@EvilBakaCat I like it because its dark and more metal than they have done in along time. Don't get me wrong I love their stuff just this song is more kickass for the metal side of it, not the concept of the lyrics.
@EvilRakdos yeah, I realized that after I posted. I always get simple endings confused. German two is going to be hard. Do you know German grammar well? It seems like you need to know lots of grammar to write German correctly.
@snes317 Well, yes. Grammar is a important part of the german language.
Instead of "the" we use "der" (male), "die" (female) and "das" (neutrum). That´s just one example. Here´s another one: gift means in german "Geschenk" while "Gift" has the meaning of poison. You should watch out for the familar words because they often have a different meaning in german. I hope i wasn´t writing much. ^^
this song isnt about athiesm. athiesm means you dont believe in god and i did not here anything in this song saying they didnt believe in god. this song is about people who use religion to get wat they want and tous god as a shield to hide behind
@4everUSNavy There will always be more than one meaning to a song or story. This one is no exception, from the behggining Ive seen both possible meanings, and I can say they both make sense but its how you interpret them that gives you a conclusion to a song or story's meaning. But when you look at it more than a few listenings, you can see both meanings. Its about both.
To me, it sounds like they're saying that the belief in god is harmful. Gods are for animals who betray themselves. When we lie to ourselves, we betray our true nature by hindering our desire.
@SteinUndStahl666 but if gods are for animals than how come ive never seen a deer pray? if you are another one of those arrogant athiest then good for you.
@SteinUndStahl666 my point is that i hate arrogant athiest trying to say their is no god and that if their was a god then why do some many bad things happen.
What's wrong with enjoying something not in your own language? I don't have to speak German to enjoy the music. That's sort of a rude thing to say.."Keep German things German".
There's nothing wrong with sharing your music with people who don't know the language. And if you'll notice, there are english translations on this video, I assume for people who don't know German in the first place.
There's no need to be selective in who can comment and in what language.
@mrNks97 But... lots of us are Americans... And I'm assuming some are Brittish people... English is already spoken a lot in Germany, so what's wrong with speaking a common language?
@GeistvonWut its awesome language and if u like this german music learn german not every german can speak english i can but dont know if the others can and want to keep german things german
Well, it is about how humans invented god. You need atheism as premise, even the song is not about atheism.
Besides the translation is not accurate, so maybe you get it wrong. For example it actual says: "If you want to be a human and no animal, put god into your territory. So being a human will be the gallow - animals dont need a god."
That has a different meaning than the not accurate translation in the video.
I've tried to buy this song on Itunes but it's nowhere to be found. I checked under the album "Glaube liebe tod" and every other album and it's not there. This is frusterating to me because I want that song on my Iphone. Any suggestions??
Agnostic, I believe. So goes the story anyway... depends how much you believe what you hear :) Chances are though that it is more a social commentary (if anything more than just a song at all) than a religious anthem for them. Regardless, *great* song!
this is very much like mein teil from Rammstein. No it's not Rammstein who copied oomph but oomph who made a song like Rammstein because this song menschsein is made after Rammstein made mein teil. Altough nice song but you can here where they got the idea from (nothing wrong with that so thump this song up!)
@GeistvonWut never said that...only that it is irrelevant if they are atheist or not...it is a great song...i simply don't see why people care whether or not they are atheist..it has no bearing on anything
ich könnt schwören, dass dero im c-part "menschen brauchen götzen..." und nicht "menschen brauchen götter..." singt. reimt sich dann auch besser auf "verletzen".
(top comment) "this is now my fav song cos it bashes god~ Thumbs up because I'm so cool cos i hate god" <_<..... ya.... I don't care.
EvilBakaCat 2 weeks ago
@EvilBakaCat I like it because its dark and more metal than they have done in along time. Don't get me wrong I love their stuff just this song is more kickass for the metal side of it, not the concept of the lyrics.
HappyIsFleeting 2 weeks ago
@HappyIsFleeting same here, I'm just tired of people getting all faptastic about their religion bashing XD
EvilBakaCat 2 weeks ago
You know who has no religion? God :)
Er ist eine Popstar.
snes317 1 month ago
@snes317 Nono, not Er ist -Eine- Popstar
Its written Er ist -Ein- Popstar.
Trust me, I am german. ^^
EvilRakdos 1 month ago
@EvilRakdos yeah, I realized that after I posted. I always get simple endings confused. German two is going to be hard. Do you know German grammar well? It seems like you need to know lots of grammar to write German correctly.
snes317 1 month ago
@snes317 Well, yes. Grammar is a important part of the german language.
