Added: 4 years ago
From: silpherx
Views: 2,138,173
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (4,118)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • iove melissa

  • 可愛い><

  • hottest girl in the universe and she is an awesome singer too!

  • 4-5 years later and I'm still hurt and angry by this decision. they pick the drop out, asia who didn't even get to sing with the group. melissa r fan for life.

  • They didn't pick her cos she looks like Nicole and it'll be weird if there were two girls that looked the same

  • I loove this song they play this at the schools dance every time

  • She has a more natural R&B vibe than Nicole, I like this actually. I think they didn't pick her because the girl who won was vocally stronger than her and a much more seasoned performer. Melissa is a great dancer but her vocals are too raw and though she's obviously super talented, she doesn't seem as driven as the other one.

  • @benjsinister ASIA was stronger vocally????? Hell naw! She sucked raw! And her dancing was ok, but desperate, and to top it off she wasn't likeable or pretty enough to make up for ANY of that!

  • @Rosannasfriend I know Asia sucked, I was rooting for Melissa R during the whole competition. Obviously Melissa R was a better dancer and way prettier but Asia did have stronger vocals than Melissa R. She wasn't as good as Chelsea vocally but she had more skill than Melissa whose voice was still raw and her technique wasn't that developed. I do wish Melissa won but I guess she has more good things before her.

  • shes amazing !

  • she is not better then nicole!!!!

  • the girl that won was never in the group ever again waht a waste

  • she looks more vanessa. But im glad they didnt pick her she deserves better!!

  • The obvious reason why she wasn't picked is because she's better than nicole and they  know it

  • I watched every episode of this, and I don't remember her.

    At all.

  • @heyyninaa she was the runner up lol

  • she was the runner up lol

  • Melissa R should have won not Asia

  • In a poll, fans voted who they thought should've won the competition. Melissa R was first, Chelsea second, and Asian third.

  • for some reason she looks kinda like vanessa hudgens

  • Melissa IS better looking than Nicole. They didn't her because she might actually outshine Nicole.

  • she cant curl her notes but she cud sing good

  • She is hotter then nicole imo wasted talent :/

  • 1:30 - 1:32 fap fap fap x2

  • She could be the sister of Vanessa Hudgens. Very nice.

  • @lovecuthbert her lips and cheek bones huh? 

  • Is it true than she could rejoin Nichole Cordova in Girlicious ? ^^ I hope because she was my fav' of PCD Present season1 and Nichole Cordova was my fav' in PCD Present season 2 ^^

  • Microsoft

  • She looks like Vanessa Hudgens.

    Really like her <3

  • robin antin chooses asia b-cuz melissa r sounds like a leadsinger and her voice is as a lead singer.. and asia sounds like a background singer...

    but melissa is waaaaaaaaay better than asia (as a lead singer of course..)

  • She so should have won. She is beautiful. shes and amazing singer. She sounds better than Nicole (and Nicole is an amazing singer.) if she was a bit taller less tan and a tiny but skinnier she would look pretty much exactly like Nicole and sound like her. So much talent from her and Asia she got something amazing then threw it away in a couple months if Melissa got it she would have stayed. - wow this is the longest thing I've ever posted

  • she is so gorgeous. ! she looks like a mini nicole . she should have won but she would steal the spotlight from nicole. but she is amazing !

  • She looks like a mixture between Nicole S. and Vanessa Hudgens. And obvi she wsan't gonna win cause she would have out shined Nicole.

  • If this is juz about talent, Melissa R. shud hav won this. But they wer lukin 4 a new PCD member, they cannot choose a shorter replica of the vocalist.

    She shud join another girl group or start a solo career instead.

  • I'on give a fuck what lil kim gotta say

  • Robin didn't choose cause she's too good of a singer and she looks like Nicole...

  • Robin not choosing her did her a favor because she wouldve went in the group and wouldnt be singing

  • @imbetterthanu15 I know but now she's disappeared :( lol I can't find what projects she's doing now

  • i think she should be in the new 2011 version of PCD

  • @Pixiebabylove Your right, since Robin wanted a new version of the Dolls why try a new version of the lead Doll, which is Melissa Reyes the smaller version of Nicole?

  • she reminds me of vanessa hudgens :Z

  • Yea she should have won!!!!!!:[

  • yea they messed up not picking her

  • HOW THE FUCKITDY FUCK FUCK DID SHE NOT WIN ?

  • She totally should've won

  • @darylovleynewaccount every brunette does not have a loud voice... lol

  • she luks lyk nicole?

  • i guess i understand why she didn't win. they didn't want another nicole. chelsea shoulda won!

  • She is GORGEOUS !

  • Lil Nicole Scherzinger

  • she looks like nicole!!

  • Melissa is so tiny lmao XD

  • @darylovleynewaccount haha ur right, tho I like Melissa :)

  • I wanted her to win sooooo bad !

