Added: 5 months ago
From: KatrinDepp
Views: 17,074
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (132)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Love love love this video!!!!!! XD what video editing software do you use?? :)

  • This is absolutely my favorite Rose video I've seen yet. I never tire of watching it. Good job.

  • Damn, this video is absolutely amazing and brilliant and.... everything!! It's just incredible and heartbreaking and all...

  • this is amazing! how in the world does this not have more views! this is one of my fav vids from you keep it up!!!!!!!!

  • everyday , i'm watching this video and i have always goosebumps, thanks <3

  • Do u mind telling me what episode that was with the 11th doctor I know I've seen it and now I wanna watch it again.

  • @Rikusmine think it was Let's Kill Hitler. I'm hardly paying attention to the new doctor who these days :/

  • wow *speechless* this is brilliant! xxx

  • This is well-done. Great selection of clips, the first minute and a half feels nicely cinematic. I liked that you provided symmetry between Ten/Eleven in some of the cuts.

    Looks like I will have to watch Tennant-era DW now... I've only seen series 5 and 6.

    Is it worth it to go through the whole Rose story? Seems like that would be like... 4 whole seasons of episodes

  • @alextoob1 Its DEFINATELY worth a watch, a few time over in fact... most of my friends who start with Season5+6 really dont get what's the big deal about Rose Tyler... Its starts with season 1, with Doctor (Eccleston;9) and grows in season 2 (Tennent;10)... in season3, it kinda shows how important Rose is to the Doctor as more than a companion and season4... ah... Rose will always be an important part of the Doctor's life... hope you enjoy it... BTW, this vid is AWESOME!! thanks 4 da good work

  • @alextoob1 Oh it's worth it alright :)

  • I really like the editing at 1:06, where you cut the wolf out of the picture and instead Rose is standing at Bad Wolf bay, like a reminder of her being the bad wolf in the first series.

  • this video made me all teary. You're a genius you are! Love the editing and the song, which fits perfectly and the fantastic clips from the best moments of DoctorxRose.

  • really beautiful vid *tear*... i love Rose and the Doctor(s)... the doctor will forever remember His Rose T.T

  • It's amazing how the video was edited perfectly ! I can't stop watching! thx <3

  • My motherfucking heart cannot handle these stuff. Beautifully made!

  • GAHH! It is videos like these that do not allow me to get over Rose being gone. GR! Again, another AWESOME video!!! Amazing!

  • Hello, can you direct Doctor Who? K, thanks, bye

  • THIS. THIS. THIS! Excuse me while I finish sobbing my eyes out.

  • This is absolutely the best thing I've ever watched.:'( It's so sad yet it explains their relationship so well. Brilliant, brilliant, brilliant work. <3

  • this is brilliant :) I made a fan film with two of the scenes you used. But it's not as epic as this. Keep up the great work :)

  • okay, i haven't watched Doctor Who in a REALLY long time (haven't even got to the point where we meet Eleven) and i would really like to know if Rose ever meet Eleven? or comes back to the show after season 4? ^^

  • @AllyFan101 The last appearance that Rose has made on the show to date was in the last episode for the tenth doctor, The End of Time Part 2. It was at the very end with the tenth doctor shortly talking to Rose before he regenerates, on new years in 2005, the year that she would meet the ninth doctor.

  • Whenever I see that shot of Rose in the snow on New Years day, my heart breaks all over again. The cameo of her was good in the newest seasons, and a part of me would love for her to come back for a time, but the Doctor has to move on. He has lost many companions, and has loved everyone of them in his own way, so if he dared to look back, it would hurt him all over again. To move on is the only way to keep going, your video(in my mind) reflects this.

  • THIS IS SERIOUSLY THE BEST DOCTOR WHO FANVID I'VE EVER COME ACROSS AND SEEN.

  • So powerful, amazing visual appeal, incredible audio additions at all the appropriate times. Pure win. So favorited. I wish I had the ability to describe just how in awe I am of this video. Moved to tears by just how amazingly well this was edited.

