Added: 3 years ago
From: ASIL72
Views: 481,152
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (432)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • YOU-CANT-FOOL-ME-BITCH---YOU-A­RE-A-FUCKING-POSER--QUIT-BITCH­-QUIT-.IF-YOU-CANT-SING-BITCH

  • Taylor Swift is not hot...but beautiful and sweet..:)...

  • @izzah4031 she is beautiful and sweet

  • i did a cover of love story, plz check it!!

  • @joesulub You should listen MEAN is for you, also listen it LIVE! It will not bother you if you already watch her videos... I think XD

  • @joesulub You should listen MEAN is for you, also listen it LIVE! It will not bother you if you already watch her videos... I think XD And I see you like Rebecca Black... so, what are you telling Tay can't sing... if Rebecca is the worst? it doesn't have sense

  • grymt!

  • Watch /watch?v=C5XcqLl2_Qo , or check my channel for a beautiful summer version of this =)

  • I love this song... but she CAN'T sing. If you listen to her, REALLY listen... it is TERRIBLE! she has no lungs and so voice it is breaking constantly, she is also WAY to quiet, you can hardly hear her.

    Or maybe that is because she is taking a breath ever other five seconds. O3o

    Either way, I love this song. I do. And I thank you for uploading. :)

  • @SlakeDragon i thought she sucked live in tv and youtube too, but i just went to 3 of her concerts in a row, and she was amazing in all!! when i heard what my brother videotaped, she sounded flatter than before, but when ur there live, she sounds almost exactly like her cd =) but still, she improved on her singing skills a LOT his year for speak now, whatever she did =) her live performances for her speak now album has been amazing

  • @shiningstars1997 thats what i have to tell people! video messes up her voice! she sounds amazing live!

  • @TaylorSwiftFan139 ikr?! i went to her concert and i was blown away, and i was taking a video, and then i watched the video afterwards and she didnt sound as good as she actually was. and im actually really confused!! why does she sound so flat when she's not?

  • wannabe

  • She's amazing!! I love you Taylor! <3

  • sub her and add her as friend.she is willing to help new talents.go now!

  • check out SaraBoutin's cover of taylor swift on her channel...she actually works with the producer taylor HAD...

  • i thinks she's hot...

  • her dress is so shiny!

  • @Hzqi think bout urself, just think bout urself...compare that to trash.. Think bout it. I'm probably going to be away.

  • she is not the greatest singer ever but she's good and plus she writes her own songs and music

  • U can't expect her voice 2 be like her album it sounds perfectly good.

  • LINDA

  • is that a signer? O.o

  • Heyvtaylor I love u .u hav to get people to watch the mystery it's funny and I love u these are my top song of yours love story. You belong with me. Our song. And today was a fairytale

  • I love u taylor my favorite 3 songs r our song love story and you belong with me

  • i hate how the audience sings..its like "STFU, its her concert!"

  • She sounds just like in the CD! Amazing.

  • Taylor is a nice girl,I like her so much,but she need to learn to protect her voice due to sing continuious without taking a good rest.

  • Thank god for that crowd singing along.  Poor girl needs something to drown out her sound.

  • @blahhduhhx3

    can you do better...i doubt it....

  • @efs5030 Hahahaha. So because I comment on how.. well "lovely" her voice is. I must have a terrible one, myself? Grow up please.

  • Actually compared to alot of singer who do live concerts she does the best job of sounding like she does on her cd's. She maybe alittle sharp or flatt in some places but she does a pretty damn good job! Keep it up Taylor!

  • its quite shocking how much her voice is editied on the cds!

  • @JCShizz Are you serious? You have no ears if you say that... She may be doesn't sing perfect, but it's almost like in her albums! Why the people write things that shows how much ignorant are?

  • @NausAllien

    Ignorant? No, really. She sucks, like. Completely.

  • @Hzqi No, you must be deaf or something. She's not perfect, but definitly she doesn't sucks... I like to see you singing like her in front of 1000 people. So we shall see WHO'S THE SUCKER ;-)

  • @NausAllien

    No, not deaf. Ears are very good. The problem isn't that she's not perfect. I like lots of signers who are far from technically "perfect". Some are outright technically off their heads. "Perfect" is an ambiguous thing to give context. No, the problem is that she's like a piece of stale white bread. Devoid of exception OR flavour.

    1000 you say? Well, we could arrange that, but that would involve me getting into contact. Fat chance of that happening.

