Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (1,587)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Don't sweat Miley v Britney v Joan

    Miley does the song because she likes it. She loves rock n roll, but she isn't a rocker. Yet she does a good job. (The bike looks scary enough, but imagine riding it blind - that is a very bright follow spot on her)

    Dear Britney does not know what rock is. Nor do her fans, who think her version is great. Imagine she singing a completely different song. "I love rutabagas and tomatoes"

    Joan... gee, I wish I could play like a girl.

  • Ohh noo

  • This was the song that she had sung it on Hannah Montana audition.

  • ONLY 450 THUMBS DOWN???

  • Miley, get the hell away from rock.

  • I Would've been scared as fuck on that bike in the air. O_O looked like it could barely hold her.

  • I don't think britney's cover is the best, because she hasn't got a high voice like Miley has..

  • what... the... fuck...

  • No. She can't sing Joan Jett. thats wrong.

  • whats the deal with the bike? :L

  • what the fuck?

  • "I Love Rock 'n' Roll" - written and recorded first by The Arrows in 1975.

  • @asaxon1378 no by Joan Jett and the blackhearts!

  • Buy the book about Joan Jett called Bad Reputation (by Dave Thompson). It clearly says in print that it's an Arrows original song first recorded in 1975 and Jett covered it a few years later.

  • bellissima myley

  • ok sta cancion es un cover pero porque

    a fueza HACER LO DE LA MOTO JUSTO COMO BRIT? .|.

  • Britney? Mavaffanculo a lei! Sempre meglio Joan Jett!!

  • She's great...

  • non si puo immitare una musi di joan jett almeno non cosi

  • Just because you're on Disney doesn't mean you can sing. Is it just me, or does EVERYONE signed onto Disney have to sing???

  • Wonderful cover of Arrows classic song.

  • Miley Cyrus Lo iso Mejor! Es Sexy y Hermosa! Mano ARIBA si. Y Britney lo canta Feo y no le cae el rock" a britney :p. A Miley si porq ella es increible :D

  • le copio a britney e hizo lo mismo q el video

  • Don't be silly. She is amazing. Yes, Joan Jett is better than her but Miley's good.

  • SHIT

  • puta mierda

  • Miley just stay away from the classics, PLEASE! first smells like teen spirit now this? Just......DON'T!

  • stop trassing rock n roll. you are nothing like joan jett generaly youn sing pop not rock

  • sorry but britney did it better

  • @TheLaraqasem123 hmmm....really? Britney was pretty darn bad

  • @TheLaraqasem123 es verdad

  • @TheLaraqasem123 Britney isint the original writer of this song and I agree.

  • wtf?? pobre de sex pistols y Joan jett esta cancion cantada por ella ?? o.O que asco

    wtf? Poor Joan jett sex pistols and a song sung by her? O.O than disgust

  • What the fuck?

  • wtf?!

  • ha fatto questa cover solo perché l'aveva già fatta Britney, che ovviamente ha saputo cantarla molto meglio!

  • Oh dear god

  • FAIL.

  • brit did it way better

  • THAT BITCH!!!!!!!! britney and her both fucked this song up

  • I'm crying.

  • AMAZING!! love miley <3

  • Britney Spears was better.

  • well...it's not bad i have to say

  • This is so terrible O.O

  • FYI- This is an Arrows original song. Joan Jett and Miley are friends and have sung together on television.

  • ooooooo i love rock and roll!!!!!!

  • I don't wanna live on this planet anymore!

  • fuck off

  • hey, your cam is really awesome, wich one did u used ? ;)

  • fuck you guys , this cover is amazing , I wanna see you to covering this

  • This sucks. Her cover of Smells of Teen Spirit FUCKING sucked, then saying that 'Kurt Cobain was her ideal boyfriend' made me laugh so hard. So what if there are hundreds of thousands of Miley Cyrus fans going against me? Today's music is horrible with a bunch of crappy pop artists which half of them pretend to sing, horrible rappers and wannabe rockers (emo's). Hard for you lot to understand, but that's all it really is. Older music was good and it isn't a matter of opinion, it's valid.