  • @darylovleynewaccount well in this specific performance she sounds ike nicole lol

  • @darylovleynewaccount lol k they both have the same tone in theyr voice they sound alike just one has a softer voice lol 

  • @darylovleynewaccount lol they both sound basically identical

  • She did good…but why did she run off stage

  • Wooooow jaw dropper!

  • they didnt pick her because she looks better than nicole!!

  • @lildeptrai she would have outshined Nicole. Plus she looks pretty much just like her!

  • @lildeptrai no the guri is joulers that she's so beautyful ;D ( i know my english sucks xD)

  • @lildeptrai shes not better looking than nicole!!

  • @lildeptrai they didnt pick her because shes better then nicole in everything and unlike nicole she doesnt mind sharing the spotlight

  • @lildeptrai I know right

  • @lildeptrai wouldn't it be cool if Melissa won? There would be two filipinas who look alike. :D And I don't think Melissa is prettier than Nicole though. Nicole's features are superior.

  • She should have won.... err.... 

  • she killed it

  • okk she looks like younger version of nicole from pcd

  • her parents must be proud

  • She cute...sexxy...and can sing.....but better than nicole?! F@&K NO!!

  • you shld be in the NEW PCD tht robin is creating now! :D

  • they didn't pick her because she looks almost like Nicole.

  • almost i reckon he said

  • I LAAAB HER

  • she is BEAUTIFUL!!!!!

  • This is amazing....

  • this song really suits her voice

  • A day i see the tv program and when i see her i in love of this girl. She is very beautiful, i like many Melissa Reyes. She sing and dance very well and she have a body very nice.All a beauty. Congratulations Melissa. A kiss for you since Argentina...

  • She was the best! :/

  • she beautiful & she can sing i honestly dont think she won tho only cuz she favors nicole alot and when ur in a group ur supposed 2 look different & have different identities. asia has talent & she is pretty but also she didnt look like nobody else in the group

  • K i love melissa R but asia was just as good as her ... she may not of been as pretty but she was a better dancer and a performer. So guys please stop with the hating towards asia she deserved just as much as anyone else.

    BUT i still love melissa R and chealsie

  • Wow

  • Around 00:43, she kinda looks like Nicole, or maybe that's just me.

  • @snowbunny1294 i agree, its not just you

  • she shoud've won she was the best!!!

  • she has vanessa hudgen's lips

  • i dont noe y she didnt win..shes BEAUTIFUL!!!

    but ASIA is bloody UGLY LIKE A MOTHER !

  • I think melissa would have been perfect in the dolls! She's talented, stunning and just amazing! But i think that she was just so much like Nicole that's why she didn't win. It's such a shame that she didn't win though :( I love her & nicole too :)

  • She's BEAutiful :D ~

  • She doesent look like nicole s

    her voice is cool

    but better than nicole in this song

    i prefer nicole s

  • i think that they didn't Melissa win because, she looks right like Nicole -.-

  • She needs to be in Girlicious with Nichole and a new member!!!!!!

  • @sveccha15 iknoww tht would be kool!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    but idont know who the 3rd memeber should be??

    or maybe they will have 4 memebers idk??

    but i am still rooting for GIRLICIOUS!!

  • I dont think melissa has a better voice than nicole but this song definitely suits melissas voice than nicoles. Love them both though

  • to be honest, if any of the pussycatdolls (except nicole) does this competition, they would deifinetly LOSE. or not even make it in the competition in the first place -_-

  • @mikobbyko That is soo true!

  • Lol I remember this show >_< madddd frigging old

  • She sings horrible im glad she didnt win. she is very pretty tho!!

  • She sings horrible im glad she didnt win. she is very pretty tho

  • 1:14 mic in left hand

    1:15 mic un right hand

    and not exchange between

  • @flofloid whoaa i juss notcied tht??????

  • nicola better than she's

  • Melissa R would've out-shined Nicole

  • Everyone says it is better than nicole, she should have won she is beautiful, sublime she sings really well I love her and I hope What will hear about it in the near future <3

  • she looks like nicole though =)

    she's pretty good

  • the judge clearly lied what they said at the end cause they chose asia...

  • she would have won if she diden't look like nicole

  • nice voice

    but i think nicole is better

  • I loved Mellisa R! she should have won >:(

  • She sings great but better then Nicole.. in my opinion i dont think so. No one can replace Nicole. She has a better voice and stage presence.

  • I do not understand why she didn't win seriously :|

    shes 100000000000000000 x better then Asia!

  • I think she sounded better than Nicole, too. Loved this.

  • I think she sounded better than Nicole, too. Loved this. Pretty girl, pretty voice.

  • I think she sounded better than Nicole, too. Loved this. Pretty girl, pretty voice.

  • awww she should of won............

  • melissas gorjus <3

  • Comment removed

  • is that paula abdul at 1:14?

  • shes okay just my opinion but shes no nicole AT ALL

  • she was the one ,stupid jury

  • make a heart with ur hands

    2.think of ur crush

    3.kiss the whole in ur hand

    4.put ur fake heart on ur real heart

    5.post this on ur fav love song

    6.tommorow will be ur best day ever!!

