This scene is very powerful because Mcleod is trying to teach Charles by using the merchant of venice 2 show the indifferences between people like Mcleod in the movie. Both charles and mcleod are outsiders in different ways in the film.
@dragszes Where in the Talmud are gentiles compared to animals? The term Adam is used to mean Jews in that one text, but that does not mean that non-Jews are sub-human. The Talmud counts them as part of mankind, just not the term Adam because that is taken to mean the Jewish people. Not once are gentiles called animals.
@acapellagirl24 The Talmud gives two reasons why the Goim are unclean: because they eat unclean things, and because they themselves have not been cleansed (from original sin) on Mount Sinai. In Schabbath, (145b) it says:
"Why are the Goim unclean? Because they eat abominable things and animals that crawl on their belly."
@dragszes Saying people are unclean and comparing them to animals are two completely different things. It's just something to try to make Jews keep kosher, which is why I personally don't like the Talmud. I'm conservative and we don't live by the Talmud as some Orthodox groups do. But it's not ok to exaggerate just to make your point and then apply that to every single Jew in the world.
@dragszes You said that the Talmud calls Gentiles are like animals. The quote you gave me says that Gentiles don't keep Kosher. The quote you provided could very well apply to me because I don't keep Kosher. Therefore, according to your quote, I am unclean. You are exaggerating by saying this is like calling all non-Jews animals because that is not what is being said at all.
@acapellagirl24 "If a Jew be called upon to explain any part of the rabbinic books, he ought to give only a false explanation. Who ever will violate this order shall be put to death." Libbre David 37.
That quotation does not appear anywhere in the Talmud, you liar. There is no book entitled, "Libbre David." That source is a piece of fiction, and I have only found references to its existence on sites such as Stormfront, a place you probably frequent.
Furthermore I just read Baba Mezi'a 114b and found no such quote. It is another falsification made intentionally by hateful fools trying to mislead the ignorant.
@dragszes Oh! Look at that! Another ridiculous fabrication meant to promote anti-semitism! Here's a tip for the future:
Don't quote made-up shit to the guy who has a Talmud in front of him, idiot. I just read Sanhedrin 58 from the Babylonian Talmud, and it concerns marital issues.
This scene is very powerful because Mcleod is trying to teach Charles by using the merchant of venice 2 show the indifferences between people like Mcleod in the movie. Both charles and mcleod are outsiders in different ways in the film.
ahdevega725 4 weeks ago
It's funny because Mel Gibson doesn't like Jews
Ryodisis 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
oh great this video became the hub for hateful bigots.
redeemer61190 3 months ago
Comment removed
redeemer61190 3 months ago
Comment removed
redeemer61190 3 months ago
obviously the jews are not like Christians.They will be the first to tell you especially since the talmud says gentiles are like animals.
dragszes 3 months ago
@dragszes Where in the Talmud are gentiles compared to animals? The term Adam is used to mean Jews in that one text, but that does not mean that non-Jews are sub-human. The Talmud counts them as part of mankind, just not the term Adam because that is taken to mean the Jewish people. Not once are gentiles called animals.
acapellagirl24 3 months ago
@acapellagirl24 The Talmud gives two reasons why the Goim are unclean: because they eat unclean things, and because they themselves have not been cleansed (from original sin) on Mount Sinai. In Schabbath, (145b) it says:
"Why are the Goim unclean? Because they eat abominable things and animals that crawl on their belly."
dragszes 3 months ago
@dragszes Saying people are unclean and comparing them to animals are two completely different things. It's just something to try to make Jews keep kosher, which is why I personally don't like the Talmud. I'm conservative and we don't live by the Talmud as some Orthodox groups do. But it's not ok to exaggerate just to make your point and then apply that to every single Jew in the world.
acapellagirl24 3 months ago
@acapellagirl24 how am" I "exaggerating .I'm quoting your talmud.
dragszes 3 months ago
@dragszes You said that the Talmud calls Gentiles are like animals. The quote you gave me says that Gentiles don't keep Kosher. The quote you provided could very well apply to me because I don't keep Kosher. Therefore, according to your quote, I am unclean. You are exaggerating by saying this is like calling all non-Jews animals because that is not what is being said at all.
acapellagirl24 3 months ago
@acapellagirl24 "If a Jew be called upon to explain any part of the rabbinic books, he ought to give only a false explanation. Who ever will violate this order shall be put to death." Libbre David 37.
need I say more
dragszes 3 months ago
That quotation does not appear anywhere in the Talmud, you liar. There is no book entitled, "Libbre David." That source is a piece of fiction, and I have only found references to its existence on sites such as Stormfront, a place you probably frequent.
Furthermore I just read Baba Mezi'a 114b and found no such quote. It is another falsification made intentionally by hateful fools trying to mislead the ignorant.
You lose.
tetrisclock 3 days ago
@tetrisclock "If a gentile hits a Jew, the gentile must be killed (BT Sanhedrin 58b).
"
dragszes 4 hours ago
@dragszes Oh! Look at that! Another ridiculous fabrication meant to promote anti-semitism! Here's a tip for the future:
Don't quote made-up shit to the guy who has a Talmud in front of him, idiot. I just read Sanhedrin 58 from the Babylonian Talmud, and it concerns marital issues.
You're done. GTFO.
tetrisclock 3 hours ago
Misquoting and lying about the Talmud, you mean.
tetrisclock 3 days ago
@acapellagirl24 "The Jews are human beings , but the nations of the world are not human beings but beasts."-Baba Mecia 114, 6 [i.e.: 114b].
dragszes 3 months ago
Comment removed
acapellagirl24 3 months ago
I like Gibson he's a great actor but his career was ruined b/c he didn't follow the Zionists' guidelines for thinking.
trc0o0az 3 months ago 2
Shakespeare is God.
ImaginedWriter 3 months ago
Ironic, but still a pretty good scene.
marlboroman1985 4 months ago
When does Mel get around to blaming the Jews for burning off his eyebrow.
faffaflunkie 4 months ago
AWKWAAAAAAAAAAAAARD
Rachulie 4 months ago
Two-Face.
Deavi783 4 months ago
i love his voice!
HKMDK 5 months ago 9
@HKMDK He started his career on stage doing Shakespeare!
YesWeCantaloupe 5 months ago 6
What happened, Mel?
albertstock85 6 months ago
who is that kid... who looks familiar...
IcyScythe 7 months ago
@IcyScythe Nick Stahl.
Stunatra 7 months ago
wow,,,, it's good to see kevin again hahahaha ,,, with natching shylocke's monologue by mel gibson, awesome!
MGraceJB 8 months ago
Oh, the irony.
omglazerspiewpiew 10 months ago
Mel Gibson: he gets stranger as he gets older?
saxcoburg 11 months ago 2
WHAT IS THIS? is Mel playing some sort of human/ Machine hybrid preparing John Conner for the apocalypse?
hoogys 11 months ago 3
wow that man missing the eye-brow
superniokas 11 months ago
...heheheheheh "GRATY-ano" silly boy it's "GRATZ-ee-ANO"
TherealMrChristophel 1 year ago
You'd think that a character that burned his face off would avoid candles.
faffaflunkie 1 year ago 15
@faffaflunkie u'd also think a guy who raped a kid with his car would avoid children and driving but hey!
Rachulie 4 months ago
lol, the warning signs sure were there:) I love Mel.
WhatsReallyGoingOn84 1 year ago