  • 1.miley

    2.joan

    3.britney spears

  • :'(

  • @xMegaBellax you are crazy miley CRAPrus ruined the whole song ....

  • @lavendaperfume britney sounds so much worse so chill out man

  • @GabrielaTofficial i am only talking about miley not britney

  • @lavendaperfume I know , but she did a good job ! Of course , nothing to original , Joan Jett's version is way better . But still , it is covered ! And she rocks

  • @GabrielaTofficial i am sorry but miley didnt rock...her songs comes under the genre pop seconldy ...she has a crappy voice... thirdly...she didnt cover it well...and i hate her ,.. :D

  • @lavendaperfume Ok but why do you comment here if you hate her ? You are kinda wasting your time , don't ya ? Go outside with your friends instead . And she covered it just on a few concerts so what , big deal , everyone complains and send hate . I mean , fuck off

  • @GabrielaTofficial fuck u hahaha.....

    listen i am not wasting my time here...actually i love Joan Jett....and i wanted to see how good Miley Craprus covers this wonderful song....and as expected it was FAIL....

  • I hope that she fell of the motorbike and die

  • 1. Joan

    2.Britney Spear

    3.miley

  • @MyEquestrianLove no,

    1.The Arrows

    2.Joan

    3.Britney

    5.Miley.

  • miley cyrus doesnt love rock'n'roll

  • her voice is to delicate and the bass is way to powerful, you can hardly hear the guitar. nice try Miley, you gorgeous (when your not wasted) but this ain't your song

  • All of these pop people went to war with rock and Maybe rock lost but IT WILL NEVER DIE.

  • Of course Joan is better than MIley.

    and though Joan is pretty fucken amazing,

    The Arrows do it way better than Joan

    it is their song after all, 

  • Her voice is pretty but rock simply dosent suit her. :/ especially this song. Btw the guitar was WAY off key! O.o

  • I love miley

  • This is one of the best LIVE cover of miley. It's really cool, her voice rocks on it, and when she screams....oh it's so sexual xDD

  • Como coños dejan a esta babosa imitar a la Leyenda Joan Jett...¬¬

    Este tipo de basuras musicales indignan de verdad!!!

    Esta niñita desafinada deberia buscarse su propio estilo!!!.... ¬¬

  • how fucking dare you to sing this legendary song?

  • Ok even you Miley fans have to admit her voice is WAY too high pitched for this song! Honestly Joan's cover is amazing because of her rough voice.

  • @iloveparamore333 Joan didint do the cover she was the original one.

  • @VevoTaylor Err no she actually isn't. The Arrows are the original.

  • ok i hate miley cyrus but this is pretty good :/

  • .|.

  • Joan Jett = Way better

    

  • No matter who sing this song if they are not tone deff the song will rock no matter what is one of the funking best songs ever YEAH! \m/,

  • 375 people are stupid!

  • robando canciones. Perra

  • Joan Jett is much better!

  • I'm with you @8VampireLover8 Joan Jett can't sleep after see this video! (yeah, she's sings well, but... Come on! (She sings pop and NOW wanna sing ROCK? TRUE AND GOOD ROCK?) And shame on this stupid fans that just like this music cuz it's Miley Cyrus sing! Someone here it's older than 15?! Or listen the original song begore watching this? If she want to sing pop, ok. But PLEASE don't sing TRUE AND GOOD ROCK'N ROLL!

  • I love Britney but this is more better :)

  • i prefer the arrows original

  • ... Taylor Momsen sings better

  • COVER not COPY , 

  • i want a studio version of this :O

  • Man she sucks.

  • @HopeForMusic15 u suc

  • @MandaMusicLover Why thank you.

  • Miley copy Britney.

  • @Baryk73 britney copy joan and the arrows

  • joan jett does this song sooooo much better.

  • @pookyroxon Joan jett is covering this Arrows song, same as Miley. Just another great cover.

  • uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu sucker sun of a bitch she sucks

  • *-*

  • no character she sang good as hannah montanah maybe (i dont think so) bu t her voice would fit something likghter not rocknroll classic... go back to your songs

  • this cover sucks ass balls and whatever u can think of come on she doesnt know anything about rock shes a pop singer and rock n roll is not about being a slut its about rocking out the original version is from the arrows not from joan jett ,miley cyrus,britney spears ...... they ar all pop so they have to leave rock n roll anlone

  • -____________- wack ass cover

  • does she know what rock 'n' roll is? :P

  • @muiteckmet If you do , so does she :) 

  • @TheRealFaChA

    I don't think so ;)

  • @muiteckmet well you don't know her but you can expect what you want.. but keep your words on your mouth :)

  • @TheRealFaChA

    well, i don't know her, but anyway i know that it's crap that people says thats *rock* or *hard rock* what she does, and thats just sad cos i and many others know what real rock 'n' roll is, and not some kid that thinks she can get popular ;)

  • she's a son of a bitch she copied this song from Joan Jett ac/dc the arrows... and she sing horrible usual i love this song but now when she sins i hate it!!!!!!!!!

  • @MissLolify1 I will say what I like when I like

  • this is putrid, worst cover of anything I have ever seen this bitch needs to stick to her own type of music and not wreck the good type

  • i love rock and roll is about music not motorcycles

  • say what you will about MIley, I'm not a fan of hers by far...but the way i see it, she's getting a new generation interested in some of the greatest songs in rock n roll history. How many of those screaming little girls do you think went home typed in that song on YouTube and found Joan Jett or even the original Arrow? Those are more fans for the real music we all love...

  • @xMegaBellax LOOOL

    haters fail today, huh

  • @xMegaBellax ok you dont even kno what the fuck your talking about. joan jett does not scream when she "OWs". miley cyrus is a fucking wannabe. and your just a fucking idiot. so stfu

  • @8VampireLover8 bella has alot of people with her, ya little maggot and you've only got thousands we've got hundreds of thousands

    beat it , rat

    is all you do all day hate?

    and you're pretty jealous of miley, there, sucker haha

  • omg no. 1:36 wtf is that???? its OW not screammmmmm. ugh horrible.

    disgrace to rock and joan jett

  • Nice try but nothing will be as good as the original arrow's recording. Not even Joan Jett.

  • S.H.I.T BIG .S.H.I.T!!!!! Joan Jett RLZ never die a real rocker!!!!

  • she did a good job she did not ruin the song nither did Britney they both did a good job singing it but I have to say Mileys bike is bad ass!!!

  • oh God I'm watching at your comments and I think to myself wtf? I'm 16 I sing better this song! It doesn't matter of she is Miley Cyrus or whoever! Thhe only rock thing in this cover is the motorbike and when she screams. I have to admit though that she is better than Britney Spears who literally nailed it!

  • She can sing everything

  • LOVE Miley, she knows were she's going, how to get there, and will go down in history as one of the best singers of time. She is a legend. Even with all the bullshit people keep giving her, she doesn't let ANYONE bring her down. People should learn from her.

  • WOOO PORTLAND. :)

  • How I got here? OMG someone help me pressing the X button

  • This is ok but Ruth Lorenzo's version is amazing!!

  • 1975's version is way better

  • S.H.I.T.

  • @zilard8 S.H.I.T. doesn't even come close to describing it.

    I have to go now and shove sharp pencils into my ears!!

  • Miley I love you too my love and my life. Do not worry these people are idiots. They have no heart. They do not know it's just a Cover. Bunch of useless. I know you will not see this message but I love you And I will always love and always remember you

  • Miley I love you too my love and my life. Do not worry these people are idiots. They have no heart. They do not know it's just a Cover. Bunch of useless. I know you will not see this message but I love you And I will always love and always remember you

  • this is a shit¡¡¡¡ 

  • did you record this? what camera is it? AMAZING!

  • what is wrong with you pepole??? how can miley be combared to a thryll of rock she sucks it is a spill for the song!!!

  • Watch our cover of the song here--------->watch?v=XiBmhIeP­1Hc AND PLEASE LET ME KNOW!!!!!!!! :)))

  • I bet u half of the kids in the audience thinks she wrote this song, but hell no Joan Jett did. Miley I don't think you're a good rebel. I'm sorry miley cryus fans, but Joan Jett did better.Miley you did fine.