  • @KatrinDepp I cannot even express my love for your videos. They are so amazing. THANK YOU!! <3

  • I can't watch any of your videos without getting shivers because of how good it is

  • I swear about 2000 of those views are mine... I freakin love this video!! You are SO good.... and Rose was the best companion (and I started out with Amy) ... The Golden age of the Doctor.. :) Well done!!

  • @Writersrevengeorigin Love hearing this! It's hard coming across Doctor/Rose fans now, because it was years ago. Everyone keeps forgetting the best years of the Doctor Who series.

  • @Rose99991000 I know right?! I started out with Doctor/Amy.. but I still love Doctor/Rose... they were so good... So sad... Truly the best years..

  • @Writersrevengeorigin I still remember seeing the very first episode in 2005. So long ago!

  • Breaks my heart every time I watch it, it's an amazing video. Oh, god, I just want them to be together. This is perfect. And heart-breaking. And I'm repetitive, I know, but this is brilliant. :)

  • this gave me chills. brilliant work!

  • sobbing

  • Amazing editing, and storytelling job- just awesome! :) Best I've seen in a while.

  • wow. I loved the whole thing, but especially the transitions between the doctors' faces at the very end. absolutely brilliant.

  • Oh my god, I love this song. You could not have done it more justice.

  • oh. my.god.

    you.are.a.god.

    just sayin'

  • This is absolutely AMAZING.

    I love it when all the Doctors are used so well together in a vid. this kind of fills the hole Moffat has left for me in the past two series. I do understand the need to move on but i really want him to mention/involve past companions more. just subtly like he does already sometimes. but more. heh. I love the thought that Eleven still somehow always holds Rose close in his heart. It doesn't shine through so much in the actual series. So thanks for this awesome vid!

  • @NeverEverFaceTheDark as heartbreaking as it is to never really get any mentions, I think I like it better this way. Russel T Davies couldn't of finished the story for the Tenth Doctor and all the companions in a better way; circling all the way to where it began, with Rose.

    There's something really sad about it all, and that's why a lot of viewers keep looking back on the good series with all these Doctor/Companion videos on youtube.

    All the same though, I miss all the old characters! :'(

  • @NeverEverFaceTheDark I love it though.. The only companion the Doctor ever talked about was Rose... So sad..

  • YES! I feel like this is the Doctor/Rose video I've been looking for all this time.

  • The Doctor's look at 0:32... Oh gosh it's heartbeaking... :(

  • Great song. Great editing. Love it!!!

  • Rose and the doctor being apart makes me cry!

  • Эх, жалко Девятого мало.

    Изумительный клип.

    Каждый раз мурашки по коже тоннами)

  • This is stunning. Just wow. <3

  • That was so sad.

  • The Doctor said Rose's name in the last episode of series 6. Pretty sure it's the first time he's said it since 2008! Amazing video anyway :)

  • omg what awesomeness is this video!! <3

  • when I saw Rose on Lets Kill Hitler, I started running around the house going crazy and then hit instant replay about 10000000000 times.

  • The best Doctor/Rose video on youtube.

  • your videos are just amazing. i was also surprised by the clip on Doctor who. it seemed like through the seasons we have seen past companions over and over, but looks like that isn't going to happen anymore :( I get why we can't see rose (sad!) but why not Martha or Donna, Jack? Again, great video!

  • INCREDIBLE! I absolutely love this. When I heard and saw "show me someone I like," I was knocked back. I never expected her to come into 11's story and now I can't shake Rose Tyler. Not that I ever was able to before. Thank you for making this!

  • Oh god i'm sobbing, this is GORGEOUS!!

  • I just saw this searching around tumblr... I'm a subscriber to you, but youtube has been acting weird and I never saw this pop up... I just started to get back into Doctor Who, and I clicked on the video and instantly knew it was you by the "viewer discretion is advised" I almost screamed I was so happy! I was like "she made a video of them?!" haha, this is WONDERFUL! just amazing!!!!! epic!

