to be honest, how do you write a song like "comfortably numb" and keep going. It's their best song and hard to top even for them as waters felt his best music was behind him at the age of 30!
fraaip,i agree that post waters,floyd were not the same.yes the wall is a roger masterpiece,it is beautiful. but come on my friend you can never dismiss dark side w here every band member contributed.wish and animals are good as well you know? echoes at pompeii,is good as well. pink floyd is all about the sum of its parts.or was.i think,that every member of that band contributed, and left us lovers of floyd a legacy so we can discuss and argue about who is best and which is the best albumn
Imagine this...Roger Waters was the "Razor Blade" of "Pink Floyd". He could cut you in half with a simple phrase or comment. That voice. That EMOTION.
Okay, Dave Gilmour maybe more harmonic, but just imagine if it was Roger who sang "What Do You Want From Me" off "The Division Bell" album!
I'll get slammed for this but personally once waters wrote most of the pink floyd material eg the wall and the final cut, I think it was way better than earlier pink floyd and later pink floyd after waters left. Pros and cons of hitchhiking - one of waters solo albums is the best.
its the same other way around too, I have seen gilmour he's also boring without roger. But then its obvious, floyd was one of the most complete bands in history; its the complete floyd experience thats missing NOT only gilmour!
@icedangel61 You could get your wish. Gilmour is showing at an unannounced stop in his current US tour of the wall. I'm doing Chicago Sept 24th and crossing my fingers!
I saw him on his Dark Side tour a few years ago and it was the most powerful show I've seen in all my years. Any Color You Like and Great Gig were impossible to listen to sitting down.
@funkyzero Yeaah! I found about that, after I got the ticket for the show. I am super super excited to see my favorite artists playing together after so many years. They are performing 3 nights in Philadelphia, and I am going to the first night. Just 2 more months!
the drummer sucks, quit trying to rock up Nick Mason's drum parts with double-bass. You're already in Roger's band, who are you trying to impress!?!? Stick to the basics, and play it well.
türkiyede tüm amanların en iyi konseriydi.Kuruçeşme arena gibi harika bir yerde waters bile hayran kaldı :) organizasyon da mükemmeldi.ulaşım falan da.2milyon dolar kaldırmıslardır o gece:)
Oradaydım, hayatımın en unutulmaz günlerindendi...Wish you were here ın ilk nota sını duydugum an bunun gerçek olup olmadıgını sorgulamıştım...Gilmour un olmamasının buruklugunu r.waters ın kusursuz performansı dengelemişti..Müthişti.
dede,.alman duvarini yiktin ama hala savaslar devam ediyor,.dunya ne yapsan da dersini almiyor,.su irak la ilgili bir muzikal yapsan diyorum,.bu isin altinda cok isledr yatar gibi geliyor,.sen daha iyi bilirsin,.hani tibette kola satisi meselesi,..
Your wish has come true icedangel61! Hope you get to see it.
fuzzyduck55 1 year ago
İstanbul da verilmiş diğer konserlerin hepsini siktiret bunun bi dvd sini çıkarmadılar arkadaş.
cereme 1 year ago
to be honest, how do you write a song like "comfortably numb" and keep going. It's their best song and hard to top even for them as waters felt his best music was behind him at the age of 30!
theplaid1 1 year ago
Roger get back with Gilmour u jerk!!
5tonyvvvv 1 year ago 2
fraaip,i agree that post waters,floyd were not the same.yes the wall is a roger masterpiece,it is beautiful. but come on my friend you can never dismiss dark side w here every band member contributed.wish and animals are good as well you know? echoes at pompeii,is good as well. pink floyd is all about the sum of its parts.or was.i think,that every member of that band contributed, and left us lovers of floyd a legacy so we can discuss and argue about who is best and which is the best albumn
dazvinci 1 year ago
Imagine this...Roger Waters was the "Razor Blade" of "Pink Floyd". He could cut you in half with a simple phrase or comment. That voice. That EMOTION.
Okay, Dave Gilmour maybe more harmonic, but just imagine if it was Roger who sang "What Do You Want From Me" off "The Division Bell" album!
That would tear anyone to pieces!!!
ffjkhguhgft 2 years ago
That one's got spots.
PowerSlaveN 2 years ago
I'll get slammed for this but personally once waters wrote most of the pink floyd material eg the wall and the final cut, I think it was way better than earlier pink floyd and later pink floyd after waters left. Pros and cons of hitchhiking - one of waters solo albums is the best.