Instead of "the" we use "der" (male), "die" (female) and "das" (neutrum). That´s just one example. Here´s another one: gift means in german "Geschenk" while "Gift" has the meaning of poison. You should watch out for the familar words because they often have a different meaning in german. I hope i wasn´t writing much. ^^
EvilRakdos 1 month ago
@EvilRakdos When you combine the three genders with the case and tense it can all get very confusing. Thanks for the advise.
snes317 1 month ago
OMG LOVE
SLPKNT06 2 months ago
this song turns me on!!!
SC1337 3 months ago
@SC1337 You just turned me off.
Aliquantisper 3 months ago
@Aliquantisper srry i tend to do that
SC1337 3 months ago
Thus song has the most DELICIOUS guitar I've heard in a while.
bigboom28 3 months ago
this song isnt about athiesm. athiesm means you dont believe in god and i did not here anything in this song saying they didnt believe in god. this song is about people who use religion to get wat they want and tous god as a shield to hide behind
4everUSNavy 5 months ago 6
This has been flagged as spam show
@4everUSNavy There will always be more than one meaning to a song or story. This one is no exception, from the behggining Ive seen both possible meanings, and I can say they both make sense but its how you interpret them that gives you a conclusion to a song or story's meaning. But when you look at it more than a few listenings, you can see both meanings. Its about both.
HappyIsFleeting 5 months ago
@4everUSNavy
To me, it sounds like they're saying that the belief in god is harmful. Gods are for animals who betray themselves. When we lie to ourselves, we betray our true nature by hindering our desire.
SteinUndStahl666 4 months ago
@SteinUndStahl666 but if gods are for animals than how come ive never seen a deer pray? if you are another one of those arrogant athiest then good for you.
4everUSNavy 4 months ago
@4everUSNavy
The song is saying humans are the only animals who betray themselves. That's why deers don't pray, lol.
Only humans are that suicidal.
SteinUndStahl666 4 months ago
@SteinUndStahl666 my point is that i hate arrogant athiest trying to say their is no god and that if their was a god then why do some many bad things happen.
4everUSNavy 4 months ago
@4everUSNavy
Dude, be honest with yourself. If you were one of the few adults in the world without an imaginary friend, you'd be arrogant too.
SteinUndStahl666 4 months ago
@4everUSNavy your god is a lie :D
Runnersfree 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Runnersfree the more you comment the more you prove my point. that atheist are assholes
4everUSNavy 3 months ago
@4everUSNavy See in it what you will, but it's a good song.
uiruu 4 months ago
"Gods are for species that betray themselves."
That actually makes perfect sense.
TalesofGirl4ever 5 months ago in playlist More videos from joshua895 3
awesome song is awesome
jaja der song is toll x333 luvluv <3
LieTheCat 6 months ago
What's wrong with enjoying something not in your own language? I don't have to speak German to enjoy the music. That's sort of a rude thing to say.."Keep German things German".
There's nothing wrong with sharing your music with people who don't know the language. And if you'll notice, there are english translations on this video, I assume for people who don't know German in the first place.
There's no need to be selective in who can comment and in what language.
AddictedToAnimecrack 6 months ago 14
@AddictedToAnimecrack AMEN!
Crimson0Raven22 6 months ago
@AddictedToAnimecrack I think youre a very sensible person!
HappyIsFleeting 5 months ago
@AddictedToAnimecrack
Agreed dude. Rammstein is my favorite band, and people are always like "But you don't even know what they are saying!".......SO!? And yes I do hahah
QuinnChandler55 5 months ago
@AddictedToAnimecrack ^ yup, german is awesome
EvilBakaCat 2 weeks ago
Götter sind für Arten die sich selbst verraten!
ALienZ0308 7 months ago
below a german (music)video is a english discussion and comments^^. learn german pls. it is a awesome language
mrNks97 7 months ago
@mrNks97 But... lots of us are Americans... And I'm assuming some are Brittish people... English is already spoken a lot in Germany, so what's wrong with speaking a common language?
GeistvonWut 7 months ago
@GeistvonWut speak for yourself, I'm in Australia hehe lol
Addikted2love 7 months ago
@Addikted2love lol, sorry, I forgot you guys.
GeistvonWut 7 months ago
@GeistvonWut its awesome language and if u like this german music learn german not every german can speak english i can but dont know if the others can and want to keep german things german
mrNks97 7 months ago
@mrNks97 Isn't it only about half of Germany can speak English?
GeistvonWut 7 months ago
1:21 - "Der Himmel war leer" should be "Heaven was empty"
Aside from that, well done as usual. =)
timeparadox 8 months ago
Sorry but this has nothing to do with atheism
AlienGh0st 8 months ago
@AlienGh0st
Well, it is about how humans invented god. You need atheism as premise, even the song is not about atheism.
Besides the translation is not accurate, so maybe you get it wrong. For example it actual says: "If you want to be a human and no animal, put god into your territory. So being a human will be the gallow - animals dont need a god."
