Punk vs Metal

[doente5]

sweet! elma chips has launched potatoes with a camera

[LiBoOo15]

JAJAJA SE LA JALAN JAJAJAJAJJA Y MUCHO :3

[TheOnlyAttrition]

shredding is lame. its just showing off. (usually) there is no feeling to the solos in death or thrash metal becuase they just wanna play fast and show that they can jack off and play the guitar at the same time.

[sebyrotten]

es una guerra innecesaria, yo toco en una banda de punk rock, thrash metal, y algo de speed metal, escucho todo tipo de metal y punk, y puedo decir con certeza que de no ser ppur el punk rock, el metal no seria lo mismo, de hecho la segunda ola del heavy metal britanico surgio por que el punk rock empezo a opacar a las primeras bandas de metal, y para que el movimiento no muriera empezaron a innovar con un estilo mas rapido y pesado, ademas el cuero y la ropa sado fue priemero punk luego metal

[PidgeonGrape]

wtf is this?

[undrclasshro]

i like punk better. but that gay shit type punk. the real shitz wer its at

[carterwhitey]

Punk saved rock.... Hardcore and the rest came of it

[MrCoww]

y battle? combine the two. THRASH FTW!!!!

[EDDX3339]

Punk + Metal + Rock = YEEAAHH!!!  \m/ (- -) \m/

[nightterrors100]

Punks amazing. Metals amazing. The end.

[eduardogodoysilva]

wowwwwwwwwww mannn this is the better HD video i ever seen...

[Picheta32192]

Punk is a lot simpler than metal, but it has more of an energy and anger that metal doesn't. Everyone thinks metal is angry music, but really it's just brutal, while no one sounds more pissed off than the Sex Pistols and such.

[Chrisethanme]

I Listen to BOTH

[ZupraVisor]

you all should listen jazz hipsters

[phreaker92]

THIS IS SHIT:D

[xxNailFirexx]

yes, without punk, we WOULD have "core" music. because core music has nothing to do with punk, therefore i agree

[gotaBadhabit3]

@xxNailFirexx actually hardcore was the first core genre and that DIRECTLY derrived from punk hence why it was called hardcore punk to begin with.

[xxNailFirexx]

@gotaBadhabit3 I kow that, and I also know that the "-core" music of today isn't the same as the -core music of the past. It's not the same at all. The record companies just pasted the name on shitty bands so that they could watch their millions pile up as 13-14 year old girls who call themselves "hardcore" because they drink and dress like emo/scene sluts give them their money so they can listen to that crap while they cream themselves to the posters of pete wentz on their walls

[gotaBadhabit3]

@xxNailFirexx haha i misunderstod what you said, but youve just hit the nail on the head. core is VERY different these days, gone from black flag, circle jerks, fugazi, bad brains and minor threat to mickey mouse bands like bring me the horizon and such. your dead right about the little scenies too, they piss me of immensely

[chaneeyy]

so ppl dont listen to some bands just because their mainstream??? that means their good you fucktards and proves that punk is shity music

[xXTHEDOUCHEBAGXx]

You think a band being popular means they are good? How retarded are you?

[xxNailFirexx]

so the jonas brothers are good?

[666deathghost]

hey ppl stop the retarded argueing

[Johan1991100]

If punk suck why did they invent punkmetal ?

[kiisfriend]

get this, NO punk bands play in drop D, but most ALL metal bands DO(some drop C).

also, punk isn't about what you play its the message you want to put across. also, punks dont give a shit what you think so no need to bother with all this negativity

[sandiegorickk]

A Wilhelm Scream play in drop D.

[MrMetallica4life]

@kiisfriend drop B is grizzly

[strikeout1991]

@kiisfriend

almost all metal plays on drop D?

what about Metallica and Megadeth for example?

they play on standard E mostly

[Mklztr]

@kiisfriend Refused plays in Drop D, so does Rise Against in some songs.

[Fluffypopcicle]

@kiisfriend

rofl you're a noob. i cane name so many metal bands that play outside of drop D i can't even put it in one comment.

