Tatu All The Things She Said (Live and subtitled)

[3cheers4Ger]

OMG they sound amazing live!

[3cheers4Ger]

Yayyyyyyy USA! In NJ, I was just a little 8-yr old when I heard this and loved it. Didn't know what it was about or who sang it. Then I found out at age 12 and found out they stopped coming here years ago and perform in Russia and Asia and stuff. Now they disbanded. I would've LOVED to see them after being a fan for 6 years.

[Megamajz]

how old are they at this performence?

[ondratatu]

@Megamajz 18 i think

[Megamajz]

@ondratatu okey

[CLmoviewatcher2011]

@ondratatu They were 17. t.A.T.u. started in 1999 when they bot where 13 years old.

[TatuLenaYulia4ever]

Love T.a.t.u, Forever and Always <3, need to listen to them everyday, theyre amazing, it sucks tht they dont sing together now, but i still love them both, who cares if they are lesbian or not (its not about tht its about their talent), they clearly show tht they love each other very much!!! :]

[Itachiboii9898]

All of you are blittering idiots, well, those who hate t.A.T.u! Anyways, they really did love each other. At the beginning, they did do it just for the fame and publicity. But then a year into faking it, they really began to love each other. They really did love each other. The band started out in 1999, so in 2000 they truly fell in love. Then in 2009 they split up for solo careers, but they will rejoin every year or so to make albums together. But, they truly did love each other.

[3cheers4Ger]

@Itachiboii9898 I agree with everything you said, EXCEPT they're not getting back together. Lena said t.A.T.u. is never coming back, and that they don't talk much these days. She said Yulia is always changing her phones and number... :(

[Itachiboii9898]

@3cheers4Ger That REALLY sucks.

[3cheers4Ger]

@Itachiboii9898 Yes... T_T

[Phsycosister14]

@3cheers4Ger I used to have this huge crush on her!

[3cheers4Ger]

@Phsycosister14 Awesome

[usemoselnitro]

this is how it should always be!! no fkin playback! LUV TATU 4EVA

[Ruwuh1]

English subs on english video FTW!

[ondratatu]

@Ruwuh1 that's called "lyrics on screen" ...FTW???

[Ruwuh1]

@ondratatu Oh, I get it, that's because there's lyrics on the screen right? lmfbo! XD

[deejayamik]

@Ruwuh1 hahahahaha you're right!

[Blndrfist]

First of all; yes this is an obvious lipsynch job; OBVIOUS. Second, these two russian bitches were never queer to being with. Take a look at 1:29; it is clear that the red head is absolutely repulsed by the notion of kissing the black haired chick. It was all a sham from the beginning, just like their alleged "talent".

[3cheers4Ger]

@Blndrfist I agree that Lena looked like she didn't want to be kissed. XD Lena said she's straight and Yulia/Julia is bi. Lena currently has a boyfriend and Yulia divorced her husband.

[jopetas96]

no se besaron :(

[returnoftheramble]

to avoid partnering, hell yes.

[GenieBella]

It's not totally live. Obviously, there's a recording in the background. But you can also hear their live voices over it. So it is partially live, which was rare back then. It's interesting to hear their voices before they grew up.

[ultima120]

@Thisshizzleisbananas I think it's the black haired one. And leena is the red haired one.

[Phsycosister14]

@Thisshizzleisbananas the dark-haired one! I should know! I wanna meet her more than anything!

[3cheers4Ger]

@Phsycosister14 She used too much botox and she looks all different now. :( And her solo music sucks.

[Phsycosister14]

@3cheers4Ger That epically sucks.

[3cheers4Ger]

@Phsycosister14 Yes... ._.

[IamThalissa]

OMG *-* I♥t.A.T.u

[IMDARKFIRE007]

YUM!

[rafalek15545454]

wish they kissed :<

[kroen]

if this really isn't lipsyncing then this is the best live performance i ever heard

[tATuFanxRoseOnPlayer]

im saying it as a tatu mega fan

this is not totally live

i mean they do sing

but they have a playback record as well so if their voices will fail all of a sudden the playback will be a backup

there is even an interview that said

that their first albumm was 100% playback or this type of singing

but its a great performance though ^^

love you t.A.T.u! :>>>

[RuckalltheFules]

HOLY SHIT!!! Real tATu fans know how hard it is to find a non playback performance in their early years. Holy crap this is a priceless treasure.

[mirtylle02]

very good super ^^

[cutie12980]

no they are real. AND I LOVE THEM.

[xrobx735]

1:54 / 1:55

I just realized that Lena tries to tell Yulia that she's waving her microphone too much and it's making it obvious she's lip syncing. XD

<3 Tatu! :)

[xrobx735]

Some parts ARE playback, some are NOT.

To me, I don't get why people make such a fuss over if they're singing live or not.

To be honest, I would go to a concert if it was all lip-synced and have a great time.

