can someone clarify this for me please? i couldve sworn that in the end he implied that he didnt actually shoot the POW's and just pretended that he did to make himself intimidating and badass so people wouldnt question his confidence or something like that. did i misinterpret this???
@Neivlak From what I understood, he never "Denied" shooting the pows because he liked the way other soldiers looked at him and were intimidated by him. So he never said he did, and he never said he didnt. that kinda thing.
Killing POWs just for the fun of it. What a motherfucker. Going home, being a happy family father... gosh - how can a man be a monster the one day and a loving husband the other day?
@Heartoftheclock You really think he killed POWs just for the fun of it? I don't think they were ordered to take prisoners in the first 3 days of the invasion.
If the Waffen SS got there hands on Speirs they would have done alot worst to him and his men then simply mowing them down with MP40's. They save that for Kikes.
They would have probably torn his fingernails off, shaved his tongue, and disemboweled him with there combat shovels.
Speirs Think's he's so badass dumping his Thompson on unarmed prisoners. Makes me glad for the 10 he killed the German's put down 100x more Polock's and others sorts.
@blizzy00 You mean the SS death squads; not the German army pal, he had no right to do it, they were protected by the Geneva convention and he has comitted a war crime.
@TheSirRoberto The Waffen SS was not only a death squad division, they had multiple divisions of the SS. And also only 1/4 Soliders at that time even thought of the Geneva Convention.
Hell, even now the US goes around it via false flag terrorism. What a vicious cycle.
what actor played the german soldier malarkey met and who played the soldier who stood in Disbelief while smoking cigarette in background as speirs killed prisoners
Actually artard, Speirs DID shoot those prisoners, in interviews from Winters and others, they ABSOLUTELY CONFIRM IT. And also a man who interviewed Speirs off the record whilst filming Band of Brothers had Speirs confess this fact himself.
@TheMra18 dont make up bull. and anyone who says atard is probably and atard themselves. spiers would have been punised for war crimes u idiot. he says later in the episdoe 'breaking point' that he didnt
@scids225 i have done a bit of research & in an interview with Winters he said that Spiers was such a great soldier compared to a lot of the other "kids" that were there,that the guys in charge overlooked what he did as they couldnt afford to lose him. Had it happened today then yes, he would have been charged for war crimes. Winters went on to say that he built his name as being a killer by killing 6 germans they had caught in order to establish himself as fearless which in actual fact he was!
Speirs never shot German prisoners, although he did shoot and kill an American sergeant who repeatedly kept disobeying orders and endangering his platoon and their mission by advancing into artillery fire. Tom Hanks decided that fact was too strong for the American public to take and still see him as a hero, so they vaguely included this prisoners scene. Notice you don't actually see it happen, that's because it didn't.
@EcoDimension Malarkey met the guy from Oregon but when he told the writers they thought it was too weak to just ad in like that so they added it to the legend of Ronald Spiers to make it more screen worthy!
This never happened gents. I am a personal friend of Don's and they messed up the city and other information. It was Portland, OR. Done went to school at UoO in Eugene. Don didn't really see that happen, nor did it happen. It was another part of the series that was just Hollywood.
-From the Technical Adviser, Battle of Brecourt Manor Documentary.
Wheres the part where they were at bastogne and there were three guys who was talking about Spiers offering the POWs cigarette before Mowing them down with a thompson. then suddenly spiers arrived and offered the three men cigarettes while they refused and shit their pants. I think that one was the best of spiers'.
@radicalaceshasbrin that was guarrnere's brother and i think he dd it because i read somewhere sink ordered it no prisoners to be took.plus major winters said he wouldnt put it past him to have done it and the shooting of the sergant was true.
the 101st airborne did gather prisoners. and when the germans counter attacked they tried to make a run for it. Spiers was on duty and gave order to fire. I would have done the same.
Uh, no, not really. Never confirmed. Dick Winters himself said Ronald Spiers was a born killer. However, Spiers only suggested to Winters that he had actually killed the POWs. Spiers is dead now, so good luck trying to prove his actions.
