The Beatles - And Your Bird Can Sing - Live

[MozerinMozers]

Ummm yeah the beatles never did this song live and even if they did the footage is clearly from 63-64 and the song was from 66.

[pallen49]

@MozerinMozers If i remember correctly. I thought there was a concert where they did do it live. Wasn't it the one in japan!!..I can't exactly remember the year that they tour japan though!..I remember seeing the video of it once!

[mistermamaluigi]

the audio is out of sync ):

[MrLizardisle]

@mistermamaluigi

The audio has nothing to do with the video... it's fake.  Most likely this song like most songs recorded by the beatles in 1966 - and after- were never played ''live'' as the beatles stopped touring at that time. And this is the studio version.

[mistermamaluigi]

@MrLizardisle thought so

[flakbac]

i feel like dropping outta society for this 1 you know just like yo grand daddy

[775987mb]

Ma che schifezza!!!! Appiccicare un brano innovativo del '66 su un video d'esordio...!!! Baaah!!!

[kos66t]

FUCK OFF YOU CUNT

[moopy239]

@kos66t Easy...easy

[mpc3po]

God you are a fucking LOSER..doing this bogus video...the footage doesn't even come close to mimicing the lyrics...You suck dick bitch. you deluded yourself but you can't delude us.

[Guytar100]

Wow. Big love. And your bird can sing.

[pythongoon]

Good vid but The Beatles NEVER done "Bird" live.

[NirvanaNerd364]

why dislike it just cuz it's not the real video? That's all music videos are.

[pcostas021]

Like they did this on the Ed Sullivan show. Stupid.

[mackpayson]

Bogus, of course. Cut the crap.

[sasquatchgamer1]

People that hated the video because it wasnt live: *dislike

Me: "Great song!" *LIKE

[Kupcho58]

This is one of my all time favorite Beatle tunes.

I only wish that they had finished and released the Anthology version too.

Great riff...

[Kupcho58]

One of my favorite Beatle songs.

I only wish that they had finished and released out the Anthology version.

Incredible riffing.

[drewsky684]

It's just a fan-made video, why is everyone freaking out?

[rihannarox11]

lol

[leanneandreese]

still great editing dont be harsh beatles were all about love that is not showing it by being mean to a person that worked hard to make it.

[Majorbliztkrieg74]

@leanneandreese I agree, But I agree with others who was under the impression that this song was performed live, I didn't think the Beatles ever performed this song live and I was excited to see it however,Seen it was not and I also got a little angry and said false advertisement . But after few seconds i watched it all the way though and think it was assembled really good and I respect the time and imagination they put in it also.

[Renelea3505]

why are people allowed to post bogus shit. Any idiot can see this is not real.

[ThisLongestUsername]

Que merda, cara! Vai se foder! Mentiroso!

[Romilson569]

apesar de não ser o clip verdadeiro ... é uma das melhores musicas dos Beatles .

valeuuuuuuuuuuuu !!

[Sienna1275Thomas]

CRAP!!!!!!!!!

[sonofabeach321]

What a piece of B---S--- video. Pretty obvious that they were singing something else. Some of the backgrounds look like they came out of "A Hard Day's Night". Not sure about all, but it's a very fake Ed Sullivan type introduction.

[327Butch]

@sonofabeach321 Just enjoy the song.

[DavidLPeel]

I knew that to start off with!!!!

[beatlesgirlsaismeow]

meow meh peeps love this vidio ta-hanks



[ElvisWexler]

Well, I guess it's better than getting Rick-Rolled. Still love hearing the song. Never Gonna Let You Down...Not so much.

[FemmeFatalee]

WHAT A CROCK!!!! THIS ISNT EVEN THE RIGHT TRACK......I GOT MY HOPES UP FOR NOTHING

[DavidLPeel]

Any Beatles fan would know, the fab four never performed this song live.

[Baci302]

@DavidLPeel Right. This is not live. The guitar riffs require two players playing it along with the rhythm guitarist.