  • @Hzqi It was just a saying 8-) ... Anyway, I agree with something: Taylor does not have enough charisma to give a good performance on stage. It is as if she had no soul. But, I still think SHE DOESN'T SUCK, she just need more stage experience...

  • @NausAllien

    I think there are far bigger crimes against the ears than Swift. The only reason she drew my attention was because of her sudden slew of accolades, which I found to be the most supreme insult against a host a truly gifted visionaries in the craft, today. I'm not personally affected, merely hurling my own 10 cents. Everyone was arguing about "Gaga shoulda this!", "Beyonce shoulda that", "No really, Swift deserved to" To what? None of them should've been there. It's a cash cow.

  • @NausAllien

    I'm all ears when people want to air their thoughts, but I still don't soften my own. With more stage experience, Swift will go from being a rough version of bland, to a polished version of bland. I couldn't say which is more lacking. To be of interest to me, she'd have to be miraculously reborn as an artist. Which means that until that unlikely event occurs she IS of no interest. There's too much of merit to be preoccupied with, rather than what might become of the exalted.

  • Her songs are like a well made brown coffee table. Make it as sure, and stable, and safe and clean as you like. It's a fucking coffee table. She's channelling archetypal visions of romance, that were pallid to begin with, and packaging them with the paddle-pool depth of a teenage diarist. Really, what is the overarching substance of her work? Teenager, boy, crush, sad, woeisme, boy, I'm pretty/ugly, whachadoingwither? It's unilaterally trite and disposable. Devoid of profundity.

  • @NausAllien

    And by that I mean on both levels. Her singing and her lyrics. Sigur Rós as a random example could imbue a random syllable with more compelling expression than her entire written catalogue of cardboard crackers.

  • @Hzqi Well, I have to be agree with some of your statements. But this is country music, like pop the meaning of this music is not about lyrics, complicated instrumental, or a great voice... is about something that could catch everybody. I listen this music to relax myself. As pop singer I think Britney is more interesting (her songs are much better than Taylor's anything). And for real music, I hear Amy Lee from Evanescence (for me this is outstanding but at the same time interesting music).

  • @NausAllien

    That's almost equivilent to saying "the purpose of pop is to do nothing interesting". There are many purveyors of "pop" music that imbue their music with rewarding substance within the context of the "pop" form. One of the most recent winners of the Best Album Grammy was a pop album that actually warranted the attention. OutKasts excellent Speakerboxxx/The Love Below. If the selecetions were usually that mindful, they wouldn't be held as such a dismal joke by nearly all peers.

  • @Hzqi I dont think u can sing as well as her... yes mayb others can but nooooo not u, taylor is ordinary yes mayb u r right but ordinary is wat makes us special in our own way

  • @coolgirl103

    I'm staring blankly at the screen. But I'm laughing inside. My inner-rofl is tickled, thanks.

  • she sucks when she sings live...well still i'm a big fan!

  • Lol good gong

  • Taylor Swify esta embarazada o que ?

  • Good gong

  • Taylor Swift porte JH qui signifie Juif Hater et elle est debout à côté d'un gars portant une croix gammée. Cela m'amène à croire que Taylor Swift est un raciste et soutient cette forme de bêtise et la haine.

    elle n'est pas un écrivain song!

    ELLE ne peut pas chanter et jouer des instruments

    D'être avec quelqu'un qui porte une croix gammée

    CELA SIGNIFIE ANTI SEMINIST!

  • @manu07041 kess tu jape toi

  • Comment removed

  • she can't sing live.

    but she makes good music ^^

  • I swear that she's actually tone-deaf... every live performance sounds like this...

  • i hate saying if its pop or country or anything else it could be either tbh

  • @xsophiex999 you're right. I am glad it failed at the Grammy's for all the world to see! Don't get me wrong it sounded good on CD and Music Videos, but seriosly, it is not good at all LIVE! She gave competition on CD for Country and POP. But LIVE, hell no!

  • @ Lencho5000Watts TAYLOR SWIFT NE PEUT pas chanter et des jeux L'guitarre!

  • @ Lencho5000Watts TAYLOR SWIFT SEULEMENT AVOIR UN RECORD COMPANY elle ne peut pas chanter et jouer des instruments!

  • Comment removed

  • YOU SUCK! Taylor is AMAZING.

  • deutch?!'. xD

  • just because her voice sounds like country does not make the song country

    :-) it is pop with very slightly country style.

