Added: 3 years ago
From: meowsercat2
Views: 4,614
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (88)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • both

  • I love both versions very much. I like the feel of the original, but I love Demi singing. I actually have to say I like Demi's version better, but thats because of my music preference. I prefer music more on the rock side, so Demi's version fits my music style more. Like I said, they're both great, but I like Demi's better.

  • Demi screams into the mike a lot!!!!! Amy rulzzzz!!!!!!!!

  • DEms!!!! ha una voce potentissima, e si deve premttere che ha solo 18 anni, anzi qui ne aveva 16...*___* è bravissima!!!

  • i think demi ruined the song even tho i like her songs, but not this one.... the original is way better

  • I love Demi's version ! She's soo good at singing. And i think Amy's version is boring. Love Demi, she's so beautiful and talented ! :D

  • i love amy adams shes my idol and she has a beautiful voice way better than a wannabe pop/rock star! GO AMY!!!

  • well, i'm not a fan of demi, but i still think amy's version is better

    amy's- oh my god, the add of the jamaican dude was great, he's got a good voice and it goes well with the whole song

    demi's- sounds like every other song in the world...oddly

    so basically, i think the way amy sings it makes it sound new and beautiful but demi's version makes it sound like every other love song and it's plain...boring...

    amy's version is definetly the best!!!

  • i like both but i like amy a little bit better

  • i think amy is much better.... amy is also prettier than demi.... but i think demi is also ok

  • I prefer Amy Adams.

  • stop comparing them..they are both great and they are both from disney so stop comparing them..I love them both..

  • AMY ALL THE WAY SO MUCH BETTER

  • I Love demi's More . Demi's Is More Exciting and not kinda boring.

  • I love Demi's cause it's more upbeat :)

  • I think demi lovato's better =)

  • Amy Adams is cutting it close at the begining, it sounds like she can barely hit those notes, which made it ruined, so Demi.

  • Amy Adams Sings This Song WAAAAAAAAAYYYYYY! Better!! (:

    No offense to Demi Fans :(

  • amy adams version is more catchy and is soooo much better :)

  • no affense 2 demi but amy adams sings this better. :)

  • everyone of you are entitled to your own opinion but you should always respect the charm and innocense atmosphere of disney's original songs bring. That's what makes disney disney. so for me original of course. no disrespect to demi of course she's a wonderful singer.

  • Demi's may not be the original, buh it's still the best! * :D

  • amy's is the best. the song does not have the same feeling. it lost something.

  • demi sucks

    amy rocks

  • I like Demi Lovato better

  • amy adams definitley she is better

  • demi!! i love demi!!

  • i like demi.

  • demi`s is more catchy. it`s much much better than the original. :D

  • Demi is better!i love her...

  • Amy's version is better about the singing and performance ...Not that I hate Demi but this song will not as successful as it was if it was a rock song ...And this song is what creates Enchanted ..You may love Demi ,but this song is not suitable for her ...You like rock songs, that's your choice but ballad is the way this song's supposed to be ...

  • Amyyyyyy !

  • amy, the original is the best, and demi's...

    is ok, but like what bsbsquad said, the song lost it's charm when demi sang it..

  • demi

  • definately the original!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!

  • Nothing beats the original. :)

  • i like amy more than demi..

    even my friends..

    boo for demi..

    she just ruined the song..

    amy is more beautiful than demi..

    VOTE FOR AMY!

  • demi's better.! she made the song more.. um, catchy. :)

  • amy's def.

  • Amy for sure! In demi's version the song lose its charm

  • i like demi's better

  • amy's definetly

  • amy`s is better, demi just totally ruined the song!!!

  • i love amy's. demi's is good but she doesnt fit the song. but i love her version.

  • demi's version was better than i expected, but amy's voice is WAYYYYY better.

  • Amy's version is way way better!

  • Demi, duh!

  • AMY'S!! no offense to fans but demi screams when she sings this but i still adore demi!!

  • I personally like the Demi's more because of the beat and it is faster... More modernized and I like modern nusic...

  • demi's is way better

  • demi's is way better, its catchy , you wanna sing along to it, not like amys, but thats not amys fault.

  • I prefer Demi's WAYYYYYYY better. Amy's is rather slow and boring.

  • i loved this video it is hard for me to make a dicition but i thing i liked demi a little bit more than amy well thanks so much for taking my awnser se ya later

  • besides, they only showed the beginning of demi's. if it's possible, later in demi's version, it gets worst.

  • demi isnt singing, shes shouting into the mic. i dont even know y disney would support a terrible singer like her.

  • she is a great singer

  • demi's version

  • ♥i like both♥

  • i agree with u but i think that demi is about 2% better

  • Demi's version is way better!! OMG big time! cuz is a lot faster y makes u wanna jump! ROCK ON DEMI!!!!

  • i agree demi's is a littl bit better because it is fast and makes u want 2 dance and sing but amy's is so slow it could be a bed time songand it dosent make u want to get up and sing and dance

  • i know!! I LUV DEMI!!!

  • totally demi's

  • I love both of them (the girls, not the versions), but Demi shouts instead of singing... so definitely the original. And anyway, the song doesn't go with rock music...it's too sweet of a song to go with that arrangment.

  • i like much demi's versoin

    really rockzzz!!!!!!!!!

  • omg i loveee enchanteddd and demis song is so much better cuz heres is fast and amys is to sloww

  • I?M WITH u!!!

  • i soooooooooo agree

  • demi demi demi demi demi demi demi demi!

  • First of, it's quite different. Sure, Demi might have a new way to sing it, I specially like the opening part, but as she sang later on, I didn't quite find the song amusing. The lyrics doesn't blend well with all her shouting =/

    As for Amy, her voice just simply takes every word to layers, and that simply is a win for me :)

  • I like them both the same but Demi's adds a new style which is really gd =]]

  • Amy's Is Magical But Demi Adds A Little Different Style & I Like That But The Orginal Is Classic (:

  • I like Amy's MUCH better. Demi is okay. But she screams in the mic, and it ruins it.

  • I like demi's verson better

    Amy sounds better in the movie then in the video but Demi still wins

  • Demi screams into her mic too much....i understand its belting but it gets annoying

  • uh, not quite belting. haha

  • haha so just screaming?

  • i like demis version better

  • demi sucks she can't sing!!

    amy can sing!! the original is always better.

  • yes i agree. the original is better i just wanted to see what people thought

  • @dude34bja Get A Life, DEMI IS AMAZIIING...

  • @WeLoveDemiL agree with you.. Demi is the best singer ever, way way better than Amy... But I love both of them!!!

  • ok first off. amy's wins hands down. demi's takes away the message and rockifies it. therefore in my oponion ruining it. its supposed 2 b a little fun song people sing with a sweet melody almost fairytale like. demis takes it and tries 2 make it rock/hip hop and in my mind not doing the song any justice.

  • demi, for sure

  • I lovee demi's. :P

  • i like them both da same they r da most prettiest girls in da world 2 thanks 4 making dis awesome vid =DDD

  • i love them too! And thanks for appreciating it! lol

  • demi's version is a-mazing

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more