[jooocho]

One must remember that in the days of this song the Beatles didn't have total control of what was going on and if you look closely they constantly threw out clues with their feelings of what they thought about what was going on.....in the end...it is still a great song

[mellamokatieq]

Ha... "live". Nice try.

[yesterdaythebeatles1]

Why this have more dislikes than likes? 159 persons birds can't sing! :(

[metafis]

@yesterdaythebeatles1

Its because the uploader lied when they said it was a live version.

The song is great, the uploader is a lying twat.

[joepicard]

poeple say this vid is a waste of time... i did enjoy the song actually

[PikesFlight]

boooooooooooooooooooo

[BCRSIX]

Wonder what song they really were playing in this clip? I think it's from Hard Days Night, but I haven't seen that movie in almost 40 years.

[lightfoot828]

mmm...mmm....but...er...aah...­mmm...???...why? 

[TheGreatMexican01]

They didn't make this song in 1964

[beethousand1]

Vid fucks goats. Waste of my fucking time. Thanks, fuckface.

[AbstractionJackson]

What a heap of bull shit!

Great band & song!

Horrible video...it sucks!

[fisiorobot]

huuuuuuuuuu

[fisiorobot]

no coincide

[freddombski]

Still, "Not a bit like Cagney"! In the "Sullivan Years" this tune was not even written yet! Fudge pie in your eye!!!

[EggeDelfDE]

Sound not synchronized. Or even wrong video to the music. Too bad. :(

[aderrrt]

Why on earth dub a later song over a video were John is clearly singing "Keep you satisfied"?

This video should only be shown with its original recording.

[MiniKirk]

Not that bad, but fans should know The Beatles never played any of the Revolver tracks live. They played live on TV a couple times (All You Need is Love on one occasion, Hey Jude and Revolution on another) and then the Abbey Road rooftop concert. If I'm missing any post-Candlestick Park (February 1966 last show they did while touring if I remember correct), let me know.

[CALLAOR]

@MiniKirk You are right!

[Electricbanjoman]

Look like the Old Ed Sullivan Studio, David Letterman has his TV show there now, Not bad for a made up clip !!

[HannahHypnotize96]

Who cares if its not live, great song, great band, great video(;

[noway2day1]

Da quality da sound of da recording is as good as it gets.....

[ashketchum602]

WHAT the beatles didnt even wear this in revolver . plus johns hair is longer and they didnt perform this song at where there performing -_-

[sawfish111]

And Your Bird Can Sing is an iconic song. Don't pretend.

[pofaro]

DIOS TODO PODEROSO EN TI CONFIO Y SOLO EN TI TENGO FE, NADA MALO NOS PUEDE PASAR A LOS QUE EN TI CREEMOS, PROTEJENOS DE TODO MAL Y DE TODA PERSONA Q KIERA HACERNOS DAÑO. NO LEAS ESTO SI LO AS LEIDO Y PEGA ESTO EN 5 VIDEOS MAS SI NO LO HACES TU MADRE MORIRA EN 3 DIAS POR FAVOR HACERME CASO ES UNA MALDICIÓN

[EHLentz]

.........what a load of codswollop. Strong message to follow



[paulphare]

Why mislead like this? This performance is from two years earlier and of a different song.

[Rubikscuber1]

footage is 2 years before song

[kezie666666]

great

[HyperJessi25]

I was really excited too...

[passiize1]

stupido this video is older than that song

[jiminlhc]

I wasn't denegrating Harrison. Beck was a professional, Harrison was 4 years out of the garage. He was never a top notch musician. He had a good voice and writing talent, and axeman, no. Ditto Paul, you wouldn't compare him to Jack Bruce would you?

[thefabfour2]

@jiminlhc Comments like that make me wanna scream. AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH LEAVE MY PAULIE ALONE AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA­AH.

