I just want to second what Bobbybabybobbybubbie said. This version of the song is a duet in the show between 2 characters getting married, the Bernadette version takes place earlier in the show (ie later in time, since is runs backwards) when that same couple is getting divorced.
Beautiful job conveying the message, Nathan. Not many people choose to do the joyous reprise of this song rather than the (still beautiful but) angsty version.
A note to everyone comparing this to Bernadette: this is the second-act song; she sings the first-act version (Merrily runs backwards, remember?). It has a totally different meaning, which I think he expresses beautifully.
Okay, I've decided that I want this song performed at my wedding ... While Bernadette Peters conveys the more biting, sarcastic edge of this song, Nathan sings it in a very sweet way that implies it's a deep and sincere song about love and devotion - till the days go by. Of course, first I gotta find me a hot boyfriend who would want to marry me.
The most honest interpretation of the song I've heard here on YouTube (besides Bernadette Peters). Bravo! Wonderful job! Hope I see you on Broadway someday.
@jlars21 He sounds nice, but I mean, compared to Bernadette (since you brought her up) it seemed rushed and emotionally stiff. Guys seem to fall into that trap too much..wanting to sound musical-theater-manly...and then ignoring the emotional nuance of great songs like this.
@ErnieFairchild1 In fairness to the guy, you can't compare him to Bernadette Peters :). He did good. I think the so-called lack of emotion is the short time all the performers are given... just thinking out loud... but definitely a clear male voice if I may say so...
I took part in Barnsley Music and Drama festival- beaten at singing by a Ann Wilkes who did this really well. If she reads the comments- WELL DONE- David Armitage, from the Read School
So, I went to high school, and actually middle school with him. Knew he went somewhere for musical theatre, but wasn't sure where, then all of a sudden I found this. Weird, hahaa. Proud of him! Awesome that he's made is this far...
This kid has a gorgeous voice and performed well...but same issue I have with most young performers of this song; I'm missing the full emotional depth and longing inherent in the piece. He acts well...but some pieces need that extra bit of life experience and/or an actor who has experienced certain emotions and can control their performance in the midst of that wrenching emotion. Though he's a good type to be cast in the show.
Lots of folks think that because lots of females have covered the song (Bernadette Peters is actually one of the better known for covering it). But it was originally made know by Paul Gemignani from the 1981 OBC Recording (yup...big musical theater dork. At least I'm a professional performer with a degree to justify my dorkdom ;).
@Mystious actually, in the show it is sung by a male character and was written for the tenor voice. however, the solo is more popular among female singers.
@Broadway42Baby Actually, no it isn't. It is sung by Beth, to Franklin, when they are in court getting divorced, near the end of Act One. It is also reprised in the second act, again by Beth along with Mary and Frank, but it is definitely Beth's big song.
That said, Nathan, you made me cry. I JUST got home from doing this show on Fire Island for a week, and this song has always been my favorite from the show. Amazing job :-)
@JoshJNYC Not to argue, but just so you are aware. The song was sung by Frank in the original 1981 production, but it became Beth's song when the musical was revived and revised.
@Mystious this was sung by the character Frank Shepard in the original broadway played by Jim Walton. The reprise is sung by both Frank and Mary in the second act.
Excellent singing art
kamisingla 3 weeks ago
I just want to second what Bobbybabybobbybubbie said. This version of the song is a duet in the show between 2 characters getting married, the Bernadette version takes place earlier in the show (ie later in time, since is runs backwards) when that same couple is getting divorced.
Beautiful job conveying the message, Nathan. Not many people choose to do the joyous reprise of this song rather than the (still beautiful but) angsty version.
Alyrt1the1medya 1 month ago
1:03 is gorgeous.
adkam2010 1 month ago
He looks so much like Mandy Patinkin. Gorgeous voice, vibrato and beautiful interpretation!
princepeterwolf 1 month ago
He has such an amazing voice :')
kattiiieeex3 2 months ago
A note to everyone comparing this to Bernadette: this is the second-act song; she sings the first-act version (Merrily runs backwards, remember?). It has a totally different meaning, which I think he expresses beautifully.
Bobbybabybobbybubbie 3 months ago 3
Okay, I've decided that I want this song performed at my wedding ... While Bernadette Peters conveys the more biting, sarcastic edge of this song, Nathan sings it in a very sweet way that implies it's a deep and sincere song about love and devotion - till the days go by. Of course, first I gotta find me a hot boyfriend who would want to marry me.
paulhogarth78 3 months ago
Awesome interpretation!! Goodluck on Broadway! :-)
noisycanary 4 months ago
@TheyLeaveAtDawn It's in F major until "And no, not a day goes by," when it modulates into G major.
dumdiddly08 6 months ago
Congrats, this is beautiful!!!
ldbarrera 6 months ago
Wow. Such a beautiful voice. This is how musical theater should sound again.
lalou0205 8 months ago
So powerful! Love it.
lloydeugenemoore 1 year ago
This was beautiful ^.^ Thank you.
puggloe 1 year ago
The most honest interpretation of the song I've heard here on YouTube (besides Bernadette Peters). Bravo! Wonderful job! Hope I see you on Broadway someday.
jlars21 1 year ago 15
@jlars21 You should listen to the Julie Andrews version. <3
moonastra 11 months ago
@moonastra have you heard carly simon's 1980 version?
wntoply6 7 months ago
@jlars21 He sounds nice, but I mean, compared to Bernadette (since you brought her up) it seemed rushed and emotionally stiff. Guys seem to fall into that trap too much..wanting to sound musical-theater-manly...and then ignoring the emotional nuance of great songs like this.