    Be hones​t If u reall​y like someo​ne right now, or miss them right at this momen​t, or can'​t get them out of your head,

    Then copy and paste this on 10 vids withi​n 5 minut​es, And whoev​er you are missi​ng, Will surpr​ise you to

  • i loved her she should've won!

  • i love her!

  • Ron Fair def says something about Nicole. You can see he says ".......Nicole".

  • I liked this performance.

  • Shes AMAZING!

  • She shouldve won! They just picked Asia because she was too bad to be in PCD at the end XD & she didnt even came in the group. Why isnt she making songs or something? shes so amazing!

  • She did a great job!

  • damn she is so pretty n can sang her ass off! for the 123 dislikes I hope they were disliking lil kim busted ass! hahah cuz IDK how you can dislike that performance

  • at 1:26 he deffiently leans over and says shes better then nicole and robin say i know!

  • @firedude9617 lol I thing he says she looks so much like nicole i have a degree in lip reading ..lol jk but i think thats what he whispered

  • @firedude9617 lol he said her voice sounds like nicole :)

  • @firedude9617 no he say she sounds like nicole

  • if they didn't let her win cause she looks like nicole than that is so dumb cause they did makeovers and could've made her over to NOT look like nicole with the dark hair... I mean come on.

  • wish she had won.! : D love you melissa!

  • wow she looks like nicole

  • Did you see him whisper..."shes looks like nicole?"

  • she's got the whole package. wish she'd won.

  • you guys are haters, if Asia won she won.

    You aren't the judges so you couldn't decide. so #stfu !

  • better than asia! she shld have won!!

  • she should have won!!!!!!

  • her voice is beautiful :) she sounds and looks a bit like nicole :)

  • Please check out RIANNTI, great Indonesian talent singing Stickwitu.

  • wow. gettin right up to 2 mill. views!

  • She should join girlicious!!! it would make their group even better!!! Trust me!!! =P

  • Now they know what bloodline..Nicole got her voice and talent.... Filipino Blood obviously!!! hahaha... im just saying =P Anyways YOU ROCK MELISSA!!! YOU SHOULD HAVE WON!!! MORE DESERVING!!! =]

  • God it's been like years scince this show , and i so reckon she should of won

    she is absoutely beautiful and has a wonderful voice ! So does Chelsa

    i don't know why asia won she got heaps of critisium from ron even on the finale , it's ridicuous honestly .. just my opinion though

  • i wish for songs like this that have feeling in them, that they wouldnt dress the girls in super short sparkle dresses with their tits hanging out. Maybe a lil more decency? Sometimes at least.

  • Asia was so stupid to not make the group. Because of her, talent like Melissa and Chelsea couldn't make it. Stupid Girl.

  • the point of this show was to get another backup singer (asia), not the new lead singer (melissa) lool xD

  • wow..she is so hot

  • at 1:29 robin whispered: she looks like nicole"

    and the gal replied : "i agree"

    perhaps the reason for her not wining is cos she looks so much like nicole?

  • @snowy103 a younger looking nicole that sings as good as her.. yeah, could be a reason..

  • she shouldve won

  • shes look just like nicole to me 2

  • How the fck did she lose?... fuckin rigged show

  • even after this many years I'm still just alittle torn up that she lost :(

  • if you watch the all the episodes you'll see her talent. don't judge her by just this episode. and comparing to the one who won. she is waaaayyyyyyyy better than her!

  • she only looks like nicole, she is nothing like her on stage, nicole has a stage presence that you can't tear your eyes away from.

  • She is good and jeah she does kinda look like nicole.. BUT she is not better than nicole.. didn't you see nicole her performance at the ny jets game!? and watch her sing babylove live @ Schlag Den Raab

    she also sings heartbeat ft. enrique very good live! Nicole CAN sing and dance!

    ohh watch her sing opera at lopez his show cause she can sing opera very well too

    Melissa is hot but Nicole is damnn hott

    If I had a chance I would totally date her :o)

    Just saying.

  • she's reminds me of Nicole lol like she could be her little sister or something

    too cute!

    and she kills this..Imo its better than the original! I wish she performed the whole song

  • wonderful performs pussy cat..dolls..best singer melissa..

  • she is a kick ass singer & asia should never have won :|

  • She looks just like Nicole to me

  • i really thought this was nicole. lolll

  • She kinda looks like Nicole

  • fckn hot !!

  • i think that they didn't let her win because they're afraid that she could get more famous than nicole..i still love nicole though..but asia? the winner? HELL NO!

  • @mikobbyko i dont think it was cuz of that... i think its cuz she looks too much like nicole

  • @mikobbyko she messed up on the lady marmalade song.. Asia sang the best by far on that song sooo i think it was fair

  • ohh wie schön ich dacht das wer nicolle scherzinger

    

  • die war ein mann dieser zwitter

  • The Best