[TheBartov]

Why "don't like" those are the Beatles !!! Like them ! Nice video :))

[jiminlhc]

Live? Even in 65 we knew that George couldn't handle a song like that, enter Jeff Beck. It's always been a great song.

[randlec6]

@jiminlhc That is the stupidest comment I have seen here in a long time. Harrison co-led with Mac. on the original song. This video is phoney, even though the Beatles did do a final tour in 1966, the same year "And Your Bird Can Sing" was written and put on Revolver. Look, I love Jeff Beck. There's no one I'd rather see live, maybe Harrison, but Harrison was a different style guitar player. He wrote and produced great music. This is where Beck falls short.Beck is better live, Harrison studio.

[blobhead12135565]

LAME

[fenderblaster21]

agreed this is a fake. Great song but you ruined it with this video. ASS

[MNTN19]

Even though it's fake, a true beatles fan would never dislike this video. It's still great music

[jdeyoung1000]

like to have the 15 seconds of my life back that I spent watching this....

[IFeelFine2011]

Awesome ...

The Beatles

Best band Ever .

[barmcakedude]

quite amusing really, great track, great video.

[kathryndeleonable]

I was relieved to see that mostly everyone knew this wasn't the real thing

Don't understand what the point of it is.

[goergesbeatles]

i didnt know u could fake this bad lol to make it more realistic u cud maybe put it in a less famous concert on their last tour, sorry but beatles fans should know that the beatles never played this song alive... well maybe after they broke up

[Florenciopolis]

Maldita Sea ! Es un montaje burdo !

[alimatttinker2150]

there r 3 problems with this video.

1. they r no singing the song at all.

2.this video is from the movie hard days night like no duh

3. THERE IS A DISLIKE BUTTON!!!

[harrymannjr10001]

You have got to be kidding me.

[victhebassman]

"LIVE" my ass, but a cute job

[mgjohnsonstudios]

alot of this video was from the movie "A Hard Days Night"...so, yeah, don't try to fool the Beatles Fan...

[mrshneakyshneaky]

if you watched this thinking that it was live your an idiot, but who cares if it is or isnt

[Remulakmarty]

blasphemer!

[douchecock427]

douche.

[dhalford22]

Wrong time frame for the Ed Sullivan recordings

[Beatlesbabe01]

This is a descrase! xD I was trying to sing along with them and I got scared because their mouth weren't moving the right way :D

[1one2two0724]

HOW FRIGGIN CREATIVE WAS GEORGE TO COME UP WITH THESE INCREDIBLE LEAD RIFFS! AMAZING... BRILLIANT!!!!!!

[SnapDLizard]

Theeease eeeeez cheeeeeeeep booooooool sheeeeeeeet, maaaaaaahn!

[Fang1213]

i think its you people's fault for thinking this was real. not this guy. get over it.

[HEARTHEANGELSVOICES]

FAKE - YOU JAKE THE SNAKE !

[slapbush]

don't care about the video, just like the music

[recuerdo000]

fraude

[SENNAMUSIC100]

Que montagem mais horrível!!!

[boyfilhote2]

Ehuehuehue that was a good try, friend, but any Beatles' fan knows "And Your Bird Can Sing" was never played live by The Beatles. Speacially in the 1964's "Ed Sullivan Show" or 1964's "A Hard Day's Night" movie, from where all these images where taken, eheuheh... you see, this song where written only in 1966. But that's fine! Let's listen to the croud and pretend they where playing it live hehehe! Hail The Beatles!

[steveconn]

So sugary it requires an insulin shot...

[huuusis]

No top comment! This is my chance...

PANKACES!

[TBlenx1995]

@huuusis I don't get it, did you mean to spell that incorrectly?

[RayMcAwesome]

@huuusis i love how you spelled that wrong :)

[huuusis]

@RayMcAwesome I know, saw it now. But I'm from sweden so I always spells things wrong in english ;)

[greenwich1754]

I knew this wasn't live before I even clicked, but I just wanted to see what kind of fakery was perpetrated. Any Beatles fan knows that from Revolver forward, there were precious few "live" performances.