What is most tragic about this scene is that it is based of a real event. How another person can simply execute a dozen unarmed persons is beyond me. Although most volksdeutsche would be recognized as traitors, and therefore after a trail would most likely receive death by firing squad to see it done so callously and so casually is shocking.
How can a single man put thousands of innocent people in camps and starve them to death, burn them, beat them, shoot them, kill their familys. It goes both ways,
WHY THE FUCK DID THEY DO THAT?!
PepperDr94 1 week ago
@PepperDr94 they did worse to our soldiers. they put them in work camps, starved them, beat them, tortured them, and worked them to death.
Grunt922 1 week ago
I don't care what anyone says. Damn nazis deserved every bullet.
BriDoh1 2 weeks ago
He places himself on the same stage with the war criminals of the germans ! Not better than one of them he wears only another uniform ! !
MrBalu1231 2 months ago 13
can someone clarify this for me please? i couldve sworn that in the end he implied that he didnt actually shoot the POW's and just pretended that he did to make himself intimidating and badass so people wouldnt question his confidence or something like that. did i misinterpret this???
Neivlak 2 months ago
@Neivlak From what I understood, he never "Denied" shooting the pows because he liked the way other soldiers looked at him and were intimidated by him. So he never said he did, and he never said he didnt. that kinda thing.
dmesz311 1 month ago in playlist More videos from mykerex
@Neivlak I think he told Winters that he did.
berserker276 2 weeks ago
The honor in the way men fought wars ended after ww1. How did we let that happen?
Buddyredale 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Buddyredale
this shows that you have no idea what happened in WW1
Danny22000 2 months ago
Killing POWs just for the fun of it. What a motherfucker. Going home, being a happy family father... gosh - how can a man be a monster the one day and a loving husband the other day?
Heartoftheclock 4 months ago
@Heartoftheclock You really think he killed POWs just for the fun of it? I don't think they were ordered to take prisoners in the first 3 days of the invasion.
berserker276 4 months ago
@berserker276
its a warcrime you idiot.
when a soldier surrenders you ESPECIALLY THE FUCKING ALLIES take them prisoner..
there where exceptions (mostly mg gunners and snipers got shot on sight) but this is murder first place according the the geneva convention etc.
arthuro13 3 months ago
@arthuro13 Yea I know..
berserker276 2 months ago
@Heartoftheclock
universal soldier will always suffer bro.
arthuro13 3 months ago
@Heartoftheclock Are you not familiar with the duality of man?
specter96 2 months ago
unbelievable...buth truth
risticnenad73 5 months ago
I wonder what the outcome would have been,if the germans wasnt forced to fight a 2-front war?
I suppose all these`heroes` would have been slaughtered at the landings on D-day.
fh3412 5 months ago
@bender1011001 Lol
berserker276 7 months ago
One of the most depressing parts of the series, hands-down.
straitjacketfeeling 10 months ago 3
If the Waffen SS got there hands on Speirs they would have done alot worst to him and his men then simply mowing them down with MP40's. They save that for Kikes.
They would have probably torn his fingernails off, shaved his tongue, and disemboweled him with there combat shovels.
Speirs Think's he's so badass dumping his Thompson on unarmed prisoners. Makes me glad for the 10 he killed the German's put down 100x more Polock's and others sorts.
blizzy00 11 months ago
@blizzy00 lol speirs raped those nazi faggets
FIDsmoggydrizzle 8 months ago
@FIDsmoggydrizzle You are a massive racist fucking dumb ass. Go die in a fucking hole.
Big5000K 6 months ago
@blizzy00 You mean the SS death squads; not the German army pal, he had no right to do it, they were protected by the Geneva convention and he has comitted a war crime.
TheSirRoberto 6 months ago
@TheSirRoberto The Waffen SS was not only a death squad division, they had multiple divisions of the SS. And also only 1/4 Soliders at that time even thought of the Geneva Convention.
