Added: 5 years ago
From: mkabkep
Views: 253,522
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (387)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Oasis created Brit-Pop. Stone Roses were more post 80's alternative rock.

  • @bestsupportingactor1 Oasis created Brit-Pop and the Stone Roses were post 80's? Let's evaluate your claims.

    Stone Roses' first album: 1989

    Blur's first album: 1991

    Suede's first album: 1993

    Oasis' first album: 1994

    There's a clear lineage, and although the Stone Roses might be more Madchester than BritPop, they still had a clear influence on the genre's formation. And how could they be post 80's if they were out in the 80's?

  • Snow Patrol aren't shite.

  • no apologies< please. Just exactly what I needed. Thanks

  • a band of united fans, there last gig of the tour is at old trafford, whats more beautiful than that :-) , love the roses !!!

  • The resurection = 29/06/12

  • THEY'RE COMING BACK GUYS

  • reni is the man

  • i hope justin beiber does a cover of this

  • @qdb07165 i hope justin beiber dies before he kills music even more.

  • emma 

  • PRICELESS...

  • Comment removed

  • haven´t heard this for 3 years.heard it today on the radio.portugal

    musica espectacular.dificilmente havera melhor

  • sometimes I fantasise there is no looser and winer sometimes I look into your eyes and see your intelligence going like a thunder through your pupil is not complicated your pain is the art everyone admires you cause sometimes I fantasise how cruelty carved your soul :)
  • @olusiaify that ain't the lyrics? :L

  • sometimes I fantasise there is no looser and winers sometimes I look into your eyes and see your intelligence going like a thunder through your pupil is not complicated your pain is the art everyone admires you cause sometimes I fantasise how cruelty carved your soul :)
  • This is what music is all about

  • Blast From The Past

  • wow, nothing beats smoking a joint to this song, just perfect.

  • genius , shame the poster got the name of the song wrong

  • genius

  • My cousin thinks that the Stone Roses is a shit band. He has absolutely no appreciation to music. Will you peopl please reply to this comment to educate my cousin?

  • @WaterfordWhiteBoys everyone is free to think what ever they want .

  • @WaterfordWhiteBoys what band he thinks is good? rap?

  • @WaterfordWhiteBoys

    Anyone who thinks the Stone Roses are shit has had a taste bypass.

  • 15 dislikes...justin beibers real fans must be starting there own campaign against real music.

  • This is the sound of Time melting into Eternity...

  • The World owes so much to Manchester: The Hollies, Oasis and The Stone Roses. What more could anyone want?

  • @animagus1

    you forgot the smiths and the charaltans

  • @animagus1

    London, Glasgo n Leeds? Madman haha

  • best band from manchester

  • just perfection..start to finish ...

  • Love this !! :D

  • MAKES ME PROUD TO BE A MANCUNIAN

  • @leedumett444 Make proud to be a human

  • sometimes i fantasize about being ian....drugs and IMMENSE music.....oh what life would be like...

  • song is perfect

  • :) makes me smile this song :)

  • you are the resurrection Andy!

  • my favourite stone roses song:)

  • the music of legend nowadays the only people who produced anything like it were oasis and their nothing without noel

  • @wulli1988 oasis never even got anywhere near this , they put music backwards

    about 20 years & no one will be putting out a 20th anniversery of "def maybe"

  • @goonchistaw just for that i will put a definatly maybe 20 years aneversary edition on

  • @o0odennyo0o1 that's fine , but why don't you learn to spell correctly first instead of guessing how words are formed. definitely learn to use grammar in a correct way

    then do what you want . seeing as you are clueless you'd just make a mess anyway.

  • @goonchistaw you spelt the word anniversary incorrectly in one of your comments. i think you need to learn how to spell correctly instead of guessing how words are formed. 

  • Comment removed

  • @kevinarmes cunt

  • @MrNewman24 and who pulled your succinct chain? LMFAO

  • @kevinarmes jus luv these mANCHESTER BOYZ WEN I DRUNK...AND ALWAYS.. SHUT UP BITCH,.......