[1thommyberlin]

@kiisfriend nirvana was a punk rock band. they used drop d and drop c tuning. listen to 'negative creep' for instance. Punk Rock = NO rules. Metal = plenty of rules.

[ThazuaBlackarrow]

@1thommyberlin Nirvana was grunge.

[eclipselight]

How low have we fallen? I listen to both... there should never be a discussion whats better punk or metal... neither of them is mainstream and punks rock! Sure, technicaly punk is on a (much) lower level but that was sort of the point when it all began... "Music is for everybody" They even used to play on stolen instruments by learning everything themselves.

[bloddyslayer]

Punk is some what mainstream......if you count the metalcore, emo and pop punk genres

[jamesbullet55]

Real punk (GBH, Casualties, Exploited etc...) is very much NOt mainstream. However subgenre's are. So in a way its 50% mainstream -fake

50% Underground - Awesome

[evelash]

@bloddyslayer we dont count that shit cause it aint punk its poser punk bull shit

[xxNailFirexx]

metalcore, emo, and pop punk are punk butchered by the mainstream

[ChromaticDeathVox]

@eclipselight HELL YEAH MAN! You are so fucking right. Finally, an intelligent individual who knows his music lore. I agree, both are amazing, yes they both have there faults and even bands that suck, but as a whole they are amazing, pure, and unrestricteed by the commercialization of modern music... well at least most of the bands in either genre. Again, they both have their faults (ie - Green Day and Metallica).

[christslayer666]

then at least get rid of this deathcore trend

[christslayer666]

then we must get ride of punk so core can nvr exist

[xxNailFirexx]

get rid of fucking Hot Topic

[christslayer666]

@xxNailFirexx scene and emo kids and metalcore fags as well

[Fluffypopcicle]

metal owns punk, excluding nu metal and metalcore. i play both and metal is by far more challenging and the better one to play. this is just my opinion dont be a jackass and start an argument.

[xxNailFirexx]

@Fluffypopcicle metal if by far more challenging XD! haha, as if no one knew that already!

[BlackSunSerenade]

I listen to Hardcore Punk and Death/Power Metal, both are awesome can't really decide but I'd choose Metal over regular Punk

[Burnthenighttable]

Both are pretty good. I listen to punk, and if you had to ask me to pick between punk and metal, my answer would be punk without thinking.. But I like the fact that both genre's aren't so.... I guess self centered is what I'm looking for. What I mean is that their are lots of punk and metal songs that talk about issues besides lost gfs, money, parties and all that stuff. I also like the fact that both are kinda outsider music, because I have never really fit in socialy.

[XxFoRealxX]

Fuck punk

Metal owns,that's all there is to say. \m/

[eyyitsjosephh]

fuck you

punks not dead asshole

[eyyitsjosephh]

metal is just shit is im listening to the radio i dont want it screaming at me

[XxFoRealxX]

Fuck punk

Fuck The Ramones

Fuck The Sex Pistols

Fuck Em' All

Metal owns all \m/

[wejw14]

1)metal head mother fucking cock sucker slimy ass bitch

2) metal is screaming into a fucking microfone just as bad as emo

3)nerdy fucking metal head

4)VIVA LE PUNX!!!!!!!

[eyyitsjosephh]

THANK YOU

punks unite ahah

[eyyitsjosephh]

fuck you if it wasnt for punks you wouldnt have you pussy ass metal cause motorhead started it all

[XxFoRealxX]

Do your fuckin homework,Motorhead did not start it all.and yeah dude punk really does suck,and pussy ass metal? say that to any true metalhead you fuckin fag.

[eyyitsjosephh]

i just did dipshit metal is for pussys and retards

[XxFoRealxX]

Yeah you said it on youtube way to go fag.

Anyone can pick up the guitar and play the same 3 or 4 chords over and over again.Punk sucks get over it.

[i9incher]

and anyone can scream into a microphone while playing the same drop D chords over and over again, which btw is easier to do than playing power chords.

[jamesbullet55]

Yea but loads of metal bands are inspired by Punk... so.... you need to get over THAT. Bitch

Oh and I listen to both so don't get pissy.