ErnieFairchild1 3 months ago
@ErnieFairchild1 In fairness to the guy, you can't compare him to Bernadette Peters :). He did good. I think the so-called lack of emotion is the short time all the performers are given... just thinking out loud... but definitely a clear male voice if I may say so...
alexmz123 3 months ago
This was wonderful. :)
Would anyone happen to know what key it is in?
TheyLeaveAtDawn 1 year ago
@TheyLeaveAtDawn The key of Awesome
kaelnyria 1 year ago
I think this a really beautiful version
abbiemccrone 1 year ago
Whoa. I think I just fell in love.
kweenybee 1 year ago
this is... beautiful... and i cried... there, i said it!
Nikkimancina 1 year ago
beautiful, sir gardner. beautiful.
logotrunker 1 year ago
BRAVO!
RenataBacardi 1 year ago
Wow. This is absolutely incredible. Your voice makes my jaw drop. You are fantastic. And such great emotion. :)
CandyBelle5 1 year ago
I loved Mr. Gardner's performance. The lyric changes were perfect to make the bitter into sweet.
The song suits both a young man in love, or someone with more battle-scars. Bravo :)
jeffka0 1 year ago
I Hate tenor ! ( Because im not one :( ) Im a stupid Bass II with a wide range. Thats a plus i guess
mrjuly 1 year ago
It sounds great. :)
9freakydarling9 1 year ago
Great job, Nathan! I want to hear you sing this in 10 years when you have lived longer and experienced more of life..it will be even richer!
menharper 1 year ago
This is an incredible performance. it made me cry. it was so beautiful :)
surprise4emmy 1 year ago
I took part in Barnsley Music and Drama festival- beaten at singing by a Ann Wilkes who did this really well. If she reads the comments- WELL DONE- David Armitage, from the Read School
DaveandSlloydowen 1 year ago
duh...DUH..nathan is the best. WIN
kameront 2 years ago
So, I went to high school, and actually middle school with him. Knew he went somewhere for musical theatre, but wasn't sure where, then all of a sudden I found this. Weird, hahaa. Proud of him! Awesome that he's made is this far...
samerz816 2 years ago
i LOVE his voice :D
tenten547 2 years ago
wasn't he nervous?
mcriff0808 2 years ago
takes my breathe away.
apexpark 2 years ago
This kid has a gorgeous voice and performed well...but same issue I have with most young performers of this song; I'm missing the full emotional depth and longing inherent in the piece. He acts well...but some pieces need that extra bit of life experience and/or an actor who has experienced certain emotions and can control their performance in the midst of that wrenching emotion. Though he's a good type to be cast in the show.
shabuchwae 2 years ago
i couldn't agree more.
Jman383 2 years ago
Very nice. Works perfectly well for a male singer.
theBestArts 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Thought this song was only for females?
Mystious 2 years ago
I'm not sure why you'd think that.
jhughespspb 2 years ago 29
@jhughespspb doesn't the male character and the female character sing this song in the show but with different lyrics?
Bluebaritone 1 year ago
Lots of folks think that because lots of females have covered the song (Bernadette Peters is actually one of the better known for covering it). But it was originally made know by Paul Gemignani from the 1981 OBC Recording (yup...big musical theater dork. At least I'm a professional performer with a degree to justify my dorkdom ;).
shabuchwae 2 years ago
@shabuchwae Nicely put- nice joke about the degree too
DaveandSlloydowen 1 year ago
@Mystious actually, in the show it is sung by a male character and was written for the tenor voice. however, the solo is more popular among female singers.
Broadway42Baby 1 year ago
@Broadway42Baby Actually, no it isn't. It is sung by Beth, to Franklin, when they are in court getting divorced, near the end of Act One. It is also reprised in the second act, again by Beth along with Mary and Frank, but it is definitely Beth's big song.
That said, Nathan, you made me cry. I JUST got home from doing this show on Fire Island for a week, and this song has always been my favorite from the show. Amazing job :-)
JoshJNYC 1 year ago
@JoshJNYC Not to argue, but just so you are aware. The song was sung by Frank in the original 1981 production, but it became Beth's song when the musical was revived and revised.
So technically, you are both correct. :)
Stewy202 11 months ago
@Stewy202 Learn something new every day! :-) Thanks for the tidbit!
JoshJNYC 11 months ago
@Broadway42Baby . You are correct.
trainjustleft 1 year ago
@Mystious in the show, the reprise of not a day goes by is in fact song by 1 guy and 2 girls
dummygeek 10 months ago
@Mystious this was sung by the character Frank Shepard in the original broadway played by Jim Walton. The reprise is sung by both Frank and Mary in the second act.
FreeSpiritMetalworks 6 months ago
@Mystious It's sung by a male character and reprised as a male/female duet.
HighKingTurgon 5 months ago
@Mystious You are really that retarded?
princepeterwolf 1 week ago