Very very very very very very good indeed. You moved me, really. The song is beautiful indeed, but the rendition is charming and amazing and moving. Simple yet wonderful. I like it so much. Thank you, for sharing this piece of your beautiful music and of your beautiful heart. Thank you, really.
Hi there, have you found a singer for your band yet? or a lead instrumentalist? would you be interested in the instrumentalist being a fiddle player? We are based in Rugby, Warwickshire. I am a lead vocalist my partner plays fiddle. would you be interested in seeing us?
I remember an instrumental version that came out in the early 60's. A rather peppy, faster beat. But I really liked it and wish that I could locate that tune. Cannot find it anywhere.
Salmon's Leap, Gaelic Storm, Cara Dillon and this version are my equal favourites of one of the most beautiful and under-rated love songs of all time.
Usually it takes few listening before I love the music but on this one I loved it immediately. Beautfil music and vocal. I have downloaded the clip and stored it in my favorite youtube folder.
It's a decent version of an old Scottish folk song. As someone said before, the song even quotes the River Clyde. Even Christy Moore will tell you that.
man, that harp player is awful!.....just kidding, this is the best rendition of this song that i have heard. all of the musicians are awesome, especially with the low whistle and harp in there make it very haunting, along with the backing vocals.
Beautiful, absolutely beautiful. I expecially like the harp in this song.
Is there possibly an instumental version of this song, without vocals? The vocals are great as well, but to me, an instrumental version would be so much more soothing. The kind of song I'd listen to while lying in bed, to enable me to drift off into a peacful, pleasant sleep
Thank you! I love the harp too, but then as the harpist I'm biased! We do sometimes add an instrumental "verse" of this sometimes when we perform it live. I do think it's a great tune and one of my favourites that we play.
This is DP, the lady who used you used to email back and forth with. Wish I could have gotten to the UK to visit you. Maybe some day! When are you coming to the Philadelphia area?
This arrangement is captivating... smooth waves of lovely sound to sooth and satisfy all the way through. Thank you for a quality, lovely to hear and look at video!
Is that the same chap as the one who plays the fiddle on other stuff? Now playing woodwind? Is he general all-round genius, also in national football team and leading army in Afghanistan?
Hi - it's a "low D" whistle (ie not strictly a flute as it's blown from the end, not the side). Hope that helps! It's a particularly difficult one to play because the finger-holes are so large.
Mark, the fingers arnt the problem, the diaphram is the real problem changing octaves etc. Suggest to him to retune a Bb standard down to an "A" it'll give him a lot of mileage on breath and dexterity and he'll be able to reel in to it :)
Just amazing... I played a symphonic band arrangement of this two years ago, and to hear it this way is just amazing. Beautiful voice on your singer(s), and amazing all around. Thank you for posting this!
what are you talkin bout?!! i think you'll find its a very old irish folk song! its as irish as irish cud get! and btw theres an area known as clyde in ireland... but those words arent even in the song so thats really not relevant
Christy learned this from a fellow folk singer while doing a tour of British Folk Clubs way back in the sixties I think beautiful song I enjoy hearing it again
WOW...What a beautiful song!! Never heard it before, but it's absolutely gorgeous! Strikes a chord in my Irish heart.....And, where have I heard Lynne's voice before? Did she happen to perform on a CD called Women of Ireland?...I could've sworn I've heard her sing a song called New Caledonia..anyway, must get one of your Slainte CDs....
In America, it's credited as a folksong from the southern Appalachian Mountains. It was set down in Sharp's collection "English Folk Songs from the Southern Appalachians." Since the Appalachians were settled by English, Scots and Irish beginning in the 18th Century, yes the song probably did originate in The British Isles, but we know it and love it in America as an American folk song. :)
I have heard that song for first time about 2 weeks ago, and I think it's one of the most beautiful song i've ever heard. Thanks for uploading that video.
Thank YOU for your kindness on replying my comments...my pleasure and honour...please let me (let us) know whenever you decide to come over for a show tour in Brazil (São Paulo) :D !!!
this is so beautiful though. thanks for posting this. i like your set-up because some of the other versions of this online are orchestral and i'd rather hear it as a folk song. the melody is the most beautiful thing i've ever heard. any websites or advice where i can find more? any really traditional versions?
BEAUTIFUL. i realized, i'm 1/2 irish, 1/2 norwegian whose ancestors came to america two generations ago. i connect with irish melody so much. it's crazy how deep some of these things can go. i think it's why america is so fucked up too but that's another story.