[eyyitsjosephh]

fuck you dipshit cause without motorhead you wouldnt have metal dipshit

[eyyitsjosephh]

fuck you

[wjavier316]

haha

Los saicos, an unknown punk band from latin america appears in 1964. Black sabbath in 1968. But .i don't care. I don't remember what i put that comment

I dont understand what you said at the end because i speak spanish and a very basic english. I think you speak spanish because your nick is AlexDurazo. o.O

[wejw14]

punk started in the seventys dipshit (i'm a punk not trying to bash the music i'm listening to just telling the truth)

but punk still woops metals whiney nerdy little pathetic ass

[wjavier316]

There was a peruvian band called The saicos that had punk lyrics. Their music is like the music people used to listen these days but the lyrics are punk.Ah! that band appears in 1964

[nicihicicsc]

wtf bad playing bad qualy

[PunksAreMe]

i like both, but i like punk way better. (which is why im in a punk band)

[robcarr710]

I like both xD

[pignataro01]

pelotudos el punk y el metal es lo +

[ALADAR16]

que celular tan malo, buen intento

[Sevenchappels]

NU-METAL RULES!!!

[vegunited06]

the bad thing about metal is, the fans. all of them are still living with their parrents, have no girlfriend, no social skills and insecure. punk is an attitude, metal is just a bunch of posers.

[NWG92]

Really, because I was under the impression that metal was primarily a genre of music about musicianship, skill, talent, and songwriting. Punk music consists of primarily short, extremely basic, catchy verse-chorus-verse pop songs. Unless we're talking about hardcore punk, which is just pointless shouting and shitty musicianship. You're right though. Punk IS an attitude. That's why punk bands focus more on "attitude" than, oh I don't know, writing actual decent music?

[aa50mm]

Punk is a bag of pussiess...you don't know any real metal head right? ASSHOLE!! go fuck with "the system" like u say

[Xmaggot93X]

Vega, you're pathetic.

My stepdad listens to Necrophagist. So he's out of the house, married, the friendliest guy you could know, and almost a little too confident. He plays guitar and lifts weights. I'm curious to hear what you've accomplished.

It's funny you should say that metal is for kids and punk is for real people.. because if you go to a metal concert you'll see adults on stage and adults in the crowd. Go to a punk show and you see scrawny kids all over the place.

[vegunited06]

ska punk > all metal genres

[aa50mm]

hahah you a stupid bitch

METAL UP YOUR ASS

[vegunited06]

DONT you be talking to me like that, talk to me like that again and we'll fall out and we don't want that. do we.

[lmiisgay]

fuck punk ! cocky dicks ! metal ftw . especially death metal ftw !

[DOA666JOEYSHITHEAD]

dude punk originated from metal

[Calamari5]

other way round, punk came way before metal, and metal came from hardcore punk

[joeybones4]

Punk involves no skill. They just throw in power chords and simple (but fast) drum beats.  Most punk vocalists are really loud and off pitch, even though I kind of like that.

[adfrocker133]

punk requires good rhythm i hate oun but you can deny that

[GunnarX7]

it doesn't need GOOD rhythm just needs to be on time. which all music needs. punk is energy. that's it. the idea behind it is that nothing in the band is of greater importance then anything else whereas most metal is based on the guitar. that being said punk is no where near as good as metal.

[adfrocker133]

well it uses some rhythm

haha and yeah metl singers can actuall y sing

[Calamari5]

lol are you kidding? metal singers can actually sing?! hahaha. i admit 9 times out of 10 a metal band is more talented then a punk band, but 9 times out of 10 a punk band has more energy. and besides, punk stands for something, metal is just 'music'. up the punx!

[adfrocker133]

dude sebastian bach one of the greatest metal singers ever name one punk singer that can actually sing, punk is just anarchy metal is against anything that is anything

[Calamari5]

first of all, it's about which style of music sounds better, and that goes to punk. although the metal beats and riffs etc are often harder to play, metal is usually about who can shout the loudest while playing the most complex piece of music regardless of how it sounds (although thats not always true). punk is always sounding good, and getting everyone on their feet enojyin the music. and as to your comment, joe strummer from the clash.