[greennin]

@greenwich1754 yeah, one live performance after 66: rooftop

[javio99]

@greenwich1754 haha, good comment¿ I would not explain it better than u

[capitolemiproducer]

@greenwich1754 yeah it's even out of phase

[TheNightOwlsSquadron]

@greenwich1754 True that. Could you imagine how detrimental it would be to their image if they played songs like For No One, Tomorrow Never Knows, Eleanor Rigby, and I'm Only Sleeping? It just wouldn't work

[greenwich1754]

@TheNightOwlsSquadron Detrimental to their image?  What do you mean, that by doing the songs you mentioned faked withe older footage? Otherwise, if the Beatles could have replicated the songs you mentioned from Revolver "live", that would have been tremendous!

[fuugon]

90 dislikes ? Come on people ! Its The Beatles ! Who cares about the video ? Lets listen to the song

[PDNV]

Hehe knew this wasn't real. Cuz 'And Your Bird Can Sing' was part of "Revolver", which was after their end of Live Performances.

But I gotta say, You did a pretty good job with the screaming in the background :)

If I wasn't a Beatles Fan, Then I would've thought this was Real.

[anotherbluesguy]

MADE ME LOOK !

[lyyz2dope]

ASSHOLE LIAR.  I despise you. Ps. die

[onlybrad]

They're not even playing the song that's sounding. Oh well, love the song anyway.

[MsRedfi]

Histai Ideovai siai a AKEFAI!!!!!

[oswaldo64]

Que buena versión por Dios...no la había escuchado antes...parece la original con aplausos...que mierda si asi es...Lennon VIVE NOW AND FOREVER

[PaulGreen11]

Great Job!

[PaulGreen11]

This plays like Nirvana, "In Bloom."

[Marinitaa11]

El playback Viene mañana, no?

[2hamboigahs]

next time overdub some eminem

[mattferranto]

totally agree with bindyman - the moptops of a hard days night were starting to grow some wings..

[Sappyspartan]

46 people are idiots

[tinystrongtiger]

@Sappyspartan make that 86 dicks

[tjbajacalif]

This sucks so bad. LOser

[JTX5]

Unlike the other people who didn't already know this was fake before clicking on it, I do have to say you did a good job matching the video to the song to make it seem as real as possible! And for that I like it!

[bestvidos]

FAKE that is the ed sullivan show- wanna hold your hand get your fact stright!

[capitolemiproducer]

The song is gotta be YOU CANT DO THIat It's even the wrong year

[WallOfSound1990]

What the hell is the point of this?

[BINDYMAN3]

I cant believe many of you are missing the point with this amazing video, the idea is you get the excitement of the beatles visually at a time when they had the amreica at their feet coupled together with music that was as incredible as it gets of a later period , the whole concept is quite mind blowing if you just let it happen and enjoy it!

[BEATLES4EVER57]

He took this from The Beatles Rock Band video game ! LOL

But nice custom made ! (; Enfin t'est français non ?

[CrispyRingo]

The crowd's way too quiet to be believable :D

[LookingRU]

Fakes

[tiranchula]

Creative.... I just wish that there were footage of them performing this one! Thanks for giving me a second of hope!

[drummingprince3]

haha almost in sync.

[beatlestoneful]

lol!!!!so what were they really singing?

[theglassechoe]

How can any real Beatles fan believe the title???

After the whole "Bigger than Jesus" incident the band never played live again

until the rooftop concert.

[swanseajack1908]

weak...

[antistatica]

bullshit 

[TheHeLennon]

bollocks...why lie

[lookylooky2006]

The quintessential culmination of their early music captured as they had obviously left that period to produce EVEN GREATER GIFTS FOR THE WORLD TO RELISH IN

The PERFECT HARMONY THE PERFECT JINGLY JANGLY SOUND, THE SOLO PEAKS

[ladybug19919]

realy this suped thing a fake! (i dont mean stuped cause i LOVE beatles everything)

[modalmood]

So what if it is fake. It is inspired. We can dream can't we?