  • @kevinarmes jus luv these mANCHESTER BOYZ WEN I DRUNK...AND ALWAYS.. SHUT UP BITCH,....... do you even make sense soft cunt......?

  • @rickwriteoff well, sounds coherent. The media created the shitty phenomena known as grunge too. But different to the Roses, neither of the bands from that phenomena actually did good music. Just young rebels' anthems that nowadays are considered as classic, but in fact are rubbish.

  • Del Shannon Runaway 

  • Love this tune,god bless the Roses

  • It's Bowie and Iggy's China Girl.

  • @theelephantman thats not a bad call... but its actually very like a song called runnaway from early 60's...

  • @seanreillyireland No it isn't!! It doesnt sound anything like Runaway. Where did you get that idea from?

  • @KernowFilms Maybe its just me, so!

  • bring back the roses. a 1 off gig like spike island would b legendry.

  • Thanks Stone Roses, FOR BEING THE BEST OF MADCHESTER AND CREATING BRITPOP

  • TENGO EL POSTER CUANDO NADIE LOS APOYAVABA,BARRACA Y VALENCIA SI.killandy572

  • @rickwriteoff they are playing on Saturday, August 7 @FifeFest 2010 in Dunfermline so I may try and get tickets to see them - never had the chance to see them live.

  • @rickwriteoff - If you want to be reminded of Belfast listen to SLF - absolute F**king brilliant group and songs!!

  • me hace recordar un dia que senti soledad

    great!

  • you know ....! I am one of those pricks who don't like the music when its relesed but only realise the brillance of it years later . I was into larry levan and house music at this time ,but now i hope I have dropped all this snobishness about music and can appriate good music even if am too l8 to enjoy it at the time , I still dont listen to the charst But i guess there must be a few good bands in there today ?

  • obviously a genius song from the greatest band EVER! its quite annoying how utter shite bands like athlete,coldplay & snore patrol have sold more records than the stone roses. there is no justice

  • oh dear i think someone has sussed that bands steal ideas and make tunes by mixing their own aaaaaaaaahhhhhhhhh what will we do have a word with yourselves and just listen who cares whos the best take it from someone who knows both bands personally

  • @nipperj61 your a cock

  • @scottmarshall83 grow up sunshine i dont know you and vice versa but your obviously small minded

  • reminds me of my yoof :)

  • You fry and melt, I love the scene.

  • all i can say thats a real comment is... i wish these dudes were still makin music cuz this shit touches my heart & soul! seriously

  • ok , wots their best tune then?

  • @muzzamania this!

  • they were the best.... ever

  • YAAAAAAAY! I LOVE THE STONE ROSES!!!!

  • fukin awsome tune

  • @gazzaderby1 fuckin' right its fuckin' awsome.

  • what's great about mixing "In The Year 2525" and "Paint it Black"?

  • piss poor comment !

  • off course it is a piss poor comment for narrowminded feeble brains who knows fuck all about music!

  • dont be too harsh on urself huns!

  • @drav6 OK! My point was they mixed them two songs and updated the sound and made it more dancable. that was the trick! a fucking smart trick. love the song and have both the 7" and the 12" but they were more clever than innovative!

  • there are some similarities between those 2 songs but its very subtle and does'nt seem deliberate,but yeh damn good song.

  • excellent music, not beaten by anything in today`s world music scene.

    Nostalgic as hell!

  • Comment removed

  • norm stop whinging about people enjoying incredible music from the past and you'll be have more time to enjoy the 'breathtaking' delights that music right now has to offer

  • good driving music at night

  • Brilliant! Classic! Timeless. Music like this is not made any more which is a bloody shame.

  • Pure Manc genius

  • Lyrics are pure genius, infact the whole song is genius.Shame music like this isnt around anymore.

  • @ColieHatesBohs

    sure it is....... im listening to it now :P

  • @ColieHatesBohs

    D.I.Y. mate

    dont wait on the next Roses.... live the dream!! x

  • @ColieHatesBohs well it fuckin' is your fuckin' listening to the fuckin' stuff you shit head.