  • @freedp3 actually the arrows wrote the song ;))

  • @ArtemhPlacebo yea I honestly meant to the arrows I keep copying and pasteing so i was in a hurry, because I was writing a my chemical romance fanfic.. I meant Joan Jett did better and Miley did good.

  • @freedp3 oh ok..!! :))

  • @freedp3  um. us miley fans arent stupid we all know bout joan jett... even before this... miley doesnt just do pop.

  • @SmilerAndProud I know, but some of the kids in the audience don't know joan jett, the runaways, or the arrows. I'm saying some of the kids think she wrote. I say this girl and she was bout 17, she was older than me, and I asked her and her little sister what songs she sang cherry bob, I love rock n roll, and bad reputation. I asked who do you think wrote it and they said her. I replied the arrows wrote I love rock n roll and they said no she did, but I let them go on.

  • @freedp3 well i knew

  • miley just cuz u copy some1 doesnt make u kool srry miley fans

  • i dont know why so many people hate her. she may look like a slut and stuff but when your acting like how she does sometiimes you dont even realize your acting sluttty

  • Mejores comentarios

    Miley does a good job on this so

  • Miley:oooh yeah I am so sexy and I'm so cool cuz i got to ride a fake moterbike

  • Just to correct anyone, Joan Jett & the Blackhearts didnt write this song. It was wrote by The Arrows in 1975. Joan Jett covered it in 1981. But i'm actually liking mileys one... and im a metal head.....

  • I'm not a huge fan of Miley's or anything but I think she does an awesome job on this song...

  • Mileyy Cyrus ROCKS and this video is bomb .!

  • I tylko dwa słowa JA PIERDOLE !!

  • miley cyrus rock and roll? jajajajajaja

  • I'm pretty mellow when it comes to artists doing covers of great songs, but I have to admit that Miley's cover of this song just wasn't that strong, I couldn't feel it. Just like, who was it? Green Day? Doing The Clash's cover of I Fought The Law, I didn't really like it because of how they sang it, it just didn't have that....spark. Does anyone get what I'm saying?

  • she isnt rock an roll tho

    

  • .¡.

  • I think it is lame that a pop singer should even TALK about rock, but she didn't do bad... I mean like as long as you have a good voice you can kick ass at this song. At least she make it too poppy, like brittany spears. Plus Joan Jett's version was a cover also. The Arrows wrote it, Joan Jett just made it famous.

  • @crimsonmeat44 Amost right. Joan Jett was the first to make the song famous... in the USA. In England everybody already knew the Arrows 1975 version which is why Jett did NOT have a number one record with the song in the UK in 1982. It peaked at number 4 in the charts for her there. The USA is not the whole world.

  • shes not a slut all girls dress like a whore but who cares its there body and its about the music you dumb haters

  • Miley is such a poor role model, and now she's doing covers of songs made before her dad even got into the music business. Crash and Burn, Miley!

  • @zienkai does it really matter when then song was written? good songs are timeless. besides, on the poor role model thing, everything she does is actually legal, no matter how shocking or weird or whatever. she's just not perfect, nobody is.

  • @DobbysUnmatchedSocks So smoking a bong full of weed is legal now, is it?

  • @elephantasmic it wasn't weed. it was this other drug starting with s that is completely legal in the state she was in.

  • oh wow, now she's on a motorcycle? kinda desperate.

  • Miley looks like a troll. STOP COPYING EVERYONE AND SUCKING!! Christ..

  • gaaaaaaaaaaaayyyy.

  • @atlaskick If u think its so gay then why are u watching the video .

  • @Cyrusbieberful can you come up with a better arguement, child?

  • @atlaskick Its not an arguement its just the truth k .! Just sayingg .!

  • @atlaskick And i bett u cant even do anything that miley cyrus does .! so wouldnt be talking if i were u .!

  • I'm Gonna Throw Up!

  • @LorennaZ16 you actually got 8 thumbs up :)

  • Okay so like Miley you dont do rock you do pop and that even sucks Jett is legendary you r a piece uv shit

  • @SpenceAndAria729 totaly agree with you!!!

  • @M3talElite Yeah! And wouldn't you agree humping a motorcycle doesn't do justice?