  • I dislike Rose with a passion :)

  • @sherrytastic I agree! Okay, this video is absolutely beautiful, and so well done, but I don’t really like Rose Tyler, and she was NOT the greatest companion ever. Does everyone not remember the Christmas Invasion, where she decided that instead of trying to help the situation or help the Doctor get better, she would just WAIT IT OUT IN THE TARDIS?! And whilst she was doing this, she kept going on about how the Doctor had left her, and how he wasn’t the “proper” Doctor?

  • @demonwings1031 I’ll admit that she was happy, and her happiness was good for the Doctor to a degree, but she never asked about the Doctor’s past, about his home planet except for that ONE TIME in The End of the World – she was pretty much content to just go along for the ride. She treated Mickey and her mother terribly, and left them again even after the Doctor had accidently taken her away from them FOR A YEAR.

  • @demonwings1031 She didn’t have the courage to stand up to the Doctor when he was being a jerk to her either (the End of the World, when the Doctor shouted her down about asking where he was from, and she just gave in). And THE DIMENSION CANNON: a potentially time and space-shattering device that she was building and testing BEFORE she knew it was the end of the universe, while being fully aware of the dangers of killing people, just so that she could get back to the Doctor, is just ludicrous.

  • @demonwings1031 I’m not saying she was awful, but really, it cannot be said she was the best companion. The Doctor will always have a love for her, as he has loved all his companions, but please don’t over-romanticize her or her relationship with the Doctor.

    I'm sorry for this exceedingly long rant, and I'm sorry to the Rose lovers, I don't hate her, but it irritates me when people describe her as perfect, when she really wasn't.

  • @demonwings1031 That being said, this video is still tragically beautiful and absolutely, fiercely lovely in it's creation. Good on you mate!

  • @demonwings1031 TRUE SAY! didn't remember that one until you typed it! come on peeps she was useless when it comes to being a companion...ok I'll admit that the only time I did like her was at the end of series 1 when she destroys all them Daleks but technically it was the heart of the TARDIS that possessed her I liked, not her herself, she was VERY clingy towards the Doctor and rarely ever showed independancy. She treated Mickey like rubbish :( can she get any more selfish?

  • This is really cool! I love it :)

  • @squirmzeeworm the editor (if they arnt already) could go pro for making preview...or w/e, this is extremely very well done

  • You made me cry.

  • this video is perfect. PERFECT.

  • Beautiful. Beautiful.

    I actually started to cry.

  • way to wrench out my heart strings one by one. this is incredible. thank you for gracing the world with this video.

  • wow, this is really good. your editing is fantastic! I'm jw what program do you use?

  • i think i watched this already... but i cant stop watching it.. its soo awesome :')

  • HP, House AND Doctor Who? Not Just Doctor Who but ROSE era as well? WIN

  • Why does this video make me want David Tennant and Billie Piper to announce that they are in a relationship? (skulks away with a tear rolling down face as the realisation occurs that this will not happen since they are both committed to another person :'(.)

    It is a fantastic vid though, so bravo!

  • David Tennant ...... the ONLY Doctor. Never to be beaten.

  • First I discover you make HP videos, and now Doctor Who ones as well? Dude. I totally subscribed. Just sayinn. <3

  • that was just...wow, literallyy words cannot describe how amazing that was,,,,WOOOOWWW! x

  • omg...FANTASTIC!!

  • Wow! This was great. Makes me think how epic it would be to bring Rose back and have her play off the eleventh doctor.

  • Oh David... I love you!

  • This was Incredible I loved it - You have the ability to capture the true emotion in these videos. I am huge fan of Doctor Who and I feel you have done an excellent job of capturing and portraying the Doctor and Rose's relationship here. Great Work.

  • I genuinely got the chills from this piece. This is PERFECTION.

  • This is the real Doctor Who OTP. ;___; I just love them so much

  • Comment removed

  • THAT WAS BEAUTIFUL. I loved it.