[Calamari5]

infact lets go for a modern singer, Tim McIlrath from Rise Against

[adfrocker133]

well im not gonna lie i do like some punk like rancid, the ramones, ect some punk bands have some really really catchy stuff and the guitarist usually have really good rhythm, at least its not like rap or hip were everything is made on computer

[Calamari5]

yeah lol, if people don't like punk, i'd rather they liked some form of rock instead of rap or hip hop or any of that rubbish

[adfrocker133]

true true i like it all from punk to hardcore metal to pop punk, ect ect but i hate rap

[aa50mm]

Punk song are only THREE CHORDS...that sound better for you?

[Calamari5]

hmm. yes.

[aa50mm]

ok...then I can't talk to you about music if that is music for you..

Almost listen to classical

[rockerguitarman]

punk is not just fuckin anarchy dibshit

[aa50mm]

I TOTALLY agree with you joeybones4

[cuymagico23]

punk=shit

[RockonDude92]

For true to the roots good oldschool punk, listen to the Dead Kennedys, Bad Brains, Bad Religion, Flipper (weird name) etc.

[jimimalmsteen7]

Emo emerged from the hardcore punk scene of early-1980s Washington, D.C., hahaha ignorant me??? hahaha yeah dude yeah all u want zipper head

[RockonDude92]

That would be the musical genre, not the fuckin' fags with the anime styles jet black hair and thick globs of crusty black eye crap and the dudes who where their sisters' pants and are all depressed all the time.

[Gringux]

imbeciles!

jAAAJAJAJAJ

[RockonDude92]

Does anybody here even have a clue what bands are punk and what bands aren't punk? Are you guys considering shit like Green Day or the Offspring to be punk? Because they suck. Real punk kicks ass.

[RockonDude92]

I kinda like really old school punk like dead kennedys and Bad Brains, but I moslty listen to metal.

[jimimalmsteen7]

the difference in the influence of big bands like metallica is that i dont fucking care if they listen punk music really i dont care, to me only cares the fantastic music that they do and i hate punk and is forever and i know that metallica likes the misfits or rob zombie likes the ramones and motorhead too i know that, but i dont fucking care what they like ,the only care is the music that metallica, zombie, motorhead etc do!! and punk = mediocre want or not and triy to kill the metal in 70s

[peulito]

solo veo unpar de nerds tocando al mismo tiempo, que caos, ademas se ve y esacucha como las pelotas

[PANDAWILLPWN]

punk and metal take really no skill the solos in metal might be hard MIGHT atleast the popular shit, i like punk way more then metal but everyones got an opinion, and the kid fi the video playing punk was so not punk..

[cenyan13]

you are... SO fucking stupid

[jimimalmsteen7]

punk is a shit , is so mediocre and so bored,stupid and have emo shit, metal have the best musicians in the world and have better subgeneresn and metal and a lot of jazz, clasicall etc.. musicans play metal and likes metal and the history says everything, punk is a shit

[DaH1pp1e]

punk has nothing to do with emo, or the commercial world.

[punisher113]

jimimalmsteen7

Tell that to Slayer, Metallica, Overkill, Megadeth and Motorhead. They all like punk and were influenced by punk.

[jimimalmsteen7]

metallica?? whre said that?? metalica's most influence is diamon head, dude if they was influenced by punk bands obviously they wouldnt even be a metal band (obviously man think before talk and dont said that each of them like it)..

megadeth yeahh?? where???

salyer, in the history of slayer maybe said that they seems to have influence in the hardcore punk '''''seems to have''' no 100% sure of that. and dont said that they like it.

overkill??? where???

motorhead ok agree with that

[RockonDude92]

Dude, I read an interview and Jeff Hanneman says he listens to more punk than Metal. What do you think of that?

[varulv234]

You're such a dumbass=) So, if your theory is right, then music would never evolve.

[jimimalmsteen7]

why not dick shit??? music always can evolve its obviously dude, but ur ignorence can think about it, and what theory ?? hahaha if u like punk good for u i hate it like u hate the religion zipper head, think before talk please

[varulv234]

Yeah, i hate religion, becaue it's retarded. If people can't get influenced by Punk, turning it into Thrash Metal, new genres would never be made, cumslurper.