Hell, even now the US goes around it via false flag terrorism. What a vicious cycle.
blizzy00 6 months ago
@blizzy00
Speirs is badass because he ran through through enemy fire (multiple times) with no regard for his safety.
tankdogg937 3 months ago
Zigaretten?
hotamali 1 year ago
what actor played the german soldier malarkey met and who played the soldier who stood in Disbelief while smoking cigarette in background as speirs killed prisoners
evan4324c 1 year ago
Comment removed
evan4324c 1 year ago
Actually artard, Speirs DID shoot those prisoners, in interviews from Winters and others, they ABSOLUTELY CONFIRM IT. And also a man who interviewed Speirs off the record whilst filming Band of Brothers had Speirs confess this fact himself.
TheMra18 1 year ago
@TheMra18 dont make up bull. and anyone who says atard is probably and atard themselves. spiers would have been punised for war crimes u idiot. he says later in the episdoe 'breaking point' that he didnt
scids225 1 year ago
@scids225 i have done a bit of research & in an interview with Winters he said that Spiers was such a great soldier compared to a lot of the other "kids" that were there,that the guys in charge overlooked what he did as they couldnt afford to lose him. Had it happened today then yes, he would have been charged for war crimes. Winters went on to say that he built his name as being a killer by killing 6 germans they had caught in order to establish himself as fearless which in actual fact he was!
lolly8686 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
why the hell did they kill the prisoners. if the germans did it would be another geocide or kills they did but they can kill the germans when ever
ww2collector1 1 year ago
Speirs never shot German prisoners, although he did shoot and kill an American sergeant who repeatedly kept disobeying orders and endangering his platoon and their mission by advancing into artillery fire. Tom Hanks decided that fact was too strong for the American public to take and still see him as a hero, so they vaguely included this prisoners scene. Notice you don't actually see it happen, that's because it didn't.
Audnorge 1 year ago
oh i get it... Speirs must have watched saving pvt ryan. he didn't want to make the mistake tom hanks did. hee...
EcoDimension 1 year ago
wait... so malarkey did meet that guy from oregon but it happened somewhere else?
EcoDimension 1 year ago
@EcoDimension Malarkey met the guy from Oregon but when he told the writers they thought it was too weak to just ad in like that so they added it to the legend of Ronald Spiers to make it more screen worthy!
lolly8686 9 months ago
Damn that american german guy is hot. And Speirs always scare the crap out of me in this series.
RoadOcean 1 year ago
Comment removed
historyman1942 1 year ago
This never happened gents. I am a personal friend of Don's and they messed up the city and other information. It was Portland, OR. Done went to school at UoO in Eugene. Don didn't really see that happen, nor did it happen. It was another part of the series that was just Hollywood.
-From the Technical Adviser, Battle of Brecourt Manor Documentary.
historyman1942 1 year ago
Does anyone know who the actor is who plays the German POW from Oregon in this clip? Have googled it but comes up with nothing!
ssassyf 1 year ago
Wheres the part where they were at bastogne and there were three guys who was talking about Spiers offering the POWs cigarette before Mowing them down with a thompson. then suddenly spiers arrived and offered the three men cigarettes while they refused and shit their pants. I think that one was the best of spiers'.
potnude 2 years ago
The part where he almost shoots that drunk douchebag was spiers' best for me. Made him look half-not-bat-fuck-insane
Arc9er 2 years ago
was he ever convict on a criminal charge ? dont think so. just the "others" are war criminals. americans always are clean. HAHA
Kettenhund1000 2 years ago
Nope. He was too valuable as a commander to ditch. And nobody of any authority actually knew it happened and it was all rumors.
Arc9er 2 years ago
i really want to know what happened
Jaihadist 2 years ago
he killed the prisoners
WackiWau 2 years ago
Lt. Speirs never really confirm nor denied the fact that he did or did not killed the 20 - 30 prisoners.
It did help keep his men in line, they didn't disrespected him.
If he did, it would be consider War crimes and he would be court marshall.
He did shot one of his man for being drunk (wasn't court marshall, becuase they couldnt risk losing a well experience officer like speirs,)
the shooting saved the lives of many soldiers who were suppose to be lead into combat by that guy.
BroadCastTuber 2 years ago
Figured that out all by your self? Nice.