Fraaip 3 years ago 4
best quality my ass
ThunderwingLP 3 years ago 2
STOP FUCK ISRAEL!!!
alewaters2009 3 years ago
I have seen them Together, I have seen them apart. Rogers Music AND shows are far Better.
marcusdolby1 3 years ago 2
roger is still the best till now. i really enjoy the style on how he play on his guitar
jakesteven1980 3 years ago
He can play guitar but he pretty much plays bass on all his shows.
skateboarding118 2 years ago
he means alot for me
shareelysheen 3 years ago
He is badass and one of the best composers of all time
Sublimerules6 3 years ago
david gilmour is better solo that waters is solo. i still love roger though!!! hopefully they get back together
stratJL 3 years ago
so ya...thought ya...might like to go to the show....
golf520man 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This is so boring without David Gilmore.
zwaqster 3 years ago
It's Gilmour
vardocrux 3 years ago
its the same other way around too, I have seen gilmour he's also boring without roger. But then its obvious, floyd was one of the most complete bands in history; its the complete floyd experience thats missing NOT only gilmour!
rafiullah1 3 years ago 2
Det bliver så stort når han kommer til Odense i maj 2008 !
obstyrer 4 years ago
det mener jeg også. Har også billetter :)
Pengefikseret2 3 years ago
I wish they could play together one more time ... A full "the wall" tour :(
icedangel61 4 years ago 13
@icedangel61 You could get your wish. Gilmour is showing at an unannounced stop in his current US tour of the wall. I'm doing Chicago Sept 24th and crossing my fingers!
I saw him on his Dark Side tour a few years ago and it was the most powerful show I've seen in all my years. Any Color You Like and Great Gig were impossible to listen to sitting down.
funkyzero 1 year ago
Comment removed
icedangel61 1 year ago
@funkyzero Yeaah! I found about that, after I got the ticket for the show. I am super super excited to see my favorite artists playing together after so many years. They are performing 3 nights in Philadelphia, and I am going to the first night. Just 2 more months!
icedangel61 1 year ago
@icedangel61 No together, but your wishes came true :)
vladvampire 10 months ago
one of the coolest men on earth
Mudkip91 4 years ago 13
This comment has received too many negative votes show
bro your sound fucks up all over the place.From what I can hear sounds like a killer show though
Rockgod4u 4 years ago
Fabulous. The genious is back
rockaires 4 years ago 2
the drummer sucks, quit trying to rock up Nick Mason's drum parts with double-bass. You're already in Roger's band, who are you trying to impress!?!? Stick to the basics, and play it well.
kenruss208 4 years ago
Very nice clean video. Saw the show in Vancouver last month. Spectacular to say the least. Can;t wait for the DVD.
kronlof2 4 years ago 2
ya madem elinde DVD'si var niye diğer şarkıları da atmıyosun youtube a ya!
emir90 4 years ago
türkiyede tüm amanların en iyi konseriydi.Kuruçeşme arena gibi harika bir yerde waters bile hayran kaldı :) organizasyon da mükemmeldi.ulaşım falan da.2milyon dolar kaldırmıslardır o gece:)
hackerinside 4 years ago
İstanbul'un gorebileceği gelmiş geçmiş en iyi konserdi.
burakant 4 years ago
oğlum benim!!
vertuu 5 years ago
Oradaydım, hayatımın en unutulmaz günlerindendi...Wish you were here ın ilk nota sını duydugum an bunun gerçek olup olmadıgını sorgulamıştım...Gilmour un olmamasının buruklugunu r.waters ın kusursuz performansı dengelemişti..Müthişti.
zakna86 5 years ago
adam bir deha olduğunu bir kez daha bizlere kanıtladı.böyle bir adam bir kez daha dünya gelmez
hysterict 5 years ago
sanırım hayatımın en unutulmayacak konseriydi bu.videoyu izledikce fena oluyorum.
hodigetria 5 years ago
çok ama çok güzeldi... hele ki perfect sense...
nickfallin 5 years ago
Thanks for this video,I saw this show in Lisbon.
This DVD will be released soon we hope!
luisanas 5 years ago
dede,.alman duvarini yiktin ama hala savaslar devam ediyor,.dunya ne yapsan da dersini almiyor,.su irak la ilgili bir muzikal yapsan diyorum,.bu isin altinda cok isledr yatar gibi geliyor,.sen daha iyi bilirsin,.hani tibette kola satisi meselesi,..
pegasusba 5 years ago
video quality is top notch, but the sound is very empty. not hollow, but it lacks body.
cldarmy13 5 years ago
Roger Waters = Genius
geetaryounggun 5 years ago
I totally agree with you. He's one of the most creative musicians.
ehfgc 5 years ago
hayatımın en muthis gecesiydi,dunya gozuyle gordum,dinledim..Daha ne isterim ki....
bade1907 5 years ago
inanilmaz bisi... mukemmel bi performansti asla unutamam...
emir90 5 years ago
muhteşem yahu, o nasil bir gundu tanrim
gozdearikol 5 years ago