It's about the experience, seeing them, not about criticizing them.

[MyMyClank]

I think they go in and out with singing play back. Some parts they are, some parts they're not.

[LariFu92]

Sometimes it looks like playback, sometimes not. I don't know. They sing on playback a lot... But, guess this time they are really singing.

[littletiger56]

@dashigara12 in the music video they are not lip synching the video is the russian version they just took out clips of them singing and added different bits, you would be able to tell if you watched the russian version called Ya Soshla S Uma

[aliceinchains898]

the drummers bad ass and theyre both hot

[toxic11fairytale]

theey are soo brave to come out x

if i came out id be dead...

[Underworld4220]

theautumnalsun this is live and live will always be defrint from the album version

[TaTuWhiteRobe]

Since I am a Russian Speaker, their shirts translate f*ck to the war.

[theautumnalsun]

This is not lip-synced. You can tell by Yulia's part starting at 2:50 that says "Daddy, looking at me will I ever be free." It isn't exactly like the album version, in which her accent is a bit lighter. Plus, this was before Yulia's vocal cyst, and she sounded much more smooth and clear back then.

[savannah2467]

do they lip sing?

[dashigara12]

in their music video for all the things she said, it is very obvious they are lip singing. They are slighty off for the singing.

[DninK]

Yeah its playback.

But, as many other Tatu live performances, you can hear them over the playback. So its live/playback.

[arunalf]

"Early on Katina and Volkova put forth an image of a lesbian couple but in their 2003 documentary Anatomy of t.A.T.u. they have stated that they're not really lesbians [1], mimicing the practise as part of their stage act."

They aren't actually lesbian...

[TIMONLIK]

is it live vocals?

[Eklerek993]

хуй войне!!! :) PEACE!!!

[Rachamijn]

lol on their shirts mean f***k war (хуй войне) :P en thats why its censored.

[Luffymon88]

they're gay

[MotherFerginPrincess]

Their shirts actually say "CENSORED!" in Russian. They were protesting that their kiss was censored a lot of times.

[0Jovana0]

I think that thair shirts say "F*ck war"!!! Love t.a.t.u.

[thenightmarecafe]

agree

[groovealoose]

___yuppp they are definately singing this LIVE......they should do that more often....I love Yulia's voice !!....this song is amazing!!

[Luffymon88]

which one is that?

[brigilim]

me encata t.a.t.u.

[ondratatu]

this song is whole live for those not-believing=) my favorite part of it is 2:50-3:00...Yulia's high beatiful part...and no playback=)

[SweetAndSxcChik]

its not whole live, they have the track playing in the background. you can tell cuz you can hear the track, and them over the top of it

and i am actualy a huge tatu fan, and i dont mind them doing playback

[SweetAndSxcChik]

WOW!!

Im not the only one who has noticed the bit in the english version that goes Ya Solsha S Uma!!

XD

[taty4ever]

is it the part where They go this is not enough and you hear a sorta what what. Or that's what it sounds like. But it is the russian part. I've wonder too if i was the only one who got it,

[SweetAndSxcChik]

Yeah they go "This is not enough" And listeraly just after they say that you can hear "Ya Solsha S Uma" LOL I Guess That Forgot to translate that bit XD

[MotherFerginPrincess]

You're right, I noticed it too. I hate it when people sing it and they just go "Ah-maaaa!" at that part instead of "Ya soshla s uma." xD

[shimbob666]

i think that on some videos when at the just music bit and they just throw themselfs on eachother is fake... but when they actually take there time like on this video its real..

If you dont belive me look on there myspace =]

[arunalf]

"Early on Katina and Volkova put forth an image of a lesbian couple but in their 2003 documentary Anatomy of t.A.T.u. they have stated that they're not really lesbians [1], mimicing the practise as part of their stage act."

They are not actually lesbian... sorry to burst your bubble.

[victordiego1]

mmmmm... pense que las rusas estaban mas guapas y mas buenas

[katherineashley]

dayummm I love Tatu=D

[Vinc1259]

this is not enought!!!!!!!

[1337LPit]

i think playback every time!?

[ondratatu]

No, this show is totally LIVE....it's obvious,there's no playback

[LorraineEEWykes]

i think there singing live with the track playing in the back like incase they forget words or stuff like tht

[FuckinLovinCheatin]

@ondratatu It's not totally live.. 1:14 .. It's obvious that she cant do this live :) It's playback.

[xXxcrazyxXxmeeganxXx]

this definatley isnt synced. but they do sometimes

[utopiawhite]

@1337LPit Yes, they quite obviously lip sync every live performance. It's not a dis on them - I <3 them and when you watch their interviews their english is pretty limited. You can also see that their lip syncing doesn't match the sound, and its not just the video...it's the same for all of their performances in english. If it sounds just like the cd, its just about always a playback.