  • this is pop not country actually,

    but then i hate boxing people into different types of music if you are a musician you should have the freedom to do what ever style you like

  • @dyslexic89 Wel it's country, wih alot of pop in it, but not all poop...

  • @Avalon1929 hehee u sed poop

  • @librafools12 pls lets just appreciate her!

  • Now do you understand why the music industry is on life support? This young lady is the best that the country music industry has to offer? If so, this industry is in deep trouble. I thought at least country music had gotten past the cheap studio tricks. Please find the next Reba, Martina, Carrie or Patty Loveless. It doesn't need a new Shania.

  • what is ur problem, u keep commenting the same thing on all her vids! do u have no other opinions except to tear down someone who works hard and makes other ppl happy? sheesh! just because she doesnt naturally have the voice of a diva, doesnt mean she can't be a singer. Geez. lighten up

  • Couldn't agree more. She writes very cute songs though, I will give her that.

  • I like her soo much .

    She´s a very good singer ..

  • This was on October 12th 2008. I was at a Jonas Brothers concert that day!

  • taylor é super perfeita *-*

  • Instruments are fine. It's the vocals.

  • Kanye west is a stupid guy i think she amazing

  • @ruidor4 Kanye west was right when he says that what beyonce did is better .

    but he has not the right . i think a lot can sing like Taylor but not like beyonce .

  • @marrakechmusique But they can't write songs like taylor. Nothing is better than a original singer writing there original songs.

  • you know what arsen she is good, better than the so called miley cyrus slut

  • YOUR A MEAN PERSON BIG TIME

  • She's not a Britney Spears wannabe. For one thing, Taylor is country and Britney is pop. For another thing, I sure don't see Taylor strutting around onstage wearing barely anything like Britney does.

  • Taylor is more pop than country actually, but that's fine by me. Beyonce is a fantastic singer and personality, but JLo or Jenny from the block what???, and Muhammad Ali was perhaps one of the few men in history who acted like an asshole, bragging and declared that he was the greatest man alive (while having some losses unlike Rocky Marciano...ouch). I can't even remember Hitler saying the same thing.

  • You guys don't get it do you? Sitting flapping your gums as your typing bs down. I already said everything I needed to say about this PRIMA DONNA, if you don't like it then it's not my fault that you can't see the big picture!!!

  • @ kanov TAYLOR SWIFT CAN NOT SING AND PLAY THE GUITARRE !

  • If there's one thing I respect about Taylor its that she's genuine. The type of HW starlet that could say she was a virgin & I'd believe her. Miley not so much. Problem is I find Taylors music very juvinile. Its all about frilly romance & boycrushes. Basically its all fluff w/ nothing at the core. Not worthy of major music awards. Also I hope she improves her singing. Her live performances need work.

  • @Juvchan TAYLOR SWIFT ONLY HAVE A RECORD COMPANY she can not sing and play instruments !

  • @FlyleafLover18

    give her a few years... noone thought brittney would end up the queen of trailor park trash either. Taylor isnt a good singer, when the looks go, which too me arent that great to begin with... will see what happens. and was directed to this video to settle a debate on if she can sing live... she isnt very good.

  • Taylor isn't trying to be another britney or JLO in the making i agree with flyleaflover18 she does no strut around with hardly anything on and the video is pretty poor quality no affence but she's just a girl living up her dream!!

    Go Taylor!

  • woah dude

    u need to chill out wit that little comment of yours

    romeo and juliet is a great play and y wouldnt u wanna make a song out of it???

    and getting an idea from the play isnt plagiarism

    its being creative

    i mean seriously???

    stop being such a hater!

    oh yea and u spelled plagiarism wrong:P

  • i will always love u taylor swift..

  • The sign language lady should be in every taylor swift concert! She's awesome!

  • I just love how everyone sings along. :D.

  • i luv Taylor Swift she is such a sweet girl a talented singer :)

  • the audience shud shut up...i can barely hear her...

  • Comment removed

  • loving the banjo!!!

  • Have you, who are talking she can't sing, ever heard e.g. Shakira singing live? It's just horrible! Taylor is perfect - and it's good, it isn't exactly the same as on her CDs. She is human and very talented.

  • @JeanneMaryT dont compare Shakira with taylor.