ABeans07 2 years ago
he killed them all with his thompson in rage because his brother died in the italian campaign
radicalaceshasbrin 2 years ago
@radicalaceshasbrin
That was Bill gaurnere (spelling!) i think speirs did it because germans bayonetted and shot paratroops hanging in their harnesses from trees..
l0rdmuff 1 year ago
@radicalaceshasbrin that was guarrnere's brother and i think he dd it because i read somewhere sink ordered it no prisoners to be took.plus major winters said he wouldnt put it past him to have done it and the shooting of the sergant was true.
123gamerboy 1 year ago
his name is Speirs, not Spiers.
Sleepyhead54 2 years ago
Dude, Lt. Spiers is so cool, I like him, this is how the real officer should be.
StalkerDariy 2 years ago
They never clarified wether or not speirs actually killed them
elfishgrin 2 years ago
I feel bad for that POW from oregan.
shouavaj12 2 years ago
but if this scene had been germans shooting american pows... i'm just saying (by the way spiers is scottish not american)
warmadscot 2 years ago 24
@warmadscot Yeah but he moved here when he was 4. I don't remember anything before 4, and I'm pretty sure he became an American citizen.
DeCavalcante 1 year ago
@warmadscot actually the wehrmacht didnt shoot prisoners. they where ppl to. the ss might have though and this never happend by the way
scids225 1 year ago
absolutely. Anyone gunning down Americans is Satan on Earth. Americans gunning down anyone but Americans is 'HEROIC!'
19Truth53 2 months ago
in your discription you worte PW when it's P.O.W, and also Speirs is the dephinition of Badass!!!!
NarutoDude134 2 years ago
SHIT! WHAT THE HELL HAPPENED?!!!
masterDevis 2 years ago 2
i dont think he killed em' i probably used it as a way to fear and gain respect from the men
freebird199 2 years ago
man Speirs is like the MOST likely to find a career as a modern-day SEAL
lol
redxsaxe 2 years ago 29
I HAVE A THOMSON love it!!!
SEETER1 2 years ago
Does it sound just like that?
masterDevis 2 years ago
Good for you, have fun with the "thomson" maybe next time you could ger a real thompson.
parskaa 2 years ago
the 101st airborne did gather prisoners. and when the germans counter attacked they tried to make a run for it. Spiers was on duty and gave order to fire. I would have done the same.
jrmljrmljrml 3 years ago
Really? Is that why those shots were fired here?
masterDevis 2 years ago
omg anyone who watches tv shows know what i am talking about.
RUFUS HUMPHREY VS DETECTIVE CHARLIE CREWS!
omg LOL
brokenxstitches 3 years ago
speirs is just as bad an SS officer
jrmljrmljrml 3 years ago 5
Yes, Speirs looks kinda weird to me. He has been a good soldier but sometimes he acts strange
rcttim 3 years ago 3
very sad scene but true...
bloody507 3 years ago 5
Uh, no, not really. Never confirmed. Dick Winters himself said Ronald Spiers was a born killer. However, Spiers only suggested to Winters that he had actually killed the POWs. Spiers is dead now, so good luck trying to prove his actions.
sniper034 3 years ago
Great. Now im gonna have to buy his book.
1PAcouchpotato 2 years ago
Lol
sniper034 2 years ago
What is most tragic about this scene is that it is based of a real event. How another person can simply execute a dozen unarmed persons is beyond me. Although most volksdeutsche would be recognized as traitors, and therefore after a trail would most likely receive death by firing squad to see it done so callously and so casually is shocking.
UNKNOWNPOW 3 years ago 3
How can a single man put thousands of innocent people in camps and starve them to death, burn them, beat them, shoot them, kill their familys. It goes both ways,
awesomesolo 2 years ago
like a bi-sexual , im srry awesomesolo . u put up the dominos and had to drop them
airsoft6839 2 years ago
i dont like this scene, its so bad..
michaelkrois 3 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
To bad they didn't think of having a Geneva Convention after WW1... but instead waited until after the WW2 xD
codfreak38 3 years ago
Geneva Convention was before WW1.
ImperialGuard9001 3 years ago
awesome and sad scene.
Frenkyv 3 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
proof that cigarettes KILL...hahahahaha
anteracmacash 3 years ago
LOL
jrmljrmljrml 3 years ago