more adam though. haha i love adam <3 but p!nk didnt need this song she has a ton of hits ! this was adam's first so its good for him <3

  • I love her!! I always do!!!

  • Her voice fits the song better who agrees???? Adams I didnt really like his pitch on it

  • i like this version much more than the from adam lambert....

    pink is great..love her<3

  • Hmm.. no offense to Adam Lambert, but I never quite "felt it" with him and this song. Then I listen to this version and we -ALL- know P!nk's story - the lyrics just make sense now. Love hearing her heart in her voice.

  • I like both. 

  • She was the one who wrote this for Adam Lambert guys!

  • @JoJoBeebe she didn't write it for Adam. She wrote and recorded it for her album FunHouse but decided not to use it and later sold it to Adam

  • I like adams better but its good!

  • Both equally great!

  • I like both versions but I think adams version is a bit better =)

  • awesome pink's version but i prefer Adam's version :)

  • I like both, though if I had to pick. I'd choose Pink.

  • Appreciate it Pink, great emotion but I feel Adam's voice more so than Pink's to the tune of this song - just a preference! in all honesty Petie Pizarro's cover blows them both out of the water

  • OMG !! I never knew she actually wrote that song ! OMg ! SHE's perfect <3

  • PINKS IS WAY BETTER!

  • Why do you have to compare versions? I like both.

  • The track was originally recorded and co-written by Pink for the album Funhouse but did not make the final cut

  • ofcourse pink sing much better

  • from what I know (and read) The song was originally from Pink for the album Funhouse but didn't make it and was left unreleased until Adam Lambert sang it on American Idol....but I might be mistaken....I LOVE BOTH VERSION! I specially love the one in which bothe versions are mixed up as a duet! :)

  • I don't know which version I like better! They're both great!

  • @iheartiker i gotta agree so bummed not on the albumn in the uk

  • I love them both. They're both very talented musicians. (:

  • i like 'em both

  • I love them both!!! She actually wrote this song for Adam Lambert!!

  • @amyfite1 actually pink wrote this song, and then decided she didnt want it anymore, so then it went floating around, then adam heard it and decided he liked it so he took it (with pinks permission obviously). it wasnt actually made for adam specifically

  • I love them both!!!

  • not much of a difference. =D pretty similar voices :D

  • Adam´s version is so much better =D!!!!

  • i would say that is more of a pink song from the start

  • P!nk <3 all the way.

    Don't give me wrong, I love Adam; I was one of those people screaming at the tv when he didn't win. XD But being written by her, she sings it with the most heartfelt emotion.

  • i love versions. but i do favor adams more. i love adam

  • Pink's version is way more better!!

  • p!nk's

    

  • I like Adams version more ;>

  • this version is better! :) .

  • I like both songs sung by Adam Lambert and Pink :)

  • i think that adam lambert and pink should do a song together, they would sound amazing! They both got such awesome voices:P

  • Being a Lambert fan, I adore his version but after hearing P!nk, her's sounds a tad more emotional and I think her voice suits this song better. (Hey, I still love Adam's version!!!)

  • Prefiro a P!nk cantando, muito melhor. I ♥ P!nk

  • i like P!nks betterrr :) Fersurreee

  • Both of version are both beautified and amazing! Pink wrote the song, and Pink and Adam version, are both emotions.. <3 <3 <3

  • I love Pink's version so much! The emotion (especially the "I'm a a freak part) is much deeper than in Adam's version.

  • I actually like both versions...they both have that husky rockish great voice so...I love it

  • are you guys kidding?? adam's version is so much better. it's incredible! not only does he sing it n the exact same key, but i hear far more emotion in adam's version than in this one. at some points, it almost sounds like she's bored singing this. this just doesn't do it for me. adam lambert all the way!!

  • @whatsabolero xaxaxa ...No way , P!nk's version is much , much better .... Because her voice , emotion And because it's Pink! Perhaps your hearing is damaged?Cuz when adam sings this song is like "I'm devoid of emotions!" :)

  • @VaNcHeTy1 +fwnwwwwww

  • @VaNcHeTy1 Adam Lambert devoid of emotion??? MY GOD. Seriously? Have you heard him sing? You can say everything about Adam but not that he is devoid of emotion.

  • @VaNcHeTy1 Pink wrote it and let Adam use it.

  • @MrTresFierce Yeah,I know that! :)