  • brilliant tune reminds me of away days in edinburgh :D

  • @bairns123 LOL

  • just love this song.. remind me of my time in England..

  • im 15, i wasnt around during the time os the stone roses, but i wish i was. they are incredible. amazing!

  • me too

  • So many great memories of this song, just makes me feel great when I hear it.

  • elroy ook

  • Koen is een faggot

  • one of thier best, without a doubt.

  • this song puts me somewhere that is so hard to explain , i grew up with this , live with this and will die with this .

  • thoughts go out to Big Dan of South London Origin.....Luv Ya Matey Peeps

  • Pure quality.

    Top notch tune, in my mind their finest.

  • love it best roses tune

  • great song (L)

  • two minutes of silence, cant ya'll count ?

  • Well sorry for saying it was a good song. Why did you give me a thumbs down. I got confuse becasue i was looking at the other guy. So go give him a thumbs down. And cant YOU spell?

  • Annoying that teres 3 miutes of silence bt its a graet song, reminds me of football (or soccer in america)

  • You don't need to listen to the silence. ¬¬

  • Erm. I never said you did, Dumb ass.

    I said its annoying theres silence because when i listen to it in my playlist it doesnt automatialy change when its ended becasue of the silence

  • It doesn't automatically change, no. So change it manually. Or is that beyond a "Dumb ass"?

  • Click play all and it will automatcially change but you gotta change it manually because of the stupid silence unless you wait 3 minutes.

  • class tune :)

  • Fantastic song. Great chorus, just makes me feel so happy when I am down.

  • greatest chorus ever... never fails to make me feel uplifted wen it kicks in... god I love this song! x

  • The Em-Em7-Em6-C-Em intro is fuckin class. Taken directly from Eleanor Rigby I'd be willing to bet.

  • about time someone posted a comment with a fuckin useful question ,wy the silence? it's a great song but do we have to mourn on it?

  • The person who uploaded the song has poor editing skills. I never literally listen (and never watch) music "videos" on Youtube from end to end though.

  • Why is there about 3 minutes of silence in this?

  • incredable shit that someone has put as spam on my favourite list.

  • Epic song isn't it :)

  • Made of Stone is like pearl from the bottom of the sea

  • secret agent man?

  • lol...how did you get to secret agent man??? same sounding music score?

  • love it when the chorus kicks in.

  • start again!!lol

  • this song is the best of the best, stone roses, una de las mejores bandas del mundo. malcom x

  • Reni is god

  • Best band ever!

  • Best band and one of the best songs ever

  • very true very true

  • proper game as f*ck tune!!

  • wow so concerned wot u think

  • Why does everyone talk shit on youtube? your all yanks who have such a bad music up bringing with the likes of the jonas brothers! the good abnds that you do produce you dont even like!

  • go on my son!! love it mate

    england #1

  • i adore you

  • hah!

    well said mate

  • @bilbib11 Too rite mate!! Yank bands are fukin crap!!!

  • @bilbib11 True, true.

  • @bilbib11 *goes out to a club and listens to dubstep, defends it musically*

    oh right lol

  • Simple amazing.

  • exceptional..........

  • uaaaaaooooo!

  • super nuta;)

    Karolina

  • This song sounds too much like China Girl by David Bowie.

  • ARE U FUCKIN STUPID M8? It sounds nothing like it! Prick

  • Wow...didn't think I would get called a prick for that observation. I hear the correlation...especially in the bassline.

  • nothing like it mate lol, take that fish bowl off ur head u numpty :P

  • It's the same chords as China Girl

  • just noticed that myself, you can actually sing along the China Girl lyrics, " my little china girl, you shouldn't mes with me. I'll ruin everything you are" Spot ON! lol

  • Em-D-C-B....both tunes. Can't argue with that.

  • Well there's some "clever" people who can't hear anything beyond a pretty chorus heh heh!

  • Comment removed

  • what a tit china girl

  • Can't believe it's been 20-years since the album was released. It still sounds incredible. Throws up so many memories of being 19 with the world at my feet.

  • Great tune! Great! I fav. of the Stone Roses!