[1deduce]

"Dr Robert" would be a really good one to do in the same way :)

[NYYTeixecute09]

the audio is real but the video is clearly fakee

[tribegoddess]

It's a fake video, but we are looking at the Beatles and listening to authentic Beatle songs being sung by the Beatles, so it's okay by me.

[LanceHelmut]

man puh-leeeze....unless you just wished to god that.. A) you coulda seen the beatles live and B) the technology had existed to enable the beatles to perform this multi- over dubbed lead guitar symphony live

[Blues20XX]

It's like he took a perfect Beatles song and mixed it with "the sounds of seagulls, disc 2 track 7" and a bunch of Ed Sullivan clips.

[trippydubstep]

POPPYCOCK!

[tonydominoactor]

C'mon. This is fun

[SupernalOne]

in effect saying "you've seen so much, you're so full of yourself, you can't see anything else" - think of Stevie Wonder's Don't You Worry 'Bout a Thing -- same message

[dawnabrendan]

The guy who posts this makes all kinds of fake videos... do us all a favour and stop polluting You Tube

[ReSistaNceCitizenX]

Fuck you Frenchy. You stinky Mo fo's dont know shit about music. This is just you trying to get views for your pointless videos. Failure. Go shove a flute up your ass and play it.

[stratas2]

ok, we know it's got all this fake Live thing going on, but it's actually quite good.

[zwaqster]

anytime you see somebody playing Beatles songs, request this song. Nobody can do it. :-(

[DaveBais]

0:52 best beatles guitar sound ever.. awesome...

[billpranty]

The video is mostly the Ed Sullivan Show from Miami in Feb 1964; this song was NEVER played live -- and it's from 1966.

[Qdude88]

umm, george sings this doesnt he?

[MrMattnethan]

Actually, not a bad fake.

[CoIeStones]

@MrMattnethan Actually its a horrible job none of the guitar playing matches it same with the bass, same with the singing, and did you not notice them in a different place witha different crowd? And the Hard Days Night clips randomly in the video?... Its an awful job of trying to fake it.

[MrMattnethan]

@CoIeStones :(

[Valerie40066]

WHO CARES IF ITS THE SONG IS PLAYING IN THE BACKGROUND BUT THE BEATLES ARE PLAYING A DIFFERENT SONG!?!?!?!?!? YOU SHOULD BE GLAD THAT YOU GET TO EVEN HEAR THE SONG!!! AND WHAT WOULD MAKE A DIFFERENCE IF IT WAS REAL!!!!!

[Beatles2134]

isnt this from the movie A Hard Days Night.?.....

[crowley24]

GABAGE

[transcan321]

STOP ALL YR COMMENTIN THE BEATLES WERE JUST THE BEST BAND EVER. BEFORE AND AFTER THERE IS NO OTHER. WHAT CAN WE SAY ? JUST BE THANKFUL WE HAVE THEIR BODY OF WORK AS THE BE ALL AND END ALL, OK, THEY'D OF DUG JIMMY TOO AS THEY DID DYLAN AND THE BIRDS.

[mirkocrash116]

"And Your Bird Sing" in the '64??? Excuse me but I don't think so!!!!

[flashy52]

it's fake. I can see fragments of 'A Hard Day's NIght' movie here.

[whyyeseyec]

This is crap. The Beatles never did this song live. This performance was done before the song was written....

[jfn1188]

not even close.

[halcon7000]

BOOO!

[TheTzdope]

this is from "a hard days night"!

i believe they are singing "tell me why"!

[migsly]

That song was not even written when this video was taken. It's superimposed.

[Bubsonrocket]

you suck! this is not live and they're not even lip sync-ing to the song you posted! again, you suck

[GM300GM]

they never play this song live