Oh my luve's like a red, red rose - James Mulholland

[SuperDirk1000]

Die beste Interpretation des Liedes überhaupt.

Ein hervorragendes Dirigat!!!

[13evertomorrow]

This is beautiful. I'm doing this for a choir competition coming up next month, and I am so excited because it's beautiful!

[apocalyptica003]

I personally like the quicker tempo. In fact, on of our judge's comments when my men's choir performed this at the state music festival was that this piece was often too slow, but our tempo (roughly same as this) sounded better

Regardless of tempo, that was incredible.

[fiddlecub]

Great sound, and a sensitive performance that shows an understanding of the work. Mulholland's version is beloved to me. While I do see some comments about the tempo--comments I understand--I admire the tempo in this performance. The rubatos have more meaning and impact. Sluggish performances of this piece tend to have lots of deeper breaths, which in turn chops up the flow. I like this interpretation; the director and the singers "get" this music, and I am in deep appreciation.

[jerrysings]

Lovely, but too fast.

[jmaa59]

Excelente, cantado con mucha expresividad. Emocionante y excelente directora.

[anywayhome]

I love this version, and have listened to so many on you tube, This conductor did a great job! I love this song! Just listen the the crescendo, and decrescendo in the right places, and her face she loves the song too!!!

[JAnthony37]

What a beautiful performance. I love this conductor- she is very expressive with her choir. Beautiful work.

[Tibbles2010]

Excellent!

[icdiversity]

Absolutely beautiful!!! We sang this back in high school 15 years ago. I have been looking for this song for a long time...brings back so many wonderful memories. Thank you!!!

[MisterSenseless]

beautiful tone, and intonation, diction was very clear. I want to see so much more expressiveness, the text itself is gorgeous, both demanding and deserving the most sensitive possible treatment. I wouldn't want to rush through telling my Amalia how much I love her...., just something to think about, but otherwise some great things happening.

[irishboyinalabama]

OMG !! Beautiful

[Chae19805]

Great Job!I love this piece! although i think its taken a bit to fast..its a love song.

[HEADBANGING69]

Where was this performed and what country?

[kaohsiungchamber]

It was performed in Kaohsiung, Taiwan.

[HEADBANGING69]

This version is the best. Truly amazing Mulholland. I like the Rene Clausen version to but this version really touches the heart.

[aeloria]

Superb. I've been looking for this version for a while, and this is an excellent performance.

[kahluabisque]

Excellent Intonation!!! Very difficult on this one... Nicely done.

[kahluabisque]

Slow Down

[JamesJET57]

I learned of this piece a few years ago but had never actually heard it performed before. I have the choral score sitting on my piano and love the voice parts, but the piano part is beautiful too. The closing chords in particular express so well such a sense of melancholy yet the hope of being reunited one day. I love playing and hearing them. Bravo to the composer and to the choral ensemble. Well done and what a pleasure to hear and see. Thank you and good wishes to all.  Jim T.

[LovestheOrgan08]

OMG.. just lush!

[orlandzeo]

i love the song. it has such a beauty to it. we did this for festival, and got a superior rating.

[dwinber]

I sang this in the Arkansas All State Choir way back in 1990. It was beautiful. It was a 200 piece choir. I'd have to say I think we were much better, but this was good too although the piano was a little loud for me. I'd post our version, but it's audio only. If anyone want's me to, I will though.

[BlushingRoses]

post it!!! This is the best version of this that I've found, and if yours is better, then I definitely want to hear it :-)

We did this song when I was in high school in All-County or All-District... I don't remember which anymore... going to All-State was by far one of the most memorable, lovely musical memories that I have! Nostalgia is a wonderful thing :-) Even better when you can share it :-)

[sassymo11]

I looked everywhere for this version..

I think it's beautiful :)

My choir is singing it this coming month.

[photoshopluvr13]

really? i was looking for it too! reeths-puffer chorale sang it last year for festival. i was in it, amazing. i LUVE this song.

[sassymo11]

We had the oppurtunity to sing it in festival also, it's so powerful, it gave me chills!

We got a one, which is the highest score you can get.

We were pretty proud :)

[photoshopluvr13]

so did we! lol

[sassymo11]

That's awesome!

[photoshopluvr13]

wait... i just said that...

[neenykin]

They sound beautiful. I haven't sung or heard this version in over 10 years but I never forgot it and can still sing along. I do agree it is a little fast but it is still very nicely performed.

[wharp75]

I really love the sound that this choir makes, but I feel that the conductor tends to rush through pieces such as this.

[WinriiRockbell]

Yes, I agree.

I know for a fact that the time signature for this is 3/2 (because my choir is singing this version as well), and we did not go as fast as this!

[michellebellx]

i sang this song last year at all state chorus in new york, i love it! this choir is amazing.

[hilgerst]

Great choir, keep rocking the Mulholland! I worked with him last Spring, hes a fantastic human being.

[s006221]

I sung this song in a music camp under the direction of Prof. Jerry Blackstone. This is an amazing song!!! Thanks for posting it.

[krnkph3]

amazing....