That has a different meaning than the not accurate translation in the video.
lumberj23 7 months ago
I've tried to buy this song on Itunes but it's nowhere to be found. I checked under the album "Glaube liebe tod" and every other album and it's not there. This is frusterating to me because I want that song on my Iphone. Any suggestions??
Samantha55544 8 months ago
Best Atheist anthem ever.
SteinUndStahl666 9 months ago
pwns Korn's "Evolution"
gottspieler 9 months ago 3
@gottspieler pwn gibts im englischen nicht es gibt nur pawn was verpfänden heißt
mrNks97 7 months ago
@mrNks97 It's internet speak...doch nur ein Witz...
gottspieler 7 months ago
The song is OK, but the lyrics are freaking awesome! Respect, guys!!!
Nightmare2077 11 months ago
da ist was wahres dran....
karaokefischer 11 months ago
OMG! da is ein mensch in youtube gewesen und hat auf den nicht-mögen button geklickt O.o
Mazzoni229 11 months ago
Agnostic, I believe. So goes the story anyway... depends how much you believe what you hear :) Chances are though that it is more a social commentary (if anything more than just a song at all) than a religious anthem for them. Regardless, *great* song!
aedansma 1 year ago
this is very much like mein teil from Rammstein. No it's not Rammstein who copied oomph but oomph who made a song like Rammstein because this song menschsein is made after Rammstein made mein teil. Altough nice song but you can here where they got the idea from (nothing wrong with that so thump this song up!)
spaansholland 1 year ago
So, is the band athiest, or are they being figurative?
GeistvonWut 1 year ago
@GeistvonWut It is figurative.
Coolwhiteboy56 1 year ago
@Coolwhiteboy56 Ah
GeistvonWut 1 year ago
@GeistvonWut who cares?
gottspieler 1 year ago
@gottspieler The Christian?
GeistvonWut 1 year ago
@GeistvonWut yeah..seems like an ode to atheism to me...great song :)
gottspieler 1 year ago
@gottspieler You're not really peaceful with Religous people, are you?
GeistvonWut 1 year ago
@GeistvonWut never said that...only that it is irrelevant if they are atheist or not...it is a great song...i simply don't see why people care whether or not they are atheist..it has no bearing on anything
gottspieler 1 year ago
Menschsein means human being. Or... I think it does. O.o Sorry if I seem offensive. I...that's what I thought. X_X
Coolwhiteboy56 1 year ago
@Coolwhiteboy56
Pretty much, it means humanity.
danteslight 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
es hat recht. so recht.
kasuhdeeee 1 year ago
der intro erinnert mich i-wie an "Die Krupps" ^^
heiland16 1 year ago
geile lyrics.
Lydiasama0010 1 year ago
the perfekt song
doppelheer 1 year ago
I love that song...^.^
Hexen28 1 year ago
Die haben verdammt recht!
duskdragon01 1 year ago 3
This song came at a time when I realized that I didn't believe in god. I found this song right at that time. Awesome!
Redtrooper2 1 year ago
okay is this Pro-God or Anti-God, I cant tell.. is this literally or figuratively saying "Hol dir Gott in dein Revier"? Just curious.
luekdethwish 1 year ago
@luekdethwish
Not necessarily against god or for god, it's anti religion.
There is a difference.
SwordStriker 1 year ago 3
@joshua895 Thanks for another job WELL DONE!!
bigwo56 1 year ago
This song is so awesome!!!!!!!!! *head explodes*
mysticking16 1 year ago 4
J'aime beaucoup !
milodie09 1 year ago 3
I am amazed at both how good this song is and how truthful the lyrics are.
OdinCalls14 1 year ago 3
They always say what they feel that is for sure
devilsfan2662 1 year ago 3
Badasssss!!!! I discovered oomph for myself 1year ago and I keep finding songs like this that blow me away. Awesome song
OU812HoosierDaddy 1 year ago 3
ich könnt schwören, dass dero im c-part "menschen brauchen götzen..." und nicht "menschen brauchen götter..." singt. reimt sich dann auch besser auf "verletzen".
realkontschi 1 year ago
@realkontschi Jap Du bist richtig.
ParietinaeUmbra 1 year ago
This is suddenly my favorite Oomph! song.
Thank you so much for sharing!
SwordStriker 1 year ago 32
little translation fault^^
"Dann wird das Menschsein zum Schafott"= "then humanity will become a gallow"
It doesn't say thet humanity goes to the gallow, it says that humanity is a way to kill
SerenaSumeragi 2 years ago
I agree with this song! :)
richardfanx3 2 years ago 49
thank you thank you thank you thankyou sooooooooo much for doing this song
pyrothesis1 2 years ago 4