[jimimalmsteen7]

no!!! dont confused zipper head, read a little, dude if thrash metal was 100% influenced by punk abviously trash metal will be punk, man its obvious, and for example metalica was influenced by the misfits but not totally for them, themost influence of metallica is diamond head and is metal and other is sabbath the thing is that yeah agree with a lot of trash metal bands have punk influence but no 100% is 1-10 influences is simple man want or not is metal and come of sabbath, zepelin etc,not punk

[varulv234]

No, but there was no Thrash Metal before Punk, so, it's a great deal of influence.

[jimimalmsteen7]

ok, agree with u on that, but u cant say that trash metal depends of punk ,its stupid, trash metal is metal and is a subgenr of metal, not of punk but ok have their punk influences but not 100%

[varulv234]

It REALLY depends Punk.

[jimimalmsteen7]

no dude obvously not, you are so lost ..read the history of trash metal and never said that, never!!! hahaha bye dude nice to meet you and good luck

[varulv234]

It was heavily influenced by Punk, therefore, it depends on it.

[jimimalmsteen7]

mmm no dependsof the New Wave of British Heavy Metal and speed metal in 80s , and yeah have influences of punk but it really depends of the new wave of british heavy metal but its ok everyone has their own opinion, and if u think that i respect ur opinion

[varulv234]

Of course, that's right, but Thrash Mwtal still depended on Punk, although it's very true that it's also very much inspired by The New Wave Of British Heavy Metal.

[RockonDude92]

I watched a thrash documentary and James Hetfield said the stuff they mostly listened to for inspiration was a lot of punk and the nwobhm.

[RockonDude92]

Look at Slayer's Undisputed attitude album. That whole album pays homage to oldschool punk. The album is a bunch of punk covers you ignorant ass-fuck.

[jimimalmsteen7]

haha man first im not a big fan of them, and i dont fucking care if they played backstreet boys cover or punks cover, fucking ignorant the only think that cares is that slayer is a trash metal band and they are not a punk band and thats the only cares and why metal is much better than punk , if ur ignorance wants to talk about influences talk all u want but this about punk vs metal and metal is better music

[RockonDude92]

Is english a second langauge for you? Your grammar is atrocious.

[jimimalmsteen7]

ahhhh hahaha thanks mediocre punky emo dick shit, and dude at least i try to learn a speak other language, im sure that u can say ''fuck u'' in other language with out a traductor ''pinche puto de mierda recibeme esta pendejete'' jajajja

[RockonDude92]

First off, let's get one thing straight. Emo is far from being punk. Second, I'm a metalhead, but that doesn't mean I'm so closed minded I'm not going to give other genres, like oldschool hardcore late 70's to mid 80's punk.Shows how little you know you ignorant fuck-twat! Third, I speak a wee bit of spanish.Usted es un poco maricón pito mierda coño!!!

[jimimalmsteen7]

ahhhhhhh jajaja good for u!!!! jotete vete a mamarle la verga a tu padre si es que lo conoces y recibeme esta hijo de tu reputisima madre m vale madres si t gusta el punk o el metal de todos modos eres un ignorante hijo de puta que no sabe defenderse con otra cosa mas que con tu ignoracia jjajjajaja chupame esta pendejin ''usted es un poco maricon pito mierda coño'' ahhhhhhhh jajajajajja good spanish de huevos tu pinche español gringo cara de pene.. nice to meet u zipper head

[RockonDude92]

Usted se merece una muerte lenta terrible. 16 syllables to say that in spanich. in english it only takes 11 syllables. You deserve a slow excruciating death. Also, to say parking lot it is 3 syllables. In spanish it is playa de estacionamiento. 11. 11 vs. 3. English can explain concepts quicker than spanish. spanish is inferior to english. so piss off you twat.