This is one of my favorite songs. Your arrangement is truly beautiful. I first heard it on Windham Hill's Celtic Christmas 3, as an instrumental piece by James McNally. His use of instruments and the way his arrangement begins with fewer instruments, then builds depth and complexity as more instruments are added, carries the listener on a sensual and haunting journey. When I discovered YouTube just a few weeks ago, this was one of the first songs I looked for.
Some people just cant deal with something different...There are so many versions of this song floating around, but I like yours the best. Thank you for sharing with us!
very impressive...that piper slash whistler of yeres is somehting else and theres just a fantastic sound with all this put together...im well impressed.
Thank you! We have recorded CDs in a studio, but personally I like the TV recordings we've done here, because they are recorded in one take - just like playing a gig, really!
The first time when I heard this lovely song had a place in Poland, in the some castle, 'ksiaz' perhaps. It was the concert of Lincolshire Youth Choir and Symphony Orchestra. Since then I was looking for this amazing ballade without any resoults. And now you give me this pleasure to listening it. You don't have any idea how much I am grateful. Please, tell me have you recorded and published your CD album? I wish to buy one and I'm intrested is it possible to deliver it to my place in Germany?
wow! you're one of the members? wow great song! You really do justice to this irish traditional song. I love the way you guys play and the way your singers meld their voices together. Just listening to the song tugs at my heart at bring a tear to my eye. I can feel the love and the passion in the song. Well done! Very very wonderful work. I added this video to my favourites. It is so beautiful!
I echo all the other comments best version of this song ever
GaldoroftheHavens 3 weeks ago
Heavenly..... such a beautiful rendition....sends chills down my spine!!! 5*****
rosslavel 5 months ago
awesome
ruffynest 5 months ago
Very very very very very very good indeed. You moved me, really. The song is beautiful indeed, but the rendition is charming and amazing and moving. Simple yet wonderful. I like it so much. Thank you, for sharing this piece of your beautiful music and of your beautiful heart. Thank you, really.
A big ciao from Italy.
TagtTheSpellcaster 9 months ago
Great song guys. We jammed with you out in Skerries on Paddy's day and the day after a few years back! Come back to Skerries! Great craic altogether
fergusgannon2008 1 year ago
What a delightful recording of a moving song. Mark, I've enjoyed many of your harp videos. Great job!
A fellow harpist...
Harpsong85 1 year ago
@MarkHarmer damn..... so far away. So far I only sing and play bodhran, tho. Good luck.
Fionnuala1969 1 year ago
Just beautiful! What is the wind instrument? Sorta looks like a penny whistle on steroids! LOL!
Gorgeous sound!
lilypog 1 year ago
@lilypog: it's a low whistle. It *IS* a penny whistle on steroids, actually :-) Same fingering, easier to play than a flute, has a nice sound.
TagtTheSpellcaster 9 months ago
Just beautiful!
lilypog 1 year ago
I am interested. I am a lead vocalist. I am based in Rugby. Would you be interested in seeing me?
1moondaisy 1 year ago
Hi there, have you found a singer for your band yet? or a lead instrumentalist? would you be interested in the instrumentalist being a fiddle player? We are based in Rugby, Warwickshire. I am a lead vocalist my partner plays fiddle. would you be interested in seeing us?
1moondaisy 1 year ago
I remember an instrumental version that came out in the early 60's. A rather peppy, faster beat. But I really liked it and wish that I could locate that tune. Cannot find it anywhere.
motowngirl65 1 year ago
While Judy Collins is my favorite version. This one is very nicely done.
motowngirl65 1 year ago
slainte,cavan, i love my love!!!!!!
failtecavan 2 years ago
jas mc nally version turned me on to this tune
he has this tune on spiritual high album
take ikt fay therr
gotz777 2 years ago
Pleasant enough and well executed. For me has nowhere the depth of emotion that Christy Moore puts across - but that's personal opinion for you : )
quagswag 2 years ago
Slainte!
Fantastic version of this classic song.
Salmon's Leap, Gaelic Storm, Cara Dillon and this version are my equal favourites of one of the most beautiful and under-rated love songs of all time.
maltavmalta 2 years ago
This has got to be the sappiest thing I've ever absolutely loved.
JuniusFaction 2 years ago
i love this song it's really beautifull all the respect in the world to slainte
carstenwjensen 2 years ago
Great, man!
stenfisher 2 years ago
I also love Lynn's voice and everybody else's singing and musicianship!
xoxoxo
DP - USA - Bensalem, PA
JTDebris 2 years ago
Yes, Mark, I really like the harp player!
DP
JTDebris 2 years ago
Lovely song, excellent singers and musicians ... Five stars !!!