  • wow breathtaking.ı wish there was be a vid of you like it with donna.

  • This is amazing!

  • This video literally made me gain an appreciation for Rose. Before I really disliked her... but I'm gaining some appreciation now.

  • Loved it! The beginning is amazing, great editing there!

  • I can't believe you made a Doctor/Rose with this song! I ... I... LOVE IT ! The song , the band and Doctor , and you putted all those things together * crying* Again, amazing vid

  • Wow this was just amazing!...I love Rose and the dr. in his weakest moments he always goes back to her <3

  • Really intense!

  • I'm not a very big Rose fan, but I really enjoyed this video! Great job :D

  • This was BRILLIANT!!! I really want to see Rose/10.5 come back in a future series :)

  • When I saw that part, I went crazy. Like I started running around the house in happiness because rose is the last person you expect to see now.

  • Thankyou! I miss Rose so much, and David Tennant as the doctor. I really got emotional everytime she left. Brilliant video, as always. x

  • You never fail to deliver. Amazing job, as always!

  • This was an amazing video! Awesome job!

  • As far as I know, Rose is stuck in a different dimension. I'm too curious so I do know she will come back at the end of 4th season, and apparently she's appeared in the 6th. I really hope she will come back. I know there is no such thing as a happy ending with the Doctor, but I can't really stand them being apart.. :| And this is brilliant, very well made!

  • @xIceM I hope that Rose doesn't come back. We've seen enough of her. We've gotten the happy ending.

  • @xIceM She does have a Doctor with her .w.

  • @pinkykhan464 Yeah, I hadn't seen that last episode of season four when I wrote that.. :3

    But still, I don't think it's the same. And I don't mean for Rose, maybe she's happy with it, but it really broke my heart watching it, because I knew it must've hurt so much for the Doctor. She got her happy ending, but that just makes it all the more painful knowing the Doctor never could have it. If you know what I mean..

  • I'm just in love with this video. GREAT JOB!

  • Brilliant video, looks fantastic quality and you have used the lovliest clips of the Doctor and Rose

  • Beautiful!

  • BREATH TAKING!!! <3

  • Wow, epic.

  • this is one of the best doctor/rose videos i've ever seen! no wait, one of best video iv'e see on YOUTUBE!!! OMG :') thank you

  • This is fantastic! You make the best DW vids, love, love, love it please keep more coming!

  • Brilliant, as always.

  • god you make the best DW vids. i love doctor rose and i miss them so much. i love this video, the clips selection is so epic and the coloring is so pretty. i love how it speeds up at the end! hey whered you get the clips of the doctos faces fading into one another? specifically the one of 9? thanks- keep it up!

  • D: amazingly stunning and beautiful <3

  • thank you for making more doctor who vids, its hard to find good work worth a damn out there...presses like button till it breaks...

  • :O < that's the best I can sum it up

  • Wow! That was amazing! Such a great and emotional vid!

  • This was just beautiful. Wow. As a big Doctor/Rose fan, I can honestly say that this is the most amazing fan vid I've EVER seen. Absolutely marvelous.

  • I don't even ship Rose/Doctor (in fact, I rather hate it) but this...this is simply just too lovely to ignore and NOT adore.

    This is beautiful, a real feat of emotion and editing. You are such a bloody genius.

  • Man, I miss Rose so much and her relationship with the Doctor. Your vid is stunning.

  • I don't even watch dr who.. but I was just mesmerized throughout this whole vid. That rarely happens w/ shows I don't watch ahah

    beautiful :)

  • this was so heartbreaking, brilliant editing. <3 that also surprised me too.

  • i effing miss Rose so bad. i loved those two together.

  • this made me cry :*(

  • Lovely, as always! I figured with Stephen Moffat's dislike of Rose, we'd definitely seen and heard the last of her - glad it wasn't true, and also glad that great vidders like yourself haven't forgotten how much fun it was to vid this 'ship!

  • wow, it gave me chills.

  • Awesome keep on guys :)

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more