Red Faction Guerilla (Demo) Frame Rate Analysis

[gamers151]

Didnt red faction almost max out the 360?

[strider3283]

PS3 recovers fast on fps.

[Max160]

xbox is dark as shit

[9eminem11]

no its the rgb colour on the ps3 dipshit

[GameSiphon]

Wow, the PS3 version sure looks bright. I don't remember it being that bright when I tried the demo myself. Are you running it with maxed out brightness or something?

[kmann1994]

SOOOOOOOOOOOoo much worse on PS3!!!

[GeForce47]

You're blind

[randonessdude123]

lol i have this demo for my xbox, ps3 and pc

pc: perfect

xbox: frate rate gets shit when you reach the walker and stomp on everything

ps3: graphics arent as good as pc and xbox

[randonessdude123]

this means:

pc owns everything!!!!!!

my pc:£1000

my xbox:£150

my ps3:£300

if i where u and you didnt own any of these id get a 360.

but as im rich.......... :)

[kungfukahn]

i think you can´t really compare xbox360 and ps3 because you must have a good tv and on the tv you can cease the brightness and the color and the acuity and much much more so let´s say they´re altogether as good as the other console

[danieldgloquendo]

ps3 better again

[Gaberiel666]

Anyone who has playd the game on both consoles knows that once you get to the EOS sector, the xbox version runs like crap.

Also do something like block up a gap with like 10 cars and let other cars navigate through it, then set off like 8 remote charges, watch the xbox slow to 2 fps while the ps3 goes fine.

[Gaberiel666]

then read the developer blogs about how they had a really hard time getting this to run on an xbox. not because of the graphics but because of the CPU, the ps3 has a cell processor witch is much more effective at calculating the complex physics. the 360 struggles a bit here and that's what drops the frame rate.

[chadheck96]

They always have trouble making PS3 games with the incompatibility of the Cell.

[441meatloaf]

@chadheck96

because no fucking game developer wishes to spend millions in research and development of the codes to optimize the cell processor.

MS tends to release their production codes to people so other developers can use it to make programs for microsoft (MS vs Apple). Same for gaming. Sony wants to protect the uniqueness of its system.

So only developers like Uncharted, Konomi, are willing to go far to research the cell processor.

[randonessdude123]

i swear my xbox has a shitter frame rate that others

on that demo, once i got on the walker, the screen is laggy :(

i got the demo on my ps3 and it doesnt lag

[projectraven1]

after playing the final versions its clear 360's anti aliasing really helps image quality on this game. ps3 version runs fine thank god, but its an awful lot nicer looking with 360's filtering applied. the pc version is decent enough, but i wasnt too bothered with the game full stop if im honest

[trowa170]

The 360 has like 5 different visual options in the menu and the PS3 only has 2. The Xbox360 one is darker and u can make it look like the PS3 one by setting all display to 100...i had it running on both PS3 and Xbox at the same time.

[SiLeNtXaViOr]

I tried both demos... and 360 lags when you've deliverd the walker and getting chased, and when when you're crashing in to things with the walker... PS3 runs smoother.. But oh well it's a demo and i will still get the 360 version because my friends will get it for the 360.

[SirPwn4lot]

Lol, I can't wait for the PC version.

100fps maxed here we come :P

[TurboSnail6]

That all depends on weather they make a good PC port. Hope so, its been all too long since a good port was made and fully optimized for the computer.

[DigitalFoundry]

The "recordings" are digitally lossless dumps from the HDMI port of both consoles. The 0s and 1s coming from the HDMI port don't lie and can't be tampered with. Different gamma levels are par for the course between PS3 and 360.

[Enkei1989]

ps3 version looks washed as shit..

360 version wins as usual

[chobe156]

its just darker.

[Max160]

its jsut contrast thats all

[halojoe10]

liek omg ps3 r n00b

Just kidding

Like I have said before - This game is like a blow job that never ends...