Gillesscott 2 years ago 8
the only better version iv heard is from a band called "Ghost of a dead dog" who have disappeared unfortunately
cunlahound 2 years ago
Favorited!!! 5*****
Robikitara 2 years ago 2
faite,what a fab songx
failtecavan 3 years ago
A beautiful arrangement of a gorgeous song.
nichshang 3 years ago 5
sounds good
josephkahlilwilliams 3 years ago
nice nice nice - this lady does the song justice.
motowngirl65 3 years ago
muy buena versión, la que más me ha gustado.
the best version
jolinfolly 3 years ago
I love that song!!=) xx
xXxLaur2K7xXx 3 years ago
the music is PERFECT!!!the singing voices:i like the woman more than the man.
but:all togethet>beautifull!!!
vikisisa 3 years ago 2
you play it very good. best regards from switzerland.
(and for the other fuckers, go and learn to play anything you assholes).
this is really good. thank you
spinnoff57 3 years ago
lovely song - with kind regards from Bulgaria! :)
semkiibonbonki 3 years ago
Hi Mark, Are Slainte still playing? I enjoy the music so much. I think you guys do the best version of this song to date.
Slan
LilysApple 3 years ago
Usually it takes few listening before I love the music but on this one I loved it immediately. Beautfil music and vocal. I have downloaded the clip and stored it in my favorite youtube folder.
inepali 3 years ago 3
I am exactly the same as you. loved it, the first time I heard it.
CumbyOnThePiss 2 years ago
Such a good group. Come back to London.
allwillbewell 3 years ago
And black is the color of my true love's hair
Her lips are like some roses fair
She has the sweetest smile the gentlest hands
And I love the ground whereon she stands
I love the ground whereon she stands
I love the ground whereon she stands
There ya go Princeykun!! ^^
read from the last message up because i had to paste them in blocks.
KateForte 3 years ago
And black is the color of my true love's hair
Her lips are like some roses fair
She has the sweetest smile the gentlest hands
And I love the ground whereon she stands
I go to the Clyde and mourn and weep
But satisfied I never shall be
I'll write her a letter with a few short lines
and suffer death a thousand times
KateForte 3 years ago
Black is the color of my true love's hair
Her lips are like some roses fair
She has the sweetest smile the gentlest hands
And I love the ground whereon she stands
I love my love, and well she knows
I love the ground whereon she goes
I wish the day soon would come
When she and I will be as one
KateForte 3 years ago
I loved this song with just the music, but with the vocals, it's even more beautiful. Is there any chance that I could get the lyrics?
Princeykun 3 years ago
*A* prolly one of my most favorite celtic songs~ and this is such a lovely version!!
LittleLadyMab 3 years ago
:'( its beautiful
gobrowns1 3 years ago
O_o Wow! I love this song and i love this arrangement!
I play the harp and i love your hands, mark :)
Sorry for my bad english :( I want to say you more things but i don't know in english :P
kisses!
LokaNaranja 3 years ago 2
It's a decent version of an old Scottish folk song. As someone said before, the song even quotes the River Clyde. Even Christy Moore will tell you that.
Ossian67 3 years ago
Absolutely my favorite rendition of this beautiful song. You have captured it perfectly! Great job!
rjganley 3 years ago
yes slainte is irish.!!!
erkz13 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
r ye irish???
ye do not sound like me atal!!
im irish nd fukin proud!!
wooooooo
blondeyalert 4 years ago
ok, true Irish people type out their accents. I'm from Scotland and you don't see me typing out rolling R's....
bassjammer14 3 years ago
ahh i meant "Irish people DONT type out their accents"
bassjammer14 3 years ago
so being scottish,....how exactly would you know?
britboymacjudascock 3 years ago
lovely version. What tuning is the bouzouki player using...GDAD, GDAE or other?
clanntara 4 years ago
man, that harp player is awful!.....just kidding, this is the best rendition of this song that i have heard. all of the musicians are awesome, especially with the low whistle and harp in there make it very haunting, along with the backing vocals.
TheWhistleCollector 4 years ago
Awesome tune =) Very nice.
dot101 4 years ago
17th century maybe ... ehehehehe
ratodasdocas 4 years ago
Please guys some one out must have the bass tabs for this song.Please I need em asap!!!!
MickeyLynott 4 years ago
excellent rendition of an already excellent song!
sacredsong 4 years ago
Beautiful, absolutely beautiful. I expecially like the harp in this song.