  • at least she actually sings and not lip sync like 90% of the artist

  • im talors biggest fan i love her im planning on being a singer just like her she is so preety. shes got the preetyest voice anybody could have love ya taylor

  • She's best new comer for a reason. Her voice definitely is unusual, perhaps she knows how to use it to the best advantage. Her background shows that she has been singing since birth. Decided to this when she's only 10 while we just play games. Furiously devoted, practice 4 hrs a day rigorously; sometimes she don't stop even when her fingers bled. Very focus. It's no matter why she can write all her songs. At 19 this level of accomplishment is deserving of such talent.

  • @yendirna

    I nearly fell over laughing when I heard the "played til my figners bled" line. The only thing she's more mediocre at than singing is playing guitar. I don't even need to outline an opinion on how overrated this "nice girl" is. Time is the enemy of mediocrity, and time is on my side. It will consume her like an anaconda. Her voice is not unusual in any way, other than how blindingly ORDINARY it is. Not only is she a technically weak singer. She's utterly devoid of charisma.

  • LOL, if u hate her why cant u atleast sing as her when she sings bad huh? well duh she has a singing voice. She is a normal human bean after all not a radio or sumthin. We all know we cant sing like her, and shouldnt make fun of somebody in singing or watever, atleast u cant do it as well as tht person. Answer tht haters! why u watchin this video then answer my comment u talyor HATERS!

  • god you people are dumb. pitch problems? no. it's called she's human. she's gonna miss a few notes here and there. all singers do it. nobody's perfect

  • ye she prob just missed the notes because she couldnt hear herself over the people

  • why are people talkin bout my girlfriend like that, =P

  • i love taylor swift eyes

    very beauty

  • I love Taylor all... :D

  • uhm, she was having some pitch problems.. she didn't quite hit some notes.. Or maybe that's just 'cause she couldn't hear her own voice that's why she was having trouble with controlling her notes.. :D

    But hey, still love her. :P

  • oh wow im so glad the world has you as a critic .. she should not sing anymore cause your such an expert hey .. fucking loser go bash somewhere else why you even watch this vid if you dont like her singing?

  • Oh wow, I'm so glad the world (youtube) has you as the police? This was the first video I've seen of her playing live, because if you read my entire comment, which wasn't "bashing", then you'd know that I enjoy the music. I'm no expert, believe me, but clearly you're far inferior to me when it comes to musical knowledge if you can't hear that she does not have a voice powerful enough to be wielding the millions of dollars that she gets for it. Way to be mature about it though (sarcasm).

  • Were is that guy went the song is almost ending?? Were Is Him?

  • omg oô

    sooo great.

    & her DRESS! WOW! ♥

  • aahhaahahhaaha

  • hahah lol wts wrong with that guy....:P:P lol

  • its sounds amazing live:)

  • whats with the guy headbanging to this song?

  • Hahahahaha can't help but to reply... Totally agree to u!

  • what kind of music is this?

  • country-ish pop. <3

  • country with a pop "spillover" :)

  • more like pop with a banjo.

  • i memerrize this song even when im a boy

  • i think shes still hot,but her voice is worse then the music video

  • i love this song and taylor swift too

  • Look at the guitar-man :D

  • that was in reply to mustangcassie17

  • I think the VERY BIG difference beteween MJ and taylor swift (even if it isn't comparable) is that MJ is the King of Pop and enven when he was on live he had a great voice ! His songs are mythics and taylor swift is just a blond ordinary singer with an ordinary voice with ordinary songs that maybe in two years we definetly forgot !! I'm sorry for her fans but please don't mixe these two singers...for the music pleeaasse !

  • actually no, it is pretty damn stupid to compare a pop singer to a country singer.

    but some people are right about how her voice is going to sound on stage or in a recording studio. you can go to a concert to any artist and its going to sound different. that's how it is.

  • Exactly right! Happens to everyone! Even listen to Miley Cyrus on American Idol singing the climb!

  • you guys are dumb for comparing taylor swift to mj. those are two different music styles...wtf. and every singer's voice is different live than on a cd or the radio or whatever. its not that hard to figure out if you've been to concerts.

    its called common sense people.

  • SO true! I mean Taylor does country and Michael does pop.. They have different voices, yet they are both good!

  • You aren't very smart mustangcassie.

  • imádom ezt a számot

  • go and watch her other live vids. her voice is the same so its not the mike.

  • (correction) problem with the audio or mike or something...thank you so don't blame her...

    i like her!

  • She's better live then most teen stars, not amazing but good.

  • I agree!

  • best live talent live was Michael Jackson.

    R.I.P