[jimimalmsteen7]

y que te hago mole o q pedo pinche gringo cara de pene,playa is parking?? hahahaha playa is beach idiot hahah dude byeee hahaha youre so stupid no bueeno queee lee pasooo a rockondude, infaaame una verdadera vergoñaaa, hahahah byeeee good luck, about james hetfield i dont care, punk is a shit and so mediocre like u and only cares the beautiful music that metallica do!!.. y recibeme esta putin hahaha

11.11 vs 3 hahahahaha wtf! shut up! i dont care dick shit bye and Rock on dude!!!!

[RockonDude92]

Thanks for the indecipherable minless tidbits. I'm sure you and your wetback freinds will really look back at those comments fondly.

[jimimalmsteen7]

yeah!!!! your welcome!!!!! hahahaa bye puto

[mastervideogame]

gana el metal y por mucho diria yo, el punk tiene muchas debilidades ejemplo los emos y los happy punk etc. el metal no tiene, me gusta todos los generos del metal k ai, ademas deke los solos del metal son mucho mejores y por muchas kosas mas, asi ke el metal es mucho mejor k el punk.

[4gamerz]

Punk does not take skill? Go listwn to some fucking Bad Brains then tell me about skill.

[steelangelblack]

?? if punk dosent take skil i wanna see a vid of you playing a famous punk song and lets see how you manage

[4gamerz]

I dont ned to dude. You should check out the movie American Hardcore it explains every thing. Check out bad brains too. There are one of the best ones out there. If you think that punk is just a couple of power chords then think again dude, BTW I do listen to metal I like Both.

Do you know slayer and metallica did some covers of punk songs?

[steelangelblack]

not you bro lol i just meant to reply to someone else accidently clicked you sorry

[DaH1pp1e]

yeee, slayer did sick boy by gbh

Metallica does a lot of misfits songs.

[gotthkid2]

PUNK 4 LIFE

[JomalSharks]

Punk and metal Rullz!

[punkgdqueen]

PUNK RULES!!!!

[Sheogorath2008]

Metal rules, punk is primitive music

[HercNastyz999]

punk is just too easy and dont need skill to play

[Sheogorath2008]

True that. So i said that

[jase08drums]

punk is just a stage leading 2 metal, most metal musicians goes through it..

like me

i started out punk and now im a metal/hardcore drummer XD

[ChozoL0rd]

i heare punk and i heare it 4 ever :-D

[naleo8]

i see what your coming from but, do u believe

that a person can be successfully both, whats your opinion on that?

[verbaledge]

hardcore is punk num nuts

[josecarlos316]

deperdis gravenlo bien

[laingio]

if the band is American and has formed in the early 90s onwards and call them self punk chances are their not they will be pop/rock shit

[metalheadofcalgary]

check out some underground bands

[laingio]

no i shall not america can suck my dick

[LessthanJake14]

Underground bands are more in the European area than America.

[ESmaniak]

Blink 182 punk? GTFO. If Blink 182 is punk, then Pigs MUST be able to fly.

[kijanapunk29]

this is shit

[bogd4nstelystu]

rogger that...

[NuNuPants]

dont even say Blink 182 is punk. they are pop garbage

[007DV]

no entendi ni una wea O.o!!!!??

[RAVAX2]

hahahh ,blink 182

travis hip hop musico, haahahahaha.

foda-se blink 182

[LolzNdolz]

What the hell is this?

[doda74]

stick to your books you god damn nerds

[dopesniffereater]

lol messy but michael batio LOL good job

[chochothrash00]

la weaaaaaaaaa fomeeeeeeeee

[DAMIANSILIAN]

no q video mas basura no me gusto graben uno x uno

[pqq18]

go fuck your self!!! YOU SUCK!!!!! :P

[lolas33]

bad quality

[slayerister]

Simplemente Gay & poser

[oreocookieguy]

are you retarded thats not punk, thats scene, emo shit your retarded

[DarcK09]

q pena m da el de blanco

kakajajajajakajakajajajaj

que se dedique a tocar el timbre mejor

[rubas07]

los huebiesen grabado a uno y despues al otro

[fallen5501]

was that first sng a terrible cover of "calling all cars"?

[pqpmasterunlimited]

W-T-F

[Crisalius]

consiganse... un mejor camara jajajajaajjajaa

Ya enserio... no estubo bueno

no saben