[Thedudesam]

PS3 version has better dust, and a better framerate overall, but 360 has slightly better ground textures.

BUT WHO CARES, LETS ALL JUST BUY THIS AWESOME GAME ON ANY CONSOLE AND ENJOY IT!

RED FACTION 3 PEOPLE! FUCK YEAH

[Kuchcikpro]

yea FUCK RIGHT i will destroy EVERY building in this game that's my personal mission

[0OmixO0]

saaame, but I wanna destroy the tallest thing in the game xD

[SeargentGunner]

LOL? The Xbox 360 version has better dust, and a better framerate overall! And BETTER ground textures!

[Jameswho123]

there like the same dude, ust 360 is abit darker, textures are the same and theres abit ore dut on 360 altho i think that has somthing to do with the darkness

[Jameswho123]

and to be fair, the graphis look shocking on both systems

[SeargentGunner]

no they dont. theyre awesome!

[Jameswho123]

compared with some games today there not all special

[SeargentGunner]

yeah of course theyre not as good as crysis, but in crysis, you cant destroy everything ^^

[slatanic2142]

Better framerate?are you freaking blind?!

[battyd]

i have a 360 and ma brother has a ps3, i prefer the xbox's darker look, but thats not to say the ps3 is bad, its just wat i prefer. also CANT WAIT FOR THIS GAME!

[standrick]

PS3 looks a lil better to me

[fudgenasty]

game is now comming out june 2 not june 9

[projectraven1]

both demo versions are now available to download. having both these machines and calling myself a pc gamer, my objective view is that 360 wins, quite easily in truth. it has 4 x MSAA, which removes all significant aliasing. ps3 has no AA filtering whatsoever, a lot of nasty hard edged jaggies compared to the 360 version. 360 also edges on texture, and effects. ps3 does at least have a nice solid framerate, those looking to choose, 360 is noticeably superior. im waiting for the pc version...natch

[gal5656]

on the 360 is dark but it's look good

[cday131]

Both look and run good. PS3 is a little washed though.

[redice1024]

you can adjust the brightness and color

[GTCarro]

Too dark 360 version.

I prefer PS3 version.

[LtShield]

you can adjust the brightness

[flamebite]

Looks better on xbox 360.

[Massiznassiz]

I'm starting to hate these tests. They're just starting more and more internet fights.

[Cimlite]

Don't hate the tests, hate the fanboys.

The fact is that games do look different on either machine, something which is great for people who own both to know. Just because certain people feel a need to get all hot and bothered trying to defend their purchase does not mean these comparisons are to blame.

[JigenD]

In your article you stated the PS3 had better shadows but technically the 360 version has better shadows. More samples / more filtering = technically better, even if you prefer a different look.

[DreadRaptor85]

I think the RGB and Super White settings depend on which HDTV you using.

[DigitalFoundry]

Our TrueHD capture card is calibrated for full range RGB, so full range RGB (or Expanded on 360) is what is used on all of our videos.

[MikaOwns]

why is the 360 version so dark? are you running it on rgb full vs. ps3 rgb limited?

[DigitalFoundry]

These are the default settings on both PS3 and 360, both of which are set to full range RGB. Many 360 games are darker in this manner.

[GamingBlitzDOTcom]

ps3 gets the port so it looks crapy but Hawx is reversed

[MikaOwns]

true multiplats on ps3 are almost always crappy ports.

you say hawx looks better on ps3? i think 360 got the better version but no worries it runs at 1280x1024, 2XAA, all maxed settings, 40 fps on my bottlenecked 3.2ghz pentium 4 and 8600gt.

it's sad what multiplat devs are doing with the ps3. exclusives like kz2, uncharted, gt5p, and mgs4 look like they're from a future gen compared to some multiplats lol.

[Hunter4Vids]

from what i can see ps3 version looks a bit better and lighter but i dont care since i have both console :)