Is there possibly an instumental version of this song, without vocals? The vocals are great as well, but to me, an instrumental version would be so much more soothing. The kind of song I'd listen to while lying in bed, to enable me to drift off into a peacful, pleasant sleep
Guytsu 4 years ago
Thank you! I love the harp too, but then as the harpist I'm biased! We do sometimes add an instrumental "verse" of this sometimes when we perform it live. I do think it's a great tune and one of my favourites that we play.
MarkHarmer 4 years ago
I also love the harpist, Mark!
This is DP, the lady who used you used to email back and forth with. Wish I could have gotten to the UK to visit you. Maybe some day! When are you coming to the Philadelphia area?
Love,
DP
JTDebris 2 years ago
REAL NICE VERSION
THANKS
PET SHOP PETE
petsoundspete 4 years ago
This arrangement is captivating... smooth waves of lovely sound to sooth and satisfy all the way through. Thank you for a quality, lovely to hear and look at video!
whispererslady 4 years ago 2
yea slainte is used as a toast but also to say "to your health"
ThisisDublin 4 years ago
I see from your Sliante site that Sliante means cheers..that's cool...how would one pronounce this Sliante? I love the video so much
whisperer2700 4 years ago
Strictly speaking Sláinte means health, however it is often used in Ireland as a toast - as in 'your health'
Chelseagal246 4 years ago
lovely, dreamy and admirably done...am so grateful for the quality
whisperer2700 4 years ago
luv dis song sang very well....mwah class classic.... im proud 2 be irish wen i hear dis song..... up da dubs best people u'll ever meet.....
XXXJESABELLAXXX 4 years ago
hi mark,
beatiful version i love it! ive been looking all over the country for low d sheet music for this tune, could you help??
thanks !
hoopthecoupe 4 years ago
Is that the same chap as the one who plays the fiddle on other stuff? Now playing woodwind? Is he general all-round genius, also in national football team and leading army in Afghanistan?
allwillbewell 4 years ago
It's the same guy - he also plays bagpipes on one of our other videos. When he's not out meeting the Pope, etc...!
MarkHarmer 4 years ago
i don't think any other version is as good as this one
wmk007748 4 years ago
a song done up great!
rexx2230 4 years ago
Beautifully rendered!!! What kind of Flute is that and what key???
Would love to know...Thanks!!!
JaiMaJames 4 years ago
Hi - it's a "low D" whistle (ie not strictly a flute as it's blown from the end, not the side). Hope that helps! It's a particularly difficult one to play because the finger-holes are so large.
MarkHarmer 4 years ago
Mark, the fingers arnt the problem, the diaphram is the real problem changing octaves etc. Suggest to him to retune a Bb standard down to an "A" it'll give him a lot of mileage on breath and dexterity and he'll be able to reel in to it :)
ThreshHoldHarry 4 years ago
Awesome song, thanks for sharing!
josephkahlilwilliams 4 years ago
Don't know how I got here :-).... Sure glad I did though 'cause this is lovely
SweetmammaE 4 years ago
Just amazing... I played a symphonic band arrangement of this two years ago, and to hear it this way is just amazing. Beautiful voice on your singer(s), and amazing all around. Thank you for posting this!
ianhart 4 years ago
beautiful.... listen to it while playing couterstrike...
vcxlll 4 years ago
i dont know what that yank is on about, its a jock song end of story.
IrishMartin 4 years ago
The song is Scottish not Irish,listen to the lyrics"I go to the Clyde and i mourn and weep"the Clyde,the river Clyde,Glasgow,Scotland,enough said.
fritz252 4 years ago
what are you talkin bout?!! i think you'll find its a very old irish folk song! its as irish as irish cud get! and btw theres an area known as clyde in ireland... but those words arent even in the song so thats really not relevant
ronandelargy101 4 years ago
i thought dis was a christy moore song
ben15193 4 years ago
Christy learned this from a fellow folk singer while doing a tour of British Folk Clubs way back in the sixties I think beautiful song I enjoy hearing it again
gerose64 4 years ago
alrite!!!!!!! didn no dat haha
ben15193 4 years ago
yup tis an irish-scottish song.......lovin it big!!!!!!
kelacooley 4 years ago
This is one of my favorite songs I've ever found on the net and their version is by far the best.
orbifolia 4 years ago
WOW...What a beautiful song!! Never heard it before, but it's absolutely gorgeous! Strikes a chord in my Irish heart.....And, where have I heard Lynne's voice before? Did she happen to perform on a CD called Women of Ireland?...I could've sworn I've heard her sing a song called New Caledonia..anyway, must get one of your Slainte CDs....
