OK I have to weigh in here... There are SOME carriage horses that are not cared for properly but not all of them FIRST OFF. Second to the people trying to ban these horses from doing the job in which they were intended... theses horses are being sent to slaughter you MORONS! They are better off doing a job than dying because people think it's cruel. Check out horse slaughter and tell me what's cruel. Just because they aren't being killed in the US doesn't mean they aren't dying.
The drivers in this video are disgusting. They talk like typical new york scum, uneducated poor bastards. They are conning people, what makes anyone think that someone who takes advantage of their customers won't take advantage of the animal in their care? The only way those horses see proper vet care is if they were t-boned by a bus....and the asshole driver would still be by its side whipping it to get up. sick.
How awful for the horses that they are subject to long grueling days in extreme weather in congested city traffic carting about oversized tourists so that loud-mouth thugs and bullies can line their pockets with cash.
This sickening spectacle of animal exploitation must end.
Wow, you guys are pretty rude. I don't see anything wrong with the horses. If a horse was limping you would see it because they take an odd funny step when they walk. Honestly, horses like that are bred to pull carriages. If you're shedding so much anger toward that then why not shed some toward rodeo as well. What's next? You're going to try and ban carriage rides in Germany and Chezlovakia as well? These horses look perfectly taken care of.
It saddens me to see the abuse that this fine species is being subjugated to by humans.
Horses do not belong in a auto infested polluted environment from petroleum based carbon emissions, automobile & city noise pollution, and the visual chaos they also go through.
I have never ridden in any carriages in cities and never ever will, and I also discourage people I know as well to do the same.
You just have to look at any of these horses, and you can see a miserable existence and a broken spirit.
These people should be arrested for animal cruelty! This video makes me cry... Horses are intelligent, sensitive animals. To be exploited and tormented in this way is heartbreaking... Please save these poor creatures from this torture, exploitation and abuse!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
all the horses looked healthy and happy to me.. you guys don't understand that these animals have a great life.. i love horses..and a horse you can take through traffic without it freaking is a great animal to have.. why don't you guys get a life and let these people do what they are doing.. none of the horses were sore or limping.. all healthy and happy.. idiots..
these horses don't have natural lives and live miserable lives in NYC. we all have lives? I am not in the mood to compare them right now. those that can't defend the cruelty tell peope to get lives. those horses don't even have a mandatory retirment home.
Outrageous. These animals don't belong in traffic! None of my friends or family will be taking these rides. The time has come to end this for good. People doing this for a "living" will have to do what the rest of us do when we lose our jobs - retrain. It's really not difficult.
Feb 14th 2011 PROTEST HORSE CARRIAGES IN NYC....
vanessrosep 1 year ago
@vanessrosep yes, thank you> i was there
horsesinnyc 1 year ago
OK I have to weigh in here... There are SOME carriage horses that are not cared for properly but not all of them FIRST OFF. Second to the people trying to ban these horses from doing the job in which they were intended... theses horses are being sent to slaughter you MORONS! They are better off doing a job than dying because people think it's cruel. Check out horse slaughter and tell me what's cruel. Just because they aren't being killed in the US doesn't mean they aren't dying.
m3lissacoleman 1 year ago
Horse are live animals, not machines.
The drivers in this video are disgusting. They talk like typical new york scum, uneducated poor bastards. They are conning people, what makes anyone think that someone who takes advantage of their customers won't take advantage of the animal in their care? The only way those horses see proper vet care is if they were t-boned by a bus....and the asshole driver would still be by its side whipping it to get up. sick.
lmarieaa 2 years ago
How awful for the horses that they are subject to long grueling days in extreme weather in congested city traffic carting about oversized tourists so that loud-mouth thugs and bullies can line their pockets with cash.
This sickening spectacle of animal exploitation must end.
CDLver 2 years ago
GAY
spam1237 2 years ago
Wow, you guys are pretty rude. I don't see anything wrong with the horses. If a horse was limping you would see it because they take an odd funny step when they walk. Honestly, horses like that are bred to pull carriages. If you're shedding so much anger toward that then why not shed some toward rodeo as well. What's next? You're going to try and ban carriage rides in Germany and Chezlovakia as well? These horses look perfectly taken care of.
raventhedarkspy 2 years ago 2
It's not fair for the horses to wait in traffic. They should be running free in a field.
Horses shouldn't have to deal with whiny people neither should anyone with a good personality.
NiggiTube 2 years ago
It saddens me to see the abuse that this fine species is being subjugated to by humans.
Horses do not belong in a auto infested polluted environment from petroleum based carbon emissions, automobile & city noise pollution, and the visual chaos they also go through.
I have never ridden in any carriages in cities and never ever will, and I also discourage people I know as well to do the same.
You just have to look at any of these horses, and you can see a miserable existence and a broken spirit.
Aegialeus 2 years ago 6
These people should be arrested for animal cruelty! This video makes me cry... Horses are intelligent, sensitive animals. To be exploited and tormented in this way is heartbreaking... Please save these poor creatures from this torture, exploitation and abuse!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
astroqueen67 2 years ago 2
This is a terrible life for these horse. It is in No way natural and it has to be stopped.
NoAnimalTesting 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
all the horses looked healthy and happy to me.. you guys don't understand that these animals have a great life.. i love horses..and a horse you can take through traffic without it freaking is a great animal to have.. why don't you guys get a life and let these people do what they are doing.. none of the horses were sore or limping.. all healthy and happy.. idiots..
SassyMustang1980 3 years ago
these horses don't have natural lives and live miserable lives in NYC. we all have lives? I am not in the mood to compare them right now. those that can't defend the cruelty tell peope to get lives. those horses don't even have a mandatory retirment home.
horsesinnyc 3 years ago
Outrageous. These animals don't belong in traffic! None of my friends or family will be taking these rides. The time has come to end this for good. People doing this for a "living" will have to do what the rest of us do when we lose our jobs - retrain. It's really not difficult.
askalice50 3 years ago 6