gloworm7 4 years ago
Gorgeous, gorgeous, gorgeous! I love the harmonies! And, that's my favorite American folksong! :)
lswise2451 4 years ago
erm..sorry to inform you but It's not an American song.. It's a scottish-Irish song... :)
brianhourigan 4 years ago
In America, it's credited as a folksong from the southern Appalachian Mountains. It was set down in Sharp's collection "English Folk Songs from the Southern Appalachians." Since the Appalachians were settled by English, Scots and Irish beginning in the 18th Century, yes the song probably did originate in The British Isles, but we know it and love it in America as an American folk song. :)
lswise2451 4 years ago
I have heard that song for first time about 2 weeks ago, and I think it's one of the most beautiful song i've ever heard. Thanks for uploading that video.
scott123hc 4 years ago
what a beautiful voice she has...thanks for both music and performance of you all :D ...
SandraEgidio 5 years ago
Thank you for visiting us and for your nice comments!
MarkHarmer 5 years ago
Thank YOU for your kindness on replying my comments...my pleasure and honour...please let me (let us) know whenever you decide to come over for a show tour in Brazil (São Paulo) :D !!!
SandraEgidio 5 years ago
Great version of a beautiful Scottish song
jordimc 5 years ago
Very nice. I enjoyed your singing. :-)
Happy New Year!
OMM06 5 years ago
this is so beautiful though. thanks for posting this. i like your set-up because some of the other versions of this online are orchestral and i'd rather hear it as a folk song. the melody is the most beautiful thing i've ever heard. any websites or advice where i can find more? any really traditional versions?
hans1753 5 years ago
BEAUTIFUL. i realized, i'm 1/2 irish, 1/2 norwegian whose ancestors came to america two generations ago. i connect with irish melody so much. it's crazy how deep some of these things can go. i think it's why america is so fucked up too but that's another story.
hans1753 5 years ago
love it, wow.
Moon2Earth 5 years ago
Thank you!
MarkHarmer 5 years ago
This is one of my favorite songs. Your arrangement is truly beautiful. I first heard it on Windham Hill's Celtic Christmas 3, as an instrumental piece by James McNally. His use of instruments and the way his arrangement begins with fewer instruments, then builds depth and complexity as more instruments are added, carries the listener on a sensual and haunting journey. When I discovered YouTube just a few weeks ago, this was one of the first songs I looked for.
cheri720 5 years ago
To the person who commented that Christy Moore does this a lot better, we did ask but he was washing his hair that night.
MarkHarmer 5 years ago
LOL! ;)
Some people just cant deal with something different...There are so many versions of this song floating around, but I like yours the best. Thank you for sharing with us!
s0ulrider 4 years ago
its wonderful! I love it
jojonin 5 years ago
Great job Mark, really nice sound. That song is very polular here in Newfoundland.
SillyWizard 5 years ago
Nice! Love the Corrs version as well...
cloudwalker92 5 years ago
very impressive...that piper slash whistler of yeres is somehting else and theres just a fantastic sound with all this put together...im well impressed.
kevo32a 5 years ago
Thank you! We have recorded CDs in a studio, but personally I like the TV recordings we've done here, because they are recorded in one take - just like playing a gig, really!
MarkHarmer 5 years ago
I love this song, and it's played beautifully. I've heard it by The Corrs, and Banshee in the Kitchen, but your version is just as good. Cheers.
Hecky123 5 years ago
The first time when I heard this lovely song had a place in Poland, in the some castle, 'ksiaz' perhaps. It was the concert of Lincolshire Youth Choir and Symphony Orchestra. Since then I was looking for this amazing ballade without any resoults. And now you give me this pleasure to listening it. You don't have any idea how much I am grateful. Please, tell me have you recorded and published your CD album? I wish to buy one and I'm intrested is it possible to deliver it to my place in Germany?
xxxShadowSongxxx 5 years ago
wow! you're one of the members? wow great song! You really do justice to this irish traditional song. I love the way you guys play and the way your singers meld their voices together. Just listening to the song tugs at my heart at bring a tear to my eye. I can feel the love and the passion in the song. Well done! Very very wonderful work. I added this video to my favourites. It is so beautiful!
sentrei 5 years ago
Thank you! That's me in the back, on the harp, and we're all still playing, and have added another member.
MarkHarmer 5 years ago
Beatutiful song. Thank You. Greentings from Slainte! from Warsaw, Poland.
dziemmak 5 years ago
this song is wonderful! I love this song!
sentrei 5 years ago
Thank you! It's one we absolutely love playing.
MarkHarmer 5 years ago